Nathaniel Comfort’s misguided take on The Selfish Gene at 50

October 27, 2026 • 9:51 am

Nathaniel Comfort is identified by Wikipedia as “an American historian specializing in the history of biology. He is an associate professor in the Institute of the History of Medicine at Johns Hopkins University”. Comfort has written several books on the history of genetics, including a biography of Barbara McClintock, and I’ve heard he’s nearly finished what is likely to be the definitive biography of J. D. Watson. I have a great deal of respect for him.

Thus I was baffled by Comfort’s new piece in Nature discussing (or rather, dissing) Richard Dawkins’s The Selfish Gene. Despite that book’s influence and renown, Comfort claims that it’s outdated: indeed, not worth reading at all compared to books that discuss the view of evolution favored by Comfort. And Comfort’s favored view is that of the “Extended Evolutionary Synthesis” (“EES”), which argues that the “neo-Darwinian view of evolution” that fused natural selection and Mendelian genetics, is wrong and needs replacement with a new theory. I’ve discussed this view at length over the years (see my posts collected here), and, along with Doug Futuyma (see his article below), I note that while new discoveries have created add-ons to evolutionary theory (and dispelled some of Darwin’s own tenets, like the widespread inheritance of acquired traits), they don’t call for a new theory of evolution. The Selfish Gene is not outmoded—far from it.

In his essay, Comfort says that Dawkins’s view of evolution by natural selection as a process you can think of as driven by “selfish genes” is wrong: it’s too narrow and best left on the shelf. You can read Comfort’s piece here or by clicking on the title below:

As you may recall, Dawkins’s main point was that the unit of evolution by natural selection was the gene, or “replicator”: a bit of DNA that can reproduce itself from one generation to the next.  The unit is not the individual, the group, or the species, but the replicator, which can be seen as “selfish” because those genes that replicate faster than their alternative forms will be the ones most represented in the the future. Faster replication can, for example, be effected by building bodies (“vehicles”) that last longer and leave more offspring than others. This is the main way we think of evolution by natural selection, but Dawkins’s “gene’s-eye view” is broader than this.  Transposable genetic elements, for example, facilitate their own reproduction and survival by replicating quickly and infesting other parts of the genome.  They spread through a species not by enhancing an organism’s adaptation, survival, or reproduction, but their own reproduction.

Further, as the book points out, a gene can spread by selection even if it reduces the survival or number of offspring of the bearer itself, but enhances the number of copies present in relatives or groupmates—via kin selection or reciprocal altruism.  This view of natural selection can be thought of as the spread of “selfish” genes, but, as Dawkins asserts repeatedly, it need not lead to selfish or aggressive behavior of individuals—one of the most common misunderstandings of the book.

The gene’s-eye view influenced not just the public, but many biologists, including me, and it clarifies a number of points that were murky (e.g., kin selection). But Comfort says it’s narrow and outmoded. Take a look at Comfort’s second paragraph:

Re-reading it now, with decades of scholarship in the history of biology under my belt, it seems less benign. The determinism baked into the “gene’s-eye view” in the book troubles me, as does the passivity of the organism in Dawkins’s telling — a “vehicle”, a mere “replicator”. The implication: that traits such as aggression are hard-wired into people. Fortunately, over the past couple of decades, new tools, fresh models and scholars in many disciplines have begun to embrace the complex reality of biology. Readers in search of an understanding of life on Earth today would do better to reach for books that take a broader view.

Yes, in fact organisms are passive, for although they can influence the spread of replicators via their own behavior, those behavioral features are themselves the product of “selfish genes” (an example is “extended phenotypes”, like the beaver dam—one subject of Dawkins’s eponymous book). This is truly a deterministic, naturalistic process that has no room for “agency,” “will”, or teleology, though I’ve suggested that truly nondeterministic processes like quantum mechanics might influence evolution by producing mutations. Absent quantum effects, evolution is indeed deterministic, and organisms are vehicles that express the products of replicators. (Yes, I know that some physicists think quantum mechanics is deterministic in ways we don’t understand.)

As for the implication that selfish genes imply the evolution of aggression or other such behaviors, Comfort apparently hasn’t got Dawkins’s message.

So what is the “broader” view of biology that, Comfort argues, should replace that of the selfish gene? It is the “Extended Evolutionary Synthesis,” which calls for a wholesale rebuild of neo-Darwinian evolution because of things like epigenetic modification, “niche construction” (e.g., the beaver dam cited above), behavioral and morphological plasticity, and what is called “natural genetic engineering”, a quasi-teleological view, largely touted by James Shapiro, which claims that organisms engineer their own fates by some “intelligent” process that did not evolve in the Dawkinsian way.

As Doug Futuyma explains in his paper below, all the phenomena mentioned above, save “natural genetic engineering,” fit comfortably within the modern synthesis, even though some discoveries, like epigenetic modification of DNA, have been made in recent decades. (I’ll point out here that DNA modified by the environment can cause evolutionary change only insofar as it produces “selfish [modified] DNA that replicates faster than unmodified DNA. And we have almost no cases of epigenetic modification not themselves coded in the DNA forming the basis of evolutionary change.)

I’ll make just two more points; the first involving the “directionality” of evolution. Here’s more from Comfort’s piece:

For instance, neo-Darwinism teaches that evolution is a random walk through changing environments, with selection favouring whatever traits help an organism to survive. Today, many scholars argue that there has to be direction to evolution. In How Life Works (2023), for instance, journalist Philip Ball points out that in a single cell, there is an unfathomably large number of possible interactions between different kinds of molecule — and there are about 37 trillion cells in one human body. “Such a system,” Ball writes, “can only hope to be stable if, out of all this complexity, only a limited number of collective ways of being may emerge”. Living organisms are forced to evolve in those few directions.

