Repost: Worst lines in popular songs

October 20, 2026 • 11:30 am

As I’ve mentioned, posting will be light for a week or so as I have to deal with eye issues. Today I go to the retinologist and have little time to post, but as I was perusing my list of favorite music this morning, I came upon my subsection of “Worst lines in popular songs.” I did a post on it in 2023, which I now repost exactly in the form from 1 July, 2023. Perhaps there are enough folks who haven’t seen it that I can get away with posting it again.

So here it is, below the line.  I’ve added a newer discovery of bad lyrics at the end.


I was looking at my very long list of “best and worst” music today, and found an old section called “The worst lines in popular songs”.  I present them to you as an inspiration. There are many more, of course: I expect people may bring up “MacArthur Park” or “I’ve got a brand new pair of rollerskates,” but those are just overall bad songs.  Bad songs needn’t contain bad lines, though. Here’s some of the lines that I’ll never be rid of as earworms:

This is a story about Billy Joe and Bobbie SueTwo young lovers with nothin’ better to doThan sit around the house, get high, and watch the tubeAnd here is what happened when they decided to cut looseThey headed down to, ooh, old El PasoThat’s where they ran into a great big hassleBilly Joe shot a man while robbing his castleBobbie Sue took the money and run

. . . . Hoo-hoo-hoo, Billy Mack is a detective down in TexasYou know he knows just exactly what the facts isHe ain’t gonna let those two escape justiceHe makes his livin’ off of the people’s taxes

—Steve Miller “Take the Money and Run”

Rhyming “El Paso” with “hassle” and “Texas” with “facts is” are just not rhymes. And someone should remind Mr. Miller that “facts” is plural. Steve Miller may in fact be the premier producer of the worst lines in rock music. Don’t forget “Abracadabra” and the immortal lines in “The Joker”:

Some people call me the space cowboy, yeah
Some call me the gangster of love
Some people call me Maurice

‘Cause I speak of the pompatus of love

There is no such thing as “pompatus,” at least not in the Oxford English Dictionary


Here’s an example of a not-bad song with terrible lines.  The first two just make me cringe, and the words “when we rode the horse we got some thrills” does likewise. Only one horse? Some thrills?

“Sittin’ in my car outside  your house
Remember when I spilled Coke all over your blouse.

. . .Miniature golf and Hondas in the hills(Miniature golf and Hondas in the hills)When we rode the horse, we got some thrills.”

–Beach Boys, “All Summer Long”


This is a good song but Loretta strains for rhymes several times. Here’s one example:

“The work we done was hard
At night we’d sleep ‘cause we were tard.” [“tired”]

–Loretta Lynn, “Coal Miner’s Daughter”


Here we have one of at least three uses of the word “chicken” in a rock song (can you name another?), but rhyming “chicken” with “bit me” doesn’t work. That said, I love this song; it’s bouncy and one of the best songs Stevie wrote:

“I was knee high to a chicken
When the love bug done bit me.”  (a rhyme)

–Stevie Wonder, “I Was Made to Love Her”


This speaks for itself:

Wooly bully, wooly bully.
Wooly bully, wooly bully, wooly bully.

–Sam the Sham and the Pharaohs, “Wooly Bully”


This song was on the jukebox in the greasy diner where we ate every night in college (99 cents per meal, including rice pudding!). It is one of the worst songs of that era. And the verse just cuts off: we don’t know what they will find in 2525!

In the year 2525,
If man is still alive,
If woman can survive
They may find.

–Zager and Evans, “2525”


I never understood this verse. These words may make some arcane sense to the band Chicago, but didn’t to me:

Should I try to do some more?
25 or 6 to 4.

–Chicago, “25 or 6 to 4”


I’m a huge fan of Steve Stills, but when he got it wrong, he got it wrong big time. And here’s one of those times!

The deeper you go ’cause of the pressure of the air
The nitrogen comes and goes (gets you high)
It’s an alien atmosphere
They call it rapture of the deep
Be you not afraid
You’re too far down by now to be scared
Two hundred and eighty-seven feet
I saw Jesus and it made sense that he was there

–Stephen Stills, “Black Coral”


This comes from my late friend Kenny, who found the lyric:

“Ooooh, poor Romeo
Sitting’ all on his own-e-o.
Ooooh, poor Romeo.

–Phil Lynott, “Romeo and the Lonely Girl”, from “Jailbreak”, by Thin Lizzie

UPDATE (AT THE TIME): I’ll retract the last quote as “bad rhyming” based on one a comment in the thread by Brendan Teeling, who says that “own-eo” was normal Dublin parlance at the time. Also, this was the only quote that was given to me by someone else; all the rest I’m well familiar with.

2026 UPDATE: And a new one.  The song “Drops of Jupiter,” by Train is FULL of awful lines and I didn’t put it in the previous post.  In fact, though the melody is okay, the entire song’s lyrics qualify as dreadful.  Here are a couple of stinkers. (Note: this is one of only two rock/pop songs I know of that contains the word “chicken.”  The other is mentioned above.)

Now, that she’s back from that soul vacation
Tracin’ her way through the constellation, hey-hey (Mmm)
She checks out Mozart while she does Tae-Bo
Reminds me that there’s room to grow, hey-hey, yeah

Now, that she’s back in the atmosphere
I’m afraid that she might think of me as
Plain ol’ Jane told a story about a man
Who was too afraid to fly, so he never did land

“Checks our Mozart while she does Tai-Bo“, indeed. Checks him out!

But wait! There’s more! Another verse from the bridge:

Can you imagine no love, pride, deep-fried chicken
Your best friend always sticking up for you
Even when I know you’re wrong?
Can you imagine no first dance, freeze-dried romance
Five-hour phone conversation
The best soy latte that you ever had, and me?

My technician at the time loved soy lattes and made me drink one.  It was dreadful and I’ll never have another. The “best soy latte that you ever had” is worse than emulsified cow pies.

2026:  You know the drill: NOW IT’S YOUR TURN! Put your worst lyrics below.

Tuesday: Hili dialogue

October 20, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to The Cruelest Day: Tuesday, October 20, 2026, and it’s National Chicken and Waffles Day, celebrating a dish that is purely American, and arose in kitchens of the Pennsylvania Dutch. From Wikipedia:

Chicken and waffles, as a combined recipe using pulled boiled chicken, first appeared in the United States’ colonial period in the 1600s in Pennsylvania Dutch country.  The traditional Pennsylvania Dutch version consists of a plain waffle with pulled, stewed chicken on top, covered in gravy.

A version using fried chicken is associated with the American South. The soul food version of chicken and waffles grew in popularity after the opening of the Wells Supper Club in Harlem, New York, in 1938. The waffle is served as it would be for breakfast, with condiments such as butter and syrup. This version of the dish is popular enough in Baltimore, Maryland to become a local custom.

I’ve never had it, but would gladly devour it were I presented with a dish (to be sure, lots of restaurants on the South Side serve it). I’d prefer the Southern version with butter and syrup, as I think the salty chicken would go good with a sweet waffle. Here’s a photo from Wikipedia:

Evan Swigart, TheCulinaryGeek from Chicago, USA, CC BY 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons

It’s also International Chefs Day, National Brandied Fruit Day, National Mozzarella Stick Day, Office Chocolate Day, and World Calvados Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the October 26 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

*The NYT gives us a biased account of “what you need to know” about the riots and protests in France.

What happened this weekend?

More than half a million people joined some 110 marches throughout France on Saturday, the interior ministry said, in the biggest day of protest since the demonstrations began about a month ago. A major union, the C.G.T., gave a higher estimate, saying 800,000 protesters had turned out.

Amid many peaceful demonstrations, rioters vandalized roughly 1,500 shops and many symbols of the French state, leading to roughly 2,000 arrests. An arson attack largely destroyed the town hall in Limoges, in central France. In Marseille, the second-largest city, masked people broke into a government building and tipped over a bust of Marianne, a symbol of the Republic.

. . . Why are students protesting?

High school students started protesting last month to express frustration with the condition of their schools.

They have pointed to crumbling infrastructure, overcrowded classrooms, overloaded schedules, a shortage of teachers and staff, and underfunding in schools. Many are also calling for an overhaul of state-run admissions platforms for higher education and universities that they call unfairly selective.

Students have blockaded hundreds of schools. They have set fire to, or damaged, at least 24 of them, according to the government. Thousands have been arrested since September and over 1,000 police officers, students and school staff have been hurt.

. . . Why did other groups join the students?

Throughout October, labor unions and other campaign groups have increasingly joined the students’ demonstrations. They have held bigger rallies to express solidarity with the students as well as to protest a broader range of issues.

Some are angry over the cost of living and rising fuel prices that have surged, in part, because of the Iran war. Farmers have joined in, angry at agricultural costs.

. . . And left-wing parties have also seized on the protests as part of a wider expression of discontent at President Emmanuel Macron, who is limited to two terms and is nearing the end of his time in office.

. . . What is the political fallout?

