Why Evolution is True is a blog written by Jerry Coyne, centered on evolution and biology but also dealing with diverse topics like politics, culture, and cats.
Romantic comedies, or “rom-coms”, are making their return, or so I’ve noticed. Grok agrees, citing the recent movies “Anyone But You,” “The Idea of You,” “Finding Emily,” and “The Invite” (I’ve seen the last one, which is well worth watching and is more serious than the two movies discussed below.)
I’m not drawn to this genre in particular, but there are times when you need a feel-good movie with a happy ending (yes, a happy ending is a requite for a good rom-com). After watching “The Invite” (it has a sort-of-happy ending), I thought back about the rom-coms I’ve watched, and two of them came to mind.
The first is the 1999 movie “Notting Hill,” which I love because it has a great plot, superb casting and acting, a happy ending, a lot of twists and turns, and of course features my heartthrob Julia Roberts. (Her best performance is not in a rom-com but in the 2000 film “Erin Brockovich“, for which she won a well-deserved Oscar for Best Actress. ) Hugh Grant is also great, although some critics say he’s just playing himself (I disagree).
“Notting Hill”‘s most famous scene is below when, after ups and downs, Julia Roberts, playing a rich, famous actress named Anna Scott (basically herself) gets involved with Hugh Grant, a Brit who owns a bookstore in London. She realizes that she loves him, and comes to his bookshop to try to keep the relationship alive by asking for another chance. The clip below shows that scene and its setting, featuring Roberts’s famous line, “I’m also just a girl, standing in front of a boy, asking him to love her”. She loses it during the last five words: terrific acting. Grant thinks that he’s not up to have his heart broken again, which he thinks would be inevitable with two people having such different lives. And so she departs.
Afterwards, Grant asks his extended family what to do about her, and at first they all agree the relationship is a no-go. Then Grant’s disheveled Welsh roommate hears what she told him and calls Grant “a daft prick” for not continuing the romance. That leads to the happy ending (not shown).
The other is “When Harry Met Sally” (1989) starring Meg Ryan and Billy Crystal. I’ll show two scenes about the differences between men and women. In the first, below, Harry (Crystal) explains to an unbelieving Sally why men and women can’t be friends. (They are driving, by the way, from the University of Chicago to New York.) The terrific screenplay was by Nora Ephron, and the director was Rob “Meathead” Reiner):
But of course the most famous scene in that movie is the “fake orgasm” segment filmed in Katz’s Deli in New York. (There’s still a sign over the table where they sat, and people vie to sit there too.). This is a classic scene of movies in any genre. The topper, the line “I’ll have what she’s having,” was not written by Ephron but suggested by Crystal in a read-through and delivered here by Rob Reiner’s mother Estelle.
Oh, hell, I’ll throw in the last scene, too: the happy ending on New Year’s Eve. Nora Ephron was a terrific screenwriter.
There are two other great rom-coms that come to mind: “Sleepless in Seattle” (1993, directed by Nora Ephron and starring Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan) and “You’ve Got Mail” (1998; also starring Hanks and Ryan, with a screenplay Nora Ephron). I can’t be arsed to put up iconic scenes, mainly because I can’t think of any, but I did like those movies. However, “Notting Hill” and “When Harry Met Sally” top my list of best recent movies in this genre (I’m not considering ones that came out before my time.)
I’m probably forgetting some films, and here is where readers should chime in. Feel free to disagree with my choices or suggest ones you think are better.
Bill Maher’s latest “Real Time” monologue plumps for a centric position between Peak Woke and Republican “full asshole”. He goes after Trump’s Cabinet, including Kristi Noem and Pete Hegseth, and also has a few choice words about Musk and Ramaswamy—all, he says, “a team of dicks.”
But he also makes fun of patronizing “lawn sign” Democrats, which, he says, was tiresome to Americans (you know the lawn sign, and yes, it was a tiresome example of virtue signaling). Also in his sights are land acknowledgements, acceptance of shoplifting, and denigration of standardized tests.
Maher is a classical liberal, so he’s not advocating, I think, for absolute centrism, but more centrism on the left than many people have.
The people on the panel (not shown this week) were attorney and journalist Aaron Parnas and Politico‘s Dasha Burns.
In case you’ve been in Mongolia and haven’t seen the Virtue Lawn Signs, here’s one from Signs of Justice. Every time I see one of these (yes, they’re still around), I have a moment of dyspepsia.
. . . and just for grins, here’s a Jewish Virtue lawn sign that I found on Facebook (h/t Melissa Steinberg Brodsky). Believe me, if you put one of these up it would be removed in a day, and you’d be demonized.
Thank Ceiling Cat that readers are sending in photos again. I actually have one batch in reserve!
Today’s photos come from UC Davis ecologist Susan Harrison, highlighting the Birds of Fall. Don’t miss the lovely Wood Ducks at the end. Susan’s captions and IDs are indented, and you can enlarge the photos by clicking on them.
Fall (bird) colors
As the season has gone rapidly from golden to gray in Ashland, Oregon, my most exciting bird experience was the flock of Gray-crowned Rosy-finches (Leucosticte tephrocotis) gracing the summit of Mt. Ashland (7,500’). These remarkable little birds live in alpine zones, where in spring and summer they hunt insects trapped in snowfields. As winter approaches they move down in search of seeds and fruits, while still sticking to cold and open environments. Mt. Ashland with its tiny expanse of near-alpine vegetation is an occasional stopover for them.
Seeing 30+ of them at “Mt. A” was already a thrill, but even more significantly to local birders, this flock was a mix of two geographic forms (subspecies, to some): “Brown-cheeked,” found in the interior western US, and “Hepburn’s” with its all-gray face, which is more coastal and northerly. These birds are evidently not fussy about the migratory company they keep.
Two Brown-cheeked (first two) and two Hepburn’s Gray-crowned (last two) Rosy-finches:
Morning view of Mt. Shasta, seen while searching for Rosy-finches:
The second best recent sighting I had was of Varied Thrushes (Ixorius naevius) eating the last few pears on our neighbor’s trees. These lovely birds always make me think of an American Robin with an upgraded trim package. Unusual numbers of forest seed- and fruit-eating birds have been on the move this fall, looking for winter resources, and Varied Thrushes may be part of this “irruption”.
Varied Thrush:
Varied Thrushes, converted from a not-sharp-enough photo to an Impressionist work by ChatGPT:
During my early morning Varied Thrush – pear tree stakeout, many other birds stopped by.
Welcome to Sunday, November 15, 2026: Sabbath for goyische cats and National Raisin Bran Cereal Day. This is one of the few cereals I’ll eat, though I never buy the stuff (I also eat granola if it’s not half candy-fied). The cereal has a long history involving its name:
Skinner’s Raisin-BRAN was the first raisin bran brand on the market, introduced in the United States in 1926 by the Skinner Manufacturing Company. For 17 years, Skinner had ownership over the product’s name, until Kellogg’s and Post began to sell their own versions of raisin bran. With concerns of losing money within grocery store sales, Skinner filed a cease-and-desist in an attempt to keep ownership over his raisin bran product.
The name “Raisin-BRAN” was at one time trademarked by Skinner, however in 1944 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit found:
The name “Raisin-BRAN” could not be appropriated as a trade-mark, because: “A name which is merely descriptive of the ingredients, qualities or characteristics of an article of trade cannot be appropriated as a trademark and the exclusive use of it afforded legal protection. The use of a similar name by another to truthfully describe his own product does not constitute a legal or moral wrong, even if its effect be to cause the public to mistake the origin or ownership of the product.
Now, any brand or manufacturer may create their own version of raisin bran and name it just that.
So, be careful when you’re buying it as it’s not a proprietary name. Actually, after I wrote this I went grocery shopping and, hungry for Raisin Bran, looked at it in the store. It was NINE DOLLARS FOR A BOX! This is what happens when you haven’t bought cereal in a long time. I gave it a pass.
Federal officials said the cascading communications failures that forced the government to shut down flights across the United States on Friday started with a contractor upgrading air traffic control equipment, replacing copper wire with fiber optic cable.
The upgrade set off communications failures across the facilities that manage the national air space, the officials said. Alarmed at the scope of the problem, the Federal Aviation Administration decided to issue a rare nationwide ground stop for several hours.
Speaking at news conference in Washington, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said that the specific problem with the upgrade, which took place in what he called a “remote” facility, was not yet known. The contractor, L3Harris, has worked for the Federal Aviation Administration for decades, he said.
Mr. Duffy said his agency was trying to determine whether the problem had been caused by the contractor’s incompetence or faulty equipment. “We haven’t determined what the fault was,” he said. He added, “We’re going to hold people accountable.”
The F.A.A. administrator, Bryan Bedford, said there was no evidence the communication problems had stemmed from a cyberattack or the use of artificial intelligence.
Mr. Bedford said that he expected the system to be back to normal by Sunday night. “The worst is behind us,” he said.
But even though the system came back online Friday evening, the effects of the shutdown were vast and continued on Saturday.
Travelers across the United States were still facing delays and cancellations on Saturday as airlines and airports struggled to recover from the ground stop.
The NBC news on Friday said night that flights might still be affected during the Thanksgiving holidays, and since I’m flying then, I’m concerned—but not all that concerned. Imagine the money that this glitch cost; will the contractor have to pay for it?
Iran’s military said on Saturday that fires had broken out on a total of three oil tankers that struck mines in the Strait of Hormuz.
Tehran has insisted vessels obtain its authorization to cross the strait since war erupted with the United States in February, and has attacked ships that do not comply.
“A short while ago, two oil tankers that had switched off their radar and positioning systems and were secretly attempting to transit the Strait of Hormuz through an unauthorized route exploded and caught fire after striking a naval mine,” the Revolutionary Guards Corps said in a statement on the incident in the south of the waterway, carried by the Iranian state broadcaster early on Saturday.
A separate statement from Iran’s conventional navy said another tanker “navigating through the unsafe and prohibited zone east of the Strait of Hormuz with its tracking and identification systems switched off, caught fire and was forced to stop after striking a naval mine”.
The statements did not provide the names or origins of the vessels but the Guards said one of those hit in south Hormuz was a supertanker.
If Trump needed any excuse to resume hostilities with Iran, this is one. We can’t even keep the Strait of Hormuz open, so Iran still has the upper hand in that respect. Meanwhile, at the same link, Israel is reported as reaching the limits of its patience:
Invoking Iran’s pursuit to rebuild its nuclear program, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Saturday it’s time to eliminate the threat from Iran “once and for all” in a speech about forming a new government following a meeting earlier this week with opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot.
“The Iranian regime, which seeks to destroy Israel, is once again working to revive its nuclear program,” Netanyahu said, translated from Hebrew. “And let this be clear: This murderous regime, which did not hesitate to murder many thousands of its own people, will not hesitate to use nuclear weapons against us.”
“It will do so the moment it manages to resume uranium enrichment and the accelerated development of nuclear weapons,” he continued.
Netanyahu said he met with Eisenkot on Thursday, and the meeting “only strengthened my understanding of how essential it is to establish a national unity government at this time.”
Eisenkot, who may be the next PM of Israel, was head of the IDF, is still in the IDF as well, and it looks as if he’s okay with going after Iran since he’s historically been a hawk on Israel’s security. If nobody does anything, the war will fizzle out, oil prices will remain high, the people of Iran will remain oppressed, and Iran can boast that it’s defeated the U.S. Not to mention that Iran will get busy trying to build nuclear weapons. Is this what most Democrats want? Apparently.
The Pan American Health Organization, an international health body, has revoked the U.S.’s measles elimination status, people familiar with the matter said, a stunning reversal for a nation that has kept the vaccine-preventable disease at bay for decades.
The U.S. achieved measles elimination status in 2000 after robust immunization campaigns and the creation of a program that made shots free for millions of children.
Many public health experts and epidemiologists expected the U.S. to lose elimination status, as outbreaks over the past two years have exploded to highs not seen in decades. States such as Pennsylvania, New York and Wisconsin reported five measles deaths so far in November from unrelated outbreaks.
To regain elimination status, the U.S. must halt the continuing spread of the highly infectious disease for at least 12 months—an effort that could take years of public health work and substantial political will to achieve.
PAHO didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.
“Runaway measles outbreaks in the United States, as well as the needless deaths, are all due to low measles vaccination coverage,” said Noel Brewer, chair of an independent U.S. committee who presented findings about the country’s measles outbreaks to PAHO. “We’ve gotten comfortable letting children be stopped by a deadly disease and die from it.”
Measles is considered eliminated when a country has no continuous spread of the virus for at least 12 months. PAHO makes its determination based on a review of recent outbreaks and a report from the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that shows whether disparate outbreaks are linked or whether any one outbreak lasted more than a year.
Measles has largely been under control in the U.S. over the past 30 years, with often just a few dozen cases recorded annually. Over the past two years, states such as Utah, Texas, South Carolina and Pennsylvania have all reported big outbreaks. In 2026 alone, the CDC has reported more than 5,400 cases—a level not seen since before measles was eliminated.
Now the big downside of this, of course, is the death of people from the disease (10 so far, as well as 5,400 cases) as well as a strain on the healthcare system, but there are also formal consequences for America, mainly a loss in reputation and the fact that to get the “elimination status” back again, the U.S. has to submit an elimination plan to PAHO, Two nights ago on the evening news, they reported on an outbreak in an Amish community (some Amish oppose vaccinations and others don’t), but they asked one woman whose large family of kids all got measles if she’d get vaccinated had she known that every child would get measles. She said no, becaue she considered the family outbreak a “bonding experience”! OY!
Here’s the latest example of how suspicion of vaccines is, lamentably, gripping far too many Americans: Parents are refusing vitamin K shots for newborns, even though they are not even vaccines, sometimes with tragic results. Thus does ideological fearmongering further erode the hard-earned triumphs of medical innovation.
Vitamin K is necessary for blood clotting, but infants typically are not born with sufficient levels of the vitamin and can suffer serious health problems as a result. Before physicians started routinely injecting infants with the compound in the early 1960s, up to 1 in 60 newborns experienced incidents of uncontrolled bleeding.
A new JAMA study, which examined 5.2 million infants, found that 6.8 percent of newborns did not receive vitamin K shots in 2025, more than double the 3.1 percent in 2017. Across the study period, infants who did not receive the shot had a 47 percent higher adjusted risk of bleeding in their first six months of life. Their risk of bleeding in or around the brain, which can lead to lifelong disabilities and death, was 2.43 times higher. Among the 235,000 infants who did not receive vitamin K, 69 died during their birth hospitalization with a concurrent bleeding diagnosis, a rate nearly three times that among babies who received the shot.
A separate JAMA Pediatrics study, encompassing 11 million infants, documented the consequences of this trend in another way. Between 2017 and 2025, the rate of diagnosed vitamin K-deficient bleeding rose 347 percent, from 24 cases per 100,000 infants to 107.4 per 100,000.
Some of those refusing the injections for their children are vaccine-hesitant parents who associate all shots with immunizations. Americans increasingly do not trust the medical establishment, often falling for social media influencers peddling false information and sketchy alternatives to well-established medicines. It didn’t help that Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. refused to endorse vitamin K shots when pressed to do so during an April congressional hearing.
The result is a twisted sort of trypanophobia, or fear of needles. Some parents have opted to give their babies oral drops of vitamin K, despite warnings from pediatricians that they are not nearly as effective as the shots.
I had no idea that there were Vitamin K shots given to newborns, but they are safe and effective. I asked Grok how many American infants were affected by bleeding caused by lack of these shots, and it said that mortality data are sparse but added this (with a reference). This is a huge rise: nearly a doubling between 2024 and 2025.