And the neo-Darwinian idea of evolution as a random process seems to run counter to the unavoidable observation that life has evolved towards ever-greater complexity. Biochemist Nick Lane has argued that, right back to life’s origin, the main driver of this complexity is the second law of thermodynamics — entropy, the tendency toward disorder. “Energy-releasing chemical reactions are at the core of the living process of all organisms,” wrote he and others (W. F. Martin et al. Science 344, 1092–1093; 2014). The detailed chemistry behind this idea is outlined in depth in Lane’s brilliant 2015 book, The Vital Question. The overall idea is that complex life forms dissipate more heat than do their simpler counterparts. Life on Earth is pushed towards greater complexity and abundance because, given the composition of the planet, it is energetically favourable.

The first paragraph is in fact not a refutation of the selfish gene view.  The only direction to evolution—and one that Dawkins notes—is that replicators get better and better at replicating over time.  This in general leads to an increase in survival and reproduction of the “vehicles”—organisms—but it need not.  The spread of transposable genetic elements, which account for a great deal of “genetic junk” that dominates our own genome, is one example. And nobody I know of thinks that organisms are unconstrained, either by their own nature or by the environment, in the way they can evolve. There are guardrails.

Second, the discussion of why life was once simple but has become more complex is not new. For one thing, life started out simple and thus if it was to go anywhere, it had to become at least a bit more complex. But the view of unidirectional complexity is simply not true. What is true is that life is a cumulative process, with new “adaptations” evolving from old ones, so a great deal of adaptive residue remains in our genome. But you’d be hard pressed to show that “complexity” has increased unidirectionally after we had multicellar organisms inhabiting many of the world’s niches. (By the way, each organism becomes or makes niches for other organisms, so evolution creates new ways of life, but that doesn’t mean that “life is more complex”).

Finally, there are many organisms that have evolved to become less complex, as replicators that “de-evolve” some features may be favored in some environments. Parasites are a common example. Tapeworms, for example, used to be free-living flatworms, but when they invaded the guts of organisms they lost most of their nervous and sensory systems, their digestive system, and their genomes became much simpler.  Cave-dwelling organisms often lose their eyes: a decrease in complexity. Snakes used to be lizard-like organisms but have lost their limbs. Whales also lost their limbs. These examples are rife, and I won’t go on.  The point is that Comfort is either distorting what Dawkins says, distorting what the Modern Synthesis says or implies, or distorting what’s happened in evolution.

Touting the EES, Comfort tells us above that there are better books to reach for than The Selfish Gene if you wish to understand where the theory of evolution stands.  I would simply recommend Doug Futuyma and Mark Kirkpatrick’s high-level evolution textbook, simply called Evolution (Fifth Edition), published in 2022. To deal specifically with claims that the EES dismantles or greatly modifies the view of evolution in that textbook, you should read Doug Futuyma’s article below (click on the link). I’ve put its abstract below the title:

Abstract:

Evolutionary theory has been extended almost continually since the evolutionary synthesis (ES), but except for the much greater importance afforded genetic drift, the principal tenets of the ES have been strongly supported. Adaptations are attributable to the sorting of genetic variation by natural selection, which remains the only known cause of increase in fitness. Mutations are not adaptively directed, but as principal authors of the ES recognized, the material (structural) bases of biochemistry and development affect the variety of phenotypic variations that arise by mutation and recombination. Against this historical background, I analyse major propositions in the movement for an ‘extended evolutionary synthesis’. ‘Niche construction’ is a new label for a wide variety of well-known phenomena, many of which have been extensively studied, but (as with every topic in evolutionary biology) some aspects may have been understudied. There is no reason to consider it a neglected ‘process’ of evolution. The proposition that phenotypic plasticity may engender new adaptive phenotypes that are later genetically assimilated or accommodated is theoretically plausible; it may be most likely when the new phenotype is not truly novel, but is instead a slight extension of a reaction norm already shaped by natural selection in similar environments. However, evolution in new environments often compensates for maladaptive plastic phenotypic responses. The union of population genetic theory with mechanistic understanding of developmental processes enables more complete understanding by joining ultimate and proximate causation; but the latter does not replace or invalidate the former. Newly discovered molecular phenomena have been easily accommodated in the past by elaborating orthodox evolutionary theory, and it appears that the same holds today for phenomena such as epigenetic inheritance. In several of these areas, empirical evidence is needed to evaluate enthusiastic speculation. Evolutionary theory will continue to be extended, but there is no sign that it requires emendation.

No, evolution does not need a rebuild, and The Selfish Gene is not outmoded. It remains, for those who haven’t read it, a page-turner.

h/t reader John, who called my attention to Comfort’s article

Colossal & Co. at it again, trying to create “War Dogs”

October 26, 2026 • 10:25 am

Dogs are used by first responders and the military for a number of tasks.  Their keen sense of smell, speed, and keen hearing give them advantages over even drones or robots, and, according to Grok, trained dogs are used for a variety of tasks, including detecting explosives, providing security, locating enemies, doing sentry and perimeter work, and performing search and rescue.  Two other duties mentioned by Grok are these.

