Caturday felid trifecta: A new Kiffness song; Defib the cat; feral cat Captain Jack brings two dozen friends to his adoptive home; and lagniappe

November 21, 2026 • 9:15 am

The Kiffness, a South African musician whose real name is David Scott, has a Wikipedia page, where, believe it or not, there is no mention of his cat songs like the new one below. They do mention his “They’re Eating the Cats” video, which I’ve also put below.

The title of this song is “Oh Yeah Oh Yeah (Cat Singing Duet)”:

The video below is described on Wikipedia:

In September 2024, Scott produced a video satirising a claim made by Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump in that month’s presidential debate. Trump repeated unverified reports that Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, were eating cats and dogs kept as pets by members of the local community. The claim was subsequently denied by the mayor of Springfield, Rob Rue, and widely ridiculed in the media. Scott’s video, “Eating the Cats”, went viral on social media and was viewed over one million times on X within 24 hours of its posting.  Scott pledged to donate all proceeds to the Clark County SPCA in Springfield, raising over $20,000 for the organization.[24] On 18 September, the Kiffness performed “Eating the Cats” live in Munich, Germany, and he has continued to play it at subsequent concerts.

Here’s his satire of Trump, “Eating the Cats”:

*********************

Whisker Theory gives us the story of Defib the Cat, a rescue cat who lived at an ambulance station in London, was named after a defibrillator, and was facing eviction.  There are two videos below. First, a 2024 story in the Independent (click headline to read) before Defib was saved.

A rescue cat that has lived at a London ambulance station for 16 years is being threatened with eviction.

The feline, named Defib, was rescued as a kitten by staff at Walthamstow Ambulance Station in 2008 and has lived there since.

But the cat’s days at the station look to be numbered as London Ambulance Service want to rehome the animal.

The service says some staff cannot use the station due to allergies and that the cat’s slow reactions mean it is at risk from moving vehicles.

However, more than 60,000 people have signed a petition against the cat being moved.

Local Labour MP Stella Creasy has even come to Defib’s support, urging health secretary Wes Streeting to intervene.

“Defib the cat facing a no fault eviction from Walthamstow’s ambulance base – hard to see why given he’s lived there for 16 years happily and helps staff cope with a stressful job,” she wrote on X.

“Perhaps Wes Streeting if you are feline the staff’s pain you could have a word with the London Ambulance Service.”

And the petition worked! Defib was not evicted! Sadly, he died in January of this year.

From Whisker Theory:

Defib, the cat who lived at Walthamstow Ambulance Station in east London, had a petition to keep him pass 12,000 signatures within 48 hours of the first report in October 2024, and it later passed 62,000.

He had arrived as a stray kitten that staff rescued, and by October 2024 he had lived at the station for about 16 years. He was named for the defibrillator. He sat on top of ambulances, and he had a meow that people said sounded like an ambulance siren. Staff described him as a little bit needy and fond of cuddles. He had a small hut in the back garden, and people came to the station specifically to see him.

That October, London Ambulance Service planned to rehome him. The reasons reported were his age and slowed reactions, several near misses with ambulances at the busy station, and severe allergies among some staff. ESN Report said a new station manager made the decision.

A staff member started the petition and stayed anonymous. They told the Waltham Forest Echo they had expected a few thousand signatures in a week. They also called the allergy worry “nonsensical”, said no one had died of a cat allergy in Defib’s years there, and noted that he stayed mostly indoors because of his age. Those are the petition starter’s views, and the starter also said managers bring dogs to work.

They gave a longer account too. Several years earlier, they said, management had tried to rehome him, and he was allowed to stay on condition that the public not know about him. This time, they said, management suggested Battersea Dogs and Cats Home as a last resort if staff did not house him before Christmas. [JAC: Battersea is where 10 Downing Street procured Larry, the Chief Mouser of the Cabinet Office.]

Stella Creasy, the MP for Walthamstow, shared the petition and called the move a “no fault eviction”. She said he had lived there happily for 16 years and helped staff cope with a stressful job, and Hello Rayo reported that she urged the health secretary to intervene.

On 17 October 2024, London Ambulance Service chief executive Daniel Elkeles wrote on X that “Defib can remain at Walthamstow Ambulance Station”. The service said it had listened to staff and the public.

Defib died in January 2026. Station staff began raising money through the London Ambulance Charity’s London Heart Starters Campaign for public-access defibrillators in his memory. BBC London quoted a description of him as “very friendly and therapeutic”. A cat named for a lifesaving machine is now being remembered with more of them.

Has a workplace, a street or a building near you ever had a cat that everyone there would have fought to keep?

Sources: Waltham Forest Echo / Hello Rayo / ESN Report / BBC News

A short video of Defib:

A longer news report on Defib, recounting the aborted eviction:

The announcement of Defib’s death:

*********************

This report appeared on my “News” app on the iPhone, and you can link to it by clicking on the headline (alternatively, you can go to the I Heart Cats website):

A few excerpts:

Captain Jack was once a feral cat living near farmland behind a woman’s home, but his growing friendship with her would eventually change life for an entire colony of cats. What began with one cautious visitor slowly turned into a remarkable relationship, with Jack becoming comfortable enough to accept affection and even enjoy some indoor comforts. But he didn’t keep his newfound safe place to himself. Before long, he began bringing other cats along, and the woman’s garden became a welcoming refuge for 24 feral cats.

Today, Captain Jack remains an outdoor cat who enjoys visiting his favorite person, sleeping in his special spot, and occasionally causing trouble among his feline companions. His caregiver would love to welcome him indoors permanently, but Jack has made it clear that he still prefers having the freedom to come and go.

The woman first noticed signs of a feral cat colony living on farmland behind her house. Captain Jack was among the cats who began appearing near her property, and she gradually developed a connection with him.

After Jack started visiting regularly, she arranged for him to be neutered. That was only the beginning of what would become a much larger effort to care for the neighborhood’s outdoor cats.

As Jack grew more familiar with his caregiver, something unexpected happened. He started bringing other cats to her garden, and the number of regular visitors continued to grow.

There are now 24 feral cats living around the garden, where they have access to food, shelter, and a person who looks after them. The woman has provided several outdoor cat houses filled with straw to help keep them warm and dry.

She also leaves her kitchen door open during the day, giving the cats opportunities to become more comfortable around people without forcing them into unfamiliar situations.

Although Jack is still an outdoor cat, he has developed a fondness for certain indoor comforts. One of his favorite activities is curling up on a bed placed on a chair, where he can relax while staying close to his caregiver.

However, Jack has one important rule about visiting the house. He doesn’t like having the door closed behind him.

His caregiver explained that they have managed to keep the door shut for approximately two seconds before Jack begins to panic. Despite enjoying his cozy resting place, he still needs to know he can leave whenever he wants.

. . .Perhaps the most remarkable part of Captain Jack’s story is the influence he has had on the other cats. His caregiver believes that watching Jack accept affection has helped some of his companions become more comfortable with human interaction. Of the 24 cats in the garden, approximately eight now allow her to stroke them. She credits Jack with helping them feel safe enough to approach her.

By seeing Jack interact comfortably with her, the other cats have had opportunities to observe a familiar companion receiving attention without anything frightening happening. For cats that previously avoided close human contact, allowing someone to touch them is a meaningful change.

The colony has also received important veterinary support. Thanks to a charity that covered the appointments, all 24 cats have been spayed or neutered. Since then, the caregiver reports that no new kittens have been born within the colony. Instead of watching more litters arrive, she now enjoys seeing the adult cats playing and spending time together.

Here’s a photo of Captain Jack taken from YouTube, followed by a video of Captain Jack, his staff, and his feral companions:

Be sure to hear Captain Jack’s owner, especially about how Jack demands his pets first:

 

**********************

Lagniappe: A VERY spoiled moggy!

A photo of a cafe sign that is labeled accurately:

A video evincing proof that cats know their names:

Saturday: Hili dialogue

November 21, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to CaturSaturday, November 21, 2026, shabbos for Jewish cats and National Gingerbread Cookie Day.  Gingerbread cookies at Christmas are a big deal in Poland, and here’s a hand-decorated pair I saw in Katowice in December of 2024:

It’s also National Cranberry Day, National Stuffing Day (celebrating the foodstuff, not the act), and Pumpkin Pie Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 21 Wikipedia page.

