I must have signed up without remembering for a subscription to the Jewish quarterly journal Sapir, which comes in a spiffy thick version on quality paper and nice formatting. (You can sign up too for free, or access it online.) Sapir is edited by NYT op-ed writer Bret Stephens, who has an article on “A Lesson in Resilience for America” in the latest issue, whose them is “Fixing America”. Click the screenshot below to access all the articles
In Hebrew, by the way, “Sapir” means “sapphire,” but can refer to anything precious and shiny.
Here’s the table of contents for this issue:
I’ve read three of the articles so far, the ones by Stephens, Caroline Bryk, and Yasha Mounk. Unlike the other themed journals I get for free (like Dadalus, which I recycle as soon as it arrives), it looks as if this quarterly is worth getting. It’s a pleasure to hold in your hands given the quality of production, and at least some of the articles are good. I’ll excerpt a bit from Stephens’s piece after I expatiate a bit (click below to read):
Stephens’s point is that Americans, by and large, want an end to the war with Iran, while Israelis don’t. He sees Israelis as being more rational in this belief, even though America isn’t as threatened by Iran as is Israel. But we are threatened, of course, for Iran spreads terror throughout the world, and some of that not only endangers America, but works to turn some misguided “progressives” towards the side of the IRGC and Hamas. The Democratic Party is becoming infused with antisemitism.
This difference, argues Stephens, is that America has lost its resilience to fight for what is right: we’ve grown soft, unwilling to take on long-term projects that require individual sacrifice, and self-interested as a nation, even if our American principles of freedom are under attack in our democratic allies. He prescribes American “unlearning”—unlearning of the mantra that our country was born mired sin and bigotry and unlearning of our self-interest and the notion that “our ideals count for nothing against our material needs or commercial advantages.” We should also relearn rhe real founding principles of America: equality, freedom, universalism, and the rule of law. That does not, he asserts, mean forgetting the bad parts of America’s past, but remembering the ideals on which America is founded. To Stephens, Israel serves as an exemplar of resilience as it still walks the walk, embracing the ideals on which a nation is founded. (This does not of course mean that Israel is perfect!)
This may seem like a lecture from your grandfather, but we’re supposed to be celebrating the 250th anniversary of America’s founding. Stephens’s words remind me of a bit of Lincoln’s Gettysburg address:
Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.
. . . . The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here. It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us — that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion — that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain — that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom — and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.
Here are a few quotes from Stephens’s article:
Maybe it’s to be expected that Israelis, for whom the threat from Iran and its proxies is immediate and existential, should be willing to sacrifice so much for the sake of prospective security. Maybe it’s to be expected, too, that Americans see the threat from Iran as distant and notional, even among those who know that Tehran is responsible for the death of hundreds of U.S. citizens. That sense of distance is surely compounded by the bitter memory of two Mideast wars that cost thousands of American lives without delivering on their promises.
But there’s something deeper at work. Israelis — by necessity, circumstance, and self-selection — largely tend to be tenacious, self-disciplined, resilient people. Americans — through good fortune and a penchant for ease and convenience — tend not to be. That is a long-term threat to America’s safety and well-being. We could stand to take a lesson or two on it from our Israeli friends.
He notes the changes in America since WWII:
Scores of books have been written about how that culture fell by the wayside. Reserve gave way to self-revelation. The old virtue of delaying gratification was replaced by the habit of demanding and getting it — immediately. Material plenty led to an expectation of physical comfort, which later morphed into a demand for emotional cossetting. The word parent went from noun to verb, from a role to an activity, infantilizing adults while coddling children. Safety became a legal requirement; risk-taking, a legal liability; “safetyism,” a state of mind. The status of victim was valorized, and often monetized, at the expense of moral responsibility and personal agency. Ideas such as “microaggressions” and “unconscious bias” took hold; instead of trying to make our skins a little thicker, we discovered new ways to take offense. When things went poorly, we no longer asked, self-reproachingly, “Where did we go wrong?” Instead, we looked, conspiratorially, for a culprit: “Who did this to us?” And while fierce individualism has always been a part of America’s character and creed, we now have a kind of cancerous and metastatic individualism that cannot recognize occasions in national life that call for collective sacrifice.
. . .Now turn to Israel.
Israeli resilience is proverbial — so much so that the idea of it is sometimes resented. “No country should be expected to live indefinitely in a state of managed danger,” writes Joshua Hoffman in his excellent Substack newsletter, Future of Jewish. “When that reality is reframed as ‘resilience,’ something deeply dangerous happens: The abnormal begins to be framed or at least is expected to be normal.”
Hoffman is right that what Israelis must endure just to live should not be normalized to the point of being forgotten. But resilience is a virtue, however one comes by it. And it’s a mistake to ascribe Israeli resilience solely to the forms of adversity that it faces. It also comes from the purposes for which the state was created in the first place.
You can read for yourself about the founding principles of Israel (which were not, by the way, to drive out the Arabs). Stephens ends this way:
Finally, we could stand to learn something from Israel.
That isn’t much in evidence today. On the contrary, polling data show that more Americans are souring on the Jewish state. It would be easy to read that as a bad omen for Israelis, and perhaps it is. But it would be much wiser to see it as a warning sign about us — about our diminished capacity for critical thinking and moral reasoning. How have we in the United States managed to confuse perpetrator and victim in this war? When did we lose the capacity to use the word terrorist? Why have we so easily fallen for the baldest and most blatantly dishonest Palestinian propaganda? Why are we so beguiled by conspiracy theories plainly rooted in antisemitism? And since when do we malign an immensely capable and brave ally that fights by our side?
Most important, how do we fail to see in Israel a model of what a democratic people, which for 78 years has been battling for survival while still managing to thrive, can be capable of achieving through self-belief and the ability to recover its strength after taking blow after blow? Americans cannot hope to regain our old resilience unless we know what resilient looks like. The sooner we learn from the Israelis, the faster we might save ourselves from what, increasingly, we risk becoming.
Without doubt I’ll be called a Zionist—or even a promoter of genocide—for singling out Sapir and this article. Too bad. In my view, America is being weakened not only by the autocracy and mendacity of Trump, but by the “safteyism”, victimhood mentality, antisemitism, and sacralization of theocracy from the Left (see the new Free Press article, “How the Left abandoned the Jews“) . No wonder many of us, including but not limited to Jews, feel that we have no political home.


































