A field-trip course in England on Darwin and evolution

August 9, 2018 • 9:30 am

Every year my friend Andrew Berry, a lecturer and student advisor at Harvard, teaches a summer course at Oxford for Harvard undergrads. Its theme is Darwin and evolution, and the best part is that since the course takes place in DarwinLand, he can take the students to various historical sites and show them the science and history behind the Great Idea. I went to Down House, Darwin’s adult home, with Andrew’s course one year, and we were given a tour by none other than Janet Browne, historian of science and author of the wonderful two-volume biography of Darwin (see here and here) that I consider the best account of his life and work. Janet still takes the students to Darwin’s home, and you can see her in the penultimate photo.

Every year Andrew puts up a photo website of that summer’s course for the delectation of the students, and I thought I’d share some of them with you so you could see what the course covers. Go here to see all of the pictures. Andrew has kindly furnished captions for them giving the historical background, and his descriptions are indented. You can enlarge all the photos by clicking on them (twice if you want to eliminate the text).

The program runs for 6 weeks in Queen’s College, Oxford. It is a mix of history of science (the development of evolutionary thinking) and of science (current thinking in evolution).  This photo comes from a previous year during a more typical English summer.  The current heatwave (yes, in England) has scorched the college lawns.
Most of the students (there are 17 in this year’s class) spend the two weeks prior to the program in London, interning at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, on a history of science project dedicated to creating an online archive of the writings of Joseph Dalton Hooker, Victorian botanist, director of Kew, and Darwin confidante.  Pictured is Kew’s extraordinary Palm House (1848), commissioned by Hooker’s father, the previous director, and designed by Decimus Burton.
Hooker traveled on James Clark Ross’s Erebus & Terror expedition to Antartica (1839-43) where his skills as a botanical illustrated were challenged by the local fauna.
Hooker undertook another major expedition, to the E Himalaya (1847-51).  Here is a sample of his exquisite pen-and-water color sketches of the landscape.  Among these is numbered the first known view by a European of Mt. Everest.  http://blogs.nature.com/news/2011/02/first_sketch_of_everest_credit.html
Hooker’s ticket, as pall bearer, to Darwin’s funeral, 1882.
Cambridge.  Darwin was a student here (after dropping out of his medical studies at Edinburgh University), and came back here after returning from the Beagle voyage so that he could start processing the specimens he had brought back with him.
Darwin’s undergraduate room in Christ’s College, Cambridge.  This is where he lived when he was the same age as my students.
In the archives of Christ’s College is a wealth of Darwin-related material, including illustrated letters celebrating his undergraduate beetle-hunting excitements.
Christ’s College boasts a statue of the young Charles Darwin (an attempt to re-create Darwin as he was when he was at Christ’s).  He is, as such, inevitably a selfie target.
Behind the scenes in the Cambridge Zoology Museum: bird of paradise specimens collected by Alfred Russel Wallace in the course of his Malay Archipelago journey
The commonplace book of Erasmus Darwin, physician, inventor, poet, evolutionist, and grandfather of Charles Darwin.  Erasmus gave us the best ever synopsis of evolution (from his Temple of Nature, 1803):
Organic life beneath the shoreless waves
Was born and nurs’d in ocean’s pearly caves;
First forms minute, unseen by spheric glass,
Move on the mud, or pierce the watery mass;
These, as successive generations bloom,
New powers acquire and larger limbs assume;
Whence countless groups of vegetation spring,
And breathing realms of fin and feet and wing.
Erasmus Darwin lived in Lichfield’s cathedral “close” (ie the community associated with the great church).  He had to be careful in the use of his evolutionary motto, E Conchis Omnia (from shells, everything), for fear of offending his ecclesiastical neighbors
Linnean Society, London, with archivist Isabelle Charmantier.  It was at a meeting here, on 1 July 1858, that the theory of evolution by natural selection was unveiled, though neither of the paper’s authors, Darwin and Wallace, was present.
The Linnean Society possesses the papers and collections of Linneaus himself, the Swedish father of taxonomy.  Here are some of his early notes as he explores ways to categorize and organize nature.
1735: the first edition of Linneaus’s great work, Systema Naturae.  Here he has already grouped humans with primates (“Simia”), though he mistakenly includes sloths (Bradypus) in the group as well.
Revising life.  In later editions of Systema Naturae, Linnaeus had blank pages bound between each printed page and used these to make revisions for subsequent editions.  In his tiny, cramped hand-writing, then we are seeing Linnaeus in the process of revising the organization of living things.
Linnaeus’s specimens.  By definition, most of Linnaeus’s specimens are type specimens — ie the key specimen from which a species was originally described.
Linnaeus’s Lapland expedition note book.  Linnaeus’s reputation was established by his journey into the northern wilds of Scandinavia.  His field note book contains of wealth of biological, geographical and anthropological observation.  His drawing skills, however, left something to be desired.  This is a charming illustration of the preferred local way of carrying canoes.
The room in which Darwin was born, 12 Feb 1809.
Shrewsbury, where Darwin was born and grew up.  The family house, The Mount, built by his father Robert Darwin on a small rise overlooking the town, is now a district tax office, but they generously allow pre-arranged visits by small groups.
(Old) Shrewsbury School.  Darwin attended the local private high school (as a boarder even though the school was less than a mile from his home).  The school has since moved out of the centre of town, and the Darwin’s school building is today the town library.  Darwin’s retrospective assessment of his experience there was not especially positive: “Nothing could have been worse for the development of my mind than Dr. Butler’s school, as it was strictly classical, nothing else being taught, except a little ancient geography and history. The school as a means of education to me was simply a blank.”

Update: the next picture is a close-up of the statue taken by reader Al Lee and just sent along:

In the Shrewsbury School library: Presentation copy of the Origin of Species given to Darwin’s prominent opponent, Richard Owen.  Note that it is dated prior to the publication of the book (24 Nov 1859).
In Darwin’s geological footsteps.  After finishing his undergraduate degree at Cambridge, Darwin traveled to N. Wales with Adam Sedgwick, his geology professor.  Sedgwick was trying to make sense of the sequence of rocks that would later become formalized as the geological column.  In particular he was interested in finding Old Red Sandstone (from the Devonian) on his travels.  This however proved elusive. Darwin visited Cwm Idwal in Snowdonia (ie the mountainous area in the NW of Wales) twice.  First, in 1831, as part of his Sedgwick expedition.  He attempted to interpret the landscape but was defeated by the region’s complexity and his own lack of experience.  He came back after the voyage of the Beagle  when he had read Louis Agassiz’s theory of Ice Ages.  He recognized that the best place he could go to to see for himself whether or not these new fangled ideas were sound was Cwm Idwal.  He was convinced: “a house burnt down by fire does not tell its story more plainly than did this valley.”
Learning to read the landscape with our guide, Michael Roberts, geologist, historian, and vicar.
Darwin’s Boulders” beside the lake in Cwm Idwal:
Hiking Y Garn, the mountain overlooking Cwm Idwal.
Castel Dinas Bran, above Llangollen.  Another site visited by Darwin and Sedgwick in pursuit of recognizably Devonian deposits.  The hill is crowned with the picturesque ruins of a 13th century Welsh fort.
Fossil hunting.
Oxford University Natural History Museum, June 1860: site of the famous spat between T  H Huxley and Samuel Wilberforce, Bishop of Oxford.  The exchange is probably somewhat apocryphal, but it has entered popular consciousness as a canonical science vs. religion moment.  As recounted by historian Frank Sulloway, “Following a lengthy, pro-Darwinian paper, Samuel Wilberforce, the slickly eloquent bishop of Oxford, began a half-hour-long attack on Darwinian theory. With glib lines like “Is it credible that a turnip strives to become a man?,” Wilberforce’s speech met with peals of sympathetic laughter, and his rhetoric hit home. Finally he turned to Huxley, who was seated near him on the speaker’s platform, and asked him whether it was on his grandfather’s or grandmother’s side that he claimed descent from an ape.”  Huxley’s supposed response: “[Asked] if I would rather have a miserable ape for a grandfather or a man highly endowed by nature and possessed of great means and influence, and yet who employs those faculties for the mere purpose of introducing ridicule into a grave scientific discussion — I unhesitatingly affirm my preference for the ape.”
Natural History Museum, London, archive.  A drawing by A R Wallace of an Amazonian fish.  That this picture still exists is remarkable.  This was part of the set of materials — specimens, notes, drawings, living animals — that Wallace had with him as he headed back to the UK after four years in the Amazon.  His ship caught fire in the middle of the Atlantic, and Wallace and the crew had to abandon ship precipitously.  Wallace had time to grab one small case of materials from his desk, and this drawing was in it.  It was ten days before Wallace and the crew were rescued.
Darwin (statue) and Wallace (portrait): side by side (OK, with a big gap between them) at the Natural History Museum.
[Photo from previous year, as we have yet to go to Down House this year].  Down House, Kent, where Darwin lived for more than half of his life and where he penned the Origin of Species, the Descent of Man, and more.
[Photo from previous year, as we have yet to go to Down House this year].  Darwin’s “thinking path”, the Sand Walk, where he would stroll and ponder.  I live in hope that my students will have correspondingly significant insights as they walk along the path, but it’s yet to happen. Here they are accompanied by Janet Browne, Darwin scholar and biographer.
Finally, Andrew sent me this photo (taken some years ago when I was a lot pudgier!), also at Down House:
Isn’t that a lovely course? I’d love to take the whole thing, but time prohibits that. Many thanks to Andrew for the photos and captions. I suspect this is the inspiration for the “Jumping at Down House” photo above.

Readers’ wildlife photos

August 9, 2018 • 8:00 am

In response to my call for photos, reader Joe Dickinson found some six-year-old shots from a trip to Africa. His notes are indented:

Responding to recent requests for more wildlife submissions, I’ve gone to my archives and pulled up photos from my first Africa trip.  Dating from April, 2012, these are from Zimbabwe, Botswana and Zambia in south central Africa.  This the first of perhaps 6 or 8 sets I’ll put together over the next several days.

I’ll begin with some scenery at spectacular Victoria Falls, featuring wonderful rainbows in the all-enveloping “mist” (actually more like a downpour that killed a camera, fortunately just my backup ).

Here is an up close and personal look at a segment of rainbow.  Have you ever noticed that the sky looks brighter inside a rainbow than outside?  Here you can see streaks produced by falling drops on the concave side but not on the convex side.  And streaks that traverse the bow change color as they do so.

Here is a plains zebra (Equus quagga) nursing a fairly large foal.

We had a ride on an African elephant (Loxodonta africana) in a private game park.  The elephants were free range within the reserve but came when summoned by a bell, presumably because they got treats.

There was an opportunity for meet and greet after the ride.  That’s my wife again and you can see from her name tag that this was another group tour with UC Berkeley (Cal) alumni.

We also had a boat ride (the first of many) on the Zambezi River upstream from the falls.  There were many hippos (Hippopotamus amphibius).

We stayed at a lodge that overlooked the above mentioned game reserve, set on a terrace about eight feet above a nice meadow that was frequented by an assortment of wildlife.  Here is a young elephant that came right up to the terrace wall as we were sitting on our porch with cocktails.

I think this vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus) is perched on the roof of one of the Toyota safari vehicles in which we took twice daily game drives.

Banded mongooses (Mungus mungo) were common on the grounds of pretty much every lodge we stayed at.

 

Thursday: Hili dialogue (and Leon monologue)

August 9, 2018 • 7:00 am

It’s Thursday, August 9, 2018, all my ducks—both of them—are in a row, and I just got a new shipment of mealworms. All is well with the world—for the nonce. It’s National Rice Pudding Day, too—one of my favorite desserts. Sadly, the best version in the world, at L’Ami Jean in Paris, has declined precipitously, and now I don’t know where to get it. It’s also National Book Lovers Day, which I think covers most of us (e-books not included!).

Today’s Google Doodle celebrates the birthday in 1908 of Mary G. Ross (she lived 100 years), the first known Native American female engineer and a designer for Lockheed, specializing in interplanetary space travel:

As you know, yesterday was International Cat Day, which I wrote about at the time. But it was all in vain in light of this tweet (from Grania):

On August 9, 1173, the Leaning Tower of Pisa (formally known as the “campanile [bell tower] of the Cathedral of Pisa” started being built. It wasn’t done for two centuries, and the tilt began in the same century.  It’s now been stabilized and will last for at least 200 years. Get there before it topples! On this day in 1854, Henry David Thoreau published his famous book Walden. On August 9, 1930, in the cartoon Dizzy Dishes, the character Betty Boop first appeared. Here’s that cartoon, which I put up every year. It’s freaky! Cartoons in those days were dark and scary, not like the feel-good pablum of today.  Boop makes her appearance at 2:30, but be sure to see the dancing cats at the beginning and the dancing headless chicken at 3:56.

On August 9, 1936, Jesse Owens, a black man, won his fourth gold medal at the Summer Olympics in Berlin. This greatly angered Hitler, who thought that Aryans should win.  And on this day in 1945, the atomic bomb “Fat Man” was dropped on Nagasaki, killing 35,000 people instantly.  On this day in 1969, the Manson Family committed the Tate Murders, which were formally on August 8 and 9 since they continued over midnight. On August 9, 1974, Richard Nixon resigned the Presidency at noon, becoming the first American President to resign from office. I remember how overjoyed many of us were. But of course Gerald Ford (not a crook) took his place and pardoned Nixon.  Finally, on this day four years ago, 18 year old Michael Brown, a black man, was shot by a policeman in Ferguson, Missouri, leading to protests and riots.

Notables born on August 9 include Izaak Walton (1593), John Dryden (1631), Jean Piaget (1896), Philip Larkin (1922), Bob Cousy (1928, still alive at 90), Melanie Griffith (1957) and Anna Kendrick (1985). Here’s a clip of Kendrick doing her famous “When I’m Gone” cups song and routine in the 2012 movie “Pitch Perfect” (song starts at 1:24):

Even more impressive is her spontaneous performance on Letterman (starts at 1:00):

Notables who died on this day were few, including only Chaim Soutine (1943) and Jerry Garcia (1995). Here’s a lovely Soutine from Chicago’s Art Institute: Landscape at Cagnes (1923):

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili makes a literary joke. As Malgorzata explains, “You may not remember, but Winnie the Pooh always had eleven o’clock on his watch. This is just a variation on the Winnie the Pooh theme.”

Cyrus: Do you think it’s eleven o’clock already?
Hili: It depends on how you look at it.
In Polish:
Cyrus: Czy sądzisz, że jest już jedenasta?
Hili: To zależy jak na to patrzeć.

Leon is here, too, and makes a funny:

Leon: Do you want a second cat? Here you are – I’ve cloned myself.

From reader Gethyn, the old tale of a very brave and protective cat:

Tweets from Grania. The article in Quillette to which Pinker refers was also discussed on this site, but read the Quillette piece by the much maligned Heather MacDonald:

Another tweet by Pinker, this time reporting a little known case of progress:

From the wonderful Shappi Khorsandi (former President of the British Humanists), reporting, with some humor, that she’s alone. . .

Noooo! Tell us it ain’t so, Italy!

I’m sure I’ve posted this before, but you can’t see this baby kangaroo video too many times:

Terry Gilliam has a new film! Choose the poster for “Don Quixote” and tweet it to Gilliam:

I love that old Cardinal too! The article from Audubon is here.

Nichols has a point here. . .

Monkeys in tanks! Monkeys in tanks!

https://twitter.com/YouHadOneJ0B/status/1026898268414992384

Via Matthew. I just in fact went through the same dilemma King had, and the correct answer is “lay”:

And a cartoon from Merilee:

 

Local red-tailed hawk catches a rat in Manhattan Park

August 8, 2018 • 3:00 pm

This video, taken in Tompkins Square Park in the East Village of New York City on September 9, 2014, was sent by reader Tom, who notes: “How grand to see these large raptors doing so well seemingly inured to the sirens and other distractions of NYC.”  Indeed.

The YouTube notes are these:

This is Christo, a wild adult red-tailed hawk (in molting stage). He lives in Tompkins Square Park where there is a lot of food: rats, pigeons, squirrels, mice and small birds.

Christo prefers rats and this video shows him as he hunts for one. The squirrels in the park are large, strong and fierce. They can defend themselves and often harass the hawks. Christo will go for small squirrels, but tends to avoid the larger ones, as shown in this video.

For those who have complained about the length, I have presented the video here in its entirety as it shows the hawk’s complete hunting task. I was sitting on a bench when he landed on the fence a few seconds before the video starts. I stood some distance away to give him room to do his thing. We are fortunate and thrilled to have a wild hawk right here in our urban park. A note about the squirrels – they are all gray squirrels, which come in different colors: gray, black, brown, orange and blonde. They are all the same species showing different fur color just as people have different hair color.

Christo in action:

It’s International Cat Day!

August 8, 2018 • 1:30 pm

Yes, August 8 is International Cat Day, except in parts of Europe and Russia, where it’s celebrated in March and February, respectively. You can see a bunch of cat-related tweets at the two hashtag sites, #internationalcatday and #InternationalCatDay on Twitter. The BBC has a short announcement with a video and a poll, and the cats are cleaning up at the poll (click on screenshot):

Bustle has some Instagram captions with puns, which aren’t all that funny, so it’s better to look at a few tweets. I’ve chosen a few for you:

An oldie but a goodie:

Taylor Swift’s cats are in on it:

and one more geology/cat tweet:

Be sure to give your moggie extra fusses and treats today, mindful of this quote from Terry Pratchett (via reader Paul):

h/t: Grania, Dom

 

Democratic socialism: sounds good, but is way too expensive, and not the future of the Democratic party

August 8, 2018 • 12:30 pm

Bernie Sanders and now the upcoming Democratic candidate Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, an American-born of Hispanic extraction who may well sit in Congress this fall, have gotten a lot of airplay espousing “democratic socialism”, which proposes an expansion of social programs funded by the government. While I’m in favor of some of these in principle, nobody really asks—and candidates avoid talking about—how much they will cost. Well, Vox did a survey of what the programs Sanders and Ocasio-Cortez would cost the government (and that means the taxpayer); the sources used to estimate the costs were liberal organizations, so there’s not much anti-progressive bias in the numbers. Many of the numbers come from the Urban Institute, which is a leftist organization often in favor of government interventions.

Read the Vox story by clicking on the screenshot:

Here are the costs that Vox author Brian Riedl came up with:

Medicare for all (Sanders and Ocasio-Cortez): $32 trillion over the next decade

Social Security expansion (Sanders): $188 billion over the next decade

Paid family leave of 12 weeks for new parents (Sanders): $287 billion over the next decade

Free college for all (Sanders and Ocasio-Cortez): $807 billion over the next decade

Guaranteed jobs for all at $15/hr plus benefits (Ocasio-Cortez): $6.8 trillion over the next decade

New infrastructure (Senate Democrats): $1 trillion over the next decade

Payoff of all student loan debt (House Democrats): $1.4 trillion over the next decade.

As Vox notes, this is a huge sum (my emphasis):

Total cost: $42.5 trillion in new proposals over the next decade, on top of the $12.4 trillion baseline deficit.

To put this in perspective, Washington is currently projected to collect $44 trillion in revenues over the next decade. And the Republican tax cut, decried universally by Democrats as irresponsible (and by Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi as “Armageddon”) will cost less than $2 trillion over the decade.

The 30-year projected tab for these programs is even more staggering: new proposals costing $218 trillion, on top of an $84 trillion baseline deficit driven by Social Security, Medicare, and the resulting interest costs.

What would be the effects of such an unprecedented spending binge? Federal spending, which typically ranges between 18 and 22 percent of GDP, would immediately soar past 40 percent of GDP on its way to nearly 50 percent within three decades. Including state and local government spending would push the total cost of government to 60 percent of GDP by that point — exceeding the current spending level of every country in Europe.

. . . These numbers are not partisan. They come from the Congressional Budget Office, top liberal think tanks, and the lawmakers themselves. They are the left’s own figures. (And note that we included an absurdly low-cost estimate for the jobs guarantee.)

Vox notes that single-payer health insurance is not going to fix government health spending (e.g., Medicare), nor would the moving of money from private citizens (spent on their own healthcare) to government healthcare (via taxes); that has “serious economic and redistributive side effects.” And engineering the $26 trillion tax hike needed to cover this would be nearly impossible, as it would set the payroll tax at 29% (now 15.3%).

The rest of the Vox article tries to figure out how to pay for all this social engineering, and author Riedl concludes that there’s just no way to do it in an acceptable fashion. He concludes like this:

Mix and match these tax policies and it still represents an unfathomable and impossible tax burden. American taxes would be higher than most of Europe because its spending levels would also be higher. (Our health care system would still cost more, and Europe does not have an expensive government job guarantee.)

Taxing the rich is not enough. America would need to match, or even surpass, Europe’s enormous tax burden on the middle class. There is no evidence that American voters will accept this level of taxation.

Democratic socialists are disingenuously cagey about the exorbitant tax burden they require. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez recently offered a list of tax increases — such as a 28 percent corporate tax rate, a “Buffett tax” on millionaires, and carbon tax — that collectively add up to just $2 trillion over the decade, according to the CBO.

Ocasio-Cortez, only 28, is often touted as “the future of the Democratic Party,” but I haven’t been impressed by her. She’s young, for sure, and that may be why I don’t see her as ready for prime time, but she’s also a new face, a Hispanic woman, and a socialist, which appeals to Sanders fans (note: I voted for him in the Illinois primaries). She’s the social justice warrior that Democrats think, unwisely, is the person that can defeat the Democrats.

But she hasn’t seemed to grasp the difficulties with her proposals, and she doesn’t look especially thoughtful in interviews. RealClear Politics analyzed her statement that unemployment is low only because everyone has two jobs, and found that it, along with much of she said, was a big “pants on fire” whopper (note: I don’t think it’s necessarily a conscious lie). Here she is with that proposal, and a prediction that we are (and should) be marching toward socialism and against capitalism. Much as some socialistic programs appeal to me, there’s still a lot to be said for the retention of some capitalism in the private sector.  And let’s face it: America isn’t going to buy a completely socialistic society, and espousing it is political suicide.

Here’s her not terribly well thought out stand on Israel on Palestine, with several professions that she’s not an expert in geopolitics. Well, I agree with the two-state solution, but she needs a more eloquent response.

As I said, she’s young and I won’t hold this against her. But I do hold her adamant and unthinking socialism against her, and that’s exactly what makes her popular.

Like every Democrat, I am desperately looking for a viable Leftist to contest Trump (or, if he’s out, his Republican replacement) in 2020.  Ocasio-Cortez isn’t even close, though of course I’d rather have her in Congress than almost any Republican. But I don’t want the future of the Democratic Party to be ignorance and untenable forms of socialism.

 

Jesus ‘n’ Mo ‘n’ apophatic nonsense

August 8, 2018 • 9:30 am

Today’s Jesus and Mo strip, called “tell2,” is appropriately described as “a resurrection from 2009”. Take that, David Bentley Hart and Karen Armstrong! They may not say they’re apophatic, but their obscurantism means that they really are, for what they say about God is so flaccid and unspecific that they might as well be saying nothing.