I will be out of Chicago from Monday through next Friday, as I’m going to visit friends for Thanksgiving in the warm Southwest. Posting will be erratic, but I trust that at least the American readers will be busy with the holidays. I do my best.

Da Nooz:

*This is just in the discussion stage, but I like the idea: according to the WSJ, U.S. envoys have been broaching the idea of Ukraine joining NATO. But there’s a catch (bolding below is mine):

In closed-door peace talks over the past few months, President Trump’s son-in-law and special envoy Jared Kushner has discussed an idea once believed to be dead-on-arrival: NATO membership for Ukraine if it cedes territory to Russia, said people familiar with the matter.

Moscow has fought for years to prevent Ukraine from joining the 32-member North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Trump himself ruled out NATO membership for Ukraine early last year as unacceptable to Russia.

But the idea has been raised in several conversations between European officials and Kushner and his fellow envoy Steve Witkoff in recent months, said people involved in the talks.

Most recently, Kushner discussed the possibility with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and European officials at a Dublin military airfield last week, said people familiar with the discussion. There, the U.S. envoys met with Zelensky, his adviser Rustem Umerov, and selected European national-security advisers.

It also came up in at least one meeting last week in the United Arab Emirates, where Kushner and Witkoff were meeting with Ukrainians, Europeans and Russians in a series of meetings aimed at negotiating a deal to end the war, said people familiar with those discussions. The idea was raised in a phone call as early as August, one European leader said.

The U.S. has raised two possible scenarios in recent talks, according to people involved in the negotiations. The first would require Ukraine to give up the territory it still controls in a region of eastern Ukraine known as the Donbas, where the two sides have been battling for much of the war, in exchange for full NATO membership. The second idea was to freeze the conflict along the front line—which would leave part of the Donbas territory in Ukrainian hands—and give Ukraine security guarantees to protect it from a future Russian assault through an international treaty with the U.S., and potentially with European allies.

A U.S. official said negotiators are discussing many ideas, but both Ukraine and Russia would need to agree to any final deal.

Broaching the idea of NATO membership for Ukraine shows how far Washington might be willing to go to break a stalemate in talks between Russia and Ukraine. Trump and previous U.S. administrations have resisted offering Ukraine membership in the military alliance, fearing that doing so would risk drawing the West into a confrontation with Moscow. Some European leaders share that fear.

Russia will certainly not agree to give Ukraine membership in NATO in return for anything, as it would represent an extension of Allied powers further into Europe, something Russia has adamantly opposed. The second alternative: security guarantees for Ukraine, is doubtful, and certainly would not work if those guarantees were international as well as with the U.S.  For that would be almost equivalent to Ukraine joining NATO. I think Russia will just keep fighting and destroying Ukrainian infrastructure.  That said, I’m wholly in favor of both suggestions. We are not doing enough to help Ukraine and Zelensky.

*I thought that Trump’s “triumphal arch,” one of the worst architectural ideas of this Administration (the Great Ballroom is in the running) was changed from a military-security facility containing snipers, drones, and ammo, back to a peaceful monument. Not so. As the NYT reports, it’s still going to be a military facility, too, putting weapons and ammo around tourist (article archived here).

The president is rebranding the triumphal arch as an armed military complex that would also host tourists. Nothing in the design explains how civilians would be kept safe.

President Trump has championed his idea for a 250-foot-tall arch in Washington as a commemoration of America’s 250th birthday or, on at least one occasion, a monument to himself. Recently, though, he has added a new rationale — national security.

Mr. Trump first announced in September that the arch would be outfitted with drones, snipers and ammunition storage. After a federal judge temporarily halted its construction this month, the White House promoted a website launched by Trump allies that declared it would be a “highly secretive” and “lethal” structure.

A New York Times analysis of the latest arch design shows how much it clashes with the administration’s military goals.

Converting the arch into a dual-use facility could put military operations in close proximity to up to 450 tourists at any given time.

An exploded diagram showing the interior of each floor. Public spaces are highlighted on each floor.

Plans for the arch have visitors flowing through much of its interior. The website promoted by the White House said munitions would be stored in the columns.

Any government snipers would likely have to be stationed on this public observation deck for tourists [JAC: the highest yellow level below]. . . … or on the roof. Sensors and communication equipment would also likely have to be housed at the top of the arch.

The website said drones would be launched from around the base of the monument, where visitors would be entering and exiting.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said in sworn statements to a federal court last month that the arch would address pressing security threats facing the nation’s capital, namely from small unauthorized drones.

The National Capital Planning Commission, a federal panel stacked with Trump allies, approved the arch on Nov. 5 without reviewing details of the military proposal. Immediately afterward, Tanya S. Chutkan, a federal judge, blocked construction, saying that the project would cause harm to surrounding areas and would most likely need congressional approval. Her order has been extended until Dec. 3.

Judge Chutkan called the national security argument “belated and unsupported.” The same retroactive justification may have helped secure a Supreme Court ruling in August that allowed construction to continue on Mr. Trump’s White House ballroom.

In an October hearing, Judge Chutkan demanded more evidence on the need for military use, which administration lawyers were unable to provide. “We’re not talking about plans for a cafeteria,” she said, later questioning, “munitions, military drones at a site that is anticipated to get between 2,000 and 22,000 civilian tourists a day?”

Seriously, if they need beefed-up security in Washington, D.C. (and I’m not sure they do), they can do it from government buildings in the city where public access is barred. This is insane.

Here’s a gif of the Arch’s architecture as taken from yesterday’s NYT morning report. The orange parts will supposedly be the bits open to the public.

*I was doubly surprised when I read this WaPo op-ed written by its editorial board. First, it notes that Starbucks workers have failed to unionize despite a movement to create a union. Second, the editorial says that American’s shouldn’t support these failed attempts to unionize (article archived here).

Nearly five years after Starbucks Workers United began trying to organize the coffee chain, the union still represents only about 5 percent of its U.S. baristas and has yet to secure a contract. Asking customers to stop patronizing Starbucks is its latest attempt to gain leverage.

So far, the boycott is a revolt on decaf. Union supporters last week staged rallies on about 40 college campuses. (There are more than 3,900 degree-granting institutions in the United States.) The Cleveland City Council voted this week to encourage residents to join the boycott.

The union claims to represent about 12,000 baristas at nearly 700 of the company’s more than 16,000 U.S. outposts. Its demands include a $17 wage floor, 4 percent annual raises, minimum staffing of three workers and “just cause” protections against discipline and firing.

Staffing mandates tie managers’ hands when stores are quiet. Automatic raises weaken the link between pay and productivity. “Just cause” rules make it harder to dismiss poor performers. Higher labor costs can mean higher prices for customers, fewer hours for workers, more automation and more store closures.

Competition offers better protection for workers than any union does. As rivals expanded, Starbucks’s share of U.S. coffee-shop spending fell from 52 percent in 2023 to 48 percent in 2025. If baristas don’t like their working conditions, they can take their talents to Dunkin’, Dutch Bros, 7 Brew, Scooter’s, Peet’s, Caribou, Tim Hortons, Blue Bottle or thousands of independent cafes. Restaurants and retailers want those workers, too.

Starbucks already offers generous benefits to attract and retain staff. The company says average hourly pay exceeds $19, and eligible workers can receive health coverage, stock, paid parental leave and college tuition. Turnover among hourly workers is roughly half the industry average.

Starbucks Workers United is free to call for a boycott. Americans are equally free to order a pumpkin spice latte and raise a toast to Thanksgiving in the land of liberty and free enterprise.

The same arguments could be raised against many unions or their contracts with management.  Of course people have the right to organize and employees have the right to resist. But unions have played a valuable role in preventing exploitation of workers, and it seems unseemly to say they somehow contradict “liberty and free enterprise.” Of course, it looks like the working conditions at Starbucks are pretty good, including high wages and medical benefits.

*A Democratic Socialist who decries the wokeness of Democrats? Yes, it’s Meagan Day, a writer for Jacobin magazine, with an op-ed in the NYT called, “I’m a socialist. Wokeness is stil the Left’s biggest liability” (article archived here).

A large and spirited class of freshman progressives is officially headed to Congress, including six democratic socialists and nine more candidates endorsed by Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont. Even moderate candidates won their midterm elections by talking about economic inequality and billionaires, suggesting the distinction between Democratic Party factions may be softening. The left has the best opportunity in decades to showcase its politics and values.

We can’t squander it. For nearly 20 years, I’ve watched one pattern pull the left off course after it takes power. It used to be called political correctness, then call-out culture, then cancel culture and now wokeness.

Over the summer, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York tried to consign these excesses to the recent past, declaring that “Woke 1 was crazy.” But woke rhetoric has embedded itself into the party, and Democrats will have to work to excise it. Representative Ro Khanna of California celebrated the election results as heralding the return of D.E.I. Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, whom Democrats on Wednesday nominated to be the speaker of the House, dismissed a group of critics because they were mostly white. Leftist groups still find themselves divided over identity and privilege. And progressives have flooded the internet with jokes that “woke is back.” These posts may be kidding, but if our movement doesn’t distance itself from identity politics, we could jeopardize everything we’ve achieved.

To hear many conservatives define it, I would be considered woke. I’ve been a member of the Democratic Socialists of America for 10 years. I believe this country needs deep criminal justice and police reform. I am galled by ICE agents ethnically profiling and brutalizing people. I not only support gay marriage but am an enthusiastic participant in one.

But wokeness is not about a basic concern for social justice. It hyperfocuses on language and identity, fights dirty from the moral high ground and mandates deference to self-appointed spokespeople for marginalized groups. It conflates disagreement with harm, and keeps careful watch for heretics.

. . .Wokeness’s vague, maximalist rhetoric trickled up to Congress. Moderate Democrats put on silly stunts to signal their “allyship” and co-opted woke terms like “feeling unsafe” to shut down protest. Leftists including Ms. Ocasio-Cortez and Representatives Rashida Tlaib of Michigan and Ilhan Omar of Minnesota echoed calls in 2020 to “defund the police,” an unpopular slogan that Ms. Ocasio-Cortez defended by tweeting that the “whole point of protesting is to make ppl uncomfortable.”

President Trump’s re-election quieted calls to defund and diversify. But wokeness persists today. In D.S.A., which I joined on the heels of the first Bernie Sanders presidential campaign, one still encounters debates about whether clapping is ableist or whether socialists should commit to “decolonizing ‘Minnesota.’” At its best, D.S.A. strikes me as our greatest shot at building a broad-based and politically serious organized left. At its worst, the energy reminds me of a scene from an Oberlin dining co-op, where a group of members filed in during a meal and silently unfurled a sign reading, “This co-op is messed up.” (They were protesting the privilege inherent in cliques; the sign’s wording was in fact less polite.)

The next Congress can’t let these debates trickle up again. The freshman representatives from the bluest districts, such as those in Brooklyn and Los Angeles, will still face pressure to spend their time denouncing offensive language and censuring members to their right. Instead, they should focus on making life better for working-class people — working toward Medicare for all, labor law reform, maybe even a Green New Deal. For the first time in a while, the moderate members of their party might actually be open to compromising on these issues.

That last paragraph lays out the characteristics of wokeness, but doesn’t define it. I’m often asked to do so, and my short reply, which isn’t really sufficient, is “Performative social-justice acts that flaunt one’s virtue and don’t create much (or any) social change.” You can tender your own definition below. All I can say is to echo Justice Potter Stewart’s statement on obscenity: “I know it when I see it.” A bit more:

I’ve seen a lot of wokeness in my time, and I’ve never seen it produce a sustainable, appealing and effective political formation. I have, on the other hand, seen the left make phenomenal advances by focusing on coherent, universalist, usually economic demands that unite people across differences and foster solidarity.

The American left can focus on meeting people’s material needs rather than scrutinizing their moral fallibility. But to get there, we must convey our actual opinions, not just the ones that keep us in good standing.

The message is not new: wokeness is not only a danger to Democrats, but a recipe for accomplishing nothing. What’s new is that the message is coming from a Democratic Socialist.

*As always, I’ll steal a few items from Nellie Bowles’s weekly news-and-snark column at the Free Press, called this week, “TGIF: Consensual non-consent.”

→ The new world: The good folks at Pew Research Center bring us new demographic projections. Here we go:

First of all, Jews are absolutely exploding in numbers from 0.01 to 0.02?! Wow, hell yeah! It’s 0.02 and don’t you forget it. Meanwhile, the religiously unaffiliated simply die off from lack of reproduction (which checks out). And Islam will be the largest religion in the world, by far. All ye worried about gender-related microaggressions in your Protestant societies are in for a rude awakening when you’re not allowed to go to the market in France without an escort. The LGBTQIA2S+ community will be begging to live under the Woke Pope’s benevolent papal authority after all of this shakes out.

→ Our underfunded schools: New York City’s public school population is down 21.5 percent since 2013. Yes, it’s fallen by a fifth as families with young children flee the city to find schools that teach their kids forbidden knowledge like math and reading. People suffer miserable commutes and deal with things like lawn care and carpooling because the alternative is a man-child communist telling their children that America is satanic while a kid twirls a handgun one desk over. Anyway, school enrollment is down 21.5 percent. But funding is up! Oh yeah it is. New York City now spends $59,450 per student! Per year! That’s the number people are arriving at because the ​​city’s public school budget this year is now $45.6 billion. For only 766,900 students. This is the math they don’t want you to do. $59,450. For that price, these kids should be speaking Mandarin while they code a new internet. For nearly 60 grand, those kids should be able to land back handsprings on the moon. Sixty grand should mean the kid has some alternative thoughts on Russian literature.

→ . . . Also on campus: ​​Hunter College’s “Cultural Arts Night” was canceled, apparently after it was discovered that Jewish student group Hillel had been invited to participate. Hunter’s Undergraduate Student Government (USG) declared, “USG does not endorse this event or this collaboration,” adding that it “doesn’t align with our values.” “Going forward,” they wrote, “every club and every member of USG will know who is involved in an event.” Student government president Sumaiya Ahmed and VP Ahmad Waraich signed the cancellation statement, drawing a flood of gleeful antisemitic social media comments and praise from City College’s Students for Justice in Palestine chapter. It’s always important to root out collaborators from the Cultural Arts Night.

→ One last thing on the JQ: One of America’s newly elected senators laid out his vision of an acceptable Israel. Here’s soon-to-be Senator Abdul El-Sayed on the Jewish state: “I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens. . . does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws. That’s, again, the question of peace, dignity, and self-determination.” So all the 25 or so countries whose official religion is Islam are totally fine. Now, if he said he hopes those nations also dropped their state religions—and, um, cultures?—that’s at least a cohesive argument. But no. The existence of those doesn’t seem to bother anyone.

→ Rest in peace, Fiona the Hippo: A beautiful premature hippo baby named Fiona grew up to be the star of the Cincinnati Zoo. She died Thursday, days after eating a hat a child had gotten into her enclosure. I’m not ruling out foul play. Lawyer up, kid.

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, but we have a vintage Hili dialogue.

Hili: How do we know what we know?
Andrzej: Usually from questionable sources.

In Polish:

Hili: Skąd wiemy to, co wiemy?
Ja: Na ogół z wątpliwych źródeł.

*******************

From Divy:

From CinEmma:

From Jesus of the Day:

From Masih; two Iranian protestors sentenced to death for “enmity against God”:

An old but a good post from my heartthrob Sophie Cunningham:

From my feed, food-stealing cats:

From Will. The Community note attributes the video: “This Woman HAS A NAME. https://x.com/Le_Turtle1/status/2123279706216874437 Her own posting of her own video generated no credit as others reposted and got an incredible amount of views.”  Another says, “The video was created by Simona Hap (Simona Hapciuc), a Dubai-based Romanian content creator. https://www.instagram.com/reel/Df4wE13MXGB/ https://www.instagram.com/eusimonahapciuc/

One from my feed; a heartwarming and tearjerking ad from Thailand:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

This Polish Jewish girl was gassed to death, along with 90% of her convey, as soon as they got to Auschwitz. She was 12 years old.

— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2026-11-21T12:26:33.489Z

And two–yes, two–from Dr. Cobb. First, a famous cat photo for Caturday, taken at just the right moment:

Cat jumping by Neil Hibbert, Salford 1957

— Mark Forrest (@rowiecrumbs.bsky.social) 2026-11-20T00:07:16.070Z

And a 43-second horse fart. Where is Guinness when you need them?

My sister sent me this: a 43-second horse fart. You are all most welcome

— Odd This Day (@oddthisday.bsky.social) 2026-11-06T14:05:48.077Z

.

Jesus ‘n’ Mo ‘n’ Cat

November 20, 2026 • 8:15 am

Today we have a Friday Flashback from Jesus and Mo, a cartoon called “Yusuf”. It came with an explanation:

An ancient, old-style, Friday Flashback from exactly 20 years ago, featuring the artist formerly known as Steven Demetre Georgiou.

Yep, it’s Cat Stevens, and that’s his real birth name (he was of Greek parentage, born in London). After a promising musical start, he embraced Islam in 1977, started making Islamic recordings thereafter, and since then things haven’t been the same. The drowning part is true.  But what a waste of musical talent.  It’s odd, though, that Mo liked the old, non-Muslim Cat Stevens better.

When I started graduate school at Rockefeller University in 1972, I looked like Cat Stevens, and on a subsequent trip through Europe I was mistaken for Cat Stevens twice in Greece, a country where he was a hero.  Here:

Me (about 1972):

Cat:

Here’s my favorite Cat song: “Father and Son“. The live performance is from 1971. The theme of parental estrangement is similar to that in the Harry Chapin song “Cat’s in the Cradle“.

Friday: Hili dialogue

November 20, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to Friday, November 20, 2026, and National Absurdity Day. Here’s one example (click to go to post):

It’s also Beautiful Day, Transgender Day of Remembrance, and National Peanut Butter Fudge Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 20 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

BREAKING NEWS, ripped from the headlines.  Although below I wrote that Fiona the hippo, a resident of the Cincinnati Zoo, seemed to be recovering after ingesting a visitor’s hat that somehow was thrown into her pool. The beloved animal (she has her own Wikipedia page), didn’t make it:  Fiona died yesterday from complications of the hat she swallowed.

Fiona the hippo, a beloved figure at the Cincinnati Zoo and internet sensation, has died after suffering health complications from swallowing a child’s hat. She was 9 years old.

She had been receiving around-the-clock care as she tried to pass the knit hat she swallowed earlier this month after it was accidentally tossed into her enclosure by a visitor.

The zoo confirmed Fiona did not make it after “multiple attempts from our amazing vets and keeper team to help her through what ended up being a medical emergency.”

“The vet staff tried everything they could to help her after she ingested a hat that ended up in her habitat by accident last week. Despite multiple attempts to move the hat out of her system, it was ultimately too much to overcome. The team performed necessary supportive care today in an attempt to save her, but it was not successful and she did not recover. We know everyone in the community will be crushed by this news, as we all are. Please keep her keepers and everyone who tried to help her in your thoughts as they try to navigate and come to terms with this shocking news. They are also, understandably, asking for space at this time,” the zoo shared.

Here is the announcement.

She was beloved because she was a fighter: born prematurely at half the weight of the smallest known surviving hippo, she made it to adulthood, only to be killed by some stupid visitor:

Six weeks before Fiona was due, Bibi showed signs of going into labor. Fiona was born six weeks premature on January 24, 2017, with a birth weight of 29 pounds (13 kg); the recorded range of birth weights for the species at that time was 55–120 pounds (25–54 kg).  Zoo staff named the baby hippo Fiona because her ears resembled those of the Shrek character.

She was unable to stand and required bottle feeding with milk from her mother, supplemented with infant formula.  This was the first time a hippopotamus had been milked and the milk analyzed.[5] The following month, while teething, she began refusing her bottle and became dehydrated; a catheter for the delivery of intravenous fluids was inserted with the assistance of members of the vascular access team at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital. The preemie team had previously sent the zoo a care package for her

Fiona took her first steps on February 5,  weighed 275 pounds (125 kg) by May 31 when she was introduced to the media,  and by June had reached a normal weight of 317 pounds (144 kg).[9] By the time she was six months old, she weighed over 375 pounds (170 kg),  and in late August, 451 pounds (205 kg). 

*The UN’s International Court of Justice has ruled that Myanmar (the former Burma) has committed genocide against the Rohingyas—the first such ruling in the history of the court. (Wikipedia will tell you about the Rohingya and their history of oppression in that country.)

The International Court of Justice ruled on Thursday that Myanmar had committed genocide against Rohingya Muslims, a landmark decision years in the making that could have far-reaching implications.

Myanmar is the first state — as opposed to an individual — held to account for violating the 1948 Genocide Convention. Though the court does not have the power to enforce its rulings, the finding that Myanmar committed genocide could set an important legal precedent and pave the way for determining reparations for Rohingya survivors.

Judge Yuji Iwasawa, the president of the court, read the verdict over more than 2½ hours, recounting atrocities committed by Myanmar’s security forces against the Rohingya people, hundreds of thousands of whom were driven out of Rakhine State into Bangladesh.

In a 9-6 vote, he said, the court “finds that the Republic of the Union of Myanmar has committed genocide against the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine State.” The court also found that Myanmar had violated its obligation to prevent genocide and to punish those involved.

At a camp in Cox’s Bazaar, Bangladesh, where about 1.2 million Rohingya refugees live, some people broke into cheers at the announcement while others wept. Some held up a sign that said, “Thank you Gambia,” the Muslim majority African country that brought the case against Myanmar in 2019.

Since Gambia brought the case to the court, the United Nations’ top judicial body located in The Hague, Netherlands, 11 other countries have formally lent their support. The United States has previously deemed the Myanmar security forces’ campaign of violence against the Rohingya, which culminated in a frenzy of killing, sexual violence and mass arson nine years ago, to be a genocide.

. . . The case hinged on whether Myanmar acted with the specific intent to physically destroy the Rohingya, in whole or in part, as an ethnic or religious group. Under the U.N. definition, committing acts of cultural destruction is not enough for such violence to be considered genocide.

The article says this could have bearing on another case: the accusation of South Africa that Israel committed genocide in Gaza (readers will know that I utterly reject that contention, which is not at all like what Myanmar did to the Rohingya).

A related article also makes me sad, because Aung San Suu Kyi used to be one of my heroes, but proved to have feet of clay.  She was under house arrest for 15 years and is now in prison.

During one of the first hearings of the case, in 2019, a Nobel laureate defended the state of Myanmar against the accusation of genocide at the International Court of Justice.

It was Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, then Myanmar’s de facto civilian leader, who had been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1991 for her nonviolent resistance to her country’s military government.

*Trump, Xi, and Putin have concluded their trilateral summit in China, and wound up with a statement of intent to reduce their stockpile of nuclear weapons.

President Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin said they agreed to open a dialogue on reducing the risks of nuclear weapons in a first-ever gathering of American, Chinese and Russian leaders.

The unprecedented summit on Thursday in this southern Chinese city reflected a shifting global order in which U.S. dominance is increasingly challenged by Moscow and Beijing.

“We are really making history,” Trump said as the three men opened the 90-minute meeting, sitting around a large, round wooden table under a towering Chinese landscape painting. “No problems were ever solved under the old school, refusing to talk about them.”

In the end, the meeting yielded a joint statement that outlined broad areas of agreement between the three leaders but offered few specifics.

Trump, Xi and Putin agreed that the U.S., China and Russia would engage in a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation, according to the statement, which added that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.”

The statement gave no details about further meetings or how the three countries would translate their broad commitment into concrete action.

After departing the summit, Trump dialed in to a meeting of European leaders attended by his envoy and son-in-law Jared Kushner.

The president updated the group on his meeting with Xi and Putin and “sent a very strong message to both of them on his desire for peace,” Kushner told reporters. “But I believe he also came away believing that peace is achievable.”

There were rumors that Kim Jong Un from North Korea would show up, but he didn’t, and what’s the point of having him there? (He is going gung-ho on nukes for North Korea.). I was pleased to hear that, before the meeting, Trump was planning to negotiate a reduction in nukes. We have way too many and it’s overkill.  I detest Trump as much as the next person, but that intent was something that pleased me.

*Over at The Free Press, Douglas Murray discusses the most taboo of subjects, the hottes of the hot potatoes: “Race, IQ, and the danger of forbidden knowledge.” The occasion for the piece was the attempt to deplatform a speech by Nathan Cofnas (the man who first uncovered Jason Arday’s plagiarism) at Oxford. Cofnas works on group differences in IQ, which of course has made him canceled and led to his firing from the University of Ghent.  A few excerpts:

Sudent protests are nothing new. Nor are violent riots on campus, like those organized by people inside and outside the University of Oxford on Tuesday evening. The intimidation of students and others was intended to prevent people from hearing from the academic Nathan Cofnas. He leaped to fame earlier this year when he was the first academic to blow the whistle on the fraud committed by another academic, Jason Arday of the University of Cambridge. Cofnas’s reporting revealed to the public what was long suspected within Cambridge’s walls: Arday had fabricated important parts of his life and career, and was unqualified for his job, not to mention his celebrity status.

Arday later took his own life as public scrutiny increased, and his suicide has led to a massive inflation of claims about his death and against those who exposed his fraud. These have been made by figures as prominent as the principal of Homerton College, Cambridge, Lord Simon Woolley, who told a demonstration in London’s Trafalgar Square that Arday, who was black, had been the subject of a “lynching” and a “public assassination.” These are strong terms to throw around, even metaphorically—which is what Woolley now claims he intended them to mean.

Not all of the demonstrators who turned out by the hundreds on the streets of Oxford on Tuesday night will have taken these words metaphorically. Enraged activists formed a human cordon, blocking not only attendees of the event but also other students trying to access their dormitories. When one student attempted to pass, he recalls that a protester rebuked him, saying, “Don’t try and break the picket line, mate. It makes you look as though you hate black people.”

In their eyes, Cofnas is guilty of two crimes. The first is his decision to speak up about the plagiarism, false CV claims, and other fabulist aspects of Arday’s career. Presumably, Arday’s supporters think either that Arday was eminently qualified for a Cambridge professorship despite the evidence, or that academics should be allowed to get away with such fibs if they fit the criteria of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Cofnas’s employer, Ghent University, appears to agree. It suspended him after Arday’s death, saying it intends to investigate him for discrimination.

. . .The deeper problem with Cofnas, in the eyes of his opponents, is that he has researched and written about the relationship between race and IQ in the past. If there is one subject in our era likely to bring down the furies, it is this one.

The question of IQ differentials between racial groupings is probably the most verboten subject of our time. Prominent academics have occasionally addressed the issue. Charles Murray and Richard Herrnstein famously explored the question in a chapter of their 1994 book The Bell Curve. Others, including James Watson, have spoken on the matter, as have people as prominent as David Reich, a professor of genetics at Harvard. In 2018, Reich even addressed race and IQ in a piece published in The New York Times. There, Reich argued that academics ought to explore differences in average intelligence among different populations, while striving to avoid stereotypes and hasty conclusions.

Reich laid out his research in an accompanying book and explained that the job of someone doing the research he does is simply to describe the facts. He conceded that he had “deep sympathy for the concern that genetic discoveries could be misused to justify racism.” But as the backlash to him and that article showed, many people appeared to believe that experts like Reich were breaching a dam even by saying this much. The views of critics such as Ezra Klein, then writing at Vox, ranged from denying that the research was valid to expressing concern that the ignorant masses would interpret any link between race and IQ as a license to discriminate against any group that was suggested to have lower average intelligence.

In one respect, the fear was understandable. Once facts are out in the public square, nobody has very much control over how they can be used. But knowledge cannot be “secret,” particularly in the era of social media. And the fact that someone like Cofnas—who has described himself as a “race realist”—was speaking about DEI in his Oxford lecture is no coincidence.

. . . If academics and students think that someone holding Cofnas’s views is wrong, then they should be able to refute his claims. But that is not what they tried to do. They tried to prevent him from speaking to a small number of students in their spare time and then tried to stop students from getting into the lecture hall to hear him. This is not evidence of intellectual strength. It is evidence of intellectual failure. And that encourages interest in the forbidden subject.

. . .For what it is worth, my own observation of these debates is that much can be told by the way someone debates IQ differentials. If they survey them as the ethical and moral minefield they are, then they will discuss them in a spirit of interest and concern. If they describe their findings—accurate or otherwise—with glee, then you can be fairly sure they are engaged in another game. The only way to surmise the tone in which someone like Cofnas addresses these issues would be to hear him.

His opponents think they know what he is saying. In fact, they have simply closed themselves off from hearing him. In doing so, they have set up the conditions for many more people to listen to him. And the violence that greeted Cofnas on Tuesday suggests that much of his audience, present and future, will want more than some statistical evidence at their side. They will want to settle on the evidence and go to war with it. If they do, they will be able to claim, with some justification, that it is not a war they started.

Luana tackle the subject of group differences in our Skeptical Inquirer paper, emphasizing that we do not think this research should be prohibited or the researchers demonized, and, regardless of the results (which are far from in by now), whatever differences are found that reside in the genome could conceivably be used to help individuals, not serve as a foundation for bigotry.

*Several people sent me this NYT article called, “National Book Award for nonfiction goes to writer denied visa to attend” (article archived here.) But it also lists many of the awards given this year, which gave several of us pause, including a friend quoted below.

The Egyptian writer and activist Abdelrahman ElGendy on Wednesday night won the top prize for nonfiction for “Huna: A Memoir of Revolution, Prison, and Becoming” at the National Book Awards ceremony in New York City. The book chronicles his arrest at 17, along with his father, during mass protests in Cairo following the military coup that ousted Mohamed Morsi, Egypt’s president.

The memoir, published by Hogarth, follows ElGendy’s years of imprisonment, exploring his struggle for political resistance, survival and liberation under an authoritarian government.

ElGendy was not able to collect his award in person after the U.S. government denied his visa to travel to New York for the ceremony, according to an article he published in The New Yorker last week.

. . . Hannah Lillith Assadi took home the top prize for fiction for “Paradiso 17,” a story told from its narrator’s deathbed about a life lived in exile from his Palestinian homeland. Loosely based on the experiences of the author’s father, the novel, published by Knopf, is “a study in inheritance, in the afterlife of ideology, in the way history seeps into every curated idyll,” Zain Khalid wrote in The New York Times Book Review.

The National Book Award, established in 1950, honors literature published in the United States, and is considered among the most prestigious literary prizes in the country. Past winners include some of America’s most celebrated literary voices, like Ta-Nehisi Coates, Robert Caro, Flannery O’Connor and Ralph Ellison.

This year’s roster of finalists included authors of Egyptian, Palestinian, Haitian and Colombian descent, and the titles up for the awards grappled with Gaza, displacement, immigration, disability, imprisonment and gender identity. Two of the fiction finalists identify as transgender and wrote novels about trans experiences. All but one of the nonfiction nominees were at least partially works of memoir.

I haven’t read any of the finalists or winners, so can’t pronounce on their quality, but almost everyone who sent me the article is wondering if the Awards are now designed to reward social justice books.  I have no idea, but one person who sent me the link added this (quoted with permission, but anonymously.

There are questions.


Are publishers preferentially green lighting Arab authors? Very possible
Are Arab authors writing more, perhaps sensing that the world is more receptive to them? Possible.
Is this enough of a bump to account for the results? I am doubtful.
Are Jewish authors writing less. Unlikely
Are Arab authors writing the best books? Unlikely

If you’ve read any of the finalists or winners, or can answer any of the above questions, weigh in below. But for me there is one good highlight:

The Medal for Distinguished Contribution to American Letters, a lifetime achievement award, went to the author Salman Rushdie, whose most recent work, a memoir called “Knife,” chronicled a 2022 attempt on his life. The crowd heralded him onstage with a standing ovation. Previous winners include Toni Morrison, Joan Didion, Arthur Miller and Tom Wolfe.

I wrote about my take on Knife previously, and Midnight’s Children is, to me, one of the best novels of our time. It was chosen as the best of the first 25 winners of the Booker Prize. You’ll remember that Rushdie was the subject of a fatwa by an Iranian Ayatollah for his book The Satanic Verses, and in 2022 was seriously injured by a Muslim attacker obeying that fatwa.

NOTE FOR THE REPORT BELOW: As I said at the top of the Nooz, Fiona died yesterday from effects of the ingested hat.  People don’t know how to behave at zoos!

*Fiona, a beloved hippo at the Cincinnati Zoo, has swallowed a woolen hat that accidentally fell into her enclosure, and it’s not certain that she’ll be able to pass it. It could kill her, but so far she appears to be doing well. I was surprised to learn that an operation is off the table:

Fiona, the Cincinnati Zoo’s famed hippo, underwent a colonoscopy this week, and now veterinarians are trying a new way to help her pass a knit cap that she swallowed after it slipped into her enclosure.

The zoo’s animal care team borrowed a vibration plate from a horse farm, hoping the shaking will help move things along through her digestive tract, the zoo said Wednesday.

Video released by the zoo Wednesday shows Fiona snorting and moving about her indoor enclosure.

Veterinarians sedated her Tuesday for a second time to evaluate her condition, said Mike Wenninger, the zoo’s director of animal health.

An ultrasound showed some bunching of her intestines, indicating she is still trying to pass the obstruction, Wenninger said. They also conducted a colonoscopy, using a 9-foot scope, he said.

Specialists have told the zoo that surgery isn’t an option for full-grown hippos, he said.

Fiona, who became a global sensation as a tiny newborn after her premature birth in 2017, has inspired books, a line of beer and a bobblehead. During her first year, the zoo recorded her progress while fans worldwide followed her growth online.

. . .The beloved hippo swallowed the hat just over a week ago. A visitor tossed it into the air, and a ceiling fan caught and catapulted it through a small opening above the area’s viewing windows, said zoo spokesperson Michelle Curley.

Zoo staff are now monitoring her around the clock, trying to keep her hydrated and giving Fiona her favorite foods to help her pass the knit cap, the zoo said.

“Her care team even offered her a sniff of coffee, a scent she has always liked,” Curley said Wednesday. “And they were happy to see her respond.”

Good luck, Fiona!  I will update her condition as it changes. Here’s a recent video saying that she’s improving:

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, and Andrzej has posted a vintage Hili dialogue.

Hili: What is “today”?
Andrzej: A point of life in brackets between yesterday and tomorrow. Its value varies depending on different variables.
Hili: Make my today better.

In Polish:

Hili: Co to jest „dziś”.
Ja: Punkt życia w nawiasach między wczoraj i jutro. Przybiera różne wartości w zależności od różnych zmiennych.
Hili: Zrób moje dziś lepsze.

*******************

From Cheryl’s Amazingly Positive, No Politics Allowed, Interesting People Group:

From Terrible Maps; “What each country calls splitting the bill, literally”:

From Bad Spelling or Grammar on Signs or Notices.  This person has ADS (Apostrophe Derangement Synbdrome):

From Masih; Iranian authorities tried to arrest a protestor, but, lacking that, they tortured the protestor’s relatives.  Such is the regime that nobody seems to care about, save their effect on the price of American gasoline.

From Malcolm: a cat vs. a d*g:

From the Number Ten Cat; a cat’s-eye view:

From Luana (I may have posted this before). These are not satirical stories, and Salon went bankrupt:

From Jay; a very good Simon’s Cat cartoon:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

This French Jewisgh girl was gassed to death as soon as she arrived in Auschwitz. She was seven years old, and would be ninety today had she lived.

— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2026-11-20T11:29:04.810Z

Two from Doctor Cobb. First, poor grammar in a headline:

Journalism is in such bad shape that they’ve got owls writing stories now

— stuffing enthusiast (@tacoenthusiast.swifties.social) 2026-11-19T00:52:11.080Z

Rays and manatees. I’m lucky enough to have seen manatees in Florida:

a manatee swimming through a huge school of rays in St Pete, Florida. #manatees can be seen all year long in the southern half of #florida. They're in almost every bay, bayou, the intracoastal waterway, the Atlantic, And the Gulf. They're also in most of the rivers, creeks and springs. #nature

— See Through Canoe (@seethroughcanoe.bsky.social) 2026-11-19T14:03:40.610Z

.

NOVA series on evolution

November 19, 2026 • 9:45 am

I didn’t realize that NOVA/PBS/BBC has had a multi-segment series on evolution that you can watch online for free until December 12. It’s already at episode 17, and you can click the screenshot below to go to the programs available, They are a bit idiosyncratic, including shows on running, mating (really about sex), the evolution of the elephant, the evolution of feeding, and the evolution of intelligence. But I don’t know what was covered in the first 12 episodes. Some of these may be useful as adjunct material in evolution courses.

I decided to choose one episode to watch, just to get a sense of whether I wanted to see more. The episode was “The Mating Game,” which purports to answer the question,”How did sex create the wondrous world we see around us?”and I watched the entire 53 minutes.

My verdict is rather “meh”: the show is okay, but I think it could have been much better.  Perhaps I’m being hypercritical as a professor in this field, but I would have liked to talk to the creators before they put out the final version.  The cinematography is good, but the explanations seem wonky, and the whole show, while purporting to show how sex evolved and “unleashed” evolution (which it did to a large extent, but evolution, mutation, and natural selection did, too), is largely a recounting of what happened during evolution: there were cells, multicellular organisms, fish, fish that became terrestrial, amphibians, reptiles, and then the branches that led to birds and mammals.

In other words, the show is infused with a soupçon of teleology: that evolution was more or less a drive towards complexity, culminating in what we have today. Well, yes, what we have today is the longest-standing products of evolution, but evolution will continue, and natural selection doesn’t always favor more complexity (viz., tapeworms or lizards that have lost their legs).  Yes, some amphibians that produced amniotic (“terrestrial”) eggs may have had an advantage over their conspecific individuals because they didn’t have to return to the water to breed, but I the show doesn’t mention that this is how natural selection operated to produce evolutionary “innovations”, but there are still plenty of amphibians and plenty of fish still in the sea.

My view is that the producers missed a chance not only to raise some interesting questions, but also to emphasize that there are things we just don’t understand about sex and evolution.  One of these is the question, “Why did sex evolve?”  We don’t know the answer, but the show implies that it evolved to facilitate evolution. That’s a result of sex, but is a somewhat teleological answer, and scientists have many possible answers, all of which must involved the adaptive advantage of combining genes among individuals (technically, “to break up linkage disequilibrium among gene forms”). These include meeting environmental changes, meeting the challenge from parasites, getting rid of deleterious genes, repairing errors in DNA, and so on. (Just Google “why did sex evolve?”).  It could have been one or several of these advantages, but nowhere in the show will you hear “We don’t know the answer.” Nor do they answer the question of why we don’t see more asexual lineages since asexual mutants can have twice as many offspring as do their sexual ancestors; this is the “twofold cost of sex.”

Likewise, although they imply that there are two sexes, they don’t state that this condition holds in all animals and vascular plants. The question of “why sexes are always two?” was first asked by R. A. Fisher, and we have a pretty good answer involving “evolutionarily stable strategies.” Tbere is no mention made of this issue, which has become contentious.

The talking heads they use are somewhat idiosyncratic, concentrating almost entirely on North Americans and South Africans; I didn’t recognize any names save Sarah Otto, but perhaps the producers wanted to show some diversity among the commentators.

A few more of my notes:

A. Sexual selection is first shown in dinosaurs, favoring feathers, but of course sexual selection began evolving as soon as there were separate sexes. This isn’t mentioned, nor do they show that classically there are two forms of sexual selection: male-male competition (Darwin’s “law of battle”) and female-choice (Darwin’s “law of beauty,” the main explanation given here). There is no discussion about why some male traits, like bright colors and displays, are favored by females. To me, this is one of the great unsolved mysteries of evolution, and there are many possible explanations.  Further, the big claws of fiddler crabs, which are correctly mentioned as an example of sexual selection, not only enable males to fight with each other, but are waved in front of female crabs to attract them, showing that some features can participate in both form of sexual selection.

B. They make a big deal about the “invention” of the penis as a way to effect internal fertilization: “the origin of the penis was a major moment in evolution.” This importance is, they say, because it is THE way to effect internal fertilization in animals like birds, where the egg is fertilized before the shell is put on.  Unfortunately, 97% of bird species do not have penises (some ducks do); they have cloacas that they quickly evert when copulating in a “cloacal kiss”.  Other animals, including some amphibians, deposit spermatophores (packets of sperm) that a female snatches with her cloaca. I’m not sure why there’s all the brouhaha about penises unless the producers wanted to put a salacious spin on the theme.

C. Perhaps this is explained in an earlier show, but natural selection is minimized in comparison with sex (sexual selection is, of course, a form of natural selection involving mate choice or access, but that isn’t even mentioned.) It’s vitally important that these shows keep natural selection constantly in the foreground, and mention mutation and competition for reproduction between members of the same species.

Again, perhaps I am speaking from the point of view of an evolutionist; I’m not the kind of person who make up the target audience, but I was not impressed. I am not going to watch any more shows. But you can!  Watch this show for yourself, or choose another, and see if you want to go through other available videos.

Click below to go to “The Mating Game”. If you watch it, please comment below and let me know if I’m being unfair.


 

Thursday: Hili dialogue

November 19, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to Thursday, November 19, 2026; it’s the Great American Smokeout, a day when you encourage people to quit tobacco.  I quit smoking cigars, but not because they were unhealthy: the number I smoked (3/week) was statistically indistinguishable, in terms of health consequences, from zero cigars. It’s just that they changed the rules in my flat, and I can’t smoke there. What a great pity that was: there was nothing more relaxing than enjoying a good book with a drink (preferably root beer) and a fine Habano.  Here’s one, and look at that fine ash!

Oh, and I didn’t inhale.

It’s also Beaujolais Nouveau Day, when the pink “wine” better known as Grape Kool-Aid goes on sale. I recommend avoiding it. And it’s National Men’s Day, International Carbonated Beverage With Caffeine Day, National Macchiato Day, World Philosophy Day, and World Toilet Day, so declared by the World Toilet Association, whose homepage has a link called “Our Movement.”

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 19 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

Note: the news may be truncated today as I’m writing this the day before and have errands to run. As always, I do my best.

*We have a new Speaker of the House, a Democrat, of course, but also an African-American—the first to hold this position.

House Democrats on Wednesday nominated Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York to be speaker, voting overwhelmingly over resistance from the left to put him in line to become the first Black lawmaker to hold the post.

The election by secret ballot came just over two weeks after Mr. Jeffries, 56, who has led House Democrats since 2022, presided over sweeping victories for his party, which won a historically large majority in the midterm elections.

The vote was 251 to 11, with two Democrats abstaining, according to a person who attended the confidential session and detailed the results on the condition of anonymity. The margin demonstrated the breadth of Mr. Jeffries’s backing in a large and ideologically diverse caucus.

Accepting the nomination, he paid homage to the civil rights hero and long-serving Representative John Lewis of Georgia, who frequently exhorted people to get in “good trouble” fighting injustice.

“It’s a ‘good trouble’ moment in America,” Mr. Jeffries told the assembled Democrats.

He will still have to be elected on the House floor in January, when he will need a majority of members in the chamber to rise and say his name to formally win the post that is second in line to the presidency. But the lopsided secret-ballot vote suggested he will have more than enough support to do so.

Mr. Jeffries’s nomination was almost a foregone conclusion; no Democrat emerged to challenge him, and even some of his loudest critics ultimately did not want to publicly oppose the man in line to be the nation’s first Black speaker.

His frictionless ascent counted as a rarity in the House, where party leaders often rise through tumultuous challenges.

Another bonus besides Jeffries’s position as “unifier” is that he’s not by any means “progressive”, hewing more to the label of “mainstream liberal.” Further, his views on Israel are favorable and to my liking, though he has favored the insupportable “two-state solution”, a solution that as speaker he has no power to effect. When I asked Grok to compare AOC’s views on Israel with those of Jeffries’s, Mr. Grok said this:

Hakeem Jeffries and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) represent opposing poles of the Democratic Party’s divide on Israel. Jeffries is a longstanding mainstream supporter of Israel’s security who has recently called for policy adjustments; AOC is a consistent progressive critic who has labeled Israeli actions in Gaza a genocide and now opposes all U.S. military aid.
I’ll take it.

*As many people expected, the war between Iran and the U.S. (not much doing with Israel so far) has ramped up again:

Kuwait and Bahrain said that they had intercepted Iranian aerial attacks on Wednesday as peace talks between the United States and Iran stalled and uncertainty lingered in the region over whether a new round of fighting would erupt.

The Iranian military said that it had fired drones at a Kuwaiti air base, aiming for U.S. air-defense systems and launch platforms, Iranian state media reported. The Kuwaiti foreign ministry denounced the attack, the first Iranian offensive against the country in about two months, saying that it was a dangerous escalation that threatened regional stability. It was unclear whether the attack caused damage.

Bahrain, an island nation in the Persian Gulf that is home to the U.S. Navy’s Fifth Fleet, said it had also been attacked on Wednesday. The Bahraini authorities have reported several attempted Iranian attacks since Friday. On Sunday, Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps said that the Iranian military had targeted a radar system at a Bahraini air base.

Iran has also continued to go after ships in the Strait of Hormuz, the narrow waterway that is a crucial shipping route for Gulf oil exports. On Wednesday, ADNOC Logistics and Services, a subsidiary of Abu Dhabi’s state oil company, said that one person was missing and 11 were injured after one of its vessels was attacked the previous day while sailing through the Strait of Hormuz.

Iran’s leaders have hardened their negotiating position with the United States since President Trump’s setback in the midterm elections, which were partly seen as a rebuke of his handling of the war, according to American, European and Iranian officials.

The United States has sent more military assets to the Middle East in recent weeks, and it struck Qeshm Island in Iran this month in what American officials said was a defensive measure. American and Israeli military officials have also drawn up plans for renewed strikes that would most likely target energy infrastructure and other sites vital to the Iranian economy, according to U.S. officials and other people briefed on the deliberations.

Several Gulf countries have lobbied against another round of fighting and pushed for a comprehensive deal to end the war. Qatar, which is mediating between the United States and Iran, condemned the Iranian attacks, saying that they were “a dangerous escalation.”

If Trump has an ace up his sleeve here, he needs to play it before January when the majority-Democratic Congress is seated, though Trump may still be able to control the military then.

*I’m a sucker for analyses about the 2028 Presidential election, and the NYT has a clickbaity article called, “The best Democrat for 2028 might come from this quadrat.” Which quadrat? Read on.

The battle within the Democratic Party is usually framed as one between progressives and the establishment. There’s a fair bit of truth to that, but political analyst Nate Silver recently offered an assessment suggesting there’s another, more stylistic aspect to the division. Silver’s intriguing analysis does more than broaden understanding of the intra-Democratic divide: It also points to the central role that Black voters and leading candidates will play in resolving it.

Silver argues that Democrats are actually fighting on two dimensions: ideology and inclination. That second aspect distinguishes fighters (people who want to battle opponents, whether within the party or outside it) from uniters (those more inclined to find common ground with adversaries). A chart with his piece used those two categories to create four handy quadrants for visualizing the relative positions of 13 potential Democratic 2028 presidential contenders.

Here’s Silver’s graph from the link above. La-La land is the upper left quadrant (my view).  Attribution of figure: Graphic by the New York Times; ratings by Nate Silver.

More from the article:

Silver’s upper-left quadrant contains candidates who are progressive and fighters. The candidates land at different points in that square, but the ones found there are unsurprising. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (New York) is the most progressive potential contender, with fellow progressive firebrand Rep. Ro Khanna (California) right behind her. Others in this group include Govs. Gavin Newsom (California) and JB Pritzker (Illinois) and Sen. Jon Ossoff (Georgia).

The lower-right quadrant, meanwhile, contains figures more favored by the party establishment — politicians who are more moderate and more inclined to unite. Gov. Josh Shapiro (Pennsylvania) appears as both the most moderate and the strongest uniter, followed closely by Gov. Andy Beshear (Kentucky). Former transportation secretary Pete Buttigieg and Sen. Mark Kelly (Arizona) also land in this region.

To me, the most interesting quadrant is the lower left. This is the one that contains progressives who also are temperamentally uniters. Three potential candidates, all of them Black, fit here. In this group, former vice president Kamala Harris is rated as both the most progressive and the most inclined to fight. Gov. Wes Moore (Maryland) is rated as the least progressive and theleast inclined toward divisive battles. Sen. Raphael Warnock (Georgia) sits between the two.

. . .This suggests Silver may have put his finger on the decisive factor in the 2028 presidential battle. If the moderate uniters can’t get the support of Black voters, they cannot beat someone from the progressive-fighter camp. But if the progressive fighters can’t counter the long-standing tendency of Black voters to shy away from their brand of politics, they are unlikely to prevail either.

This means that perhaps analysts should be looking at one of the Black contenders more seriously than many are. Clearly, Harris’s two national campaigns have not gone well, but recent polls show her as the front-runner primarily because she leads with Black voters. If she can hold that support, White voters who might otherwise prefer a Buttigieg or Shapiro would probably choose her over a progressive firebrand in the crucial Super Tuesday contests.

A Harris failure could open the way for Moore, Warnock or perhaps Sen. Cory Booker (New Jersey). Warnock is probably the most intriguing potential candidate from this group, given his position as senior pastor at the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.’s Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta. No candidate can match that level of leadership lineage.

Republicans salivate at the prospect of the Democrats nominating an unrepentant progressive. Much of the Democratic establishment wants a unifying moderate. Don’t be surprised if the eventual nominee, drawing on strong support from Black voters, splits the difference.

Sorry, but the only person in that quadrant who I can say I will never vote for is Kamala Harris. She may be the front-runner among Democrats, but that speaks poorly of the Democratic Party. The foreign-born Mamdani can’t run, thank Ceiling Cat, and I’m willing to consider the others in that quadrat.

*There’s a Quillette discussion run by the site’s podcaster Zoey Sankey (not Jewish) featuring Mark Zlochin, described as “[an Israeli] computer scientist and independent researcher and data analyst”; the topic is “How Wikipedia rewrote Zionism,” and the video is below while there’s a transcript at the link. Here are a few excerpts from the transcript about the increasingly woke Wikipedia, which is not reliable on anything “progressive”.

From the intro:

For almost 20 years, Wikipedia’s article on Zionism was one of the most heavily worked pages on the site. Then, after October 7th, it began to change. Researcher Mark Zlochin wrote a script to trace the article revision by revision, and found that more than 80 percent of it has been rewritten since.

In this episode of Quillette Cetera, Zoe Sankey talks to Mark about what his data shows: which themes grew, which were cut, and how the work of historian Benny Morris was, Mark argues, stitched together to say things Morris never said. Morris himself reviewed Mark’s analysis.

From the interview:

MZ: When we think about Wikipedia, we think of it as a rather objective source of information. Obviously every source has some biases, but I never expected it to be biased to such an extent. The whole process was completely skewed: at the level of the people doing this, the tricks they play and how they game the system. There is a large system of guidelines for how editors are supposed to take part in this process and how they’re supposed to conduct it, and you see people really abusing it to push a very partisan, very biased narrative. The article about Zionism was just the tip of the iceberg, but I think it was very illuminating to focus on it, because it became the focal point of a much larger endeavour, and it was very illuminating to inspect it in more depth and see what was going on behind the curtain.

. . . Wikipedia is a good example of biases playing out, where the biases basically override whatever evidence comes in. If we look at it strictly from the point of view of Bayesian statistics, this is a pathological situation in which there is no balance: whatever new information comes in, it’s still not strong enough to override the prior biases. And you can see it play out in the way people edit Wikipedia and the way the information is fed out to the wider world, to a larger audience.

. . . So at some point I became curious about how you could quantify this, and I built a script that traced how much the text was changing. I looked at what was happening before October 7th, and I saw that almost immediately after October 7th some changes started, and then they started to accelerate. After about a year and a half to two years, like I said earlier, about 80 percent of the article had been completely rewritten.

. . .ZS: So in your essay, and there’s a great graph for this, there were four main topic clusters on the page. Return to the historic homeland: that absolutely shot down after October 7th. Antisemitism and persecution also dropped off; there’s not a lot of text about that now. It’s been wiped. Colonialism, topic three, shot up, and ethnic cleansing and displacement also increased.

MZ: Yes, exactly. And this is the narrative that the critics of Zionism, if we can put it mildly, try to push: this narrative of Zionism being a settler-colonial project, which is basically people who are foreign to the land coming and conquering it. One of the repeating themes, especially after October 7th, is talk of ethnic cleansing and expulsion, describing it as a premeditated project from the very start of Zionism. This is basically the picture that started to emerge after October 7th.

One of Zlochin’s theses is that Israeli historian Benny Morris, the person most quoted in the article, has had a very nuanced view of the Israel-Hamas war but that view is distorted by Wikipedia to favor the Zionism as a settler-colonial, pre-planned and nefarious endeavor:

MZ: [Morris’s] contribution was important in bringing it down to earth from the heights of idealism, and describing it: it was a war, it was a dirty war, and each side committed war crimes, both the Israelis and the Arabs. He openly acknowledged this, and he documented it based on very scrupulous research.

But then what do they do? They take particular incidents that happened late in the war, and they phrase them in a way that makes the reader believe it was a premeditated plan, which was not only implemented from the very start of the War of Independence, but actually goes way back to the very beginning of the Zionist movement. So the whole narrative is that the evil Zionists, starting from Herzl, planned from the very beginning to ethnically cleanse the Arabs, and that this is what led to what the Palestinians call the Nakba, the expulsion of the Palestinians during the War of Independence. And this is not what he’s saying. But they take half a sentence here and half a sentence there, and they mix it together. For someone who doesn’t, as I did, actually go and read the sources, that makes sense: “Benny Morris said that the Zionists wanted to ethnically cleanse the Palestinians from the very beginning. He’s such a respected figure, so it must be true.”

Zlochin had Benny Morris himself check the Wikipedia article, and Morris was angered by the distortion appearing under his name.

MZ: Yes, I think that [promoting “cold neutrality and the truth”) was the primary reason for my conducting this research. You can always dismiss criticism, not only on Wikipedia but particularly on Wikipedia, by saying, “Okay, this is just your opinion, and other people have different opinions.” But once you quantify it, once you see how the numbers change, you have an objective indicator. And you need to explain how it makes sense that there is such a sudden change, when nothing in the scholarship has changed and there are no new findings, and suddenly 80 percent of the article has been rewritten.

ZS: Exactly.

MZ: It’s no longer a matter of opinion; it’s just an objective fact that there has been some massive change. And I hope that more and more people, even if they are critical of Zionism or critical of my own work, will engage with the facts and address the objective part of the research, at least.

ZS: Yes, I hope for the same thing. Well, thanks again. I will link the essay in the show notes. Thank you, Mark.

Zlochin recommends Grokipedia as a more objective source of information than Wikipedia, at least for controversial topics.  It’s driven by AI, but people may object because it was created by Elon M-sk.

If you want to listen instead of read, here’s the hourlong discussion, and Zlochin has a long article on Quillette describing what he found (I believe I mentioned it previously).

 

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree. But Andrzej posted a vintage Hili dialogue:

Hili: We must be principled.
Me: In what matter?
Hili: I don’t know yet.

In Polish:

*******************

From Stacy:

From Meow Incorporated:

From The English Language Police:

Masih is quiet today so here’s a tweet from Larry. I don’t like the new James Bond. There’s been no acceptable substitute since Sean Connery, but they have to keep making up new stories with new people playing Bond.

From Luana: Abrogation of free speech at Oxford regarding a talk by Nathan Cofnas:

From Jay, who adds: “Both Grok and Perplexity.ai confirm that this is a genuine, newly released ad for Aer Lingus.”

From Barry, who says, “This cat from twenty days ago was correct.” Indeed it is.

“It’s going to be 56-44 in the Senate.”

— 𝕊𝕦𝕟𝕕𝕒𝕖 𝔾𝕦𝕣𝕝 (@sundaedivine.lol) 2026-10-27T00:59:58.197Z

From Malcolm. Bears have to swim so far because global warming is melting the ice:

One from my feed. Noa Argamani was NOT a soldier of any kind; she was kidnapped from the Nova Music Festival by Hamas and subsequently was one of several hostages rescued by the IDF. There’s an iconic video of Argamani being taken away on a motorcycle, which you can see in her short video below (a tearjerker). The professor should apologize.

Argamani:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

This French Jewish girl was gassed as soon as she arrived in Auchwitz. She was 12 years old.

— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2026-11-19T12:07:18.112Z

One from Dr. Cobb; Shostakovich and his moggy:

18 y.o. composer Dmitry Shostakovich and his cat (1925) sovietpostcards.tumblr.com/post/8336185…

— By Cory Doctorow (GPG 0xBF3D9110957E5F4C) (@doctorow.pluralistic.net) 2026-11-18T11:57:25.281Z

Jesus ‘n’ Mo ‘n’ The Argument From Subsequently Proved Prognostication

November 18, 2026 • 9:30 am

Today’s Jesus and Mo strip, called “pool“, came with a note: “Seriously, it’s the only book you’ll ever have to read!”

When I was writing Faith Versus Fact I had to plow through acres of ridiculous arguments that the Bible anticipated science in the same way Mo interprets the Qur’an. There should be a name for this kind of argument for God, perhaps “The Argument From Subsequently Proved Prognostication.”  But would think that God would be clearer in his predictions!