On Sunday, far-right leaders and the centrist government blamed the far left for the chaos. They pointed in particular to a major far-left party, France Unbowed, that they said provoked the unrest.

Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu has accused party leaders of sowing distrust about the police among student protesters, and said some rioters were members of the “ultra-left.”

France Unbowed has rejected that accusation and its leader, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, has instead blamed the government for actions that he said made the unrest more likely.

And that’s about it. No mention of pro-Palestinian protestors and Palestinian flags, no mention of immigration, no mention of looting of the “vandalized shops”. All of that, of course, would make the protestors/rioters look worse.

*For another view, read the WSJ’s editorial-board op-ed, “Why France is burning.” In fact, the piece doesn’t tell us at all why France is burning (apparently the paper did that before), but discusses how French politicians on the right and on the left are using the protests/riots to their advantage.

We’ve explained the underlying fiscal and political woes behind the crisis, but the news this time is the pre-election play by far-left candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon.

Heretofore Mr. Mélenchon, head of the far-left Indomitable France party, had taken a somewhat detached attitude to the protests. But this weekend he participated in protests in Paris. He also blamed police for “unleashing” on protesters, while condemning looting and arson.

The riots are ostensibly about declining public services, but the presidential election next April figures into the protest calculations. Marine Le Pen of the insurgent right National Rally is leading in current presidential polls. Mr. Mélenchon is in a three-way tie with two candidates on the center-left.

The race now is to see who can emerge from the first round of voting to get to the two candidate runoff, probably against Ms. Le Pen. If the riots help Mr. Mélenchon consolidate support on the left, he could be the one. If the riots move more center-right voters away from the centrist candidates and toward Ms. Le Pen, Mr. Mélenchon may figure he has a fighting chance to become the next President in the May runoff.

. . .The parties of the right and left see a rare opportunity to use the moment to gain the Élysée Palace. It’s no coincidence that some protesters came uncomfortably close to the palace before police dispersed them.

Mr. Macron addressed the country Sunday evening, asking for public calm and order. But as a lame duck, he is left to rely on police to protect the French streets. They couldn’t do it on Saturday, as protesters ransacked shops in Marseille and elsewhere, and even torched the historic town hall in Limoges that survived the Nazis.

France is in a violent democratic funk, and it will probably get worse. Don’t think it can’t happen in the U.S. given the current state of American politics.

That’s a lot of the editorial’s content. Not only does it not answer the title question, but it doesn’t even show how the parties are using the unrest to their advantage. All it shows is what the consequences will be if the riots move the public in one political direction or another. Sadly, this op-ed appears to be a waste of space.

*Trump is justifying his easing of sanctions on Russia because it’s part of a “peace deal” that presumably will end Russia’s war with Ukraine—by facilitating the release of unnamed hostages.

President Trump, defending his decision to ease tariffs and other sanctions against Russia, said on Sunday that he was making “great progress” in a peace deal with the Kremlin and suggested for the first time that the process included “hostage negotiations.”

He did not specify whose release he was seeking. But the only American now categorized by the State Department as “wrongfully detained” in Russia is Stephen Hubbard, a Michigan teacher who was seized from his home in Ukraine just months after Russia invaded that country in February 2022 and was charged with being a mercenary. He was sentenced to more than six years in a penal colony, on charges that the United States has said are fabricated.

“My decision on Russia is a very simple one,” Mr. Trump wrote on social media, an apparent reference to his move late on Friday to neutralize the sanctions resolution that he had signed only a few weeks earlier. “I am in the process of negotiating Peace in the war between Russia and Ukraine, and don’t want to do anything that will drive, foolishly, Russia away from the bargaining table.”

Until Sunday, Mr. Trump had said little about the remarkable, rapid-fire steps he has taken over the past 10 days to side with the Russians in a conflict that has now gone on longer than World War I. Those steps amount to the reversal of nearly five years of sanctions following President Vladimir V. Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine.

In that time period Mr. Trump has announced that the United States will buy diesel fuel from Russia — though the announced purchases are far too small to have a significant effect on prices, despite Mr. Trump’s claims — and that he will waive imposing tariffs on Russia under a newly signed law named for its chief proponent, Senator Lindsey Graham, the South Carolina Republican who died in July.

Both decisions have been criticized by U.S. lawmakers, including fellow Republicans. Senator Darline Graham of South Carolina, who was appointed to her brother’s seat and is now running for a full term, gently disagreed on Saturday with Mr. Trump’s decision on the sanctions law, saying that she “would choose to put the pressure on Russia to end the war and get gas prices down.”

The breach with Ukraine has been sudden and perhaps irreparable.

Indeed!  Presumably a peace deal will require the cooperation and assent of Ukraine and Zelensky, and you don’t get that by suddenly cozying up to Russia. (There has been no cozying up to Ukraine.) And one hostage does not a peace deal make.  All we have is the depressing site of Trump cozying up to a dictator and blaming Ukraine for America’s high gas prices. .

*The WaPo personalizes the U.S. administration’s war on science with a piece called “Meet the researchers leaving the U.S. because of Trump’s funding cuts and politicization of science“.

Halley Froehlich was sure she’d spend her scientific career in the United States. Her family has been in America since the 1700s.

But over the past two years, delayed federal grants and fears about the future motivated her to pack her life into boxes. She moved to Finland with her husband and daughter and is continuing her research — studying how fish, shellfish and seaweed that humans eat are responding to climate change — at the University of Helsinki.

When the Trump administration began upending U.S. scientific research last year, dismantling the federal grant-giving process and attempting to exert more political influence over what projects get funded, foreign universities saw an opportunity. They adopted programs to lure U.S. researchers abroad, promising more stable streams of funding and academic freedom.

Since then, many have taken the bait. While there is no way to quantify the overall change across the nation, scientists, researchers and professional groups say the shift is clear, unprecedented and concerning.

“You can almost talk to any vice president for research at a university and they will tell you of one or two top faculty that they’ve lost,” said Tobin Smith, senior vice president of government relations and public policy for the Association of American Universities.

. . .White House spokesperson Liz Huston said Trump is “ending waste” and is “committed to keeping America the world leader in scientific innovation, and that means funding real science.”

But more than half of American states have lost scientists to recruitment programs in other countries, according to an April report from the Business for Federal Research Funding Coalition. Last March, early-career biomedical scientists were about 20 percentage points less likely to say they would “now” stay in the U.S., compared to their recollection of how they felt six months earlier. And physics Ph.D. graduates in 2025 left the U.S. at the highest rate in 30 years, according to the American Institute of Physics.

Countries including Canada, France, Belgium and Finland are touting their recruits from U.S. institutions, a disturbing and surprising development, scientists say, for a country that far and away leads the world in Nobel prizes for medicine, physics and chemistry.

“It used to be the shining city on the hill where we all want to go,” said Christine Stawitz, now at the University of Birmingham in England. “That reputational loss, I think, is hard to quantify, but also really damaging.”

International scientists who have come to the U.S. because of its research reputation are also leaving the country.  And of course the less attractive America becomes for science, the more scientists leave, so we’ll get a snowball effect. Now I’m not worried that in the long run this will persist, as Trump won’t always be President, and I presume that future Presidents, even if they’re Republicans, will have the sense to stop cratering science. But it looks like these scientists move only when they can continue their research, so the amount of research by them won’t change. Frankly, I don’t care which country is ahead so long as the work gets done. What is more worrisome is when science is quashed, and that is also being done with Trump’s widespread cancelation of grants.

*Over at It’s Noon in Israel, Amit Segal theorizes why Trump finally endorsed Netanyahu. Segal floats the suggestion that the endorsement, if it’s successful, will make the U.S. partner with the Jewish state on what Segal thinks is an upcoming Big Attack on Iran.

If this episode teaches anything, it is that, like Mark Twain’s death, the reports of daylight between Trump and Netanyahu are greatly exaggerated. The difference is that the media only announced Twain’s death once before they learned their lesson.

When it comes to Trump and Netanyahu, there is always more to the relationship than what makes it into print. Here, the “more” is the subject the endorsement kept returning to: Iran.

It appears that after vanquishing Israel’s opposition, Trump and Netanyahu plan to move on to what is left of the Islamic Republic. If plans have already been set, it is understandable why Trump would want the leader already briefed to remain at the helm.

Whether Trump’s claim that without Netanyahu “America will have to do this work ourselves” is a threat or an observation is an open question. If Trump is demanding Netanyahu as a precondition, that doesn’t mean he is voting for the coalition, only for a government with Netanyahu.

America doing the job alone is threatening Europe with a good time but would spell disaster for Israel. If the U.S. is returning to Iranian skies, likely for the last time, Israel needs to get its punches in before the window closes. “Unity” may be a dirty word in the opposition today, but we will see how the term evolves if Trump adds Iran into the equation.

The truth is, unity is likely the only way Bibi remains at the head of a stable coalition. Trump would be angry to find out that his name alone is insufficient to net Bibi another five or six seats. That reflects the dive in both Trump’s and Bibi’s popularity, and the difficulty of convincing what even Moses called a “stiff necked people.”

All of this implies that Segal has some secret information that both Israel and the U.S. want to finish off Iran fairly soon. I have seen nothing about this in any other American media, but of course Segal has “ins” in Israel that the U.S. media doesn’t.  I would not be unhappy to see Iran “finished” to the extent that there is regime change, and I don’t think that’s a clear objective of Trump, but it may be a felicitous byproduct of military action.

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili’s sensitive ears detect a catlike noise:

Hili: A child is crying.
Andrzej: Where?
Hili: One floor up.

In Polish:

Hili: Dziecko płacze.
Ja: Gdzie?
Hili: Piętro wyżej.

*******************

From Things With Faces:

From Cats Doing Cat Stuff:

From Give Me a Sign. This might be a jab at all the flavored beers being made:

This video from Masih will make you tear up:

Rawan Osman blames most of the unrest in Europe on Islamists? I’m not sure I agree:

The Number Ten Cat appears to be healing well from his cyst removal:

From JKR, and the story is here:

Two from my feed. Sound up on the first one to hear the cat reading along:

Translated from the Turkish (of course): “The fisherman, noticing that the pregnant cat he feeds fish to every day is visiting more frequently, finally can’t resist following her and learns that she’s not taking the fish for herself 🥹♥️”

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

And one from Doctor Cobb; a photo (I like it):

Scrolling back through my phone; just re-discovered this random photo that I took in Antarctica last winter. It shows a blizzard over an ice-speckled ocean. Seems almost surreal – not sure if this is a good photo or not!

— Prof Michael Meredith 🌊🧪🥼❄️ (@oceanandice.bsky.social) 2026-10-19T14:53:30.538Z

Have some Buddy Holly: in my view, his best song, “True Love Ways“, which he co-wrote with Norman Petty.  It was first released in 1960, almost two years after Holly’s death on The Day the Music Died (February 3, 1959).  Holly was 22 when he perished in that plane crash.

From Wikipedia:

Holly biographer Bill Griggs points out that the melody borrows heavily from the gospel song “I’ll Be All Right,” a favorite of Holly’s, and one that would be played at his funeral in 1959. According to Griggs, the framework of the melody was written by Buddy, with the remainder, and lyrics, added by Petty.

Holly’s widow, Maria Elena Holly, claimed that the song was written for her as a wedding gift. On April 29, 2011, she unveiled the never-before-seen “True Love Ways” photo of their wedding kiss, now displayed at P.J. Clarke’s above Table 53, the table where they became engaged while on their first date, on June 20, 1958.

And did you know this>?

John Lennon and Paul McCartney saw Holly for the first time when he appeared on Sunday Night at the London Palladium. The two had recently met and begun their musical association. They studied Holly’s records, learned his performance style and lyricism, and based their act around his persona. Inspired by Holly’s insect-themed Crickets, they chose to name their band “the Beatles“. Lennon and McCartney later cited Holly as one of their main influences.

I don’t know a rock/pop song this old that has a jazz-influenced saxophone riff:

Buddy Holly and the Crickets, 1957 (Holly’s in the middle):

Coral Records, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The riots in Europe. . .

October 19, 2026 • 10:00 am

. . . seem to be getting worse. What started out as relatively peaceful protests against poor school conditions have devolved into full-scale rioting complete with arson, mass destruction, and looting. The far left and French unions have joined in, as well as a lot of young pro-Palestinians, many of whom may be immigrants or from unassimilated immigrant communities.

Here’s a BBC videoabout the riots:

My Facebook feed is full of people using the riots as a reason to stem immigration to France (and Europe in general).  As I’ve said, I don’t want to use these protests so much to call for a total ban on immigration (though clearly some restrictions are in order) as to call attention to the pro-Palestinian and anti-Western nature of the demonstrations, which suggest that Europe is in danger of losing its liberal democratic culture. Why on earth should a protest that’s about schools and national budgets be replete with people waving Palestinian flags and calling for another intifada? Why the destruction, symbolizing the destruction of Western liberal values.

Here’s Noa Tishby, an Israeli actress now living in America, making that point. Click the screenshot to see her video post:

Many shopkeepers have had to stand by, like this poor woman, as protestors invaded their shops, wrecked them, and looted the goods, ruining their life’s work. This woman is apparently host with her own petard:

The woman speaking, with subtitles:

Apparently mosques (unlike churches and synagogues) have been spared vandalism, as have many Muslim-owned shops.  Here’s a tweet I got from Luana:

In contrast, a non-Muslim immigrant who lost everything:

A good post from Maarten Boudry (click to read):

France has a long history of protest, student, and otherwise, but I’m worried about two things here.

First, the role of pro-Palestinians and anti-Western actors in these riots, which will have turned many Europeans into advocates (or at least osculators) of terrorism. Second, the fact that these riots may put into power far right-factions in Europe, some of which are Nazi-adjacent.

I am no pundit, but surely the solution involves recognizing the problem of immigrant communities who won’t assimilate into the European liberal-democratic tradition, as well as somehow enlightening those blockheads who shout “free Palestine” while waving Palestinian flags and chanting “from the river to the sea”. Is either of these possible? I don’t know.

And I have a bit of a worry that something like this will happen in America, as there are signs of it now in the ascendancy of Democratic Socialists and the increasing demonization of Israel and rise of anti-semitic crimes. But, as they always say, “It can’t happen here.”  Well, it’s happening in Europe.

Fall at Botany Pond: The turtles soak up some sun

October 19, 2026 • 8:15 am

All the ducks have gone, and the sky is gray. (People keep asking me, “Where do you think the ducks are?” My answer is, “My best guess is that they’ve gone south for the winter.”) But the squirrels and turtles are still here, and I’m been remiss in feeding the rodents. (The turtles get their own food from a feeder person.) One squirrel remembered me yesterday, crawled into my lap repeatedly, and was rewarded with two walnuts and four peanuts. I haven’t kissed him yet.

It’s been cool but sunny these last few days, and the turtles have taken advantage of the weather to soak up some rays and jump-start their metabolism. Yesterday afternoon four of them found their way to a sunny rock and, stretching out limbs and necks in what we call “turtle yoga”, basked for a long time. Here are four red-eared sliders absorbing UV.

Note that they’re all facing  the same direction: the sun is behind them, and they’ve exposed as much of their bodies as they can.  If I don’t miss my guess, there are two more turtles in the pond.

Notice how their rear feet are stretched out behind, and their necks are extended.

Finally, here’s a video in which turtle #4 joins the three that were already there. Be sure to watch until the end.

I haven’t seen a single duck even stop briefly at the pond since Miss Duck left along with her brood (Rupert was the last). I do wonder where they are.

Monday: Hili dialogue

October 19, 2026 • 7:00 am

Welcome to another damn week: it’s Monday, October 19, 2026, and it’s Rainforest Day. Here are shots, in order, from Costa Rica (La Selva) in 2017 and Oahu (Mānoa Falls) two years later:

It’s also International Gin and Tonic Day and National Seafood Bisque Day.

Posting will be light today as I’m off to see Richard Dawkins speak on “Genes and the Meaning of Life” at Symphony Hall this evening (I prepare most of these dialogues the day before they appear).

UPDATE: It was a good time; Richard was interviewed byNicholas Epley , a behavioral scientist and professor at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business. It was at Symphony Hall in downtown Chicago and lasted about an hour and a half.  I had given Nick a list of ten questions that I’d ask Richard (I don’t have the list) and was glad to see that about half of them came up: memes, evolutionary psychology, genetically based sex differences, Richard as a “cultural Christian” and so on. At 85, Richard hasn’t lost a lick: he’s still thoughtful, eloquent, and, as the audience appreciated, funny. It’s hard to think of another academic who could draw such crowds and entertain them and educate them so thoroughly. The crowd was urprisingly young—I estimate the mean age of about 40.  Here’s a shot of the venue from my seat on the main floor:

I found the list of questions I’d sent to Nick as suggestions to ask Richard. I know what Dawkins’s answers would be to some of them, but the audience doesn’t.

1  Of all the books you’ve published, which is your favorite, and why?
2  What do you think has been the greatest discovery in evolutionary biology in the last several decades?
3 If you could have one unanswered question about evolution or biology answered for you, what would it be?
4. Given the mountains of evidence in favor of evolution, why do 73% of Americans believe that God had some hand in human evolution (see attached Pew Survey, adding pure creationists and partial creationists)?
5. People are now proclaiming that religion is coming back, based on the fact that the number of “nones’ (people without a formal church affiliation) has slowed down or reached a plateau in the last two years. Do you think religion is inexorably on its way out in America, or has the decline stopped?
6. Evolutionary psychology, the idea that human behaviors, preferences, and thoughts, have been heavily influenced by evolution, has been widely criticized as “just-so stories”. I presume you don’t agree with that because, after all, why is the human brain exempt from natural selection? What do you make of these criticisms and could you give us some examples of human behaviors that you think have been clearly instilled in us by natural selection.
7. Your late friend and colleague Daniel Dennett called Charles Darwin’s idea of evolution by natural selection “the single best idea anyone has ever had.” Given that the competitors include Newton and Einstein, do you agree?

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the October 19 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

*After a long period of silence, Trump has finally endorsed Netanyahu in the Israeli elections (October 27).  The Prime Minister of Israel, though, is not elected directly, but rather emerges from a coalition-forming caucus after the election of Parliament.  I’m not a fan of Netanyahu, and am hoping for a better PM, but it doesn’t matter who emerges as the leader, for the world will hate Israel no matter who runs the government. And you know why. (Netanyahu was just one more excuse to hate Israel)

*France is rocked with riots that have arisen from protests, and yesterday the protestors rioters burned most of an old city hall in Limoges (see archived article here).

France was in a state of shock on Sunday, as citizens walked through streets lined with shattered storefronts, charred cars and burned-out government buildings after the country’s largest demonstrations in years devolved into riots and looting.

The unrest on Saturday — which led to some 2,000 arrests — caused widespread damage to several symbols of the state, including a 19th-century city hall in Limoges, a town in central France renowned for its porcelain, that was largely destroyed in a nighttime arson attack. More than 600 police officers were injured, Laurent Nuñez, France’s interior minister, said on social media on Sunday.

Rioters attacked city halls from Lille in northern France to Marseille in the south, where they broke into the local government headquarters and tipped over a bust of Marianne, a symbol of the French Republic. A fire also destroyed a tourist office in Lyon, and 1,500 shops were damaged or looted nationwide, according to Alexandre Bompard, head of the French federation of commerce and distribution, who estimated that the cost of repairs could run into hundreds of millions of dollars.

“I’ve never seen this before, I am disgusted,” said Sophie Vanpoperinghe, 47, as she gazed at ransacked shops on Boulevard Magenta, the road in Paris where she has lived for 22 years and which is frequently used for demonstrations.

More than half a million demonstrators marched on Sunday to protest the rising cost of living and poor conditions in schools, among other grievances. Many were stunned on Sunday at how rioters had used those demonstrations as a smoke screen for vandalism.

. . . On Sunday, the violence and protests had subsided and given way to a political blame game. Government officials and far right leaders accused the far left of stirring up the unrest, and left-wing leaders blamed the government.

These riots are, as you see from the second tweet below, being blamed on immigrants and are boosting an anti-immigrant parties and politicians like Marine Le Pen. The question is to what extent are immigrants involved and, beyond that, why would immigration itself lead to rioting? The MSM is largely silent on the immigration component, though I found this in the Spectator (archived):

As Sébastien Lecornu said, the violence was perpetrated by two groups: far-left extremists and what he termed ‘criminals’.

Far-left extremists are usually white, like those arrested earlier this year after the death of a nationalist student in Lyon. The people seen on television forcing their way into the city halls of Marseille and Lille were mainly white. On the other hand, the ‘criminals’ filmed looting in Paris, Marseille and Bordeaux appeared to be of immigrant background.

All the demonstrations I’ve seen involve some Palestinian flags being waved, but of course we saw that among American college students.  Frederick Alexander says this at The Gadfly (h/t Anna):

The hard left has spent weeks turning a legitimate grievance about failing schools into a much wider confrontation with the state.

And then there’s the Islamist connection, which the mainstream media would rather not talk about. Outside a school near Paris, a student was filmed shouting, “In the name of Allah, we can kill them all!”, to the cheers of other teenagers.

Elsewhere, there’s footage of students singing along to a rap song invoking Mohammed Merah, the Islamist terrorist who murdered Jewish schoolchildren in Toulouse, and the Bataclan massacre. Meanwhile, a 2025 parliamentary inquiry revealed the growing proximity between figures in Mélenchon’s party and organisations associated with political Islam.

So much for a protest about maths lessons.

None of this means that every student demanding a better education is an Islamist revolutionary. But it’s hard not to conclude that the political forces seeking to exploit their grievances have other ideas. France’s disaffected students offer a useful point of combustion for wider political violence.

What we’re looking at is an increasingly visible convergence between the revolutionary left and political Islam, alongside the familiar collection of hooligans and nihilists who see any disorder as an occasion to indulge their grim hobby, not just in France but across the West.

We’ll have to wait and see what the role of immigration is in these ongoing unrests, but it’s already clear that the far-left native populations are involved. And regardless of who is demonstrating, the spread of political Islam is concerning.

A tweet from Jay showing the fracas, with the English translation, “⚠️🔴 WATCH UNTIL THE END I CANNOT DESCRIBE WHAT I JUST EXPERIENCED IN MARSEILLE. ”

And a possible result (h/t Luana):

*Over at It’s Noon in Israel, Amit Segal describes the clashes between Palestiniand and Israelis in Judea and Samaria that is always described by the press as “settler violence.” In reality, says Segal, both sides can incite this violence, so it’s “chaos” mistakenly attributed by the press as totally the acts of Israelis.

t’s Sunday, October 18, and two events on Saturday captured the problem of settler violence. The first was a little-publicized provocation by Palestinians during the olive harvest, when they approached a settlement’s grazing lands pelting a shepherd with stones. The second was an unprovoked settler attack on European diplomats who had come to protect the harvest.

At 7:35 a.m., according to an Israeli emergency-response group, a shepherd from the Ma’ale Ahuvia farm was hit by stones in the farm’s grazing land near Taybeh. He was lightly hurt and got himself to treatment. Residents say the harvesters began on Deir Jarir’s land and then crossed into pasture the IDF had approved for the farm.

Palestinians, for their part, claim that settlers advanced on their harvest under IDF guard, firing live rounds. The IDF has not commented on the clash or its alleged presence, and no footage corroborates the gunfire. The casting of the IDF as an accomplice to settler violence is narratively compelling for those who see all Israelis as equally malicious, but it also sets off alarm bells for Israelis who know that if the IDF is there, it is far more likely to be separating the two sides than supporting a settler attack.

The second incident took place six hours after the Ma’ale Ahuvia clash, a few kilometers away. A little before 1:30 p.m., masked men with metal bars descended on a delegation of Belgian, French and Polish diplomats in Taybeh. A French mayor put on his tricolor sash, and it didn’t help. The window of the Belgian consulate’s car was smashed. It was a disgusting act of baseless vigilante justice.

Belgium’s foreign minister blamed Israel’s settlement policy and pledged to push for further EU sanctions. France demanded that Israel arrest those responsible, and Poland declared itself deeply outraged.

The latter incident has rightly been condemned by nearly every corner of the Israeli establishment. The IDF called it a severe act of violence by Israeli rioters, and Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar condemned it without caveats. The Prime Minister’s Office said any violence against diplomats is unacceptable.

A similar incident a day earlier is covered in the shadow of provocation and response. According to the Binyamin Regional Council, hundreds of “terrorists and anarchists” threw stones and fired fireworks directly at Israelis, Palestinian Authority vehicles were allegedly on hand, and left-wing activists had organized the confrontation so the cameras could film the Israeli response.

The response, when it came, was itself highly problematic. According to one witness, 50 Israelis, many masked and some carrying gas canisters, came down the hill onto the terraced groves. Some set trees alight and used slings to throw stones at the harvesters, who retreated downhill and threw stones back.

Caught in the middle was Heidi Levine, a photographer working for The Washington Post. Wearing a vest clearly marked “Press,” she was pushed to the ground and beaten, and was left with a broken rib, a broken vertebra and a finger injury that needs surgery. President Isaac Herzog, who called Heidi Levine after Shabbat to apologize for her beating, said Taybeh weighed on his conscience as well.

Segal’s take is that the situation is complicated, but the media and the world want to simplify it by blaming all the violence on Israelis. The world’s push for sanctions, he adds, is based not on “settler violence” in the West Bank, but on Israel’s actions in its war on Gaza.  The end:

The tragic reality of Judea and Samaria will not bend to the wishes of its indignant defenders. Palestinian violence against Israelis will always be played down or omitted altogether, while settler violence will always erode Israel’s standing abroad. Israel must reconcile itself to this reality and act accordingly.

*The NYT has two articles (here and here) suggesting that O. J. Simpson might not have acted on his own if he did murder his wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her companion Ron Goldman in 1994 (remember that Simpson was found not guilty). When Simpson wrote his fictional memoir, If I Did It, he told his ghostwriter he could not have done the murders alone.  Now there’s evidence that that might have been the case:

In the failed murder prosecution of O.J. Simpson in 1995, the government professed that he alone had killed his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her friend Ronald Goldman.

Among the issues that hampered the case: the lack of a murder weapon, which has never been found. Its absence has long stoked speculation about whether the killer had assistance.

Now, records unsealed after 30 years at the request of The New York Times show that a prized government informant had told law enforcement key information about the killings, including the supposed location of the murder weapon and details about Mr. Simpson’s efforts to evade prosecution. Together, the findings challenge the popular narrative around the case.

This year, the informant’s brother told The Times that his sibling’s role in the case went much deeper. And the brother said he actually helped discard a bag, containing a heavy object, in the hours after the murders.

Joseph Ippolito, known as Joey, a convicted drug trafficker and mafia associate, escaped from a Florida prison a month before the 1994 murders.

Mr. Ippolito’s brother said the siblings went west after the escape to Los Angeles. Before his incarceration, Mr. Ippolito had operated a popular restaurant there and was a close friend of Al Cowlings, the longtime confidant of Mr. Simpson.

In the wake of the infamous Bronco chase with Mr. Simpson and Mr. Cowlings, investigators found photos in the vehicle of one of Mr. Ippolito’s girlfriends, along with her phone number.

Mr. Ippolito was eventually brought back into custody a year later. Right away, records show, he fed federal investigators in New York information about the mafia and set up meetings with undercover drug agents, with prosecutors saying that they “found Ippolito to be a remarkable source of information.” Mr. Ippolito risked his own safety to help them, prosecutors wrote in a memo lobbying a federal judge for leniency in his sentence.

He also divulged information about Mr. Simpson and the killings.

. . .“The O.J. Simpson case remains an open and ongoing investigation,” a spokesman for the L.A.P.D. said. Because there was no conviction in the murders, “the department has an obligation to continue to pursue justice in this matter.” The spokesman added, “at a point that new evidence is found, detectives will follow those investigatory leads.”

As part of a re-examination of the Simpson case, The Times has unearthed tales of secret audiotapes, mafia links, a prison escape, and backchannel communications between state and federal prosecutors. The reporting also came across a dramatic account from the rapper Fat Joe that bolsters the informant’s supposed role in the case.

You can read more about the NYT’s investigation at the archived link here.

*When I was looking for jobs in the early 1980s, it was tough to find one. After many rejections, I finally got an offer from the only remaining school: the University of Maryland.  Soon thereafter, the job market for STEM Ph.D.s expanded and things became easy. Now it’s tough again, as exemplified by this Ph.D., from chemical engineering (Princeton) who got rejected from over 2300 jobs. 

Jack Weiss likes to joke that he’s just another unemployed guy living in his parents’ basement.

That leaves out a few key details: The Salt Lake City native has applied to more than 2,300 jobs since he graduated from Princeton in 2024 with his Ph.D. in chemical engineering. And he still doesn’t have a job.

He first pursued corporate science jobs and prestigious postdoctoral fellowships at national laboratories. Then he cast a wider net, applying to software engineering and other roles. Eventually, he was getting ghosted for food-preparation jobs, including at a company that sells frozen crab cakes.

For a time, Weis got a gig training AI on his expertise, including in engineering and fluid mechanics. That work dried up too.

I first interviewed Weis late last year, the day before his 30th birthday. Covering careers and the labor market, I endeavored to meet job seekers in all 50 states, hoping it would help me understand why many people felt so dim about their futures. Just 34% of Americans surveyed by Gallup in August said it was a good time to find a quality job.

The picture remains murky. The latest jobs report fell far short of expectations. The unemployment rate remains low, but the percentage of unemployed people out of work for 27 weeks or more was higher this summer than it’s been for more than a decade, with the exception of Covid-19 and its immediate aftermath.

The promise of AI—and unease around its application—also contributes to an environment that is harder than usual for young, college-educated workers to find work, while the opposite is true for those without degrees. More than 70% of U.S. respondents to a Pew Research Center survey released last month said they expected AI would lead to fewer jobs overall.

After dozens of interviews across all 50 states, Weis’s story struck me for the way it embodied the deep freeze that has paralyzed the current labor market in the past few years—what economists refer to as a low-hire, low-fire environment.

Many people have jobs, but they’re not leaving them, limiting opportunity for others. Those who don’t have a job are locked out of the growing economy as if it were a fortress, leaving them puzzled by the headlines of low unemployment and an accelerating GDP.

The guy is no slouch:

The son of two physicians, Weis graduated summa cum laude from Rice University and enrolled at Princeton for his Ph.D. in 2018. His research on ice formation was cited by the Nobel committee when it awarded the Nobel Prize in physics in 2024.

The situation is exacerbated not only by fear of AI, but by applicants who submit hundreds of applications using AI, and employers, drowning in applications, uses AI to screen them.  I’d still want to be 30 again if I had the choice, but the job market is one of the things on the downside of that.

*Yesterday’s Washington Post article by Mark Wagner—”My sister may have visited me after death. There’s a term for it“—doesn’t show the supernatural, it at least suggests it (see article archived here).

One summery Friday, as I mowed the lawn, I’m pretty sure my dead sister, Caroline, appeared to me as a peach. On a tree that had in five years never borne fruit, a single, perfectly ripe peach nearly touched my nose as I bobbed my head under the boughs.

How and why Caroline became a peach is a story that begins in August 1985. As part of her wedding ceremony, we sang “Amazing Grace.” At 30, Caroline was no shrinking violet. She’d been hired as a technology analyst by the CIA. She insisted that she would not sing, “To save a wretch like me,” demanding instead that we sing, “That saved a peach like me.” So we sang Christianity’s most notable hymn with new words. No divine punishment ensued. In fact, Caroline went on to have a healthy family and succeed in her career in higher education.

After her wedding, she embraced all things peachy. We called her “Sweet Peach.” At our “Yankee swaps” at Christmas, each year a niece or nephew would give her a peach candle, and they would all sing the SNL carol — “It’s a candle, that same peach candle.”

. . .And here I was, two months later, staring at a peach dangling in front of my face. I pulled it clean and ran into the house to show my wife and son.

We went out to check. There were no other peaches on the tree. We have another peach tree, one that’s actually fecund, but those peaches were weeks from being ripe.

What else could we do? My son and I made a smoothie, and I called my siblings.

And I told the story to friends. To my surprise, many shared a similar tale: After a death, a special bird appears. Or the loved one arrives with surreal lucidity in a dream. Or they catch an unexpected whiff of cinnamon, or lilacs, a scent the person had loved the most.

Of course the author can’t really say this was a miracle—a sign from his dead sister—but when you read the end, it sort of becomes ambiguous:

Was the peach Caroline? Perhaps Shakespeare said it best. As Hamlet instructed his friend Horatio, there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamed of in our philosophies. I would suggest the working word at the tip of Shakespeare’s pen is “dreamed.” Our philosophies and models of what is possible are dreams. The true reality of our lives and deaths is something other, something we struggle to put into words. Sometimes, it tastes sweet.

If you can figure out what the guy is saying, you’re better than I am! It seems deliberately ambiguous.

I take the appearance of the peach as a coincidence, and nothing more.  Sometimes it happens, sometimes this stuff happens, and sometimes doesn’t, but many people are looking for some affirmation that the deceased live on, or at least something that vividly reminds them of those who died. And you don’t hear about the coincidences that don’t occur. I suggest this article verges on affirmation of the supernatural more than it does on extolling coincidences that, after all, happen many times in a huge population.

There are two successive comments with opposite views:

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili shows her erudition:

Hili: Horace was right.
Andrzej: About what?
Hili: Almost everything.

In Polish:

Hili: Horacy miał rację.
Ja: W jakiej sprawie?
Hili: Prawie w każdej.

*******************

From Things With Faces:

From Cheryl’s Amazingly Positive, No Politics Allowed, Interesting People Group:

From Terrible Maps: U.S. states that have more cows than people:

Masih gets emotional speaking of Iranian protestors on death row:

From Luana; the town hall of Limoges, France, coming down after an arson attack:

J. K. Rowling is opposed to death threats no matter who makes them. This one is pretty scary, though.

Two from my feed. First, Greta has moved onto the latest cause:

A funny bit from Stephen Fry and Hugh Lsurie:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

And two from Professor (Emeritus) Cobb. Here’s the first cat in space. Sadly, as Wikipedia notes, “Félicette euthanized two months after the launch so that scientists could perform a necropsy to examine her brain.” That is horrible—NO MORE CATS IN SPACE!

It's Félicette Day!On the date in 1963 the first cat went to space. Here's the song we wrote about her youtu.be/70VCY9Iu6qc?…

— SPRAY (@spraypopmusic.com) 2026-10-18T07:50:41.344Z

Matthew asks, “What do they use it for?” Good question, and you can find the answer here. (It anchors the sponge in the sediment, but also keeps the animal above accumulating sediment.)

Some glass sponges may be the oldest animals on Earth. Individuals of Monorhaphis chuni are estimated at over 11,000 years old, and they build a single skeletal spike up to 3m long, the largest natural glass structure any animal makes. 🧪 #SpongeThursday #HowToBuildAGiant #marinelife

— Dr Craig R McClain (@drcraigmc.bsky.social) 2026-09-17T17:17:26.475Z

Sunday: Hili dialogue

October 18, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to Sunday, October 18, 2026, sabbath for goyische cats, and National Exascale Day, which celebrates this:

Founded by CRAY, a Hewlett Packard Enterprise company, National Exascale Day takes place on October 18—1018 (one followed by 18 zeros). This number, 1,000,000,000,000,000,000, is a billion billion, or a quintillion. This relates to exascale in that an exascale is a quintillion computations per second. A quintillion computations is also known as an exaFLOP. An exascale computer can do a quintillion computations in a second, and exascale computing is working with computers that can do at least one exaFLOP per second. Exascale computers are about a million times faster than a laptop from the 2020s. The benefit is that these quicker computers will lead to quicker discoveries and innovations, which may lead to more lives saved from disease and natural disasters, and more food provided to more people.

Wikipedia adds this:

In 2022, the world’s first public exascale computer, Frontier, was announced. As of June 2026, Shenzhen Cloud Computing Center Co., Ltd’s LineShine is the world’s fastest exascale supercomputer.

Here’s a photo of the Frontier computer:

OLCF at ORNL, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

It’s also National Chocolate Cupcake Day, National No Beard Day, and World Menopause Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the October 18 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

*In his ongoing osculation of the autocrat Vladimir Putin (and the “President”‘s attempt to lower gas prices), Trump just suspended a number of financial sanctions that Congress had imposed on Russia.

President Trump signed an executive order on Friday night exempting Russia from a new sanctions measure that Congress passed last month, offering another economic lifeline to Russian President Vladimir V. Putin as the United States turns to Russia for help in lowering gas prices.

The sanctions were intended to target Russian officials, oligarchs and financial institutions, and were part of a law that was named after Senator Lindsey Graham, the South Carolina Republican who died in July after spending more than a year building support for the measure.

The law, which is intended to squeeze the financial lifelines sustaining Russia’s war against Ukraine, also provided Mr. Trump with additional tariff authority that he could use to punish countries that continue to trade with Russia.

The White House has broad authority to issue sanctions exemptions or waivers, and the new law requires Mr. Trump to notify Congress only if he opts against imposing the economic restrictions on Russia. Two days before the law is set to take effect, Mr. Trump exercised that power.

“I am hereby waiving the application of such sanctions, restrictions and duties provided for in the Graham Act,” Mr. Trump said in the order. “I have submitted to the Congress a certification that the issuance of such a waiver at this time is in the national interests of the United States.”

The order does not explain why waiving the sanctions is in the interests of the United States or what rationale Mr. Trump is providing to Congress for the waivers.

The explanation of the “national interest”:

The decision comes as Mr. Trump has in recent weeks embraced Russia and expressed frustration that Ukraine’s attacks on Russian refineries were helping to push up gasoline and diesel prices around the world. The biggest factor limiting supplies, though, remains the war in Iran.

Is it in the national interest to cozy up to Russia and Putin? Remember, the added influx of gas and diesel from the osculation of Russia will have very little effect on the American economy, with nearly all diesel and most gas produced in the U.S. with a much smaller amount coming from abroad—mainly Canada. This is all about Trump’s image, not the national welfare, but isn’t that the usual situation.

*Israeli residents of the West Bank are going on a rampage, first attacking Palestinian residents as well as Western news reporters and photographers, and now diplomats from Poland, France, and Belgium.

Masked settlers attacked a group of European diplomats during a visit to the occupied West Bank on Saturday, Belgium’s foreign minister said, on a second straight day of high-profile assaults on Palestinians and others during the sensitive olive harvest.

At least four people have been killed and more than 100 injured since the harvest began earlier this month, according to the Palestinian Health Ministry. Activists say Israeli authorities do little to stop attacks that involve weapons ranging from slingshots to guns. An attack Friday seriously injured a Washington Post photographer and others.

In Saturday’s attack in the Christian village of Taybeh, settlers targeted Belgium’s consul general, French and Polish diplomats and Catholic representatives, Belgian Foreign Minister Maxime Prevot said.

“A French mayor was assaulted and a Belgian vehicle damaged. Our team is safe,” Prevot said. He linked the attack to what he called Israel’s “illegal settlement policy” and pledged to push for further European Union sanctions. “Impunity for violent settlers must end,” he added.

Video shared by an activist at the scene, Amit Orfali, shows the French mayor, wearing a tricolor sash, leaning against a vehicle while sitting on the dusty ground. Other clips showed young masked men knocking insistently on a driver’s side window and asking for IDs, while other masked men carrying sticks advanced in the distance.

Orfali said the masked men “threatened to kill us.”

. . . Israel’s military in a statement confirmed Saturday’s attack on the diplomats and called it a “severe act of violence,” but said the visit had not been coordinated with it and no soldiers were at the scene.

. . .Israeli police said they had opened an investigation and vowed to work “until everyone who took part in these cases is brought to justice.” Foreign Minister Gideon Saar on X condemned the “severe acts of violence by Israeli rioters,” adding that his ministry was in contact with ambassadors from the countries concerned.

But Netanyahu’s office later issued a statement warning against “premature conclusions” in the incident and noted concerns about “a coordinated campaign to smear Israel.”

Well, no. NBC News showed Israelis attacking their reporter’s car, and breaking the window, for no reason, and also the Wahington Post photographer getting beat up. I don’t think conclusions are “premature.”  The whole mess is horrible, unconscionable, and Netanyahu needs to call it out for what it was and to provide more security from the IDF. Yes, Palestinians attack Israelis in the West Bank, too, but Israel has to have stringent control over its own citizens (Palestinians in Area C are not Israeli citizens). They can’t set an example of democracy and tolerance by allowing such violence (or not punishing it), and of course they surely realize that this kind of uncontrolled violence will further besmirch Israel’s already-rock-bottom reputation in the world.

*How many Press Secretaries has Trump had? At least six or seven, but I’m not going to look it up. The latest occupant of that woeful position, Katie Zacharia, lasted just five days after a pathetic first performance combined with her misrepresentations of her past.

The new White House press secretary, Katie Zacharia, is out of her role just five days into the job, two White House officials said Friday — ending a brief tenure that began amid West Wing infighting and voter discontent with Republicans, with midterm elections just weeks away.

The departure Friday was confirmed minutes after President Donald Trump said publicly that she should think about leaving, voicing support for her as a person but skepticism that she was right for the role.

“Maybe it’s not for her,” Trump told reporters outside the White House.

Her departure marked a rare and speedy retreat from a presidential appointment after a rough start to one of the highest-profile roles in the White House. Many Trump allies were taken aback by her, at times, halting appearance during her first White House briefing on Tuesday and in a succession of friendly interviews since then.

Trump picked the press secretary after minimal vetting. Questions about her background rapidly overshadowed her.

. . . . In his comments to reporters, Trump complained about the news media’s treatment of Zacharia. She has been enmeshed in questions about representing herself as an attorney even though she failed to pass the bar examination in California and is not licensed in any other state.

Trump cited two appearances on Fox News — an outlet that the White House generally sees as favorable.

“She’s been treated, I would say, pretty nastily. And I said to Katie just two minutes ago, I said, ‘Katie, you know, you don’t have to do this if you don’t want,’” Trump said.

“I said to her, ‘Honestly, if I were you, I’d reconsider,” he said.

One Trump ally said the feeling at the White House was that Zacharia did not have the necessary skills, or the “it” factor to be the press secretary, and it was better for the administration to move quickly to resolve the situation than to let it drag out shortly before the midterm elections.

. . .Zacharia’s downfall unfolded quickly.

On Thursday night, she did an interview with Fox News’s Sean Hannity in which the anchor pressed her extensively on her qualifications and appeared skeptical she was up to the job. Hannity speaks frequently with Trump, and his treatment of Zacharia was an indicator of her tenuous position.

Then, Friday morning, a “Fox & Friends” host asked Zacharia whether she had told Trump about her legal background. Her response made clear how little vetting had been done before her landing the role.

“You never want to be the story,” Fox’s Lawrence Jones said. “Do you wish you had disclosed to the president about the bar and not passing the bar?”

“Those questions weren’t asked,” Zacharia said. “I’m being hired as White House press secretary and not White House counsel.” [JAC: She lied about this repeatedly before she became press secretary: you don’t call yourself an “attorney” unless you’ve passed the bar exam.]

Here is her cringeworthy performance. One of the first comments says, “I thought this was SNL.” She reads, haltingly, from a script, begins by touting Trump’s “accomplishments” at length.  She mixes up Trump and her husband, and then winds up the conference after only about three questions. She would have been a huge embarrassment in the job and it’s appropriate that they deep-sixed her.

*Mahmoud Abbas, President of the Palestinian authority is now in the TWENTY-SECOND YEAR OF A FOUR-YEAR TERM, with the PLO regularly extending his term or postpoining elections.  Palestinians (and the world) should be outraged by this, but nobody seems to care. It’s not because Abbas is a “moderate,” for the PA still supports terrorism. The WSJ highlights this in an editorial-board op-ed called “The Palestinians see through Emmanuel Macron.” What does Macron have to do with this? Because the promise of elections led France last autumn to recognize Palestine as a state. Read an excerpt:

It’s that time of year again. Mahmoud Abbas, the President of the Palestinian Authority (PA), has issued a decree to postpone Palestinian elections. In exchange for recognition of Palestinian statehood last year, Mr. Abbas had promised French President Emmanuel Macron that he would hold elections in 2026 at last. Sometimes leaders and nations want to be lied to.

In June 2025 Mr. Abbas pledged that the PA was “committed to the organization of presidential and general elections within a year.” Weak at home, Mr. Macron touted this as a major breakthrough abroad. “In light of the commitments you have made,” he wrote, “France will proceed with the full recognition of Palestine.”

Australia and Canada joined the statehood parade while insisting that Hamas be excluded from the vote. Mr. Abbas has now postponed elections to September 2027 in consultation with the Hamas terrorists. Naturally the PA and Hamas blame Israel, whose fault it must be that they both run dictatorships, in the West Bank and Gaza, respectively.

By the new election date, Mr. Abbas will be 91, serving the 22nd year of what was a four-year term in office. There’s an excuse each year.

France, Canada, Australia and the U.K. published a statement Tuesday expressing “regret” over Mr. Abbas’s decision—but not their own. “Credible elections are an important element of the commitment that President Abbas and the Palestinian Authority made to reform,” they write. If they had really cared, they would have insisted that Mr. Abbas hold elections before they gave away recognition. But all they wanted from the PA was a fig leaf to cover their anti-Israel political pandering to Muslim and left-wing voters at home.

Mr. Abbas understood this only too well. Which is why the PA’s “pay-for-slay” program, which offers payments to terrorists who attack Jews, still persists under a new mechanism. Diplomatic recognition, which the West had long reserved for the day Palestinians made peace in negotiations with Israel, was surrendered for nothing. It won’t now be rescinded, at least not by these leaders.

Mr. Macron, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and the rest have managed to prove how little influence they have—with both Israel and the so-called moderate PA.

In 2000, 2001 and 2008, the PA turned down Israeli offers of peace and Palestinian statehood. There is no sign that has changed, or that the PA is serious about reform, governance and democracy. There is no state-building going on in Ramallah—even Mr. Macron & Co. know that. Recognizing a State of Palestine was merely another way to bash Israel.

Yes, the WSJ op-ed section is said to be quite right-wing, but what I see in this column is not an ideological slant but the truth. Abbas keeps lying, he’s still enabling terrorism, and Western countries keep pandering to a man who enables terrorism.  Are we not supposed to recognize this?

Apropos, reader Bill sent me this cartoon. You probably know the background, which you can see in the background:

*Campaigning has become expensive, especially during the upcoming midterms where a number of races are tight. I learned of the price of the Senate campaign in Texas from Sam Sifton’s Oct. 15 NYT morning newsletter (article archived here). Texas is where, you may know, Democratic nominee James Talarico is running pretty even with his Republican opponent, state attorney General Ken Paxton. Look at the money these candidates are spending!

There are a number of tight races in the coming midterm elections, but there isn’t a more expensive one than the Senate showdown in Texas. It pits James Talarico, the Democratic nominee, against Ken Paxton, the state’s conservative attorney general. More than half a billion dollars has been spent on advertising already, and the race could become the most costly nonpresidential contest in U.S. history.

Democrats are hopeful, because Talarico has a tiny lead in the polls. But “such optimism stands in defiance of the political axiom that Texas is where idealistic Democrats go to be mugged by reality,” writes Robert Draper, a three-decade veteran of Texas political reporting. The party has not won a statewide race there for 32 years.

The race may turn on who each man says he — and his opponent — is.

Talarico has introduced himself to the state’s 32 million residents as a good Christian member of the Texas House, with a record of bipartisanship. At a town hall meeting last night, Talarico spoke about his faith and appealed to undecided voters. “I’m a proud Texas Democrat, but I already have a religion and I already have a sports team,” he said. “So, I have no problem sharing hard truths with my party if it’s what’s best for Texas.”

His appeal is meant to be broad, with proposals to cap credit card rates, cut middle-class taxes, lower prices and assist people with their first down payment on a home.

In return, Paxton and his supporters paint Talarico as a “weird” radical who believes that “God is nonbinary” and that there are more than two biological sexes. (Talarico did say those things but later renounced them.) Vice President JD Vance, stumping in Texas on Tuesday, mocked Talarico — whose girlfriend is a former aide — with a gay joke. “I love you too sir,” Vance told a man in the crowd. “In a totally platonic way, to be clear. I’m the vice president, not James Talarico.”

I’m glad I don’t live in Texas, as it would be hard to vote for Talarico with those ridiculous statements about sex and God, but harder to vote for Paxton. And I bet the total campaign expenses come near $750 million before election day.

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili has apparently failed to seize the day that has just gone by:

Hili: And so another day goes by.
Andrzej: Carpe diem.

In Polish:

Hili: I znów mija kolejny dzień.
Ja: Carpe diem.

*******************

From Stacy:

From Meow Incorporated:

From Cheryl’s Amazingly Positive, No Politics Allowed, Interesting People Group:

Here’s Masih speaking in Spain, which, being one of the most antisemitic countries in Europe, would not give visas to the blinded protestors she wanted to bring with her

I found this while looking at “X”. I think there are more than one bridge, but it’s not clear, and, at any rate, this is ludicrous.  See the WSJ article here.

From Luana. Yes, the man’s a hero for risking his own life to save children, but these situations wouldn’t occur nearly as often with strict gun control in the U.S.:

From Simon, who calls this “Another job for Marco.” I can’t figure out if it’s in bad taste but it’s funny:

One from my feed: an Irish joke:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

And two from Doctor Cobb, both in a thread about spider silk:

Slimmer than a human hair, spider silk is an engineering powerhouse. 🕸️🧪Quinten Geldhof, also known as Microhobbyist, shows how a single spider can produce up to seven different types of silk, each with its own job. #Science #Microscope #Spiderwebs #Microscopy #Biology

— Museum of Science (@museumofscience.bsky.social) 2026-10-15T18:48:10.985Z

Sturdy dragline silk builds the web’s frame, while sticky blobs of silk set the trap for prey. Pound for pound, it’s up to five times stronger than steel, and a strand long enough to circle the Earth would weigh just 4.4 pounds! What would you use spider silk for?

— Museum of Science (@museumofscience.bsky.social) 2026-10-15T18:48:18.819Z

And three–count them, three–great songs for today’s music.  Here is the song that made Peggy Lee (real name: Norma Egstrom) famous, “Why Dont You Do Right?” , recorded in 1943 with Benny Goodman and his orchestra.  It was a huge hit and a million-seller back in days when that was a LOT of sales. As Wikipedia says, it was originally called “Weed Smoker’s Dream”, a song about drugs:

“Why Don’t You Do Right?” (originally recorded as “Weed Smoker’s Dream” in 1936) is an American blues and jazz-influenced pop song usually credited to Kansas Joe McCoy. A minor key twelve-bar blues with a few chord substitutions, it is considered a classic “woman’s blues” song and has become a standard. Singer Lil Green recorded a popular rendition in 1941, which Peggy Lee recorded the next year – accompanied by Benny Goodman – and made one of her signature songs.

Goodman was born to Jewish parents in Chicago, one of 12 children, and became one of the first jazz leaders to use black players in his groups. In this song, the combination of Goodman’s solos on the licorice stick and Peggy Lee’s soft delivery is lovely:

Speaking of a swing clarinet player who led small groups, here’s one whose proficiency rivals Goodman’s: Artie Shaw. This beautiful song, “All the Things You Are” , was recorded in 1939 as well, with Helen Forrest on vocals. The song was written by Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein.

Shaw was married eight times; his wives included Ava Gardner and Lana Turner. Like Goodman, he was Jewish (so was Helen Forrest), and like Goodman, he was one of the first bandleaders to integrate his group, hiring Billie Holiday as a vocalist (she didn’t last long when the band toured the South).

If you want to hear Shaw at his best, listen to to “Frenesi” (like “All the Things You Are”, it has a great walking bass).

Wikipedia says this about the song above:

The chorus has become a favorite with many jazz musicians. The chorus is a 36-measure AA2BA3 form with two twists on the usual 32-bar AABA song-form: A2 transposes the initial A section down a fourth, while the final A3 section adds an extra four bars.

And when I heard Shaw and Forrest, I remembered that the same song was recorded, in several takes, by the immortal Charlie Parker. Here’s a 1945 recording with Dizzy Gillespie. It’s one of the first Parker songs I heard, and instantly fell in love with his music.

Caturday felid trifecta: Cat breeds that can’t be rehomed; cat taste testers; Pasadena’s CatCon; and lagniappe

October 17, 2026 • 11:00 am

We have three items today. The first, from AnimalsAroundTheGlobe, describes 19 cat breeds that, so the author claims, bond so much with their staff that they can’t subequently find new staff. Click to read:

An excerpt:

Most people think cats are aloof, coolly indifferent little roommates who “don’t really care who feeds them.” That myth falls apart completely with the breeds on this list. These cats don’t just prefer a favorite human – they fuse to one person so deeply that separation can look and feel like real grief, not simple adjustment.

Some of these cats will refuse food from anyone else. Some will pace by the door for hours, waiting for a specific set of footsteps. And at least one breed on this list has rescue workers describing them as “confused ex-partners” instead of surrendered pets. Keep scrolling, because the higher this list climbs, the harder these bonds are to break – and the final entry might change how you think about “just a cat” for good.

Here are two, and I’ll list the rest:

The Chartreux gets marketed as a “smiling, easygoing” French cat, but long-time fanciers will quietly warn you: once a Chartreux bonds, they are emotionally all-in. These cats rarely meow, yet they communicate volumes through eye contact, body language, and sheer physical closeness. They’re the type to park themselves on your laptop, not to be annoying, but to stay physically connected to you at all times.

Tonkinese cats sit genetically between Siamese and Burmese, and emotionally, they often feel like both breeds turned up to eleven. They’re social, extroverted, and crave near-constant interaction, but they usually choose one person as their emotional anchor and orbit them obsessively. That person gets the warmest greetings, the loudest purrs, and the most insistent lap invasions.

Tonks don’t do well in quiet, lonely homes. They want noise, activity, and – critically – their chosen human within easy reach. When separated, many turn vocal or destructive, not out of spite but sheer frustration. Rehoming a deeply bonded Tonkinese can feel like uprooting a tree with your bare hands; some never trust quite as fully again.

The others include Russian Blue, Korat, Burmese, Siamese, Ragdoll, Birman, Scottish Fold, Singapura, Oriental Shorthair, Turkish Van, Sphynx, Devon Rex, Cornish Rex, Abyssynian,  Maine Coon, Norwegian Forest Cat, and American Burmese.  Now you know some of these can be rehomed, but yes, I’ve heard that some of these breeds are “clingy.” If you have relevant experience with any, weigh in below.  One more excerpt:

The Bottom Line:

When people say “cats are independent,” they’re usually talking about the wrong cats – or no cats at all. The breeds on this list don’t just tolerate human company; they build an entire emotional universe around one specific person and defend that connection with startling intensity.

That devotion is what makes them magical in the right home and genuinely difficult to rehome once the bond is set. “Someone else will adopt them” isn’t a neutral fallback with these cats – for some, losing their one person is a real psychological wound, not a minor inconvenience.

A cat has absolute emotional honesty: human beings, for one reason or another, may hide their feelings, but a cat does not.

Ernest Hemingway

If you change jobs often, move constantly, or treat pets as temporary houseguests, several of these breeds simply aren’t a fair match for your life. But if you’re ready for a ride-or-die relationship with fur, claws, and occasionally inconvenient devotion, these one-person cats offer a level of loyalty most dog owners insist doesn’t exist outside their own species. Which breed on this list do you think is the most impossible to rehome – and would you sign up for that kind of love anyway?

*********************

This NYT article is really a 4-minute podcast segment about how cat food companies (and yes, there’s some about d*g food) tweak their products to deal with finicky cats whose preferences change over time.

And here’s a recent NYT article how animal food companies use captive moggies (and d*ggies) to decide what the market wants. Click to read if you subscribe:

An excerpt:

Imagine dozens of cats napping or milling around a space that looks a lot like a pet day care center.

Every day at 4 p.m., dinner is served. The cats step into cubbyholes, each with two trays of kibble atop scales. The cats choose which food they like better, and the scales measure how much they consume. Nutritionists at a Royal Canin pet center in southern France are watching: Which kibble do the animals prefer? How enthusiastically do they chow down? A team uses the data to adjust recipes and devise new ones.

Pet food makers like Royal Canin, owned by the global consumer conglomerate Mars, are pouring money into research to understand the palates of cats and dogs — and to cater to people who see their pets as family members. Even as the war in Iran has spurred inflation and wage growth has not kept up, the pet food market has kept growing.

And as pandemic pets, adopted in droves in 2020, enter middle age, pet food makers are zeroing in on foods aimed at aiding aching joints, strengthening tired muscles and protecting cognitive function.

“Aging is one of the biggest opportunities,” said Cécile Coutens, president of Royal Canin. The company’s senior cat food line includes extra-soft mousse for cats ages 11 and up and easy-to-eat kibble for cats 15 and up. Many companies sell supplements for cats with dementia and to support healthy brain aging.

. . . More than $17 billion was spent on cat food in the United States over the last year, up 14 percent from the same period two years ago, according to NielsenIQ, a consumer research firm. (Dog food sales were roughly even.) In contrast to previous generations, when parents took in pets at the request of their children, people today often have pets before they have children, if they have children, Ms. Coutens said.

Companies are investing in premium pet food lines that cater to wealthier people, as the K-shaped economy — shorthand for the widening gap between the rich and poor — persists.

While in some ways cats are lower maintenance than dogs, cats tend to require some human ingenuity when it comes to food.

. . . Like Nestlé, which has two centers where researchers study cat and dog behavior, Royal Canin has an extensive research program dedicated to dogs and cats. At Royal Canin’s pet center in Aimargues, only the most discerning eaters of the 377 dogs and cats that live on campus participate in taste tests. The company’s other pet center is in Ohio. As part of training, kittens are offered food of different textures and flavors to develop their senses. At 7 months, they are taught to eat from designated feeders.

. . .Taste is a big focus. Scott McGrane, a feline expert at Mars’s Waltham Petcare Science Institute in England, said his team was especially interested in understanding the senses and tastes of cats, including senior cats. Why didn’t they have a preference for sweet foods? Why do they love tuna so much? He said researchers determined that cats had the umami taste receptor, which enables them to taste and detect umami compounds. Tuna has a unique combination of compounds that is akin to “super umami” for cats, he said.

As cats age, some of their taste buds fade, but they retain their perception of bitterness, causing certain foods to become less appealing, Ms. Miret-Catalan said. Her team designs food for senior cats that masks bitterness and enhances attractive aromas to keep cats interested in their food as they age, she said.

Here’s an independent cat person discussing the Royal Canin cat food brand, which offer over 100 different type of cat foods (!), including foods for specific breeds, lifestyles, age, and so on. The review isn’t that glowing, criticizing the dry food for encouraging urinary problems. (It’s important to get your cat to drink.). She also says that for wet food, less expensive food may have a similarly balanced diet. A cat expert I talked to says that Royal Canin Food is okay, and so is Science Diet, and you may want to get your cat a mixture of wet and dry food, along with some NO SALT chicken broth to help them hydrate.  The Expert also said that you should take your cat to the vet once a year for a checkup, and get a blood panel to detect any problems (senior cats, over 6 or 7 years old, require additional blood tests).  Yes, it costs more, but cats are members of the family!

********************

Finally, a reader informed me that Pasadena, California has an annual Cat Convention that’s described in the article below (click to read for free):

At the Pasadena Convention Center on Saturday, a woman with bright green hair and enormous furry ears posed beside a man wearing matching ears and a mechanical-looking face mask. Nearby, a mannequin modeled a burgundy velvet robe embroidered with the words “Cat Lady.” Somewhere else, someone was in a booth for a video explaining how to pet a cat.

Welcome to CatCon 2026, where the cats are celebrities, the humans are devoted fans and nobody thinks twice about wearing whiskers in public.

Saturday’s festivities were sold out, according to floor manager Andru Cantu, who surveyed the bustling convention halls with satisfaction.

“We stopped selling tickets because we were sold out for Saturday,” he said. “We’ve had a lot of really good vendors giving away a lot of really cool treats and samples.”

And what a selection.

There were cat-themed stickers, plush toys, handmade blankets, elaborate costumes and enough feline merchandise to furnish a reasonably eccentric household. The Temptations booth featured a giant yellow “Cat Bodega,” while another vendor offered something called Rad Cat, complete with a retro beach-van illustration.

At “How to Pet Your Cat,” suggesting that even the most experienced cat owners might have something left to learn.

Presiding over the festivities was Stephen Ray Morris, CatCon’s emcee, a veteran convention moderator and former host of a cat-themed podcast called “The Pur Cast.”

For Morris, CatCon offers something beyond shopping and celebrity sightings. It provides a gathering place for people whose pets have no time for such silliness.

“Dog people [have] the dog park, whereas cat people have CatCon,” he explained.

Cantu suggested that the appeal goes even deeper.

“I think it helps the people who feel a little bit less included to feel included with fellow cat people,” he said.

Indeed, among the colorful costumes, elaborate displays and tables overflowing with feline paraphernalia, the convention seemed less like a trade show than an enormous gathering of people who understood one another perfectly.

After all, loving a creature that routinely ignores you requires a certain shared understanding.

And at CatCon, there was plenty of that to go around. Meow.

A half-hour video documenting CatCon, which appears to be one of the biggest cat shows/conventions in the U.S.:

Here’s a news video documenting one feature of this year’s convention: hunky beefcake Aussie firefighters who love cats:

********************

Lagniappe: Two items today.  First, cats who make weird meows, including one who grunts like a pig and another who sounds like a typewriter:

And The Kiffness returns with a new song, “Hey Luga Luga”:

h/t: Robert, Divy