“A JAMA Pediatrics research letter analyzing records for more than 11 million U.S. infants (birth to 6 months, roughly 2017–2025) found:
1,764 cases of vitamin K deficiency bleeding in 2025, up from 903 in 2024 and 189 in 2017.
Overall, 5,217 such bleeding events were identified across the multi-year period.
The rate of VKDB nearly quadrupled from 2017 to 2025 and roughly doubled from 2024 to 2025.
About 81% of the VKDB cases occurred in infants who had not received the vitamin K shot.”
The government needs to spend more effort and money educating people on the consequences of avoiding vaccinations and shots, but of course it’s too late, and that ain’t gonna happen with RFK Jr. at the helm.
A cruise passenger on the MSC Seascape was charged with murder on Tuesday after a woman was found dead in their shared cabin with multiple facial injuries, according to a criminal complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas.
Jason Leon Watford, 48, a resident of Tyler, Texas, is accused of striking the female passenger “several times before strangling her with his hands and arm following a dispute in their room,” said the complaint.
Around 9 p.m., a housekeeper knocked on their cabin door and briefly spoke to Mr. Watford before noticing blood on his hands and clothing and saw the woman lying face down and motionless, according to allegations cited in the complaint.
After the incident was reported to the ship’s security, the woman was declared dead, and the F.B.I. was informed, prompting the ship to turn back to Galveston early Monday.
Passengers on the ship, which has a capacity for nearly 5,000 guests, posted videos on social media of Mr. Watford in handcuffs being escorted off the vessel by federal agents. The ship has since left Galveston and continued its seven-night western Caribbean cruise.
If convicted, Mr. Watford could face life in prison and a possible $250,000 maximum fine, according to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas.
Unless you want to spend the rest of your life in prison, it’s best to avoid killing someone on a ship—especially your cabinmate. There’s nowhere to go and you’ll be caught for sure. Below is the Tik Tok video showing Watford being escorded off the boat by cops.
Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, but Andrzej has resurrected a Hili dialogue. These are some of Malgorzata’s favorites.
Me: What can you see from this rooftop?
Hili: A wider horizon.
In Polish:
Ja: Co widać z tego dachu?
Hili: Szerszy horyzont.
*******************
Gal Gadot doesn’t often talk about antisemitism, but here’s part of a statement she recently made at the Simon Wiesenthal Center:
From Terrible Maps: Countries that couldn’t think of a name for their capital
Masih is quiet today; she’s at a meeting in Berlin.
From Luana. I couldn’t find this in the news, but here’s Grok’s AI take:
“John Cleese arranged private security for Singh’s Dining (a non-halal Sikh-owned restaurant in Hammersmith, London) amid threats, protests, and alleged attacks on the owners.
The restaurant is run by Harman Singh Kapoor (previously associated with Rangrez). He has long advertised it as non-halal (serving jhatka meat) and made public statements that drew strong backlash. This has led to months of reported problems, including:
Daily death threats (one specifying a date in late October).
An attempted break-in / attack in which his daughter reportedly got the shutters down in time; the group left shortly before police arrived.
Egg pelting, forced early closures for family safety, alleged Google page issues/hacking, and online review campaigns.
Protests outside the restaurant (including chants such as “Pakistan Zindabad”).
Kapoor and his wife have said police response has been inadequate. Cleese has publicly supported the family on X, criticizing the Metropolitan Police, recommending the restaurant, and arguing they were facing intimidation over their menu choices and free speech.What happened with the securityAccording to Kapoor’s wife, Khushi Kapoor (in a post on or around 14 November 2026), Cleese funded/sent 8 security guards to protect Singh’s Dining during a recent protest/incident. She wrote that without his help the family “might have been killed” by those she described as Pakistani supporters or Islamists.
Other accounts describe roughly a dozen private security personnel present alongside police. Police eventually attended; at least one protester was arrested. Kapoor himself was also arrested by the Met around the same period (the precise charge is disputed in posts; some claim it related to social media content or other matters).”
The tweet:
Without @JohnCleese’s help, my family might have been killed by Pakistani supporters last night.
He sent 8 security guards to defend Singhs Dining
My husband @kingkapoor72 was arrested yesterday by met police
Aggressive protesters chanted “Pakistan Zindabad”, outside my restaurant
Londonistan is done
The Ancient Faces Attraction Test is based on facial reconstructions of people who lived in Europe and Anatolia thousands of years ago: the hunter-gatherers who followed the last Ice Age, the first farmers and the herders of the steppe. Each portrait is a new face drawn to a set mix of those three ancestries, so the faces you prefer show which of them you lean towards.
The Your Type Test looks at the kind of partner you are drawn to, the Mate Value Test at what you bring to a relationship, and the Beauty Privilege Test at how looks shape the way people are treated. To take the test, press Start test below.
I took the 53-question “your type” test, and got these results (I really wanted to take the “ancient your type” test but now I don’t have time).
From Simon, who’s trapped in Memphis by the groundstop. He says this deals with “the question that’s on everyone’s lips.”
Careful planning, preparation, and procedure is totally woke and gay
One from Malcolm; I don’t know where it’s from but perhaps a Brit will know. It’s hilarious.
Wedding photographer group photos that get increasingly unhinged. The last request is pure chaos. Watch to the end. They don’t make comedy like this no more 😂 https://t.co/sJTwA4zJg0
This Dutch Jewish boy was gassed as soon as he got to Auschwitz (along with about 80% of the occupants of his transport. Bernard was six years old would be 89 today had he survived.
And one from Dr. Cobb; a star vanishes in eight years:
Sometimes a star vanishes without a trace. According to theory, it can happen when a massive, aging star abruptly collapses into a black hole. Now it seems we're finding those stellar black holes. We can't see their light–but we can "see" their gravity. 🔭🧪www.caltech.edu/about/news/a…
From Discover magazine we have this astronomical feature that, they say, resembles a fluffy cat tail. Well, judge for yourself (click on the headline):
An excerpt:
A collision between objects 63 light-years from Earth may have been the driving force that created what looks like a massive cat’s tail spanning billions of miles. Reseachers detected this lengthy tail, located in a debris disk central to the Beta Pictoris system, years ago in infrared light, but the latest observations in visible light have found compelling new details about its structure and origin.
A study recently published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters has painted a clearer picture of the cat’s tail thanks to image data from the Hubble Space Telescope. The data confirmed that the vast cloud consists of porous, or “fluffy,” dust grains that may have been scattered in the wake of a high-velocity collision between bodies the size of Pluto. Looking deeper into the Beta Pictoris system — especially the dust within its cat’s tail — could give astronomers a better idea of our own solar system’s earliest years.
“How you can get dust grains that small that are as porous as we see here, no one really understands, and that’s part of why we study this feature,” said study author Arin Avsar, a doctoral student at the University of Arizona, in a statement.
Here’s the cat tail (credits on photo). The caption tells that this is an artist’s reconstruction: the “tail” is the orange bit and the white feature is a “secondary tail”:
In this artist’s illustration of the Beta Pictoris debris disk – seen edge-on as it appears from Earth – the swirling gas and dust are depicted in orange. A secondary disk, discovered previously, appears as a whitish feature below the plane of the main disk. On the right, the “Cat’s Tail” feature is visible, reaching far into space.
Here’s the paper from the Astrophysical Journal Letters. Click to read it:
We think the Cat’s Tail has eluded our observations in visible light until now because of what it’s made of,” Avsar explained. “It consists almost entirely of we call organic refractory material, which is heavily carbon-based. These long chains of carbon atoms absorb visible light, so they’re quite black.”
“We think the Cat’s Tail has eluded our observations in visible light until now because of what it’s made of,” Avsar explained. “It consists almost entirely of we call organic refractory material, which is heavily carbon-based. These long chains of carbon atoms absorb visible light, so they’re quite black.”
Not only that, but the new observations also supported that the vast cloud – whose length could be as long as 200 trillion house cats lined up tail to snout – consists of micron-sized dust grains that are also extremely porous or “fluffy.” In more astronomical terms, the structure is potentially 1,000 astronomical units long, with one AU being the average distance between the Earth and the sun.
“How you can get dust grains that small that are as porous as we see here, no one really understands, and that’s part of why we study this feature,” Avsar said.
***********************
I found a cat-related post the FB Page The Scientific Report:, which led me to the original paper.
The Facebook post:
Your cat isn’t talking to you. It’s filing a complaint.
Researchers in Japan took 38 pet cats, all known to meow a lot around food, and handed each one a problem it couldn’t solve alone: a favourite treat sealed in a small plastic box with holes in it. The cat could smell it. Couldn’t reach it.
Then they ran the test two ways. Once with a human in the room, paying attention. Once with the cat completely alone.
Alone: 20 meows total. Human present: 86.
The odds of a cat meowing were more than 16 times higher when someone was there to hear it. And the meows weren’t random noise. Cats kept glancing between the person and the box, like pointing with their eyes.
Published in Animal Behaviour, 2026. The scientists stop short of saying cats know you have thumbs. But they clearly know who to yell at when the world is broken.
The results are not new to cat owners, but it’s good to have them documented with SCIENCE. As the photo below shows, the cats meow when their staff is around, but when they’re not, the cats repeatedly glance at the doors or try to open the box. Here’s the abstract of the article; bolding is mine.
The domestic cat uses the meow more frequently in interactions with humans than with other cats. However, it remains unclear whether this vocalization serves a truly communicative purpose. In the present study, we investigated the audience effect on cat meowing behaviour using an unsolvable task paradigm involving the cat’s favourite food. We observed 38 cat–human dyads in their homes, an ecologically relevant scenario for cats, through synchronous citizen science. Cats were presented with a box containing perceivable but unreachable food in two conditions: human present and human absent. In the human present condition, cats exhibited a significant increase in meowing frequency. Meowing predominantly occurred while cats gazed at humans. Behaviours directed towards humans, including gazing and gaze alternation between them and the box, occurred significantly more frequently than zero. In the human absent condition, cats stood still and gazed at the door significantly more, suggesting they discriminated which behaviour was more effective with an audience. These results are consistent with meowing playing a communicative role in cat–human interactions, as evidenced by changes in response to the audience effect. Moreover, while directed at humans, these vocalizations were enhanced through multimodal signalling, integrating visual and vocal cues to strengthen information transmission and ensure the most effective communication.
So, say the authors, this is definitive eficence that cat meows serve a “communicative purpose”. But didn’t we know that already; many cat owners are familiar with meowing at dinnertime
An illustration from the paper with the caption below:
I liked the Materials and Methods Section:
A social media poster was shared to recruit cats that meow frequently, according to their humans’ reports. Participation criteria included: residing in São Paulo state (Brazil), being over 18 and living with no more than four cats. Eligible cats were between 1.5 and 12 years old, neutered/spayed, indoor-only and living with their person for at least 6 months. Participants completed an online form with the required information. Those who met the criteria and indicated ‘always’ for their cat’s meowing before and during mealtime on a Likert scale ranging from ‘never’ to ‘always’ were selected. This criterion was adopted because the study aimed to investigate the communicative function of meowing, which required a sample of cats predisposed to produce this behaviour in food-related contexts in their baseline. All 48 cat–human dyads from Fukimoto et al. (2026) were invited to participate. That study, conducted between 2021 and 2022, investigated vocal signals in highly motivating contexts by presenting cats with their favourite food and a new toy. Meowing was significantly more frequent in food-related situations, informing the design of the present study. Of the 48 invited dyads, 40 agreed to participate. For standardization purposes, prior to the session, each participant received a new apparatus: a plastic organizer box measuring 20.5 × 15.4 × 9.02 cm, with handles, a lid and small perforations for air circulation. The lid was not easily removable, enabling it to serve as an unsolvable task (Supplementary Fig. S1). As most cats had ad libitum access to dry food and water, their favourite food was used as the stimulus to ensure sufficient motivation and engagement during the task.
Here’s the “meow index” showing a highly significant difference between the “staff present” and “staff absent” conditions: more meows when staff are there: I’m not sure what the stars represent, but couldn’t be arsed to find out. (You can read the paper at the link above.)
The frequency of meowing corrected for visible time differed significantly between conditions (Fig. 2), being higher in the human present condition (median = 0.017, IQR = 0.035, N = 38) than in the human absent condition (median = 0.000, IQR = 0.000; W = 3.250, P = 0.001).
We’ve known for a long time that cats meow almost entirely when there are humans around, and rarely do it when outdoors and interacting with other cats. That alone suggests a communicative purpose. My question was whether the closest wild relative of the housecat, the African wildcat, also meows, or have meows evolved after cats were domesticated. I asked Grok, and it turned out that African wildcats do indeed meow, but not like housecats;
My question: Do close but wild relatives of house cats, like the Egyptian wildcat, meow?
Grok’s answer (I’ve omitted the references given):
Yes, they do meow (or produce meow-type/mew calls), though the sounds differ from those of house cats in pitch, duration, pleasantness, and typical use.
The Egyptian wildcat (or African wildcat, Felis lybica / Felis silvestris lybica) is the closest wild relative and primary ancestor of the domestic cat (Felis catus). Scientific studies confirm that adult African wildcats produce meow-type vocalizations:
A key 2004 study by Nicholas Nicastro compared their calls with domestic cat meows. African wildcat meows were significantly longer on average (~1.5 seconds vs. ~0.84 seconds), lower in fundamental frequency (~255 Hz vs. ~609 Hz mean), and had lower formant frequencies. Human listeners (regardless of cat experience) rated the wildcat versions as far less pleasant—more urgent or demanding—consistent with domestication having shaped house-cat meows to be higher-pitched, shorter, and more appealing to people.
Their meows in that study were not directed at humans but toward the general environment, occurring in contexts like food-related situations, agonistic encounters, or distress/pacing in captivity. Adult African wildcats are unusually vocal with these calls compared to most other wild felids, in which adult meowing is rare (more typical of juveniles).
Broader research on intense mew calls in the genus Felis (including African wildcats, European wildcats, sand cats, etc.) describes these as often uttered in series. They serve long-distance functions such as territorial advertisement and attracting mates. Acoustically, African wildcat versions can sound somewhat hoarse, with a two-syllable structure (raucous first part, higher/more tonal second part with slight frequency modulation).
Like domestic cats, they also hiss, spit, and growl when threatened, and they purr. In the wild, meows are less frequent for everyday social interaction than in pet cats (which largely reserve meowing for humans, building on the kitten-to-mother solicitation call). Feral domestic cats similarly meow less than pets when they have little human contact.
There you have it!
***********************
I was sad to learn that Richard Posner, a federal appellate-court judge who happened to be the most cited legal scholar of all time, died last week. I’m writing about it because he was an avid ailurophile, and had a beloved cat named Pixie, about which we had some correspondence.
The NYT gives his obituary at the link below, which you can read by clicking on the headline or reading the archived link here.
An excerpt:
Judge Richard A. Posner, whose protean intellect, relentless work ethic and startling candor made him a towering figure in the law, died on Tuesday in Chicago. He was 87.
His son Eric confirmed the death.
Judge Posner, who served from 1981 to 2017 on the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, in Chicago, wrote thousands of judicial opinions and more than 50 books on a vast array of topics, along with countless scholarly articles, essays, book reviews and blog posts.
He was, the journalist Gary Rosen wrote in The Wall Street Journal in 2002, “a one-man think tank.”
Judge Posner was the most-cited legal scholar in the second half of the 20th century, according to a 2000 study conducted by Fred R. Shapiro, beating the runner-up, Ronald Dworkin, by a factor of almost two.
In the casebooks that collect excerpts from judicial opinions and are the basis for much of legal education, Judge Posner’s work was featured for many years more often than that of any other judge. “The differential in terms of total influence on the casebooks between Posner and almost all the other judges is staggering,” the authors of a second study, Mitu Gulati and Veronica Sanchez, wrote in 2002.
When Professor Gulati and Stephen J. Choi updated the study this year, they found that little had changed. Judge Posner’s lead remained “astonishing,” they wrote.
But what about cats? Well, some of it is explained in my post here from January 29, 2018. As far as I can reconstruct with emails, Posner wrote to me first. Since he’s gone, I don’t think he’d mind my sharing his emails, which are not incriminating!
From: Richard Posner
Sent: Saturday, December 28, 2013 11:39 AM
To: Jerry Coyne
Subject: your NR article on Douthat
Dear Professor Coyne,
What a great article about that muddlehead!
Congratulations.
Richard Posner
P.S. The Nativity story in the New Testament, the Christmas trees, the carols, etc., are all very nice, treated as fairy tale and winter solstice reassurance material. The real religion of American is of course materalism–shopping is its creed, the malls are its cathedrals, salesmen are its priests, Santa Claus is its god, and Christmas is its holy day.
(Posner was of Ashkenazi Jewish descent but was secular, a nonbeliever in God but unwilling to say there definitely was no God.)
Chuffed, I wrote Posner back the same day:
From: Jerry Coyne <c525@uchicago.edu>
To: Richard Posner
Date: 12/28/2013 02:20 PM
Subject: RE: your NR article on Douthat
Hi,
Thanks a lot for your encomiums, which are especially appreciated since I know well who you are and have admired your work. I also saw, by looking at your Wikipedia bio just now, that
“He is also a self-described “cat person” and is devoted to his maine coon, Pixie.”
My website contains a lot about cats as I’m a cat person, too, though I don’t own one right now. Best to you and Pixie for the holidays.
cheers,
Jerry
p.s. I am pleased to say that I did not buy one Xmas present this year.
p.p.s. p.s. If you want to send me a photo of Pixie and maybe a sentence or two about her (I presume, with the name “Pixie” it’s a female), I’d be delighted to put it up, as I have a “readers’ cats” section.is its holy day.
And, sure enough, Posner emailed me the same day, attaching a photo of Pixie (below), including details about her and his family’s other cats, and some legal stuff about religion. None of these emails have been published.
From: Richard Posner
To: Jerry Coyne
Pixie is happy to share her photo with you:
She is a beauty, as you can see; also very intelligent; but above all affectionate, which is rare in my experience of cats. My wife and I have had cats (just one at a time) since before we were married, which means more than 51 years ago, and Pixie is the first one who actually likes me (gives me frequent nuzzles, follows me around, lies on my computer keyboard, causing chaos). I strongly recommend the breed–Maine Coon–and also buying a cat from a breeder, because breeders are very concerned with raising good-natured animals, as otherwise they don’t have a chance in a cat show–not that we would ever “show” a cat.
My court gets a fair number of cases involving religion. They are often hilarious. I have had cases involving apparitions of the Virgin Mary in Indiana, a tree resembling the Virgin Mary that the park authorities wanted to cut down, the Nazarite Oath (no hair cutting–the oath Samson took and then accidentally violated, getting him into serious trouble), insistence by a prisoner who converted to Judaism that the prison import Jews from outside (there being no other Jews in the prison) to make up a Minyan (a quorum of 10 required joint prayer), colorful fringe religious such as the Black Hebrew Israelites of Jerusalem, and so on, along with serious cases, such as persecution of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Ethiopia and Christians and Falun Gong in China. (Falun Gong is a typical East Asian religion–no god, essentially just calisthenics. The Chinese government deems it a cult and has managed to crush it.)
I acknowledge that it is important to many Americans, including some of my sophisticated judicial colleagues, several of whom are devout Catholics–and very nice. Another is a Catholic atheist.) The sects that don’t bother themselves about contraception, abortion, homosexuality, sex generally, evolution, politics, dietary laws, female subordination, and heresy seem harmless. My favorite is Methodism (though one of the Methodist sects lately has gotten in a dither over same-sex marriage), because Methodists allow one’s pets to go to heaven with one.
And here is a photo of Pixie he sent (one of several), which I posted at the link above. She is indeed a beaut!
The post about Pixie appeared on January 29, and I sent the link to Judge Posner. I got one email in return the same day:
From: Richard_Posner
Sent: Monday, December 30, 2013 1:58 PM
To: Jerry Coyne
Subject: Re: Pixie’s up
Thanks, Jerry; this is very gracious of you.
Pixie is thrilled, though she did think that there should have been more about her, and less about me. That is a typical feline response.
All the best in the new year.
Dick
RIP to a great judge and scholar, and a great ailurophile.
***********************
Lagniappe: Click to read the story of the Valkyrie cat:
KITTENMAXXING!
Here’s a comedian discussing the dangers of cats, including Death by Cat:
Oy, gewalt! I forgot to schedule this, so it’s coming out two hours late. I trust readers will forgive me. We also have a Caturday Felid post coming out soon with some nice content.
Welcome to CaturSaturday, November 14, 2026; it’s shabbos for Jewish cats and National Pickle Day. My favorite is the half-sour pickle, and the best examples of any pickle are to be had at The Pickle Guys on the Lower East Side of New York City. It’s the real thing, as this video will show you, and it’s a mandatory stop on Coyne’s Guided Tour of the Jewish Food of the Lower East Side. You can get these delicacies by mail order, and shipping is only $15 flat rate, or free if the order is over $85.
Travelers across the United States and beyond were still facing delays and uncertainty on Saturday as airlines and airports sought to recover from the ground stop the day before that brought air travel to a halt for hours.
Thousands of passengers were stranded on Friday after the Federal Aviation Administration ordered the ground stop. More than 8,200 flights — or over 31 percent of those scheduled for Friday — were canceled nationwide, according to Cirium, an aviation data firm, though some international flights received permission to take off.
Sean Duffy, the transportation secretary, said at a news conference on Friday night that the authorities had decided to issue the ground stop after aging air traffic communications equipment became overloaded and began to falter on Friday afternoon.
He said that it would take “some time” for airlines to recover, predicting that flight schedules would return to normal in time for the busy Thanksgiving travel season.
Many who waited at airports until late Friday night had to scramble to find accommodation after their flights were canceled. Some carriers, including United Airlines and American Airlines, began to restore flights after flight traffic was restored on Friday night. Aviation experts have said it could take days to fully restore flight schedules after a halt of this scale.
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, who appeared alongside Mr. Duffy at the news conference on Friday, said there was no indication that the communications failures had been caused by a cyberattack, though he said that an investigation was underway and that he could not rule out such an attack. He stressed that lives were never in danger.
Russian President Vladimir Putin has four bets on how to win the war in Ukraine. Two of them—that Ukraine’s army will break, or that the Trump administration will force Kyiv to submit to Moscow’s terms—are going badly.
But Putin’s other two bets have a better chance of succeeding by next year: paralyzing Ukraine’s economy with relentless missile and drone strikes, and waiting for European support to falter as political parties that oppose aid for Kyiv gain popularity.
This week’s U.S.-mediated talks in Abu Dhabi showed that the Kremlin remains committed to its original war aims: dismembering and subjugating Ukraine while rewriting Europe’s post-Cold War order. “All the objectives we have set ourselves will be achieved,” Moscow’s lead negotiator Vladimir Medinsky told Russian state TV on Wednesday.
Putin will likely wait to see how his stratagems play out in early 2027, most observers say, before deciding whether to stay the course or adjust it.
“The spring is what the Russians will be waiting for. They want to see what this missile campaign delivers,” as well as who wins France’s coming presidential election, said Hanna Notte, Eurasia director at the James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies in Monterey, Calif. “And then they’ll take stock.”
Even then, Russia is more likely to review its strategy than give up its goals, Notte says.
I was on a voyage to Antarctica when the war began, and when I saw the reporting on CNN on the ship’s t.v., I thought “The Ukrainian goose is cooked now.” It’s now been over four years and Ukraine is still hanging in there. I guess it’s too late to allow it to join NATO, as the EU knows what this would involve, but I don’t see why the world allows Putin to get away with it. But the two strategies that are helping Russia are still going on, and I think they’re likely to continue. The goose was just under lower heat than I thought, and I didn’t count on the Ukrainians (including Zelensky) being so resolute.
This dissatisfaction with the two main political parties has been growing in recent decades, and the number of independents has been climbing — reaching 45 percent of U.S. adults in 2025, according to Gallup. So how, amid this growing alienation, did the Democrats pull off a landslide?
The short answer is by becoming an anti-party party. Across the Western world, voters have become increasingly unhappy with mainstream political parties, which have lost supporters, members and vote shares. In Britain’s 1951 election, the Tories and the Labour Party got 97 percent of the vote; in 2024, their combined share was 57 percent. This reflects part of a broader dissatisfaction with established institutions, from government to the church to big business.
The Democratic Party fought this midterm with a motley crew of mavericks. Many openly criticized the Democratic Party itself. Axios did an analysis of campaign ads from Aug. 24 to Sept. 22 in recent election years and found that this year 47 Democratic-aligned ads criticized their own party or both parties, up from just 14 during that span in 2018. Candidates had a variety of political views, from pro-lifeand pro-oil and gas on the one hand to Medicare-for-all and anti-ICE on the other. It turns out that loosening ideological conformity allowed Democrats to be more authentic and more responsive to their local constituencies.
The great debate in the Democratic Party in recent years has been whether it should move to the left or the center. It should do both. More than a dozen of the winning House candidates were endorsed by the moderate Blue Dog PAC and more than 20 by the Congressional Progressive Caucus PAC. Adam Hamilton, a megachurch pastor, was elected to the Senate in Kansas, a state that last elected a Democrat to that body in 1932. Meanwhile, Abdul El-Sayed, an Arab Muslim Rhodes scholar and a passionate advocate of Medicare-for-all, was elected to the Senate from Michigan.
An anti-party party does not need to be incoherent. It should instead be an organization that is stronger at the bottom and looser at the top. Power should flow from the grass roots, not from the bigwigs in Washington issuing diktats.
. . . Of course there must be some core beliefs, but they should be a flexible set of principles, not rigid dogma. The Democratic identity has always been about looking out for the little guy. When speaking the language of economic populism, enforcing competition and providing access to the marginalized, Democrats sound true to that tradition. When they speak the language of cultural leftism — on asylum, trans women in sports or diversity, equity and inclusion — that dynamic is reversed. They are speaking as the elites — often down to the masses, who must be instructed in how to be virtuous.
. . .The midterm elections were in large part a referendum on President Donald Trump and his policies, from the Iran war and tariffs to immigration roundups and eye-popping corruption. It was a Democratic wave, not a liberal one. Many of the candidates who won big were moderates. Many of the ballot initiatives that prevailed were conservative. Polling suggests that on many key issues — illegal immigration, crime, major socialissues — Americans are still center-right. But it might well have been an election to reward the Democrats’ antiestablishment style: a big tent and a practical organization that reflects the diversity of this country.
The anti-party party might be a way of restoring the political party itself and of repairing politics. In an age when millions of citizens distrust distant institutions, a party rooted in the people and places they actually know could again begin to mean something.
The problem, of course, is that the groups mentioned as “cultural leftism”: immigrants, trans people, and people benefited by DEI, are “marginalized.” Is it that Democrats should give up the idea that these people are marginalized, or simply redefine what “marginalized” means. Is it a losing strategy to let other people tell you who is marginalized, especially if they’re professors? And does Zakaria really think that centrist Democrats like me are happy to have Abdul El-Sayeed and AOC in our “big tent”? I don’t think so, and for sure I won’t vote for such people.
→ Meanwhile, the ballroom is looking absolutely massive. We’re starting to get drone shots showing the full scale of this beast. I’m pro-ballroom as a concept. Like, I get that the White House needed a larger, indoor, and secure entertaining space. We were serving the Singapore president sweaty chicken in a tent before. But, uh, just look at this thing:
One part of the White House’s beauty is its human scale. Like an old English home, the rooms feel cozy and manageable. The ballroom is giving Houston living room. The old White House is a Mini Cooper. The ballroom is a Hummer SUV. It looks like it wants to eat the White House. And yet it also looks like the performing arts center at an all-women’s college. I’m confused. I’m alarmed. And I’m sure the gift shop will be even bigger.
Look at the size of that thing! I had no idea!!!
→ Nvidia CEO ousted for sexcapades: Jensen Huang, the chief executive officer of Nvidia, is out after a second extramarital affair was reported, in addition to the one that made headlines last month. This one was allegedly with his vice president of healthcare—a direct subordinate! How dare he! Sleeping with a Chinese spy and potentially doing the bidding of a hostile foreign power? That was one thing. That was fine. That was survivable. But sleeping with a 48-year-old subordinate? She’s a child! Can a woman as young as 48 even give consent? Someone check the Nvidia bylaws on sex. Because, get this, he had the affair without filling out the HR paperwork to transfer her chain of command. Jensen violated the sacred laws of Human Resources. And apparently there was a third. It’s over for you, Jen. You might be a captain of industry. You might be worth $143 billion. But no one is above the law of America’s HR ladies. Into the hole you go.
The most ruthless career obit for Mr. Huang comes from my dear friend Lloyd Blankfein, former CEO of Goldman Sachs: “Sad about Jensen. Shakespearean. But as de Gaulle said, ‘The graveyards are filled with indispensable men.’ ” Et tu, Blankfein?
→ Woke’s back, baby!: I love this recent-ish piece from NPR. We’re going back to 2020, baby!
Check the date: 2026. I was worried there for a second that we’d gotten over our national fever, but it’s spiking now! And I, for one, can’t believe taxpayers stopped funding this important journalism. From the article: “Right-wing ideology has crept into gyms across the country. Is this a new phenomenon, or is the very idea of ‘fitness’ ripe for politicization? Is our idea of fitness inherently fascist?”
It might be new to those writers, but here’s The Guardian saying fitness is right-wing in 2018 and in 2022 or GQ saying it in 2023. I actually don’t mind that the craziest members of our society decided that being sick and weak is good for them, in particular. Communists all have to stay in bed all day and sleep, that’s the rule, and anything else is fascism. That is the new protest. It’s like the incel movement on the right. It makes me sad, but if you’re that angry at society and refuse to adapt to modernity, it’s probably good not to reproduce? May the strongest, fittest, happiest, most gluted-up normies win.
And the headline:
→ Elsewhere in liberal podcast world: NYU professor and finance guru Scott Galloway says he took a shit in his Tesla to spite Elon Musk. I’m serious! Here’s Scott: “[Elon] started shitposting me on Twitter so I sold [my Tesla], not before taking a giant dump in the passenger seat. True story. Not good for resale value.” If you ever find yourself climbing into the passenger seat of your own car and squatting on it to poop, you should stop and ask yourself a few questions. If you have the urge to poop in the passenger seat out of spite, take a few deep breaths and check your insulin levels. I have a lot of big political feelings, and none of them involve me wishing death on people or shitting on my stuff. It can be done!
Peruvian officials said they had discovered thousands of tarantulas hidden inside socks packed in suitcases at an airport in Lima in an attempt to smuggle them into Germany.
The stash included eggs, hatchlings and adults. Some of the species of tarantulas identified are popular as exotic pets, the National Forest and Wildlife Service of Peru said in a news release on Wednesday.
The spiders, some of which were brightly colored, came from across Peru’s diverse geographies, including the Andes Mountains and the Amazon rainforest. At least one protected species was found.
The spiders were discovered after officials stopped two German citizens and one Polish citizen at Jorge Chávez International Airport while they were checking in at the boarding area, officials said.
The discovery of the spiders was the product of a “painstaking intelligence operation,” said the Forest and Wildlife Service, which did not specify when the seizure was made. The service said on social media that it had received an anonymous tip that had led to the seizure.
A lot of the tarantulas appear to be babies in the video below. I was glad to read that “the spiders would be housed in a breeding center after being assessed,” but really, are they going to keep 3,000 tarantulas in rehab?
I’ve watched many Trump speeches over the years. But in his recent rallies, I saw something new.
Last month in South Carolina, Trump referred to the former South Carolina governor Nikki Haley as “the governor EEHHP.” It was a bizarre belch-like noise, something uncontrolled. Was Trump going for a dis of Haley? If so, it was an oddly clumsy one for a master of the stand-up put-down. “Governor EEHHP”?
The next day, discussing the Senate hopeful Abdul El-Sayed, Trump said, “If you don’t want communists controlling the U.S. Senate which is between JAYYT … how about the gentleman from a place called Michigan?” The “JAYYT” has no meaning, and why “a place called Michigan,” as if Trump were referring to Brigadoon? Did it help him save face for a verbal glitch?
So: “EEHHP,” “JAYYT” — and then “jigger.” That one was in Mississippi, and it was Trump referring to gas prices in Iowa being $1.85 “on the top of the jigger.” What’s a jigger? (A measuring tool for bartenders, sure — but what does that have to do with gas?)
It went on. There were times when Trump was clearly grasping for basic concepts, and erring even in his attempts at correction. “They gave the wonderful peace prize, right? Does anybody know the name of that peace prize?” Trump asked. But why be coy about the name of a prize that’s as renowned as the Oscars? It’s reasonable to wonder whether he was blanking on the name of the Nobel Peace Prize — especially since he went on to refer to it as the Pulitzer. “They gave the Pulitzer Prize to a young lady …”
Now, we have to distinguish the genuinely unusual from what linguists know as ordinary speech errors.
. . . Trump plows through these odd eruptions and stark incoherencies as if they were par for the course. If President Joe Biden had popped off with even one example of what is now verbally typical of Trump, MAGA enthusiasts would have classified it as indisputably dire. One assumes they will not do the same with Trump.
Clearly these are not “ordinary speech errors,” and here McWhorter is politely suggesting that Trump has some form of dementia. The video below shows some of those errors (the belch is the scariest one). Or it might be some weird variant of Tourette’s:
From Masih. Try telling her that the U.S. should get the hell out of Iran!
From Berlin Freedom Week, I joined CBS on translational repression reported Iranian regime’s new threats to Treasury Secretary @SecScottBessent, Secretary of State @SecRubio & White House Chief of Staff @StephenM.
The same regime that massacres its own people, now threatens top US officials, and still gets a seat at the UN. Seriously?
Two from my feed. I’ve seen this Jewish woman before, but don’t know who she is. She has dialogues with Muslims and takes them apart. Anybody know? I don’t think the “monkey” thing is a racist slur.
Ah, I put a photo of her in Grok, which told me this:
Talia Yoseph (טליה יוסף), also known online as @taliaortati/ itstalia___.
She is an Israeli (Jewish, unapologetic Zionist) content creator and pro-Israel advocate known for engaging in direct video dialogues/debates on platforms like Umingle (an Omegle-style random video chat site). She frequently matches with people interested in topics like Israel, Palestine, Islam, or related issues, including many from Arab/Muslim backgrounds, and posts the resulting conversations.
Her style is straightforward and fact-focused; clips of these exchanges (often covering history, October 7, hostages, narratives around the conflict, etc.) regularly go viral on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, and X. She has a YouTube channel with hundreds of thousands of subscribers dedicated to these debates and related commentary, and she has been covered in Israeli media for the reach of her Umingle conversations.
In a minute, she turned him from a victim into a terrorist—from a movie actor into his true self.
Well, both of the world’s most prestigious science journals have gone off the rails, a fact confirmed again when I read the Science editorial and letter below on AI and indigenous science, which then led me to a Perspective in Nature on “two eyed seeing” in neuroscience. As you know, the two-eyed metaphor refers to the claimed salubrious effects of blending “indigenous science” with “Western science” (the latter is now known as “science”.)
The point of the Science editorial above is simply this: because indigenous knowledge (and I define “knowledge” as “justified true belief”) is not widely represented in publications or writings that can be accessed by AI, so it is not found very often in searches. Thus, as Running Horse Collin says, there “cannot be an indigenous AI within the current AI framework.”
There are problems of translation, too:
Additionally, AI models would have to be trained in translating Indigenous science vocabulary between languages. This is not impossible, but Indigenous languages reflect multidimensional scientific principles and concepts and how they work together. Language and context would have to be translated into those of the linear world of Western science. That is not presently possible. Moreover, AI is trained to reference Western scientific data and concepts as the “control” for the interpretation of concepts. Thus, it would evaluate Indigenous concepts, data, and frameworks against Western methodologies to determine validity, accuracy, or meaning.
Finally, the biggest problem is one that reflects how modern science’s “ways of knowing” aren’t the same as indigenous “ways of knowing.” This is a problem that I’ve discussed extensively with reference to Mātauranga Māori (henceforth “MM”), the Māori “way of knowing” that is the subject of a battle in New Zealand about what counts as science. From the paper above:
The major, overarching problem is that in Western science, the purpose of research is to obtain and convey information, whereas in Indigenous science, information must come with a purpose. Within the Lakota scientific system, for example, the point of conducting innovation, experiments, or research must align with ethics and the foundational scientific purpose, which is to preserve all life and work within it. This is a very different way to understand the acquisition, protection, and use of knowledge. In its current form and design, AI is effectively the outcome of multiple permutations of statistical calculations conveying statistically weighted output and trained to generate practical outcomes. However, within Indigenous scientific systems, there is no “right answer” without an initial, ethically aligned purpose and process. Therefore, “what is the point” is the point.
There’s more to indigenous “ways of knowing” than just obtaining knowledge under an ethical system, though. As in MM, indigenous “science” nearly always incorporates things that modern science—it’s called “Western science” in the article—doesn’t deal with qua science. These are things like ethics, religious codes, spiritual matters (as in spiritual healing), folklore, tradition, and so on.
I’m not denying that indigenous people can acquire knowledge through trial and error, as they have with navigation in Polynesia or growing mussels in New Zealand. Nor do I deny that these observations can lead to substantial medical or scientific advances. Three examples are the use of willow bark to relieve pain (leading to the development of aspirin), the use of cinchona bark to relieve fevers (leading to the development of quinine to mitigate malarial symptoms), and the use of plant-derived curare as arrow poison (leading to advances in anesthesia and muscle relaxants). These all came from knowledge acquired by indigenous (or pre-Caucasion) people.
But it’s not just “colonized” and oppressed people (a theme of all three documents) who have folk wisdom. Remember that the development of the smallpox vaccine by Jenner was prompted by the observation that English milkmaids who had gotten cowpox were immune to smallpox. This led to Edward Jenner’s development of a smallpox vaccine (the first vaccine ever) and the rise of immunology. But Jenner was successful because he tested the folk observations using methods now more refined in modern science: hypothesis testing and repeated observations with the subjects being blinded.
The point I want to make here is that folk observations can be a foundation for modern science, or even be incorporated into modern science. But they only become part of modern science when they are tested. Jenner published his repeated tests on the vaccine in 1798, and the use of salicylic acid and quinine were isolated, tested and reported on in the mid-18th century. That is when the scientific advances occurred, although again, they were derived from folk observations.
But remember that there are many parts of indigenous “ways of knowing” that do not comprise knowledge in the modern scientific sense. There are many herbal cures that don’t work, and don’t forget all the ineffective spiritual cures that are part of MM and other indigenous “systems of knowledge”. There is a well-funded branch of the NIH, the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, that has tested folk and indigenous remedies using modern blind controlled trials. Almost without exception, “folk wisdom” was not substantiated scientifically. A few examples are given in the linked 2009 article:
Ten years ago the government set out to test herbal and other alternative health remedies to find the ones that work. After spending $2.5 billion, the disappointing answer seems to be that almost none of them do.
Echinacea for colds. Ginkgo biloba for memory. Glucosamine and chondroitin for arthritis. Black cohosh for menopausal hot flashes. Saw palmetto for prostate problems. Shark cartilage for cancer. All proved no better than dummy pills in big studies funded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. The lone exception: ginger capsules may help chemotherapy nausea.
As for therapies, acupuncture has been shown to help certain conditions, and yoga, massage, meditation and other relaxation methods may relieve symptoms like pain, anxiety and fatigue.
However, the government also is funding studies of purported energy fields, distance healing and other approaches that have little if any biological plausibility or scientific evidence.
The point is not to denigrate indigenous knowledge, but to show that any folk “knowledge” not tested with the methods of modern science cannot be regarded as “knowledge.”
And that brings me to the main point: there is not “indigenous science” and “Western science” that stand as separate entities, much less coequal entities. There is scientific knowledge and there are folk assertions, and that is all there is. It is telling that Running Horse Collin, a member of the Oglala Lakota Nation, does not tell us what indigenous science comprises beyond pointing out its differences from “Western science” (see below)
And that is the second point: indigenous science is said to be different from “Western science” in ways that make the former, in several respects, a complementary and salubrious way of knowing. That feeds into the metaphor of “two-eyed seeing”: the claim that you find out a lot more things if you simultaneously look at nature from the “Western” perspective and the indigenous perspective. Here is a figure from the Nature paper below implying a coequality (or at least a substantial contribution) of both eyes, even though in reality one eye sees a much wider landscape than the other:
Journey, communities and values through different lenses of priority. Illustration by Rudi Taylor-Bragge.
Another point: examples of major contributions to human knowledge made by indigenous groups are rarely given in papers touting “other ways of knowing”. The paper by Running Horse Collin is a case in point. She cites only one example (my bolding)
Yet, these differences do not mean that Indigenous knowledge is irrelevant to the problems that Western science addresses or immaterial to the development of robust AI models. For example, a recent study that explicitly integrated Indigenous science with Western scientific methods showed that the unhindered mobility of wildlife and ecological connectivity are vital for megafauna survival, a framework that could guide modern conservation.
Developing new, nonpolluting forms of AI with an aligned purpose for sustainability of all life within the relational frameworks of Indigenous knowledge could build a technology that serves the planet. Such a shift would reposition a future form of AI as a critical mechanism for the stewardship of all life on Earth.
What is the example? No citation was given, but I’d like to at least read about the contributions of both “ways of knowing”.
More: indigenous science’s contribution to knowledge rests on claims that it is more holistic, nonlinear, nonreductionist, and multidimensional than is modern science. But these differences are never explained. Here again from Running Horse Collin:
Indigenous science embodies knowledge and problem-solving methods developed over hundreds to thousands of years through experiential learning and long-term implementation. Information is tested and refined over generations, and knowledge is passed down and applied through strict protocol-based transfer processes. This system is also multidimensional in nature in that it acknowledges the existence of all parts of life and manages their interdependence, interrelation, and interconnection. In Lakota science, there are four parts—matter, energy, relationality, and a unifying life force—for which the reductionist approach of Western science, which breaks down complex systems into smaller parts for independent analysis, has limited application.
Today’s AI models are trained on Western scientific datasets and constructs that are consistent with the linearly recorded nature of Western science, mathematics, and technology. Thus, knowledge is framed chronologically within a single dimension, in contrast to knowledge that is framed relationally and multi-dimensionally.
I really don’t know what these claims means, save that the “four parts of Lakota science” sound awfully close to teleology or spirituality than to modern science. And in what ways is modern science “unidimensional” or “linear” or “not interdependent on other relevant areas”, save that knowledge advances with time, experiment by experiment. Is that the much criticized linearity?
Yes, there is a difference between indigenous science and modern science, but I would claim that the difference rests on the toolkit of modern science that truly has led to development, refinement, and advances in knowledge: things like hypothesis testing, pervasive doubt, designed experiments and blind controlled trials, the use of statistical tests, and so on. Without these tools, folk “knowledge” is limited and stalled, and, indeed, I have seen no examples of a truly indigenous science. Certainly MM is not one, and I doubt whether Lakota science is anything comparable to modern (“Western”) science.
Before I end, I want to critique two other claims often seen in articles like these:
a. Indigenous people own their “knowledge”, i.e., it is their right to determine what is done with it. Here’s one quote from the letter of Velarde et al.:
We propose epistemic auditing as a practical step. Indigenous Peoples, exercising their right to self-determination and to maintain, control and protect their traditional knowledge (3), would co-create and audit AI models and outputs. This would retain and return wisdom to the interpretation of large datasets and counter the narrow perspectives of an AI built in a handful of knowledge-production hubs. As active partners in this context, Indigenous Peoples remain guardians of their lands, their knowledge, and data governance principles (4).
This is confusing. Surely the organicmaterial or unpublished data used by non-indigenous people cannot be used without their permission. You can’t take blood from Native Americans for a scientific purpose without getting permission, using it only in the ways agreed on, and, when indigenous people make a substantive contribution to a research effort, make them coauthors on the resulting publications. But once indigenous people have published their data, it sits in the public domain and does not require permission to be used by anybody else. That is the way all science has worked and continues to work. I am not a guardian of the data on speciation in Drosophila that I’ve produced. Publication is intended to advance science by allowing others to build on your results.
b. Indigenous people are invariably “wise stewards of their land”. This is simply untrue. The Māori, for example, not only caused extinction of every one of New Zealand’s moa species (and the predatory Hast’s eagle), but also burned off much more of the native forest than did British “colonizers”. I’ve given examples from the AI bot Grok below the fold, but here you see the claim from the Iles et al perspective in Nature:
Regardless of nomenclature, the impact of environmental despair for Indigenous people is compounded with historical transgenerational trauma. The harm faced by the anxiety around the helplessness for a situation is conversely at odds with Indigenous practices and ways of being. Indigenous cultures around the world are renowned for their respectful cohabitation with the land, not an exploitative one
That last statement is simply false; see the data below the fold. Of course some groups tied to one place try to conserve and preserve it, but that is not true of all “indigenous cultures around the world.” This is a misguided way to laud indigenous people.
***********
I conclude that these two articles and the letter below represent attempts to sacralize people seen as oppressed or colonized, done by trying to show that they have a form of science that is in any way comparable to modern science. Yes, the Maori and the Lakota were treated badly by “colonists”, and may be even be due forms of reparation via educational outreach (but not with money). But we shouldn’t give those reparations via performative things like land acknowledgments or, in this case, pretenses about the “science” done by such groups. We don’t need two-eyed seeing, but clear-eyed seeing.
Here’s the letter that directly follows the article above, and I’ve already quoted from it.
Three of the authors on the “eLtter” above are also authors on the Nature Perspective below (click to see an extract). To me it seems a long-winded attempt to show that neuroscience has been greatly enriched by infusions from indigenous cultures. But it seems more like an exercise in scientific anthropology or sociology than of science itself. I showed it to U of C neuroscientist Peggy Mason. She pronounced it, without any input from me, as “intellectually empty” and “a word salad that has only the patina of neuroscience.” (I quote her with permission.). But don’t rely on just our take: have a look for yourself if you can plow through it:
Click “continue reading” to find examples of indigenous people not being “wise stewards” of their habitat taken from Grok: