NOVA series on evolution

November 19, 2026 • 9:45 am

I didn’t realize that NOVA/PBS/BBC has had a multi-segment series on evolution that you can watch online for free until December 12. It’s already at episode 17, and you can click the screenshot below to go to the programs available, They are a bit idiosyncratic, including shows on running, mating (really about sex), the evolution of the elephant, the evolution of feeding, and the evolution of intelligence. But I don’t know what was covered in the first 12 episodes. Some of these may be useful as adjunct material in evolution courses.

I decided to choose one episode to watch, just to get a sense of whether I wanted to see more. The episode was “The Mating Game,” which purports to answer the question,”How did sex create the wondrous world we see around us?”and I watched the entire 53 minutes.

My verdict is rather “meh”: the show is okay, but I think it could have been much better.  Perhaps I’m being hypercritical as a professor in this field, but I would have liked to talk to the creators before they put out the final version.  The cinematography is good, but the explanations seem wonky, and the whole show, while purporting to show how sex evolved and “unleashed” evolution (which it did to a large extent, but evolution, mutation, and natural selection did, too), is largely a recounting of what happened during evolution: there were cells, multicellular organisms, fish, fish that became terrestrial, amphibians, reptiles, and then the branches that led to birds and mammals.

In other words, the show is infused with a soupçon of teleology: that evolution was more or less a drive towards complexity, culminating in what we have today. Well, yes, what we have today is the longest-standing products of evolution, but evolution will continue, and natural selection doesn’t always favor more complexity (viz., tapeworms or lizards that have lost their legs).  Yes, some amphibians that produced amniotic (“terrestrial”) eggs may have had an advantage over their conspecific individuals because they didn’t have to return to the water to breed, but I the show doesn’t mention that this is how natural selection operated to produce evolutionary “innovations”, but there are still plenty of amphibians and plenty of fish still in the sea.

My view is that the producers missed a chance not only to raise some interesting questions, but also to emphasize that there are things we just don’t understand about sex and evolution.  One of these is the question, “Why did sex evolve?”  We don’t know the answer, but the show implies that it evolved to facilitate evolution. That’s a result of sex, but is a somewhat teleological answer, and scientists have many possible answers, all of which must involved the adaptive advantage of combining genes among individuals (technically, “to break up linkage disequilibrium among gene forms”). These include meeting environmental changes, meeting the challenge from parasites, getting rid of deleterious genes, repairing errors in DNA, and so on. (Just Google “why did sex evolve?”).  It could have been one or several of these advantages, but nowhere in the show will you hear “We don’t know the answer.” Nor do they answer the question of why we don’t see more asexual lineages since asexual mutants can have twice as many offspring as do their sexual ancestors; this is the “twofold cost of sex.”

Likewise, although they imply that there are two sexes, they don’t state that this condition holds in all animals and vascular plants. The question of “why sexes are always two?” was first asked by R. A. Fisher, and we have a pretty good answer involving “evolutionarily stable strategies.” Tbere is no mention made of this issue, which has become contentious.

The talking heads they use are somewhat idiosyncratic, concentrating almost entirely on North Americans and South Africans; I didn’t recognize any names save Sarah Otto, but perhaps the producers wanted to show some diversity among the commentators.

A few more of my notes:

A. Sexual selection is first shown in dinosaurs, favoring feathers, but of course sexual selection began evolving as soon as there were separate sexes. This isn’t mentioned, nor do they show that classically there are two forms of sexual selection: male-male competition (Darwin’s “law of battle”) and female-choice (Darwin’s “law of beauty,” the main explanation given here). There is no discussion about why some male traits, like bright colors and displays, are favored by females. To me, this is one of the great unsolved mysteries of evolution, and there are many possible explanations.  Further, the big claws of fiddler crabs, which are correctly mentioned as an example of sexual selection, not only enable males to fight with each other, but are waved in front of female crabs to attract them, showing that some features can participate in both form of sexual selection.

B. They make a big deal about the “invention” of the penis as a way to effect internal fertilization: “the origin of the penis was a major moment in evolution.” This importance is, they say, because it is THE way to effect internal fertilization in animals like birds, where the egg is fertilized before the shell is put on.  Unfortunately, 97% of bird species do not have penises (some ducks do); they have cloacas that they quickly evert when copulating in a “cloacal kiss”.  Other animals, including some amphibians, deposit spermatophores (packets of sperm) that a female snatches with her cloaca. I’m not sure why there’s all the brouhaha about penises unless the producers wanted to put a salacious spin on the theme.

C. Perhaps this is explained in an earlier show, but natural selection is minimized in comparison with sex (sexual selection is, of course, a form of natural selection involving mate choice or access, but that isn’t even mentioned.) It’s vitally important that these shows keep natural selection constantly in the foreground, and mention mutation and competition for reproduction between members of the same species.

Again, perhaps I am speaking from the point of view of an evolutionist; I’m not the kind of person who make up the target audience, but I was not impressed. I am not going to watch any more shows. But you can!  Watch this show for yourself, or choose another, and see if you want to go through other available videos.

Click below to go to “The Mating Game”. If you watch it, please comment below and let me know if I’m being unfair.


 

Thursday: Hili dialogue

November 19, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to Thursday, November 19, 2026; it’s the Great American Smokeout, a day when you encourage people to quit tobacco.  I quit smoking cigars, but not because they were unhealthy: the number I smoked (3/week) was statistically indistinguishable, in terms of health consequences, from zero cigars. It’s just that they changed the rules in my flat, and I can’t smoke there. What a great pity that was: there was nothing more relaxing than enjoying a good book with a drink (preferably root beer) and a fine Habano.  Here’s one, and look at that fine ash!

Oh, and I didn’t inhale.

It’s also Beaujolais Nouveau Day, when the pink “wine” better known as Grape Kool-Aid goes on sale. I recommend avoiding it. And it’s National Men’s Day, International Carbonated Beverage With Caffeine Day, National Macchiato Day, World Philosophy Day, and World Toilet Day, so declared by the World Toilet Association, whose homepage has a link called “Our Movement.”

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 19 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

Note: the news may be truncated today as I’m writing this the day before and have errands to run. As always, I do my best.

*We have a new Speaker of the House, a Democrat, of course, but also an African-American—the first to hold this position.

House Democrats on Wednesday nominated Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York to be speaker, voting overwhelmingly over resistance from the left to put him in line to become the first Black lawmaker to hold the post.

The election by secret ballot came just over two weeks after Mr. Jeffries, 56, who has led House Democrats since 2022, presided over sweeping victories for his party, which won a historically large majority in the midterm elections.

The vote was 251 to 11, with two Democrats abstaining, according to a person who attended the confidential session and detailed the results on the condition of anonymity. The margin demonstrated the breadth of Mr. Jeffries’s backing in a large and ideologically diverse caucus.

Accepting the nomination, he paid homage to the civil rights hero and long-serving Representative John Lewis of Georgia, who frequently exhorted people to get in “good trouble” fighting injustice.

“It’s a ‘good trouble’ moment in America,” Mr. Jeffries told the assembled Democrats.

He will still have to be elected on the House floor in January, when he will need a majority of members in the chamber to rise and say his name to formally win the post that is second in line to the presidency. But the lopsided secret-ballot vote suggested he will have more than enough support to do so.

Mr. Jeffries’s nomination was almost a foregone conclusion; no Democrat emerged to challenge him, and even some of his loudest critics ultimately did not want to publicly oppose the man in line to be the nation’s first Black speaker.

His frictionless ascent counted as a rarity in the House, where party leaders often rise through tumultuous challenges.

Another bonus besides Jeffries’s position as “unifier” is that he’s not by any means “progressive”, hewing more to the label of “mainstream liberal.” Further, his views on Israel are favorable and to my liking, though he has favored the insupportable “two-state solution”, a solution that as speaker he has no power to effect. When I asked Grok to compare AOC’s views on Israel with those of Jeffries’s, Mr. Grok said this:

Hakeem Jeffries and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) represent opposing poles of the Democratic Party’s divide on Israel. Jeffries is a longstanding mainstream supporter of Israel’s security who has recently called for policy adjustments; AOC is a consistent progressive critic who has labeled Israeli actions in Gaza a genocide and now opposes all U.S. military aid.
I’ll take it.

*As many people expected, the war between Iran and the U.S. (not much doing with Israel so far) has ramped up again:

Kuwait and Bahrain said that they had intercepted Iranian aerial attacks on Wednesday as peace talks between the United States and Iran stalled and uncertainty lingered in the region over whether a new round of fighting would erupt.

The Iranian military said that it had fired drones at a Kuwaiti air base, aiming for U.S. air-defense systems and launch platforms, Iranian state media reported. The Kuwaiti foreign ministry denounced the attack, the first Iranian offensive against the country in about two months, saying that it was a dangerous escalation that threatened regional stability. It was unclear whether the attack caused damage.

Bahrain, an island nation in the Persian Gulf that is home to the U.S. Navy’s Fifth Fleet, said it had also been attacked on Wednesday. The Bahraini authorities have reported several attempted Iranian attacks since Friday. On Sunday, Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps said that the Iranian military had targeted a radar system at a Bahraini air base.

Iran has also continued to go after ships in the Strait of Hormuz, the narrow waterway that is a crucial shipping route for Gulf oil exports. On Wednesday, ADNOC Logistics and Services, a subsidiary of Abu Dhabi’s state oil company, said that one person was missing and 11 were injured after one of its vessels was attacked the previous day while sailing through the Strait of Hormuz.

Iran’s leaders have hardened their negotiating position with the United States since President Trump’s setback in the midterm elections, which were partly seen as a rebuke of his handling of the war, according to American, European and Iranian officials.

The United States has sent more military assets to the Middle East in recent weeks, and it struck Qeshm Island in Iran this month in what American officials said was a defensive measure. American and Israeli military officials have also drawn up plans for renewed strikes that would most likely target energy infrastructure and other sites vital to the Iranian economy, according to U.S. officials and other people briefed on the deliberations.

Several Gulf countries have lobbied against another round of fighting and pushed for a comprehensive deal to end the war. Qatar, which is mediating between the United States and Iran, condemned the Iranian attacks, saying that they were “a dangerous escalation.”

If Trump has an ace up his sleeve here, he needs to play it before January when the majority-Democratic Congress is seated, though Trump may still be able to control the military then.

*I’m a sucker for analyses about the 2028 Presidential election, and the NYT has a clickbaity article called, “The best Democrat for 2028 might come from this quadrat.” Which quadrat? Read on.

The battle within the Democratic Party is usually framed as one between progressives and the establishment. There’s a fair bit of truth to that, but political analyst Nate Silver recently offered an assessment suggesting there’s another, more stylistic aspect to the division. Silver’s intriguing analysis does more than broaden understanding of the intra-Democratic divide: It also points to the central role that Black voters and leading candidates will play in resolving it.

Silver argues that Democrats are actually fighting on two dimensions: ideology and inclination. That second aspect distinguishes fighters (people who want to battle opponents, whether within the party or outside it) from uniters (those more inclined to find common ground with adversaries). A chart with his piece used those two categories to create four handy quadrants for visualizing the relative positions of 13 potential Democratic 2028 presidential contenders.

Here’s Silver’s graph from the link above. La-La land is the upper left quadrant (my view).  Attribution of figure: Graphic by the New York Times; ratings by Nate Silver.

More from the article:

Silver’s upper-left quadrant contains candidates who are progressive and fighters. The candidates land at different points in that square, but the ones found there are unsurprising. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (New York) is the most progressive potential contender, with fellow progressive firebrand Rep. Ro Khanna (California) right behind her. Others in this group include Govs. Gavin Newsom (California) and JB Pritzker (Illinois) and Sen. Jon Ossoff (Georgia).

The lower-right quadrant, meanwhile, contains figures more favored by the party establishment — politicians who are more moderate and more inclined to unite. Gov. Josh Shapiro (Pennsylvania) appears as both the most moderate and the strongest uniter, followed closely by Gov. Andy Beshear (Kentucky). Former transportation secretary Pete Buttigieg and Sen. Mark Kelly (Arizona) also land in this region.

To me, the most interesting quadrant is the lower left. This is the one that contains progressives who also are temperamentally uniters. Three potential candidates, all of them Black, fit here. In this group, former vice president Kamala Harris is rated as both the most progressive and the most inclined to fight. Gov. Wes Moore (Maryland) is rated as the least progressive and theleast inclined toward divisive battles. Sen. Raphael Warnock (Georgia) sits between the two.

. . .This suggests Silver may have put his finger on the decisive factor in the 2028 presidential battle. If the moderate uniters can’t get the support of Black voters, they cannot beat someone from the progressive-fighter camp. But if the progressive fighters can’t counter the long-standing tendency of Black voters to shy away from their brand of politics, they are unlikely to prevail either.

This means that perhaps analysts should be looking at one of the Black contenders more seriously than many are. Clearly, Harris’s two national campaigns have not gone well, but recent polls show her as the front-runner primarily because she leads with Black voters. If she can hold that support, White voters who might otherwise prefer a Buttigieg or Shapiro would probably choose her over a progressive firebrand in the crucial Super Tuesday contests.

A Harris failure could open the way for Moore, Warnock or perhaps Sen. Cory Booker (New Jersey). Warnock is probably the most intriguing potential candidate from this group, given his position as senior pastor at the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.’s Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta. No candidate can match that level of leadership lineage.

Republicans salivate at the prospect of the Democrats nominating an unrepentant progressive. Much of the Democratic establishment wants a unifying moderate. Don’t be surprised if the eventual nominee, drawing on strong support from Black voters, splits the difference.

Sorry, but the only person in that quadrant who I can say I will never vote for is Kamala Harris. She may be the front-runner among Democrats, but that speaks poorly of the Democratic Party. The foreign-born Mamdani can’t run, thank Ceiling Cat, and I’m willing to consider the others in that quadrat.

*There’s a Quillette discussion run by the site’s podcaster Zoey Sankey (not Jewish) featuring Mark Zlochin, described as “[an Israeli] computer scientist and independent researcher and data analyst”; the topic is “How Wikipedia rewrote Zionism,” and the video is below while there’s a transcript at the link. Here are a few excerpts from the transcript about the increasingly woke Wikipedia, which is not reliable on anything “progressive”.

From the intro:

For almost 20 years, Wikipedia’s article on Zionism was one of the most heavily worked pages on the site. Then, after October 7th, it began to change. Researcher Mark Zlochin wrote a script to trace the article revision by revision, and found that more than 80 percent of it has been rewritten since.

In this episode of Quillette Cetera, Zoe Sankey talks to Mark about what his data shows: which themes grew, which were cut, and how the work of historian Benny Morris was, Mark argues, stitched together to say things Morris never said. Morris himself reviewed Mark’s analysis.

From the interview:

MZ: When we think about Wikipedia, we think of it as a rather objective source of information. Obviously every source has some biases, but I never expected it to be biased to such an extent. The whole process was completely skewed: at the level of the people doing this, the tricks they play and how they game the system. There is a large system of guidelines for how editors are supposed to take part in this process and how they’re supposed to conduct it, and you see people really abusing it to push a very partisan, very biased narrative. The article about Zionism was just the tip of the iceberg, but I think it was very illuminating to focus on it, because it became the focal point of a much larger endeavour, and it was very illuminating to inspect it in more depth and see what was going on behind the curtain.

. . . Wikipedia is a good example of biases playing out, where the biases basically override whatever evidence comes in. If we look at it strictly from the point of view of Bayesian statistics, this is a pathological situation in which there is no balance: whatever new information comes in, it’s still not strong enough to override the prior biases. And you can see it play out in the way people edit Wikipedia and the way the information is fed out to the wider world, to a larger audience.

. . . So at some point I became curious about how you could quantify this, and I built a script that traced how much the text was changing. I looked at what was happening before October 7th, and I saw that almost immediately after October 7th some changes started, and then they started to accelerate. After about a year and a half to two years, like I said earlier, about 80 percent of the article had been completely rewritten.

. . .ZS: So in your essay, and there’s a great graph for this, there were four main topic clusters on the page. Return to the historic homeland: that absolutely shot down after October 7th. Antisemitism and persecution also dropped off; there’s not a lot of text about that now. It’s been wiped. Colonialism, topic three, shot up, and ethnic cleansing and displacement also increased.

MZ: Yes, exactly. And this is the narrative that the critics of Zionism, if we can put it mildly, try to push: this narrative of Zionism being a settler-colonial project, which is basically people who are foreign to the land coming and conquering it. One of the repeating themes, especially after October 7th, is talk of ethnic cleansing and expulsion, describing it as a premeditated project from the very start of Zionism. This is basically the picture that started to emerge after October 7th.

One of Zlochin’s theses is that Israeli historian Benny Morris, the person most quoted in the article, has had a very nuanced view of the Israel-Hamas war but that view is distorted by Wikipedia to favor the Zionism as a settler-colonial, pre-planned and nefarious endeavor:

MZ: [Morris’s] contribution was important in bringing it down to earth from the heights of idealism, and describing it: it was a war, it was a dirty war, and each side committed war crimes, both the Israelis and the Arabs. He openly acknowledged this, and he documented it based on very scrupulous research.

But then what do they do? They take particular incidents that happened late in the war, and they phrase them in a way that makes the reader believe it was a premeditated plan, which was not only implemented from the very start of the War of Independence, but actually goes way back to the very beginning of the Zionist movement. So the whole narrative is that the evil Zionists, starting from Herzl, planned from the very beginning to ethnically cleanse the Arabs, and that this is what led to what the Palestinians call the Nakba, the expulsion of the Palestinians during the War of Independence. And this is not what he’s saying. But they take half a sentence here and half a sentence there, and they mix it together. For someone who doesn’t, as I did, actually go and read the sources, that makes sense: “Benny Morris said that the Zionists wanted to ethnically cleanse the Palestinians from the very beginning. He’s such a respected figure, so it must be true.”

Zlochin had Benny Morris himself check the Wikipedia article, and Morris was angered by the distortion appearing under his name.

MZ: Yes, I think that [promoting “cold neutrality and the truth”) was the primary reason for my conducting this research. You can always dismiss criticism, not only on Wikipedia but particularly on Wikipedia, by saying, “Okay, this is just your opinion, and other people have different opinions.” But once you quantify it, once you see how the numbers change, you have an objective indicator. And you need to explain how it makes sense that there is such a sudden change, when nothing in the scholarship has changed and there are no new findings, and suddenly 80 percent of the article has been rewritten.

ZS: Exactly.

MZ: It’s no longer a matter of opinion; it’s just an objective fact that there has been some massive change. And I hope that more and more people, even if they are critical of Zionism or critical of my own work, will engage with the facts and address the objective part of the research, at least.

ZS: Yes, I hope for the same thing. Well, thanks again. I will link the essay in the show notes. Thank you, Mark.

Zlochin recommends Grokipedia as a more objective source of information than Wikipedia, at least for controversial topics.  It’s driven by AI, but people may object because it was created by Elon M-sk.

If you want to listen instead of read, here’s the hourlong discussion, and Zlochin has a long article on Quillette describing what he found (I believe I mentioned it previously).

 

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree. But Andrzej posted a vintage Hili dialogue:

Hili: We must be principled.
Me: In what matter?
Hili: I don’t know yet.

In Polish:

*******************

From Stacy:

From Meow Incorporated:

From The English Language Police:

Masih is quiet today so here’s a tweet from Larry. I don’t like the new James Bond. There’s been no acceptable substitute since Sean Connery, but they have to keep making up new stories with new people playing Bond.

From Luana: Abrogation of free speech at Oxford regarding a talk by Nathan Cofnas:

From Jay, who adds: “Both Grok and Perplexity.ai confirm that this is a genuine, newly released ad for Aer Lingus.”

From Barry, who says, “This cat from twenty days ago was correct.” Indeed it is.

“It’s going to be 56-44 in the Senate.”

— 𝕊𝕦𝕟𝕕𝕒𝕖 𝔾𝕦𝕣𝕝 (@sundaedivine.lol) 2026-10-27T00:59:58.197Z

From Malcolm. Bears have to swim so far because global warming is melting the ice:

One from my feed. Noa Argamani was NOT a soldier of any kind; she was kidnapped from the Nova Music Festival by Hamas and subsequently was one of several hostages rescued by the IDF. There’s an iconic video of Argamani being taken away on a motorcycle, which you can see in her short video below (a tearjerker). The professor should apologize.

Argamani:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

This French Jewish girl was gassed as soon as she arrived in Auchwitz. She was 12 years old.

— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2026-11-19T12:07:18.112Z

One from Dr. Cobb; Shostakovich and his moggy:

18 y.o. composer Dmitry Shostakovich and his cat (1925) sovietpostcards.tumblr.com/post/8336185…

— By Cory Doctorow (GPG 0xBF3D9110957E5F4C) (@doctorow.pluralistic.net) 2026-11-18T11:57:25.281Z

Jesus ‘n’ Mo ‘n’ The Argument From Subsequently Proved Prognostication

November 18, 2026 • 9:30 am

Today’s Jesus and Mo strip, called “pool“, came with a note: “Seriously, it’s the only book you’ll ever have to read!”

When I was writing Faith Versus Fact I had to plow through acres of ridiculous arguments that the Bible anticipated science in the same way Mo interprets the Qur’an. There should be a name for this kind of argument for God, perhaps “The Argument From Subsequently Proved Prognostication.”  But would think that God would be clearer in his predictions!

Readers’ wildlife photos

November 18, 2026 • 8:15 am

Athayde Tonhasca Júnior has been AWOL for a while, but returns today with a characteristic photo-plus-education post on orchids and pollination.. Athayde’s text is indented, and you can enlarge his photos by clicking on them

Persuasions and impositions

Orchids (family Orchidaceae) are one of the largest groups of angiosperms (flowering plants), with some 29,000 recorded species distributed through a range of habitats all over the world. Over 75% of them depend on pollinators for reproduction, although from a third to half of all species are deceptive, attracting pollinators without providing any rewards. Some orchids use food deception, ‘pretending’ to give away edible stuff: they may for example release scents similar to nectar volatiles, thus attracting insects to their nectar-free flowers. Others rely on sexual deception: their flowers look or smell like female insects, luring males to a non-existent receptive partner. To dupe flower visitors or just encourage them to come for legitimate incentives, orchids have evolved a bewildering variety of flower sizes, shapes, structures, colours and scents that are unique among angiosperms.

Examples of floral diversity in the orchid tribe Epidendreae © Valencia-Nieto et al., 2018:

Charles Darwin realised that flower traits were fine-tuned adaptations to promote cross-pollination by insects and other flower visitors. Among these ‘beautiful contrivances’ (Darwin, 1862), mechanisms of pollen production and transfer were found to be particularly elaborate.

Most plants produce loose, granular pollen that’s scooped up by a range of pollinators. But for orchids in general, and also for milkweed-related plants in the family Asclepiadaceae, pollen grains are contained in a tiny sack called a pollinium (pl. pollinia), which is connected via a stipe to a sticky pad referred to as a viscidium. The three structures form a unit called a pollinarium.

A pollinarium: the two pollinia on the toothpick hang from the stripe and are held in place by the viscidium © Frederick Depuydt, CC Attribution-Share Alike 4.0:

Thanks to the gluey viscidium, a flower visitor that touches the pollinarium is likely to fly away encumbered with a pollen load. When the visitor goes to another flower, the pollinarium adheres to the flower’s female parts, so pollination is ensured.

A bee orchid (Ophrys apifera) flower with its pollinarium clearly visible © Esculapio, CC Attribution-Share Alike 4.0:

Pollen lumped together in a single package greatly reduces the wastage of loose pollen grains. It also improves efficiency: the entire pollen load is removed in one pollinator visit. That’s important in situations when plants are isolated and pollinators are scarce. Despite their species richness, many orchids are naturally rare, often widely dispersed and hidden in the canopy. But this strategy is also risky; a pollinarium lost, taken by the wrong visitor or deposited in an incorrect position would mean no pollination at all. So orchids depend on the right type of pollinator to place pollen on a precise spot of a receptive stigma. To get to the target, the pollinarium must be attached to a specific area of the pollinator’s body, such as an insect’s thorax, mouthparts, frons (‘forehead’), eyes and legs: these are smooth surfaces to which a viscidium adheres particularly well.

a: A male Japanese longhorn (Eucera nipponensis) with late spider-orchid (Ophrys fuciflora) pollinarium attached to his head. b: location of the pollinarium on the flower © Yagame & Naka, 2024:

The meticulous, highly specialised association between orchids and pollinators has been described as a ‘lock and key’ strategy: a combination of the right ‘key’ (pollen on a pollinator’s exact spot) and the right ‘lock’ (flower’s exact spot) is required, otherwise the fertilisation mechanism will not be unlocked. Few plants offer a better example of this intricate bond than the bucket orchids (Coryanthes spp.).

A bucket orchid by John Nugent Fitch, 1883. Image in the public domain:

This small group (~60 species) of neotropical orchids is characterised by large, fleshy, brightly coloured flowers containing a structure analogous to a bucket or inverted helmet – the name Coryanthes was derived from the Greek corys (helmet) and anthos (flower). The column (fused male and female reproductive parts, a distinguishing feature of orchids) has two glands that secrete a watery solution that drips intermittently into the bucket, keeping it full. The column extends all the way into the bucket and sticks out at the bottom.

A fiendish contraption: parts of a helmet bucket orchid flower © Dalton Holland Baptista, CC Attribution-Share Alike 3.0:

Such odd arrangement raised Darwin’s curiosity, but it was Hermann Crüger (1818-1864), director of Trinidad’s botanical garden, who discovered bucket orchids’ cunning machinations to get pollinated.

As soon as it opens in the morning, the flower starts producing fragrances that are irresistible to male orchid bees (tribe Euglossini) from the genera Euglossa, Eulaema or Euplusia. Each orchid produces a specific blend that attracts one or a few bee species, who collect and store those perfumes to be used in courtship. While scraping fragrances from the flower’s lip, a male bee may slip and fall into the bucket. With his wings drenched, the male bee tries to crawl out, but the smooth surface and downward-pointing hairs in the bucket’s inner walls prevent escape. But not all is lost: the bewildered bee can get out by squeezing along a narrow passage formed by the bucket walls and the end of the column. As the bee struggles to get through this tunnel at the bottom of the bucket, the flower’s pollinarium is pressed against his thorax. But his ordeal is not over. The pathway is tight, so the bee may need to labour for up to 45 min before breaking free. Which suits the orchid: it takes some time for the viscidium to settle, so holding up the bee for a while assures that the pollinarium is firmly stuck to the bee’s body.

You can go – in a moment. A male bee leaving a bucket orchid flower is ‘gifted’ with a pollen package on his back © Nazarov & Gerlach, 1997:

These tribulations are not going to deter our adventurous bee; after all, he still needs to collect the right type of fragrances if he wants to find a mate. So he goes after another flower from the same orchid species, where he may go through the same trouble if he falls again in the bucket. But this time the pollinarium stuck to his back gets transferred to the flower’s stigma as he skedaddles, so pollination is accomplished. Another type of bee or some other insect will not do: if it’s larger than the orchid bee, it won’t squeeze through the column and will most likely drown; if it’s smaller, the pollinarium won’t get attached to it.

Pollination of C. kaiseriana by Euglossa alleni. From left to right: a bee using his foreleg to pull out of the column; he’s nearly out, with a pollinarium stuck to his body; bee waiting to dry out before flying off © Gerlach, 2011:

Bucket orchids and orchid bees are entwined in a remarkable mutualistic alliance, but other partners have their essential part to play. Bucket orchids grow only from ant-gardens, which are nests of arboricolous (tree-living) ants of the genera Azteca, Camponotus and Crematogaster. Their nests consist of packages of soil, litter and plant matter accumulated on tree branches. Ants defend the orchids from herbivores and snip off competing vegetation, and their nests are sources of moisture and nutrients from ant poo and decomposing matter. In return for these services, ants take nectar from orchids’ extrafloral nectaries without interfering with bee pollination. This orchid-ant interaction is so tight that orchidarium cultivation of bucket orchids is next to impossible.

An ant garden © AntWiki, CC Attribution-ShareAlike:

In the final chapter of his book on orchids, Darwin concluded: In my examination of Orchids, hardly any fact has struck me so much as the endless diversities of structure,- the prodigality of resources, – for gaining the very same end, namely, the fertilisation of one flower by pollen from another plant. He certainly would be thrilled to learn about the complexities of bucket orchids’ pollination, another splendid example of the workings of natural selection, the catalyst for the world’s biodiversity.

References

Darwin, C. R. 1862. The various contrivances by which orchids are fertilised by insects, and on the good effects of intercrossing. John Murray.

Gerlach, G. 2011. The genus Coryanthes: a paradigm in ecology. Lankesteriana 11: 253-264.

Nazarov, V. & Gerlach, G. 1997. The potential seed productivity of orchid flowers and peculiarities of their pollination systems. Lindleyana 12: 188-204.

Valencia-Nieto, B. et al. 2018. Anther development in tribe Epidendreae: orchids with contrasting pollination syndromes. PeerJ 6:e4383.

Yagame, T. & Naka, H. 2024. Sexually deceptive pollination of the non-native Ophrys fuciflora (Orchidaceae) in Japan by the native bee Eucera nipponensis (Hymenoptera: Apidae). European Journal of Entomology 121: 355-359.

Wednesday: Hili dialogue

November 18, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to a Hump Day (“Mezsemajna tago” in Esperanto): Wednesday, November 18, 2026, and Mickey Mouse Day.  Why today?

Mickey Mouse made his screen debut in the short film Steamboat Willie, on November 18, 1928. Today is seen as being Mickey’s birthday, as well as Mickey Mouse Day.

Here is “Steamboat Willie,” infinitely better than most children’s cartoons I’ve seen while visiting friends who have kids. Mickey shows up 30 seconds in (note the duck-squeezing at 5:30). It’s a lovely cartoon, which of course would not be made today for various reasons.

It’s also Apple Cider Day, National Vichyssoise Day, and National Zinfandel Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 1 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

*A forensic scientist who had rare access to Jeffrey Epstein’s autopsy file and photos has serious doubts about whether Epstein committed suicide, saying that the data are more consistent with “homicidal strangulation.” (You can see the photos if you follow the link, but they’re gruesome.) His conclusion is of course controversial, but a really bad bit is that not only can he not find anyone to publish his conclusions, but a scheduled talk about them at University College London was canceled because it might have affected the “well being of the students.” (Article archived here, h/t Peggy)

Michael Freeman says he had one thought when he first saw a photo from Jeffrey Epstein’s autopsy: “Wait a minute, that doesn’t look like a hanging mark.”

The noose had not left a smooth, consistent line on Mr. Epstein’s neck that slanted to a peak, as in a textbook hanging. Instead, the mark was deep, ragged and branched into a Y-shape on one side.

Dr. Freeman, a forensic scientist who studies bias and error in death investigations, spent a year examining Mr. Epstein’s autopsy file, which was given to him by the dead man’s brother.

He is seeking to publish his findings in a peer-reviewed journal, but has been rejected so far. On Monday he presented them at the Middle Temple, a London legal society, where he argued that Mr. Epstein’s injuries are most plausibly explained by homicidal strangulation. He also asserted that injuries on the body suggest there was a struggle, contrary to the medical examiner’s findings.

“The pattern and distribution and multitude of injuries are not explained by a suicidal hanging,” he said.

The totality of the circumstances surrounding Jeffrey Epstein’s death in a federal detention center in 2019 points overwhelmingly to suicide, and several investigations have failed to produce evidence that anyone other than Mr. Epstein had a hand in it. Dr. Freeman’s analysis, parts of which he floated in a New York Times investigation earlier this year, may rekindle long-smoldering debates about his death.

Forensic pathologists who have seen some of the autopsy photos, though not the entire set, have agreed that the mark on Mr. Epstein’s neck was atypical for a hanging. Some of those experts said the images could still be consistent with suicide, but they cautioned that the injuries alone could not tell the full story, and that a cascade of institutional failures would make it difficult to ever conclusively determine what happened.

Epstein’s brother, who’s referred to in the next paragraphs, gave Freeman permission to not only see the photos, but post them. Again, don’t download them unless you have the stomach for this kind of stuff. I am not a forensic anything, so I can’t render any opinions. Here’s the freedom-of-speech bit:

[Freeman and his colleagues] are continuing to seek a publisher for their analysis. In the meantime, Dr. Freeman prepared his talk on Monday, which received a flurry of advance news coverage.

The talk was to be held at the University College London, where reservations quickly reached capacity. But on Sunday, the school suddenly announced that it would not take place, citing “well-being implications for our students.” The talk was moved to the Middle Temple and those planning to attend were told they would have to watch it online.

Shortly before Monday’s talk, Mr. Epstein posted the autopsy photos online for all to see.

The photos were not going to be shown in the talk, so I presume that it is the subject, Epstein himself, that would hurt “well-being”. I don’t buy that because the public is intensely interested in Epstein, because Freeman just might be right, and at any rate the public needs to hear both sides. I have no dog in this fight save to say that University College London is unduly censorious.

*An op-ed in the WSJ suggests that Trump doesn’t need to resume hostilities with Iran to finish the war with a “good outcome.” (The views are informed by an earlier WSJ op-ed by David Petraeus).

Mr. Trump took a positive step on Thursday when he sidelined Vice President JD Vance as lead negotiator with Iran. A leak to the press a day earlier had touted Mr. Vance’s plan to engage directly with the hardest of Iranian hard-liners. But Mr. Trump may not want to be pre-empted by a Veep who has already told Iran that he wants the war to end.

“We don’t need a deal with Iran. Those days have since passed,” the President wrote on Truth Social. “We’ve got their money . . . and we’ve got their Strait!” That’s more than bluster.

. . .More crude oil now transits the Persian Gulf than before the war. Washington is in a stronger position than it was before the failed April cease-fire or June Memorandum of Understanding negotiated by Mr. Vance. Mr. Trump and Secretary of State Marco Rubio said last week that the U.S. blockade-and-escort strategy is working well enough that the U.S. doesn’t need to resume bombing.

. . .Meanwhile, Iran is suffering economically with the U.S. Navy blocking oil exports and the Treasury targeting other lifelines. Inflation is some 90% amid reports of unpaid wages, and Iran’s rial currency is plumbing record lows of 1.7 million to the dollar. The regime is extending gasoline restrictions province by province as shortages increase.

The question is whether Mr. Trump and the Navy can maintain the pressure. The operational strain of the blockade and ship-escorting mission is considerable. Mr. Trump is also surging U.S. air defenses and munitions to the Middle East, with troops moved off vulnerable bases and a third carrier strike group expected to arrive later this month.

. . .As time goes on, one Trumpian temptation may be to bomb Iran for a few days again in hopes of a better deal. It’s unlikely to work. Limiting the duration tells the regime it can spend a few days in bunkers, retaliate against Gulf energy, and declare victory.

A better way to think is about objectives. Former general and CIA director David Petraeus last week offered a good guide on these pages to the goals that would end the war as a strategic victory: capture Iran’s enriched uranium, bar future enrichment, and open the Strait without an Iran toll or demand for permission. That may require a raid on Pickaxe Mountain and the trapped nuclear stockpile—risky missions but not open-ended.

. . .Mr. Trump will also face opposition in Congress as Democrats will try to cut off money for the war. Mr. Trump has his veto pen, but he will have to explain himself to the American people better than he has. This means more than social-media bursts. Mr. Trump has never been consistent in explaining his war aims, his strategy, or what would constitute a victory. He needs to be clearer now if he wants to continue the pressure on Iran.

Whatever his mistakes in conducting the war, we believe Mr. Trump entered the conflict for the right reasons. He wants to rid the world of the threat of a nuclear-armed Iran and promote a new regional order in the Middle East focused on commerce and prosperity.

I agree that the war is a just war but that Trump vacillates continuously in what he says about it and how he conducts it.  And of course you can’t “raid” the nuclear stockpile without restarting big-time war. Plus Iran will just continue to enrich uranium unless the U.S. somehow deposes the regime—which isn’t part of the game plan now.

*The NYT has a list of “Ten days that changed the world“, and guess what is #1?  Well, they’re chronological, and the first day was in 1859. That should be all ye need to know (h/t Greg). Here are the days:

Well, the last doesn’t seem as portentous as the others, but it’s their call.  Note that this is a very long article with animations, videos, etc., and you might have a look if you subscribe. Note too that the NYT also describes “the days that almost made the list.”

*Lindsay Clancy, accused of killing her three children, is to be retried again in March (the first was ended by a hung jury).

A date has been set for a retrial of Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother who killed her three children in 2023 during what her attorneys asserted was an episode of postpartum psychosis.

Massachusetts Superior Court Judge William Sullivan set March 29 as the start date for a new trial Monday in Plymouth Superior Court, where Clancy appeared in person.

Clancy’s first trial ended in a mistrial Sept. 4, after one holdout juror kept the jury from returning unanimous “not guilty” verdicts.

Clancy was initially tried on three counts of first-degree murder. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague, who represented the state in court Monday, did not say whether the same charges would be pursued again, but said a jury trial would be required

Kevin Reddington, Clancy’s lawyer, said a jury trial was indicative of the state’s intention to try her again on the same charges.

“I think you can read between the lines that when they say that the case is going to require a jury, that it’s an indirect comment from the [district attorney] that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments,” he said.

Clancy’s three children, Cora, 5; Dawson, 3; and Callan, 8 months, were killed Jan. 24, 2023, in Duxbury, Massachusetts. Clancy has admitted to their strangulation deaths, but her lawyers argued that she could not be legally culpable because she was suffering from an episode induced by postpartum psychosis.

The defense could not ask for a judge to decide the case once Clancy was charged with first-degree murder, because in Massachusetts murder is consider a capital offense even though the state does not have the death penalty.  For other charges, like second-degree murder, the defense can ask for a bench (judge) trial.  I’m not sure why the prosecution wants a jury trial given the high probability (at least in my mind) of a “not guilty by reason of insanity” verdict or even another hung jury.  At least with a bench trial you don’t get a hung jury. In my experience as an expert witness, the prosecution is interested not in the truth but in convictions.

*The UPI reports on a great biological wonder: the annual migration of Christmas Island’s red crabs to the sea to mate and spawn in the water. It’s comparable, at least to me, to the great wildebeest migration in Africa.

Crab season has begun on Australia’s Christmas Island, with millions of the small red creatures making their annual pilgrimage to the coast.

Christmas Island National Park is offering daily livestreams of the crab migration from the red crab bridge, a 16-foot-tall structure installed to help the crabs safely cross over a busy road on their way to the coast.

AD

The annual migration kicks off with the first rains of the island’s wet season, which normally occur in October or November, but have been known to come as late as December or January.

The crabs come out from their rainforest homes and make their way to the coast for their annual mating ritual.

“The exact timing and speed of the migration is determined by the phase of the moon,” the park’s website explains. “Red crabs always spawn before dawn on a receding high-tide during the last quarter of the moon. Incredibly, they know exactly when to leave their burrows to make this lunar date.”

The migration causes multiple roads on the island to be temporary closed for the protection of the crustaceans, but tourists still flock to the island every year to observe the spawning at public locations including Drumsite, Flying Fish Cove, Ethel Beach and Greta Beach.

Parks Australia is livestreaming from the bridge for one hour each day for as long as the migration lasts.

You can read more about the Christmas island red crab (Gecarcoidea natalis) migration at the link in this sentence, and this is what Wikipedia says:

Once on the shore, the male crabs excavate burrows, which they must defend from other males. Mating occurs in or near the burrows. Soon after mating the males return to the forest while the females remain in the burrow for another two weeks. During this period they lay their eggs and incubate them in their abdominal brood pouch to facilitate their development.[10] At the end of the incubation period the females leave their burrows and release their eggs into the ocean, precisely at the turn of the high tide during the last quarter of the moon.[10][5] The females then return to the forest while the crab larvae spend another 3–4 weeks at sea before returning to land as juvenile crabs.

It amazes me that crabs know when to leave their burrows so they arrive at the ocean two weeks before just the right time.  And it’s heartening to me that the locals have built a “crab bridge” so the crustaceans don’t get squashed on their way to the beach. You can see that bridge in the livestreamed video below showing the crab migration. You might be able to see it now, but if it’s dark when you look, just scroll back to look at previous days. It’s fantastic.

Here’s the location of Christmas Island as given by Wikipedia. 

This vector image includes elements that have been taken or adapted from this file:  Malaysia on the globe (Southeast Asia centered).svg (by TUBS).

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, but Andrzej posted a vintage Hili dialogue:

Hili: Who invented the vicious circle?
Andrzej: I suspect the ancestors of the Sumerians or the Etruscans.
Hili: I was expecting a different answer.

Hili: Kto wynalazł błędne koło?
Ja: Podejrzewam przodków Sumerów albo Etrusków.
Hili: Spodziewałam się innej odpowiedzi.

*******************

From Funny and Strange Signs:

From CinEmma:

From Cats That Have Had Enough of Your Shit:

 

Masih is back with a horrible instance of an Iranian school handing a girl over to her father when they discovered she had a secret romance.  She subsequently died; it’s not clear whether by murder or suicide. But it doesn’t matter, for the death occurred after the father previously beat the girl in front of school officials.  This is what happens when the state and Islam are one.

A rare rescued walrus calf. Read the story at the NYT here (archived here), and turn sound up.

From Luana. This stuff can also be seen at my own university. Be sure to look at the documents.

One from Malcolm; comedian Dave Allen teaches his kid to tell time:

Two from my feed. First, Greta laughs at climate-change demonstrators, and of course she was once one. Lucy Biggers, the poster, is still a climate-change activist.

And it is absolute cinema. Can you stop watching it before it’s resolved?

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

And one from Matthew: an amphibious rodent!

This amphibious rodent hadn't been seen in ~100 years and was presumed extinct. But then, with a little bit of peanut butter, scientists lured it back into the limelight. 🧪www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/arti…

— Jason GRIZZLED Bittel (@bittelmethis.bsky.social) 2026-11-09T16:13:25.929Z

Mamdani disbands police unit targeting terrorism and violent protests, replaces with unarmed unit using “dialogue” and “de-escalation”

November 17, 2026 • 8:00 am

Yep, Mamdani is keeping his campaign promises in a way that is delighting Democratic Socialists, for it amounts to disbanding the police—at least a police unit dedicated to fighting terrorism and violent protests. Hizzoner couches it as a step forward and a fulfillment of his pledge, but what it will amount to is giving license to terrorism and violent protests, whose participants know that the cops won’t be there. What’s worse is that Mamdani’s plan is to stop the protests and terrorism with DIALOGUE and DE-ESCALATION instead of cops.  Yes, maybe that will work on rare occasions but it’s best to have the copes on hand, too.  I am sure that, in light of protests we’ve seen in the last five years, you know how well dialogue and de-escalation will work.

I woke up to find the video below of the Mayor’s announcement, sent by reader Jay, who added, “It took me the longest time to figure out that this wasn’t parody.”  And indeed, the whole thing, including the handshake at the end, shouts “parody.” It’s stiff, overscripted and, to me, scary. But it isn’t parody!!

The NYT and Free Press have different takes on this, of course, with the NYT giving a more neutral take but also adding the approval of the Democratic Socialists of America, of which Mamdani is one, while the Free Press is more op-ed-ish (I agree with their take). Below are excerpts from both sides.

From the NYT (click to read or find the article archived here).

At 6:59 a.m. on Monday, Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a social media video to announce that he was disbanding the Strategic Response Group, a specialized police unit that has been criticized for its handling of protests.

The video was a 102-second victory lap, with Mamdani adopting a mission-accomplished tone for fulfilling a campaign vow.

But then his administration’s messaging got more complicated.

Roughly an hour later, Mr. Mamdani appeared again, this time with his police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, giving a more nuanced presentation to WABC-TV that sought to reassure New Yorkers that the changes would not make New York less safe.

. . . In its cautious approach in announcing the changes, the Mamdani administration seemed to acknowledge the potential volatility of doing anything that revamps Police Department protocol. Indeed, city leaders, police unions and activists were sharply divided over how the changes would affect clashes between officers and demonstrators.

Under the new plan, civilians from the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety would act as the first line of communication with protesters. They would create a dialogue with demonstrators with the goal of de-escalating tension before it can erupt into violence.

I can imagine how effective a group of unarmed officials in civilian clothes will be in “de-escalating tension” like the stuff we saw recently in European demonstrations! “Please, stop the looting and burning. It is hurting your fellow New Yorkers!”  But I digress. More from the NYT:

“This will not be a uniformed police unit,” Mr Mamdani said. “It will be made up of civilians without weapons or arrest powers.”

The civilians would work with 30 officers in a new unit known as the First Amendment Support Team. They will be trained in communication and de-escalation, as well as crowd management.

A new patrol unit of trained officers would make arrests “in rare instances, if necessary,” according to a statement from the mayor’s office. That unit would also take on other responsibilities that once fell to the Strategic Response Group, such as searching for missing people, patrolling major events like the Thanksgiving Day parade and responding to large-scale crime scenes.

“There will be no long guns, tear gas, kettling or pepper spray used as crowd control tactics,” said Chi Ossé, a New York City Council member who appeared in the video with Mr. Mamdani and who previously had introduced legislation known as the CURB Act, which aimed to restrict the Strategic Response Group’s tactics.

. . . In a statement, the Democratic Socialists hailed the mayor’s announcement as a “victory” and “historic.”

“The S.R.G. and its predecessors are violent teams that for decades have suppressed the people’s constitutional right to protest and organize,” the statement said.

. . . .Vincent Vallelong, president of the [police] sergeants’ union, noted in a statement that officers in the group were at Gracie Mansion in March, when, during a protest by right-wing agitators, two men tried to throw homemade bombs into the crowd.

“I fear this approach will embolden violent agitators to infiltrate peaceful demonstrations, putting protesters, police and bystanders at risk,” Sergeant Vallelong said.

. . . . The decision also divided members of the City Council. While Mr. Ossé and other progressive members hailed the changes, Joann Ariola, a councilwoman representing Howard Beach, said the mayor was appeasing his base at the expense of New Yorkers’ safety.

“When bridges are blocked and streets are overrun with agitators,” she wrote on social media, “who is going to keep New Yorkers safe?”

Indeed.  Who? Will discussion and de-escalation stop rioting? When the Democratic Socialists praise something like this, you have to be suspicious, just as you had to be suspicious when a spokesman for the Muslim Brotherhood applauded El-Sayed’s election in Michigan.  And the last question is one echoed by the Free Press article (click if you have a subscription), which is, as expected, quite critical. The author was a federal prosecutor in Brooklyn for a decade. Click below.

An excerpt:

For over a decade, I served as a federal prosecutor in Brooklyn, where I prosecuted terrorists, including ISIS fighters and those who tried to help them. It taught me something most New Yorkers never have to think about: A crowd is an opportunity for people who mean to do harm. I saw firsthand how protests can be infiltrated by criminals and terrorists who use the cover of peaceful demonstrators to carry out violence.

That is why Mayor Mamdani’s decision yesterday to disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG) alarms me.

The SRG is the department’s specialized unit trained and equipped to stop violence and terrorism at protests. The mayor is replacing 500 highly trained uniformed officers with three new de-escalation teams made up of unarmed civilians and backup patrol cops authorized to make arrests at protests only “in rare instances.” The changes will take effect by spring—just as the weather warms and protest season returns.

In a statement announcing the disbandment, the mayor said, “New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat.” To be sure, peaceful protesters deserve respect. But he’s missing the point. Protests are dynamic. They can turn from speech to violence in seconds, and when they do, we need highly trained officers ready to handle it.

We have seen what happens when they are not. The SRG’s predecessor, the Disorder Control Unit, was created after the 1991 Crown Heights riots in Brooklyn, when a state investigation found the NYPD unprepared and ill-equipped as three days of violence tore through the neighborhood. The city learned that lesson the hard way. It should not have to learn it again.

We are trading a tested unit for an untested promise.

Today, the threat of civil unrest is still very real. We have seen protests in this city that have turned violent—smashed windows, burning buses, physical assaults. In 2020, two attorneys threw a Molotov cocktail into an NYPD vehicle during a protest in Brooklyn. In March of this year, two men accused of being ISIS supporters threw homemade bombs at a protest outside Gracie Mansion. And look at what is happening abroad in France: More than half a million people took to the streets, enraged over the cost of living, and parts of the demonstrations descended into arson and looting.

Most protesters are peaceful. But it takes only a few people determined to commit violence, and the city needs a force ready to stop them.

. . .Dialogue teams don’t stand a chance against criminals. Just hours after Mamdani announced he would disband the SRG, two unarmed peace officers were shot while conducting a wellness check in the Bronx. The man who shot them didn’t want to have a dialogue. Neither do terrorists. That leaves the backup patrol cops. They may receive crowd-management training, but they will be hamstrung with new restrictions when facing down criminals who know that resisting arrest and assaulting a cop are no longer prosecuted with seriousness. Moreover, it will be a part-time assignment for officers who spend most of their time on patrol, and it is being stood up from scratch. We are trading a tested unit for an untested promise.

The most immediate effect of the decision to disband the SRG is the message it sends—it emboldens those determined to wreak havoc on our streets. Criminals will be more likely to commit violence knowing that there will be no one there equipped to stop them.

The article discusses the people who will be hurt by this decision, including peaceful protestors who may have agitators embedded in them, religious people like the many Jews who have been attacked in New York or were victims of hate crimes (see below the fold), owners of bodegas and small businesses who get attacked and looted during protests (try discussing looters out of looting!), and commuters and bystanders whose lives are disrupted by non-peaceful protests.  Author Komatireddy ends this way:

None of this is to say that every protest has been handled perfectly. Where there are specific instances of misconduct or excessive force, they should be investigated. And a discussion about methods and tactics is important for addressing legitimate concerns and ensuring all New Yorkers—including peaceful protesters—feel protected. But dismantling the entire apparatus creates a violence free-for-all. That is a step too far.

The mayor’s decision—to disband SRG rather than improve it—makes New York less safe. You can almost picture the press releases: Officials will condemn the inevitable violence that follows, calling it “random” and “senseless” when it is actually predictable and preventable. As always, it’s the innocent, hardworking New Yorkers who will pay the price.

My first thought when I heard Mamdani’s announcement was that this will hearten antisemitic and pro-Palestinian protestors who intend to hurt Jews or for whom hurting Jews is a likely outcome.  As you should know, anti-Jewish hate crimes are far more frequent than anti-black or anti-Muslim hate crimes. I’ve put the data for NYC below, and you can see that more than 52% of all hate crime incidents in New York City, more than 52% to 57% of them were against Jews: more than all other hate crimes combined. I’ve put in the references below (you can click on the two links), and my question to Grok is in bold.

In the last year, how many anti-Jewish hate crimes were committed in NYC versus anti-Black hate crimes and anti-Muslim hate crimes?
Grok’s answer:

In calendar year 2025 (the most recent full year with complete NYPD data), there were 330 reported anti-Jewish hate crime incidents in New York City, compared with 45 anti-Black and 30 anti-Muslim incidents, out of 576 total hate crime incidents.

These figures come from NYPD data released in early January 2026 and have been consistently reported across multiple outlets citing the same official numbers. Anti-Jewish incidents accounted for about 57% of the total (more than all other categories combined), despite Jewish New Yorkers representing roughly 10% of the city’s population. Overall hate crimes fell about 12% from 657 in 2024, and anti-Jewish incidents were down about 3% from 339 the prior year.

But it’s not just Jews who will suffer, though I’m sure that was on Mamdani’s mind when he announced this. The other groups will, too, especially small store owners who can lose their livelihood, as they did in the recent Paris riots.  What was Mamdani thinking when he made this bonehead decision?  To enact a defunding of the police, I think, as well as to satisfy his DSA supporters, and to give a big middle finger to Jews and those who think that the police are essential, especially in these troubled times.  Those people who voted for Mamdani, especially the Jews, are going to get what they deserve. And Democrats who endorse him will eventually regret their decision.

 

Here are three responses.  First, a direct message that arrived from my friend, U of C neurobiologist Peggy Mason (she is Jewish), right as I was writing this. She had independently read about Mamdani’s announcement and contacted me (we’re both up early, though she’s in British Columbia). Her words are redacted to protect the sensitive, and the quote is with permission.

I’m so disgusted. New Yorkers are going to learn the consequences of their election in a very painful way and I hope those f—–g do gooder Jews who voted for him feel really f——g bad.

Second, a tweet following the video above:

The Babylon Bee had its usual sarcastic take. (Click below to read.)

“We’re spending millions to address a problem that doesn’t exist,” said Mamdani. “New York City has never experienced any sort of terrorism before, leaving this police force with literally nothing to do. This is exactly the kind of government waste that we are wanting to target. New Yorkers want to know that their tax dollars are being spent on actual problems that have plagued the city, such as a lack of city-owned grocery stores selling government cheese.”

Asked whether he might be overlooking a significant event in the city’s history, Mamdani dismissed the suggestion.

“If something like that had happened here, surely someone would have told us to never forget it,” he said. “So either it never happened, or people forgot. Either way, it’s clearly not a big deal to New Yorkers.”

At publishing time, Mamdani had also disbanded the Central Park police unit, citing the fact that nothing bad had ever happened there.

Click “continue reading” to see Grok’s answer to my question about the relative frequency of demonstrations against Israel versus those against Hamas/Palestine.

Continue reading “Mamdani disbands police unit targeting terrorism and violent protests, replaces with unarmed unit using “dialogue” and “de-escalation”” →

Tuesday: Hili dialogue

November 17, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to The Cruelest Day: Tuesday, November 17, 2026, and National Baklava Day, celebrating the world’s finest pastry. Here is a baklava shop I found in Istanbul in 2008, and ONE SERVING for me (I love the stuff). Do not judge me.

It’s also Homemade Bread Day, International Happy Gose Day (Gose is a wheat beer), World Butter Day, and World Peace Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 1 7 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

*The people of Ukraine are going to have a tough winter, as the Russians plan to destroy facilities that lead to the starvation, freezing, and other debilitation of noncombatant Ukrainians (article archived here).

*In a post at It’s Noon in Israel, Amit Segal tells us that Hamas and the UN, not Israel, have blocked attempts to give Gazans better shelter for the approaching winter.

Winter has arrived in the Gaza Strip. With the rain has come a storm of criticism over Israel’s failure to shelter displaced Gazans. As usual, there is a notable omission.

Threats from Hamas forced the UN Development Programme to abandon a plan to install improved shelters for families living in tents, according to a Ramallah-based Palestinian Authority official who spoke to the Arabic-language outlet Jusoor. The official, who was not authorized to speak publicly, said Hamas threatened PA staff working on the project with kneecapping.

In February, UNDP began replacing 300 tents in Gaza City’s Al-Zaytoun neighborhood with 19-square-meter prefabricated units—sealed doors, ventilation windows, solar lighting. In April, Alessandro Mrakic, head of UNDP’s Gaza office, said the units would provide “more dignity, privacy, and protection during the winter.” Around 4,000 were planned.

The problem was who was involved.

The PA’s Ministry of Public Works and Housing ran the surveys and dealt with camp residents. In September, the official said, Hamas summoned its staff and told them to stop. They didn’t. A week later, Hamas summoned them again and made them sign a pledge to stay out of the camps. Violators would be kneecapped.

Hamas saw the project as a threat to its control of the camps. When reached for comment, Gaza-based ministry officials declined to comment. “We don’t want to create more problems,” one said. But according to Palestinian analyst Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, Public Works staff had been coerced into signing pledges not to run humanitarian projects without Hamas approval, under threat of “field justice.”

*The Free Press discusses how Chuck Schumer may not have a lock on being Senate majority leader when the new Congress convenes next year. He has a challenger, and the challenger is much more negative on Israel than is Schumer. I guess that counts as a positive for Van Hollen in the “new” Democratic Party, despite Schumer having presided over a historic Democratic recapture of the Senate.

. . . Schumer is facing an insurgent challenger, Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland senator who aligns with the progressive wing of his party. Since formally announcing his bid to be majority leader, Van Hollen has blasted Schumer for endorsing moderates in Senate primaries earlier this year. He has also threatened to shut down the federal government in order to defund the war in Iran.

Van Hollen may not be likely to win. Unlike the House, the insurgent left is still nascent in the Senate with only a handful of committed members, including old-timer Bernie Sanders, newcomers such as Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Troy Jackson of Maine, and sometime fellow travelers like Connecticut’s Chris Murphy. But the challenge to Schumer shows that Democrats’ rift over Israel wasn’t mere election fodder. It will be the most important factional line within the next congressional majority—and the side most hostile to Israel has the momentum, despite Schumer’s attempts to catch up.

The two candidates for majority leader are chalk and cheese. Schumer comes from the middle class. His father was an exterminator in Brooklyn who saved money to send him to Harvard. Van Hollen, on the other hand, was born in Karachi, Pakistan, where his father was in the foreign service and his mother worked as an intelligence analyst.

The biggest difference between Van Hollen and Schumer is how both approach U.S. policy toward Israel. Van Hollen, in recent years, has distinguished himself as a bitter foe of the Jewish state and its war in Gaza. In 2025, after leading a delegation of lawmakers to Gaza, Van Hollen and Senator Jeff Merkley of Oregon issued a report that accused Israel of ethnic cleansing. This year, Van Hollen voted for a bill to ban the sale of offensive weapons systems to Israel. He also said last week that the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee should refuse to take any money from the largest pro-Israel lobby, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC.

Schumer, for his part, has evolved over the years to cater to the leftward drift of his own party. He has not said whether he supports or opposes getting rid of the filibuster. Schumer has promised to zero out funding for the Iran war and proposed legislation to provide some federal regulation of the AI industry. And while Schumer voted against the bill this year to block the sale of offensive weapons to Israel, the senator from New York has also publicly chastised Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu. In 2024, Schumer gave a floor speech calling on Israelis to hold new elections and labeled Netanyahu one of four “obstacles to peace,” along with extremist Israeli settlers, Hamas, and the leader of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas.

More recently, Schumer was one of the first senators to endorse Abdul El-Sayed after he defeated Rep. Haley Stevens in the party’s Senate primary in August. Schumer endorsed Stevens in that contest. Despite pressure from pro-Israel organizations, Schumer steered $10 million from his own Senate Majority PAC to El-Sayed’s campaign for the general election. When Stevens herself withdrew support for El-Sayed and endorsed his Republican opponent, Schumer said she had committed an act of “despicable betrayal.”

It’s bad enough that Schumer, who is Jewish, endorsed El-Sayed, who I regard as an antisemite, but I suppose he was obliged to endorse all Democratic candidates for Senate who have won theur primaries.(Still, I don’t think that Stevens committed an act of “despicable betrayal” by going with her conscience.) On the other hand, I’d rather have Schumer in charge than “a bitter foe of the Jewish state and its war on Gaza.” I presume that Van Hollen thought that on October 7, 2023, Israel should not have responded to the terrorist attack that killed over 1200 people, right? It baffles me why this kind of anti-Israel behavior is spreading through the Democratic Party.

*Again from the Free Press, which discusses the case of Ilhan Omar. While freely admitting that the investigation was motivated by Trump’s political animus, Jed Rubenfeld, in his article “Will the case against Ilhan Omar hold up?” is more concerned with discussing the merits of the case. Conclusion: it’s far from open and shut, but there’s little new to learn.

. . . it has been widely reported that the Justice Department is investigating two primary allegations: (1) that Omar married her own brother in 2009 to help him obtain immigration papers; and (2) that she was 18, not 17, when she received U.S. citizenship in 2000. (A separate investigation, led by U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro, is looking into alleged financial improprieties.)

It’s plausible that the administration is targeting Omar for political reasons. She’s a founding member of the progressive “Squad” and a harsh critic of Donald Trump. Last month, the president called Omar “a sick,” “very dishonest person” who “hates our country.” After Omar and Rep. Rashida Tlaib (a Palestinian American) protested Trump at this year’s State of the Union address, the president posted on Truth Social that “we should send them back from where they came—as fast as possible.”

On the other hand, this isn’t the first time Omar has faced legal scrutiny. The Justice Department and Department of Homeland Security probed her immigration history when she ran for the Minnesota House in 2016—while Barack Obama was president. That investigation ended without charges when prosecutors determined that any crimes she might have committed were beyond the statute of limitations. But the fact that a Democratic administration probed Omar to begin with suggests that there’s more than raw politics going on here.

. . . Let’s take the allegations one at a time. Could she really have married her brother? Incredibly, she may indeed have done so. In fact, while there’s no proof, I’d have to say that based on currently available evidence, it’s more likely than not. But while this allegation is the most scandalous, it may have the least legal impact.

. . . entering a sham marriage to procure immigration papers for one’s brother is criminal immigration fraud. But the statute of limitations for that crime is five years—a period that passed long ago. Even if Omar was still technically conspiring to commit immigration fraud with Elmi all the way through 2017, when they were formally divorced, the limitations period would still be long over.

This claim could be disproven with a simple DNA test, but for some reason Omar has refused to take one (her brother would have to do it, too). Perhaps the search of her house got the DNA evidence, at least from her. The other allegation, which according to Rubenfeld has more serious consequences for Omar,is that Omar misrepresented her age when as 17 when she became an American citizen, for she could not have gotten citizenship at 18.

If Omar was 18 in 2000, she never legally obtained U.S. citizenship. As an 18-year-old, she would have been required to apply for citizenship on her own, satisfying the then-applicable criteria. She might well have obtained citizenship through that process, but that might-have is legally irrelevant. If her 2000 derivatively obtained citizenship was unlawful, it appears her current status would be an alien, noncitizen lawful permanent resident.

This has potentially profound legal ramifications. No statute of limitations applies to denaturalization proceedings.

Rubenfeld’s conclusion?

I myself find Omar close to unbearable. Her recent campaigning with streamer Hasan (“I hate America”) Piker is an example. But being insufferable is not grounds for deportation, and the bottom line is this: There is a strong chance that she will escape the Justice Department’s investigation unscathed.

The most scandalous allegation—that she married her own brother—may well be true, but the potential legal impact is small. By contrast, the seemingly much more technical allegation—that she was 18 rather than 17 in 2000—packs potentially drastic legal consequences, but the proof required for those consequences may well be unattainable.

I’m still wondering why the judge authorized a search of Omar’s home, and took six hours of scrutiny of the government’s case before signing the warrant. That amount of time is very unusual.  Is there something incriminating that we don’t know? Well, we have two more years to find out—as long as Trump is President. I thought this whole thing was simply a Trumpian political vendetta—until the search warrant was authorized.

*Here’s clickbait in the NYT, at least for a zoologist: ““Birdbrain’ is a misnomer.  Crows can make decisions faster than we can.” The authors of the paper below studied the ability of two carrion crows to decide which way a group of dots were moving by pecking at a “target” dot that indicated direction.  Here’s a photo from the NYT (with credit to one of the paper’s authors) showing the setup: a central group of dots that move, either together or mostly, to the right or left (or up or down), with the birds pecking at the target indicating the “majority” direction. You can see the two targets below, and the birds were trained how to respond beforehand.  They pecked very quickly at the targets, and with very high accuracy.

An excerpt from the NYT:

. . . . birds can make staggeringly quick decisions, besting their human and nonhuman primate counterparts with ease. In new findings published in Science, the crows could process and respond to visual cues at twice the speed as humans and monkeys, quantifying the neural speed of avian decision-making for the first time.

The discovery might be the final blow for the use of “birdbrains” as a pejorative.

“We wouldn’t think of birds making these decisions faster than monkeys, or faster than us ‘awesome’ human beings,” said Mike Colombo, a neuroscientist and comparative psychologist at the University of Otago in New Zealand who was not involved in the research. “But they do. They’re just incredibly fast.”

. . .For the new study, researchers at the University of Tübingen in Germany wanted to better understand how crows make decisions, so they set up an experiment to record their brain activity as the birds performed a visual task. After several weeks of training — and countless mealworm treats — Lemmy and Iggy learned to peck left or right to match the orientation of flashing white dots on a black screen.

During the experiment, the dots would randomly orient facing left or right. Sometimes a majority of the dots would align in one direction, making the task easy. Other times, only a small percentage would change, making it difficult. The crows’ objective was to peck the screen to match the orientation of the dots; at the same time, their neural activity was recorded by electrodes.

It ain’t so easy: if you can access the original article, have a look at two of the moving groups of dots the birds had to deal with.

. . .For the new study, researchers at the University of Tübingen in Germany wanted to better understand how crows make decisions, so they set up an experiment to record their brain activity as the birds performed a visual task. After several weeks of training — and countless mealworm treats — Lemmy and Iggy learned to peck left or right to match the orientation of flashing white dots on a black screen.

During the experiment, the dots would randomly orient facing left or right. Sometimes a majority of the dots would align in one direction, making the task easy. Other times, only a small percentage would change, making it difficult. The crows’ objective was to peck the screen to match the orientation of the dots; at the same time, their neural activity was recorded by electrodes.

. . . The crows were allowed three seconds to make their decisions, but the results revealed they needed less than one. They reliably pecked their answers in about 235 milliseconds, which is twice as fast as rhesus monkeys or humans when performing similar experiments. Moreover, they pecked their decisions at breakneck speeds without compromising accuracy. “This was a result that we didn’t anticipate,” Dr. Nieder said.

Of course this doesn’t mean that birds are “smart” in the “intelligence” sense, as implied in the title saying “birdbrains” is a “misnomer”.  Lots of animals can do stuff faster or better than we can, and the discriminatory ability of crows may reflect their evolutionary history more than smarts. The article does mention this at the end:

The Tübingen team suspects the ability to make such quick decisions might have evolved in response to the risky world of flight, where the difference between quickly or slowly reacting to something in the field of vision could be the difference between a smooth flight and crashing, or missing out on food.

Remember that some birds can fly at high speed through dense forest, avoiding all the trees. That would reflect a similar kind of ability.

You can read the original paper by clicking below.

There’s also a Perspective in Science that you can read by clicking below:

The authors of the paper and Perspective attribute the speed of the crows to the arrangement of the neurons in their brain, but you can read about that here.

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, but Andrzej has posted a vintage Hili Dialogue:

Hili: Did Rousseau have a cat?
Andrzej: I don’t know, why do you ask?
Hili: I’m wondering where he got the idea of the noble savage from.

In Polish:

Hili: Czy Rousseau miał kota?
Ja: Nie wiem, dlaczego pytasz?
Hili: Zastanawiam się, skąd mu się wzięła koncepcja szlachetnego dzikusa.

*******************

From Cats, Coffee & Chaos: CATZILLA!

From Meow Incorporated:

From Funny and Strange Signs:

 

Curious, the timing of this gender transition!  Fortunately, the woman did survive, and the man who identified as a woman got ten years (that would be a light sentence in the U.S. You can read about it in The Daily Fail.

From Malcolm , a cat ladder:

From the Number Ten Cat. The translation of the Arabic in Hitchens post is “Let me introduce you to the cat who has an official position at the British ambassador’s residence. 🐈#غاريالقطالدبلوماسي.”  Hitchen is the British Ambassador to Saudi Arabia, and he introduces us to the new cat there: Gary!

One I found. Discuss.

Two from my feed. First, the guy who played Doron, the star of “Fauda”, and you must watch that complete series:

Agile cats:

One I reposted frm The Auschwitz Memorial:

This Czech Jewish boy was gassed as soon as he arrived in Auschwitz. He was 14 years old.

— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T11:33:33.857Z

And one from Doctor Cobb: Orca sighting with a link:

Rare Orca Sighting. Read the full story here: buff.ly/GdkW8BW Video by MaxThis is an encounter from 2026#WhaleTales #orca

— Whale Tales (@whaletalesorg.bsky.social) 2026-11-05T21:35:32.953Z