  • “Special operations support: High-risk missions (e.g., the dog Cairo on the 2011 bin Laden raid), including some aerial insertion (parachute or rappel with specialized gear).”
  • “Israel has used MWDs heavily for detection and assault in Gaza (with high attrition).”

Note the “high attrition”: this means that the dogs die, even though they don’t choose to go into service. This is all I’m using from Grok; the rest of the writing here is mine or comes from the three sources below.

The breeds of dogs used in service are mainly German shepherds, Belgian Malinois, and Labradors, and of course undergo a period of intensive training.  But, according to the Fortune article below, there’s a shortage of good “war dogs” (most of the mention of dogs in these articles involves military use):

The Army set up the K-9 Corps in 1942. Today the Department of War’s Military Working Dog Program has more than 2,200 dog teams, according to the company, and more than 80% of U.S. military working dogs are bought from Europe. Lamm cited a Senate Armed Services Committee warning that “due to the finite number of breeders overseas, as well as rising market demand, the cost… to procure whelped military working dogs from Europe is skyrocketing.” He also cited the American Kennel Club’s assessment that “there is now a shortage of even mediocre quality foreign dogs available.”

The U.S. is “competing against other country governments” for the same animals, Lamm said, China and Russia among them.

The losses after purchase are expensive, too. According to the company, fewer than half of the dogs bought are judged fit for service after a roughly three-year acquisition and training pipeline. That means the U.S. has to buy and train about 200 dogs today to field 100 working animals later.

But Mammon to the rescue! In stepped entrepreneurs and geneticists, in the form of Palmer Luckey (“an American entrepreneur and co-founder of defense technology company Anduril Industries“), Ben Lamm, billionaire entrepreneur and founder of our old friend Colossal Biosciences, the “de-extinction company,” and Dave Spirk, who will be the CEO of Warhound Corporation.

Warhound received over $200 million in seed funding, with investors including, according to Fortune, “In-Q-Tel, Sequoia Capital, ARK Invest, Franklin Templeton, 8VC, USIT, Bob Nelsen, Breyer Capital, CAZ Investments, Neogenesis, Builders VC and Lux Capital, among others.” Colossal also benefits: to quote Fortune again:

 Colossal licenses technology to Warhound and has an economic interest in it. Spinning companies out of Colossal’s research is “an intentional part of our model,” Lamm said.

How it’s being done (they’ve already started cloning trained dogs), and what will happen to the puppies, are described in the following three articles, though the archived Fortune article is the most informative. Scientific American is okay, but they still fall for Colossal’s hype. They say this:

Colossal Biosciences, which has a stake in Warhound and is providing much of the science, is no stranger to genetic engineering: last year the firm cloned and edited a gray wolf to create an animal that was genetically similar to the extinct dire wolf. The process for Warhound will look similar, Lamm says, but with modern dogs.

Nope. As I’ve pointed out, the “de-extincted dire wolf” is really a gray wolf with 20 DNA edits in 14 genes, producing an animal that is not “genetically similar to the extinct dire wolf”. [I corrected the earlier figures.] As I wrote on October 5, “Since gray wolves and dire wolves differ by 12 million DNA bases, the edits comprise only 0.0002% of the dire wolf genome. In other words, what Colossal produced, as anyone with neurons knows, is a grey wolf with a few morphological changes.”  I wouldn’t say that .0002% is a great deal of added similarity!

But I digress in my animus towards the crumbling Scientific American. Here are the three articles; click on the screenshot to read any.

From Scientific American:

From Fortune (archived):

From engadget:

The process will involve cloning service dogs that have proven to be great at their jobs, a process that first involves replacing the nucleus of an oocyte with the nucleus from a somatic (b0dy) cell of the chosen service dog. This nucleus-replaced egg cell is then genetically tweaked to make a number of edits; these edits are designed to remove genes causing defects like hip problems and cancer, as well as to add in bits of DNA that make dogs faster or better able to smell. Only a limited number of edits are possible (the faux “dire wolves” used 20), and you better know what the DNA bits you’re adding will do. This is a problem, as we don’t often know what genes are the ones causing problems.

The edited cells—you can make multiple clones by using different body cells from the same service dog—are then artificially fertilized using chemical stimulants, and these “fertilized” eggs are placed in a receptive surrogate mother dog.  The pregnant mom’s embryos are checked genetically to see if they indeed correspond to the cloned service dog, and are usually removed by Caesarian section, as were the faux “dire wolves”. This poses an ethical issue, as it involves making dogs pregnant who never get to see their pups.

Now cloning body cells without editing has been going on for some time as rich people have sought to replace their dead or aging pets with ones that are largely genetically similar. This runs about $50,000 to $100,000 per animal, and has a pretty high failure rate, as things can go wrong at any step. I quote Sci. Am.:

Cloning dogs is not a new science. Research has shown that cloning service dogs produces puppies that have many of the same desirable traits. But the process can be harmful, says Lisa Moses, a veterinarian and bioethicist at Harvard University. The rate of successful live offspring remains low among the cloned dogs, and the process can put the surrogate mother in danger.

Another ethical problem to ponder!  Once the cloned service dogs are removed from the surrogates and raised, they undergo training—after all, training is a behavioral and not a genetic modification—in the hopes that once you have puppies, not many of them will wash out.  In addition, they will be EQUIPPED WITH WAR STUFF. As Fortune says, quoting Lamm:

Anduril is supplying equipment including eye and ear protection, body armor, and integration with its Eagle Eye system, so that “dogs, handlers, and autonomous systems operate as one team.”

Now the first thing I asked myself when I read about this is, “Why not just artifically select service dogs with the desired traits and not breed from ones with defects?”  That’s a good question, as it might, in the end, be cheaper and easier.  On the other hand, if you have a great service dog, cloning will enable you to get many copies of the dog at once via multiple surrogates. But that itself leads to another problem: since the multiple surrogates are pretty much genetically identical (that’s what clones are), perpetuating the line might lead to serious problem with inbreeding.

The upside of cloning is, of course, pecuniary. If you can get great service dogs this way, you could secure a government contract to keep providing dogs to the military, and that could be very profitable. I suspect this, and not scientific advance, is the main motivation for the effort. After all, you could take the aggressive genes out of pit bulls, but that wouldn’t be profitable.

Another problem, which I’ve noted above, is figuring out the limited array of genes you want to edit. Sci Am. quotes another geneticist:

Both scientists and private companies have genetically edited dogs before, and the research can “accelerate really fast because genomics in dog breeds already has a lot of data,” says Ben Novak, chief scientist at Revive and Restore, who works on wildlife cloning for conservation. Researchers have edited dogs to tweak genes for hip dysplasia, make them hypoallergenic and treat muscle disease, although the long-term health effects of these changes remain unclear.

But optimizing traits at scale and across service dogs could take time—and leave room for unintended consequences, Novak adds.

“It can be hard to figure out exactly what genetic element is creating a trait,” he says, “and some traits can be the combinations of hundreds or thousands of mutations across genes.”

Traits like smelling ability and running speed are, no doubt, “polygenic,” involving several to many genes, and changing just a couple may not effect much change in the War Dogs.

Finally, I’ve mentioned some ethical problems. Although the project is touted as being “certified by the American Humane Society,” I’m not sure what kind of certification will prevent problems like this (from Sci Am):

“It is by no means a perfect science, and by that, I mean it’s still a fairly inefficient process,” Moses says. “It requires a lot of dogs to have invasive things done to them and to be killed in order to produce one cloned puppy.”

Finally (again from Sci. Am.), cloning can have unintended detrimental effects that aren’t known until later, as Ben Novak notes above.

I don’t know any way this can be done without either producing unwanted dogs, killing or harming the surrogates, or producing genetically defective dogs when the cloning goes wrong. In my view, the Humane Society’s certification is premature.

Will the War Dogs program produce what’s intended? Who knows? It’s more likely to succeed than the ludicrous efforts to “de-exinct” Woolly Mammoths, Thylacines, or Dodos, projects that in the end won’t produce any de-extinction nor make Colossal any money.

Three scientists nab Nobel for Physiology or Medicine for work on optogenetics, one physicist wins for work on neutrinos

October 6, 2026 • 8:15 am

I completely missed the Nobel award in biology yesterday, but I see that one has been awarded this morning in physics. The former involves three scientists, the latter a lone physicist.

The Medicine or Physiology prize release is here. It describes advances in “optogenetics,” the use of optical signals to detect how neurons work. It’s very clever, based on an algal protein, rhodopsin, that is activated by light and, when put in a nerve cell, will create an impulse when the cell is illuminated by blue light.

There’s a clear discussion of the Prize-winning research at The Conversation (click below to read):

A summary:

Scientists who worked out how to control brain cells with light have won this year’s Nobel prize in physiology or medicine. Karl Deisseroth, Peter Hegemann and Georg Nagel were honoured for their research into “light-gated ion channels and optogenetics”.

Peter Hegemann, at Humboldt University of Berlin, and Georg Nagel, at the University of Würzburg, wanted to understand how a tiny, single-celled alga called Chlamydomonas senses light. Light-sensing is not unique to animals with eyes: organisms throughout the living world use light to detect their surroundings and respond to changes in their environment. Even single-cell organisms have proteins that respond to light. These proteins are used to move towards or away from light, to generate energy and to respond to the various demands of a 24-hour day.

Hegemann and Nagel discovered that Chlamydomonas has a beautifully ingenious mechanism of light detection that relies on a single protein called channelrhodopsin.

Channelrhodopsin is built into the outer membrane of the algal cell. Part of the protein faces the water outside the cell and part faces the inside. The protein also contains a small molecule called retinaldehyde, which is able to absorb light.

When light hits the retinaldehyde inside channelrhodopsin, it changes shape. This makes the channelrhodopsin protein change shape too. That change opens a tiny passage through the cell membrane. Positively charged particles, including sodium, can then flow from the water outside the alga into the cell. This movement of charged particles sends a signal inside the alga that helps it swim.

The researchers realised that if they could put channelrhodopsin into nerve cells, they might be able to switch those cells on simply by shining a light on them. That is exactly what Hegemann, Nagel and the third Nobel-prize winner, Karl Deisseroth, a psychiatrist and bioengineer at Stanford University in California, went on to do.

. . . and how it’s used, with a cool example:

The ability to control nerve cells with light is called optogenetics. It has become a powerful research tool because scientists can use it to switch specific groups of nerve cells on and off and see what happens.

First, scientists deliver the gene for channelrhodopsin to the nerve cells they want to study. The gene is usually carried into the cells by a virus that has been altered so that it cannot cause disease. The cells then make the channelrhodopsin protein, which makes them respond to light.

In animals such as mice, scientists can shine light into the brain through a thin optical fibre. When the light reaches the cells, channelrhodopsin opens and the cells become active. Nearby nerve cells that do not contain the protein are unaffected.

Light can be aimed at a very small part of the brain and switched on and off extremely quickly. This makes optogenetics a powerful way to investigate how the brain works. For example, if scientists want to know whether a particular group of nerve cells is involved in memory, sleep, sensation or movement, say, they can switch those cells on with light and see what happens.

In one experiment in 2012, a team at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology gave mice a mild electric shock in a particular cage. They used optogenetics to tag the nerve cells in the brain’s memory centre that were active during that the fear-conditioning experiment. Days later, in a different cage, they switched those cells on with light. The mice froze in fear, as if they remembered the shock.

Mice that were not shocked did not freeze, which showed that the light was reactivating a specific memory. Deisseroth was one of the study’s authors.

***************************************

And the press release for the physics prize is here. An excerpt:

Francis Halzen realised that ice at the South Pole could be used to track particles known as neutrinos. His vision and scientific leadership have been fundamental for the IceCube Neutrino Observatory – a cubic kilometre of ice that is equipped with light sensors. Using IceCube, researchers can capture neutrinos from extremely energy-rich processes in the distant universe.

Neutrinos are everywhere, but they do not make themselves known. They pass all the way through the Earth and through our bodies without us noticing. Very rarely, a single neutrino will interact with an atomic nucleus, which makes it possible for someone with the right equipment to discover them.

Scientists have long known that the cosmos contains natural particle accelerators, which fire out particles with energies up to a million times more than can be achieved in laboratories on Earth. Much about these sources is mysterious: what are they, where are they, and what are the main processes inside them?

Neutrinos with extremely high energies are created in the same environments as other types of particles. However, unlike other particles, neutrinos reach us without changing direction or losing energy. This means they can provide information that is not available in any other way.

Francis Halzen first presented his vision for capturing neutrinos at the South Pole in 1988. When a neutrino collides with an atomic nucleus, it produces a flash of light that can be tracked by sensors in the clear glacial ice. The South Pole’s ice has many advantages, as it is free from various types of interference and the area is geologically stable, with no earthquakes. Halzen and his idea soon gained the support of other researchers and, just a few years later, preliminary testing was conducted on sensors in ice.

Cosmic neutrinos with extremely high energies are very rare, so an enormous volume of ice is needed to observe an adequate number of collisions. IceCube covers an entire cubic kilometre and was finished in 2011. Researchers soon discovered the first high-energy neutrinos and, a few years later, could publish their discovery of neutrinos that must originate far outside our solar system. The search for the universe’s neutrino sources could begin in earnest.

“Francis Halzen has led an international team of researchers and engineers who have provided us with a fantastic instrument. His tenacity and scientific vision has paved the way for a new kind of astronomy,” says Mark Pearce, Chair of the Nobel Committee for Physics.

The neutrino interactions that are continuously collected by IceCube will provide researchers with novel knowledge about the violent settings in which high-energy neutrinos can be created – and could even reveal previously unknown cosmic phenomena.

Here’s the apparatus and how it works, taken from the Nobel Prize press release. See if you can read it by clicking to enlarge. The observed ice and detectors are buried way underground. Just getting this damn thing set up at the South Pole would merit a prize by itself!

Now perhaps some reader with expertise can tell us in the comments why high-energy neutrinos from outside the solar system are so important compared to lower-energy neutrinos from, say, the Sun.

A self-aggrandizing post concerning a paper on speciation I wrote with Allen Orr

August 24, 2026 • 9:30 am

What is an old, retired scientist to do but look back on his career and find satisfaction in the good ideas he once had? (I just finished a great novel in which a superannuated Cuban musician does the same thing.) In line with that, reader Nick called my attention to a two-year-old video by Zach Hancock lauding a paper I wrote with my student, Allen Orr, as “one of the ten most influential papers in evolution.”

First, though, in April I bragged about another video by Zach Hancock (a professor at Augusta University) that put my book Speciation (also co-written with Allen Orr), as one of the ten most influential books in evolutionary biology (we were #10). I have to admit that I consider this book my most significant accomplishment in science, as it distilled the field of speciation down to a research program that succeeded in influencing research in the origin of species. It took us six years (each) to write.

I rarely look at Speciation now, though, for when I do I realize that when we wrote it I was at the top of my neuronal game, able to read, write, and synthesize far better than I do now. And when I open it and sample a page or so from the chapters I wrote, I think to myself, “Who is that guy? He was really savvy?!” I could not write it now, nor will either of us revise it.

But Zack had another video that I missed,  one on the ten most influential papers in evolutionary biology. And again Allen and I made the list, coming it at #9 with the paper below we published in 1989 in Evolution. Note the dedication to Bruce Grant, under whom both of us studied at William and Mary (click title to read the paper):

I’ll add that this paper was at first rejected by Evolution on one reviewer’s claim that we could not use the method of correlation that we did, but the reviewer simply didn’t understand that method (it’s not rocket science). We argued with the editor, something I’d never done, and the paper was accepted.

Zack chooses papers in the field that have been cited more than a thousand times. and I’ll let him explain the findings in his video below (the discussion of our paper goes from 5:23 to 7:51).

A few corrections. To determine the relative divergence time between pairs of species or taxa, we used published data using genetic distance determined by gel electrophoresis; we did not “sequence genes”.  The purpose of the paper, as Zack says, is to determine how reproductive barriers between species arise with time by looking at the degree of reproductive isolation (measured only as hybrid sterility/inviability or as mate discrimination) between groups and correlating that with electrophoretic genetic distance, which is a measure of divergence time.

Also, Zack emphasizes the “reinforcement” aspect of the paper (I’ve put that conclusion in bold below), but that is only one of its findings—granted, a nice one. But the overall conclusions are several-fold, as the paper’s abstract notes below, including the relative rates of evolution of postzygotic isolation versus one form of prezygotic isolation (mate discrimination) as well as showing early evolution of male versus female postzygotic isolation, which explains the phenomenon of “Haldane’s Rule“, a generalization first noticed by J. B. S. Haldane in 1922, but neglected until I took it up in 1985.  This rule, pointing out the greater preponderance of sterility and inviability in heterogametic (XY or ZW) hybrids than in homogametic hybrids (XX and ZZ) is still subject to investigation and controversy, but has been a central focus of the genetics of speciation since 1985.

Here’s the abstract of our paper with the “reinforcement” finding shown in bold. Note the other findings, too:

To investigate the time course of speciation, we gathered literature data on 119 pairs of closely related Drosophila species with known genetic distances, mating discrimination, strength of hybrid sterility and inviability, and geographic ranges. Because genetic distance is correlated with divergence time, these data provide a cross-section of taxa at different stages of speciation.

Mating discrimination and the sterility or inviability of hybrids increase gradually with time. Hybrid sterility and inviability evolve at similar rates. Among allopatric species, mating discrimination and postzygotic isolation evolve at comparable rates, but among sympatric species strong mating discrimination appears well before severe sterility or inviability. This suggests that prezygotic reproductive isolation may be reinforced when allopatric taxa become sympatric.

Analysis of the evolution of postzygotic isolation shows that recently diverged taxa usually produce sterile or inviable male but not female hybrids. Moreover, there is a large temporal gap between the evolution of male-limited and female hybrid sterility or inviability. This gap, which is predicted by recent theories about the genetics of speciation, explains the overwhelming preponderance of hybridizations yielding male-limited hybrid sterility or inviability (Haldane’s rule).

Finally, Allen and I continued to collect data as new studies became available, eventually expanding the study to 171 taxon pairs—an increase of 41% in the amount of data. The results, published in Evolution in 1997, were similar to those of the earlier study, but stronger because they were based on more data. You can read the paper by clicking below.

Since electrophoretic analysis of species divergence is largely obsolete—everyone uses DNA sequencing now—the whole paper can’t be repeated with modern methods, but what has been done is analysis of a subset of species, and, as I recall (I’m not going to look up the papers), the results to date support those of our 1989 and 1997 papers.

A scientist is lucky if he or she has more than one or two good ideas in their career, and by that I mean an idea that influences their field in a substantial way. I’ve had about three, one of which is the analysis embodied in these two papers. And I have to pay tribute to Allen Orr (now retired, too): fiercely intelligent and hard-working—more a colleague than my graduate student. Both of us are honored to be included in the lists of ten books and ten papers discussed by Hancock. Josh and Esther Lederberg, W. D. Hamilton. Ronald Fisher, Sewall Wright—that is damn fine company!

Neanderthals are Homo sapiens, not a different species, and may have disappeared because of repeated interbreeding with H. sapiens who emigrated from Africa to Eurasia

August 6, 2026 • 9:45 am

I came across the following post by Professor David Hillis of the University of Texas at Austin, an evolutionist I much admire for his perspicacity and malleability: his ability to contribute to several different fields, including herpetology. (He also breeds longhorn cattle on his Double Helix Ranch in the Hill Country.)  Of course one reason I respect his work is because many of his conclusions agree with mine!

One of them is his adherence to the Biological Species Concept formulated by Ernst Mayr, which basically states that two populations belong to the same species if, when they contact each other in nature, they can produce fertile hybrids. If they can’t for any reason, then they are members of different species. Nearly all evolutionists adhere to some form of the BSC, but I won’t go into the concept in depth as it, its problems and problems with alternative species concepts are covered in detail in my book Speciation written with Allen Orr.

One long-standing question in evolutionary anthropology is whether Neanderthals were a different species from “modern” Homo sapiens.  Some anthropologists say they were different species, the former called H. neanderthalensis and the latter H. sapiens. But there is ample genetic evidence for interbreeding of the two forms in Eurasia, and for fertility of the hybrids, for many people outside of Africa carry Neanderthal genes. I myself have a small fraction of Neanderthal genes in my DNA. This kind of data is prima facie evidence that when the two groups were in contact, that they produced hybrids and also that those hybrids were fertile, backcrossing to modern H. sapiens.

At best, then, I consider the two forms to be subspecies: somewhat differentiated populations that were members of the same species. Those who agree with this, like me and Hillis, see the subspecies as H. sapiens sapiens and H. sapiens neanderthalensis.

The Neanderthals evolved from a hominin population that came to Eurasia out of Africa about 400,000 years ago.  They persisted until about 40,000 years ago, when they (identifiable by fossil features; see below) mysteriously disappeared.

There have been several hypotheses accounting for the disappearance of the Neanderthals. They include demographic fluctuations or inbreeding leading to disappearance of the species, extinction due to inability to survive changes in the environment (there was glaciation when Neanderthals lived), competition (including aggression) from “modern” H. sapiens who left Africa to populate the world about 60,000 years ago, and “extinction through interbreeding”, which is the hypothesis supported by a new paper discussed below in Nature Scientific Reports. I should add that “modern” H. sapiens arose in Africa about 300,000 years ago.

Click both screenshots to go to the comment and the paper.

This paper, by Swiss and Italian authors, shows that “extinction via interbreeding” is at least possible under reasonable and conservative conditions obtaining at the known times of extinction.  Successive waves of H. sapiens coming out of Africa, they posit, interbred with Neanderthals and eventually, because the sapiens were far more numerous than Neanderthals, the Neanderthal genome became absorbed into the modern population of H. sapiens.  Click to read; it’s highly mathematical and you should read just the abstract, introduction, and conclusions:

Here are a few of the assumptions:

  • Neanderthals consisted of tribes of about 500-1000 individuals, subdivided into “bands” of 25-50 individuals.
  • The total population of Neanderthals was about 5000-7000 individuals
  • The population of H. sapiens was ten to a hundred times larger than this
  • Repeated waves of H. sapiens came out of Africa, comprising an effectively infinite reservoir of individuals and genes
  • The genetic data in modern H. sapiens shows repeated instances of introgression

The upshot:  The “genetic dilution” or “extinction through interbreeding” hypothesis can be supported by a reasonable mathematical model that takes into account evidence of population sizes and times of migration, and accounts for the genetic data. This does not mean, of course, that this is why the Neanderthals disappeared. It could have been another scenario or perhaps a combination of this scenario with others. Mathematical models can only tell us what is possible, not what is true.  But the paper does show that an interbreeding scenario cannot be ruled out.

And the genetic data we do have, including ancient DNA data from Neanderthal bones, shows that we and Neanderthals are brothers and sisters: members of the same species. There were other distinct biological species that arose during hominin evolution, but Neanderthals and modern humans were almost surely “conspecific.”

The paper’s conclusions:

The mathematical model we presented provides a plausible explanation for the gradual disappearance of Neanderthals, suggesting that their genetic assimilation with H. sapiens, a demographically much larger species, may have been a significant factor in their decline. Rather than sudden extinction, our model proposes that repeated cycles of H. sapiens immigration leading to the Neanderthal gene dilution, could account for the Neanderthals’ disappearance and the observed patterns of Neanderthal ancestry in modern human populations. Although this model provides a possible robust genetic explanation, it is important to note that it does not exclude other possible contributing factors that were not considered in our approach, such as environmental changes, competition, or demographic fluctuations. Evidence of interbreeding and genetic introgression supports the notion that H. sapiens and Neanderthals interacted extensively over thousands of years. Therefore, the interplay of genetic, demographic, and environmental factors likely contributed to the complex process of Neanderthal demise.

Future studies incorporating both genetic and archaeological data will be crucial in refining our understanding of this pivotal moment in human evolution.

Here’s a Neanderthal skull showing distinctive subspecific features (from Wikipedia):

Jason Potter at en.wikipedia, CC BY-SA 2.5 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.5&gt;, via Wikimedia Commons

Colossal and Trump administration cooperate to sequence and store DNA of endangered species

June 28, 2026 • 10:15 am

Carl Zimmer and Catrin Einhorn are the authors of a new article in the NYT about our old friend Colossal Biosciences, which you’ll remember as the outfit in Texas that has promised to “de-extinct” the woolly mammoth, the thylacine (marsupial “wolf”), the dodo and the moa, after having claimed that they’ve already de-extincted the “dire wolf”.

As I’ve written at length here (and in an article in the Boston Globe), Colossal has not de-extincted anything. It simply edited 14 genes in a gray wolf cell, and then put that cell into the nucleus of a domestic dog egg. What came out were three slightly tweaked gray wolves, white in color and, Colossal says, larger than  normal wolves. But 14 changed genes in a genome of about 20,000 protein-coding genes, and having 2.5 billion DNA bases, does not turn a gray wolf into a dire wolf. Their response was that a dire wolf is anything that you think resembles a dire wolf, no matter how much. That is disingenuous.

I lost respect from Colossal when they decided to double down on their claim that they’ve brought something back from extinction, which they surely have not.  And their claims that they will release these things into the wild—their ultimate aim—is ridiculous. The three faux white dire wolves (I doubt the original was even white) are kept secretly on an enclosure somewhere in the West, with only a few toadying journalists or donors allowed to visit them.

Likewise, Colossal’s promise to give us woolly mammoths by 2028 is unbelievable, for they won’t be able to put an engineered Asian elephant egg into the endangered Asian elephant, much less produce a creature that has more than a minute fraction of mammoth DNA. On top of that, Colossal says their aim is to release these faux mammoths on the tundra, which won’t happen, and that when they do so, it will help with global warming since the furry elephants’ trampling on the permafrost will prevent release of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, ameliorating global warming.  Gullible donors like Paris Hilton, Tiger Woods, and Tom Brady have swelled Colossal’s coffers by $400 million, and it’s now worth, notes the article below, more than $10 billion.

I think that when Colossal realized it couldn’t make good on its de-extinction promises, it started investing in other projects.  One of them is described in this article in the NYT (click below or find it archived here). What they propose to do, with the promised help of the Trump administration, is save the DNA from endangered species.  Now this project has its good aspects, for if Colossal sequences a lot of new genomes and publishes the sequences (which it promises to make public), we could learn quite a bit about evolution. And the American taxpayer doesn’t have to foot the bill for any of it.  But Colossal has no experience in “biodiversity banking” of this sort, even though nonprofit conservation organizations like the San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance has been doing it for over half a century (Colossal is decidely a for-profit company). The San Diego noprofit has in fact created clones of black-footed ferrets, a highly endangered species, from biobanked material, so at least it has something useful to show for its efforts.

Further, if Colossal is doing this for “de-extinction” purposes, and will retain sole possession of the material, as it will do, then it is preventing other organizations or scientists from using what is “banked.” The U.S. government has no business partnering with such an enterprise.  I don’t worry about de-extinction because that is (pardon the pun) a dead issue. But the concentration on biobanking may, as the authors note, “erode support for on-the-ground conservation,” which mainly involves saving existing habitat and keeping humans from destroying new habitat.

A few quotes from the article, which, as science journalism should, maintains a neutral viewpoint while emphasizing both pros and cons:

The Trump administration and a company that is promising to bring long-gone animals back from extinction announced a partnership on Thursday to preserve cells, tissue and DNA from threatened and endangered species.

The company, Colossal Biosciences, said its goal was to store samples from every animal and plant protected under the Endangered Species Act, which includes more than 2,300 listings worldwide.

As more species face the risk of extinction, scientists see such biobanks as a critical backup. But concerns are also growing that the rise of genetic engineering and efforts to revive extinct species will erode support for on-the-ground conservation, which often requires protecting habitat from drilling, mining and other development.

The announcement comes as the Trump administration has been rolling back protections on land and water, including through actions to weaken the Endangered Species Act, in favor of expanded oil and gas exploration, commercial fishing and other economic activities.

“This partnership brings together the scientific expertise of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the ingenuity of the private sector to develop new tools that can help recover species, preserve critical genetic resources, and strengthen the future of wildlife conservation,” Doug Burgum, the interior secretary, said in a statement.

Under a memorandum of understanding, Colossal and the Fish and Wildlife Service will collaborate to identify high-priority actions, and the government will provide a list of which species it wants to prioritize.

Well, I’d prefer that a consortium of scientists decide which species should be prioritized, and I’d prefer that the material be given to the San Diego Zoo organization rather than to Colossal, which will have sole use of the material and is a for-profit organization. The agreement is supposed to run for five years, and that Colossal gets to keep all the samples it collected with its own funding, equipment, or personnel”, which means pretty much all the samples.

Colossal has been busy doing other stuff, too:

After beginning its de-extinction efforts, Colossal branched out into biobanking. In February, the company announced a partnership with the United Arab Emirates to build what it calls a BioVault in Dubai, intended to store cell and tissue samples from more than 10,000 species.

Why Dubai? Why not store all the material in one place? Who knows? And they clone pets!

[Colossal] currently gets revenue from cloning pets and horses through a company it acquired last year, and claims to have future sources of revenue from licensing technology it develops for its de-extinction projects.

The article notes some criticism of Colossal’s proposal, too (I’m not quoting the criticism of the “de-extinction” endeavors, which the article also mentions):

But some conservation biologists expressed worries about depending so much for the long-term guardianship of precious samples on a private company.

“It seems like a bit of a risk for the U.S. government to place biomaterials in a for-profit company that doesn’t have a very long track record,” said Oliver Ryder, a conservation geneticist at the San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance, which operates a storage effort called the Frozen Zoo that has been preserving cells for about 50 years.

and

Gabriela Mastromonaco, chief science officer at the Toronto Zoo, called the U.S. plan laid out in Thursday’s announcement hugely ambitious.

“To collect every threatened and endangered species, that is a massive endeavor,” she said. “That means tracking, trapping, immobilizing, and getting your hands on a lot of animals.”

She expressed concern that the initial announcement was short on planning details that would be standard in many other nations.

. . . Dr. Mastromonaco of the Toronto Zoo said the announcement left many questions unanswered, such as how Indigenous communities would participate in decisions about the program and the rules for who gets to use the samples for research. She said she was addressing these questions herself as Canada develops its own plan for biobanking wild species.

and

Concerns that genetic engineering would replace critical conservation work heightened when Mr. Burgum, the interior secretary, celebrated the company’s announcement on X, writing that “the marvel of ‘de-extinction’ technology can help forge a future where populations are never at risk.” The Fish and Wildlife Service is part of the Interior Department.

Colossal executives emphasize that their efforts are intended to add to conservation strategies, not supplant the important work of protecting habitat.

I guess Colossal needs government cooperation since that’s required to collect DNA samples from endangered species. But if Colossal is dong this “for public good and impact” as Colossal CEO Ben Lamm has said, why do they retain the sole right to use the material? Even if it’s collected by Colossal, the permission to do so has to come from the U.S. government, and we should not be entangled with a private, for-profit company that will store material only it can use.

I see Colossal as having provided some valuable knowledge, but also largely as a pack of grifters, making promises they cannot keep and distorting what they have done.  In my view they should stick to cloning Fido and Fluffy for rich pet-owners who want to “de-extinct” their postmortem pets.

h/t: Don

Readers’ wildlife photos

June 3, 2026 • 8:30 am

Leucism, the absence of pigment in all or parts of the body in animals, is a genetic condition often mistaken for albinism (leucistic animals havenormally pigmented eyes).  It’s found in all sorts of animals, from reptiles to mammals, and Scott Ritchie has spotted it in Australian ducks.  Scott sent some pictures, which you can enlarge by clicking on them, and his captions are indented:

The leucistic Plumed Whistling Duck (Dendrocygna eytoni), is back at Hasties Swamp, Queensland, the white one in in middle.  We  have seen it for at least 2 years running. And “he/she” appears to have busy, with at least one (several white light feathers head and breast), and perhaps 3 (2 based on “forehead” feathers) individuals showing leucicism traits. It’s interesting that they were hanging together at the log to the left of the hide.

This last picture is of normal-type duck: