Chait on the liberal vs. “progressive” Left

November 12, 2026 • 10:30 am

Over at the Atlantic (click on article below or find it archived here), staff writer Jonathan Chait, a self-described mainstream liberal, gives the rest of us mainstream liberals a boost with his latest article. It resemble Jesse Singal’s article that I mentioned yesterday by saying that woke policies—and by that I mean policies that are are designed to flaunt virtue but will be unworkable or un-passable as bills—is not going to help Democrats.  Chait cites data showing that moving towards a more centrist position generally helps candidates, and that the midterms gives evidence for that.

It’s way early to predict what’s going to happen in two years, but since the race for President is starting now, it’s not too early to suggest what Democrats might do, and if there’s evidence that “progressivism” (e.g., Democratic Socialism and the like) are harmful to candidates, then candidates should take that on board.

Chait also argues that the left-wing media, exemplified by the increasingly dubious and biased New York Times, has been promoting the opposite view—that Democrats’ moves towards extremes helps them get elected. This, he argues, is unsupported by evidence.

I’ll give a few quotes:

A few introductory remarks by Chait:

Bernie Sanders and his acolytes have spent the past decade insisting that Democrats would command national majorities if only they embraced his left-wing policies. After last week’s election, the movement claimed vindication. The results proved that “we can win over millions of Republicans and independents who are struggling economically if we focus on the issues that are important,” Sanders told Politico.

In reality, the results point in the opposite direction. Almost every Democratic Senate nominee gained a higher vote share in their state than Kamala Harris did two years earlier, but the five left-wing candidates backed by Sanders accounted for the four smallest swings in contested races. The one candidate who underperformed Harris, Troy Jackson in Maine, was a Sanders-backed progressive. By the same measure, moderate Democrats in the House also outperformed progressives.

Newcomers such as incoming Senators Josh Turek of Iowa and Annie Andrews of South Carolina came out against gender-affirming surgery for minors and allowing transgender female athletes to compete in girls’ sports—positions that did grave damage to Harris. Both of them, along with James Talarico in Texas and Adam Hamilton in Kansas, rejected Medicare for All. Ballot referenda in multiple states—banning the government from giving preferential treatment on the basis of race and other factors, rejecting a wealth tax—confirmed that the public’s rejection of the GOP did not entail a full embrace of the Democratic Party’s left wing.

The party’s most impressive victories, compared with the recent election outcomes in historically purple states, came from mainstream or moderate candidates: Senator Jon Ossoff of Georgia (who won by 18 points), Senator-Elect Roy Cooper of North Carolina (19.6), and Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro (21.5 points). Although every contest has unique circumstances, and no single result can be reduced to a simple test of ideology, the overall pattern is unmistakable.

Because the whole party blew the doors out, many of its left-wing candidates won anyway. But not all of them. In Maine, the moderate Representative Jared Golden retired in the face of a progressive primary challenger. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee—the dreaded party establishment—had hoped to retain the seat by nominating a mainstream Democrat. Instead, Matt Dunlap, a progressive supporter of Medicare for All backed by Sanders’s organization Our Revolution, won the nomination. The left-wing American Prospect, in an article headlined “The New Majority Makers,” praised Dunlap as “a working-class northern Mainer” who is “committed to economic populism.” Dunlap lost, turning what had been the reddest district held by a Democrat into the bluest district held by a Republican.

If the election was a test of whether Americans like Sanders’s message more or less than the standard Democratic message, the answer was clear: They like it less.

At this point in the article I asked myself, “Well, where are the data? All I see are cherry-picked anecdotes.” But then Chait proffers the data (or rather links to them), which I haven’t thoroughly checked:

The question of whether individual candidates are helped or harmed by moving toward the center has been studied extensively and has a firm answer.

The data measuring the effect of moderation on winning elections, somewhat like the data confirming anthropogenic global warming, can be noisy and messy but, in the general sweep of things, generally point in one direction: All things being equal, congressional candidates who advocate more ideologically extreme positions tend to do worse. As voters have polarized, penalties for extremism seem to have shrunk, but they haven’t disappeared. Newer models confirm that moderate candidates tend to overperform the partisan composition of their district, but extreme candidates underperform it.

Both parties have a contingent of vocal activists who deny that any such penalty for extremism exists. The arguments used by progressive activists roughly mirror those used by conservative activists: The voters in their hearts agree with our values, and the key to winning is to mobilize this hidden majority by ignoring the elitists in our party who, for their own selfish reasons, are intent on foisting wishy-washy centrists upon the electorate.

Now both references above use data at least fifteen years old, but (at least in the second paper) go in the direction Chait says.  He quotes progressives who maintain otherwise, but invariably they’re making the argument not that more extreme movement to the left confers more advantages than staying moderate, but that extremism carries less penalty than it used to. There’s still a penalty compared to moving in the other direction. Thus, so long as there’s any penalty, such moves are dangerous.  Now of course candidates shouldn’t espouse policies that they don’t believe, but these are politicians, and you simply can’t believe many of them when they suddenly change their public stands (as has AOC) to make themselves more electable. The only way we know what a candidate really believes is what he or she actually does once they get in power.

Chait chastises the media, especially the NYT, for trumpeting the benefits of extremism and “progressivism”:

rogressives have more or less succeeded in shaping news coverage of this debate. The morning after the election, Politico ran one story headlined “Progressive Victories Are Now Too Loud to Dismiss,” followed by another the next day, headlined: “Bernie Sanders Lost the Fight in 2016. A Decade Later, He Won the War.”

The New York Times followed up with an article covering the debate in studiously neutral terms: “For centrists, the results demonstrate that the best way to flip conservative strongholds where their party has long struggled is through embracing moderate candidates and positions that appeal to a broader array of voters. Progressives argue that the victories in Maine and Michigan show that left-wing populists can energize the party’s liberal base and win back some of the working-class voters who had flocked to President Trump.” A reader would not have guessed that the empirical debate is over how much of an advantage moderates have in winning elections, not which posture is more advantageous.

Another Times news story on the subject gives the left-wing interpretation even more credulous treatment. In the article, the arguments put forward by the left provide a revealing specimen of its inability to accept evidence that its ideas can hurt candidates who endorse them.

The story conveys a progressive complaint that “centrists said they would lose in the fall and cost the party control of Congress,” only to move the goalposts. The story does not cite a single example of a centrist having done this. In fact, before the election, moderate Democratic groups such as Third Way were projecting that the entire party would do well, that moderates would overperform baseline partisanship, and that progressive candidates would underperform. That is precisely what happened.

The article asserts that Abdul El-Sayed, the left-wing senator-elect in Michigan, “underperformed Jocelyn Benson, now the Democratic governor-elect in Michigan, by only a small margin.” Oddly, the article omits the gap between Benson’s margin and El-Sayed’s: 3.9 percentage points, which, in a normal election year in a state like Michigan, could easily make the difference between winning and losing.

Most amazing, the story excuses Jackson’s narrow victory by noting that he “was facing Senator Susan Collins, perhaps the most formidable Republican incumbent anywhere on the map.” Of course Collins is the most formidable Republican. The reason is that she has built a reputation as a moderate, the value of which is the entire issue of contention. Defeating a moderate like Susan Collins is hard is a bizarre way to dispute the notion that moderation confers a political advantage.

There is more, but you can read the story for free. All we can conclude at this point is that past data suggests the benefits for a Democrat of moving towards a moderate position outweighs the benefits of moving farther left. Sure, we can point to El-Sayed and Mamdani as winners who were “progressives” (though I’d hardly call antisemitism a “progressive” position), but if you’re throwing anecdotes around, Chait has plenty of counterexamples.

And we have a new anecdote-to-be: a DSA candidate challenging controversial Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania:

Less than a week after Democrats retook the Senate majority, a challenger has thrown his hat in the ring to oust one of the party’s most controversial members.

Ahmed Moor, a Palestinian American writer and businessperson, announced a bid to unseat Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) on Monday, marking the first challenge to Fetterman as questions swirl around his allegiance to the Democratic Party.

A Gaza-born Philadelphia resident and member of the Democratic Socialists of America, Moor put forth a progressive agenda as he kicked off his campaign for Senate.

“I’m running to end the war in Iran and to promote the dignity agenda: free healthcare, free childcare, and affordable housing,” Moor wrote on the social platform X. “I’m calling for accountability for genocide, for ICE and for corruption. And finally, for the protection of our civil liberties in America.”

Moor is running to the left of Fetterman, who has been more moderate since taking office, often publicly breaking with his party and drawing the ire of some Democrats. While he has said he won’t become a Republican, the Senator has warned he may leave the party if Democrats officially become anti-Israel. A poll in August showed he was more popular among Pennsylvania Republicans than Democrats.

. . .“A few years ago my birthplace was turned to rubble in a genocide funded by our tax dollars, with the support of politicians on both sides of the aisle who can’t find money for transit or removing asbestos from our schools,” Moor wrote on his website.

“It’s clear the United States funds wars based on corruption and lies and has turned its back on its own people. We must make sure this never happens again. That’s why I’m running for U.S. Senate,” he added.

But it gets worse. Noor has also said this:

In a 2009 article published by Electronic Intifada, he asserted that “‘Zionist Israel’ does not have the right to exist,” describing Zionism as racism and accusing Zionists of holding racist views.

He’s also made the case for a one-state solution to the Israel/Palestine question. Here’s one article, and here’s another. Everything we know about Noor is that he wants the state of Israel to disappear and advocates the phony “one-state solution” that will lead to the extirpation of both Israel and its Jews.  I know I digress here, but Fetterman is surely better than someone whose politics will promote terrorism, and I think Fetterman’s been unduly demonized just because he occasionally votes with Republicans.

Prognostications about 2028

November 10, 2026 • 11:00 am

I’m not a pundit, so I’m not going to predict which Democrat will get the Presidential nomination in 2028.  All I can predict is that the overwhelming vote for Democrats in the midterms raises the likelihood of a Democratic President in two years— a good thing. As for candidates, right now my favorite is Mayor Pete, and I’m partial to my governor, J. B. Pritzker, though their elections are unlikely given that Buttigieg is gay and Pritzker a Jew. (Sadly, I don’t think America will go for those identities, though I think being a woman is no longer a bar to being President.)

Oh, and anybody but AOC, who I’ve said repeatedly has no substantive record of accomplishment in anything but promoting herself on social media. But perhaps that’s what America—particularly young America—wants in a President. She’s also desperately hungry for status and a better position, like being a Senator or even the President, and so she’s figured out that she has to sound more moderate, which is a transparent ploy to get elected but not believable.

A friend of mine visited Congress last week to lobby Representatives, and went by AOC’s office. He sent photos and wrote this:

AOC’s politics are neither yours nor mine, but the public contributions to the entrance to her Cannon office underscore what a phenomenon she is.

Of course AOC’s office proffers a supply of empty stick-on notes and a pen so you can add your approbation to groundswell.

Don’t bother telling me why she’s a great candidate, for I look down on people who feel that way. . .

In today’s column, NYT writer Frank Bruni sizes up the candidates, and though he doesn’t pick a winner, he describes their pros and cons. Click below to read, or find the article archived here.

Excerpts from his take are indented, my own kneejerk reactions flush left:

Kamala Harris: Will she even throw her hat into the ring? Many party insiders say no. But due in significant part to her superior name recognition, she placed first in many early polls of Democratic voters. And she’d be the only possible nominee with the experience of playing that grueling part before.

I think many Democratic leaders and voters will regard her as a painful look backward — to the deceptions about President Biden’s fitness and the clumsy rush to replace him — when they’d prefer to look forward. But another question hovers over her. Will Democrats want to nominate a woman again?

She lost once and cannot win again. In my view she lacks both eloquence and neurons, and has the potential to become way too progressive.

Gavin Newsom: Most of the smartest political analysts I know say that Newsom’s biggest problem is heavily regulated, highly taxed, crushingly expensive California, which he has governed for the past eight years. It’s the antithesis of affordability — an issue that powered Democrats’ midterm triumphs — and his rivals would have a field day with that.

But he contradicts the spirit of the midterms in an additional way. All around the country, voters seemed to be rebuking the nastiness, pettiness and mockery that President Trump modeled and that so many of his aides and acolytes imitated. . .

. . . Newsom has at times asserted himself as the dauntless Democrat who can summon the snark and spite to match the meanest Republicans insult for insult and meme for meme. But might Democratic voters prefer a leader who can credibly pledge to make America civil again?

The word “California” will rule him out for many Americans, and, like AOC, he changes his positions to become electable. The more candidates do that, the less I like them, though of course many Dems think that candidates should say exactly what would get them in office, not what they believe.

Pete Buttigieg: No Democrat is a nimbler thinker or more fluent communicator, and those attributes, along with the youthful optimism about America that he often radiates, have won him legions of devoted admirers. In 2020, he came from nowhere to win the Democratic caucuses in Iowa and to place a close second to Bernie Sanders in the New Hampshire Democratic primary.

But he never caught fire with Black voters, who are an essential Democratic constituency — the midterms demonstrated that as well — and who will be hugely important in 2028, when the new primary calendar puts the first contest in South Carolina, where Black voters resurrected Joe Biden’s beleaguered candidacy in 2020.

That is a pity.  I’m not convinced, though, that Mayor Pete couldn’t energize blacks (and Hispanics).

Ocasio-Cortez: No potential 2028 candidate has been more fascinating to watch over the past year. She worked hard to promote progressive candidates, putting particular muscle behind the successful Senate bid of Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, and collected a whole bunch of chits. But she simultaneously made all sorts of statements and gestures to moderate her image and send a signal to centrists that her views aren’t doctrinaire and her tent is big. She’s savvy beyond her years.

That may be savvy, but it’s also dissimulation.  More:

But, ah, those years. Aren’t that many of them. [AOC] is 37 now and would be 39 when the next president is inaugurated. Too young for voters’ comfort? Or an emphatic repudiation of the Democratic gerontocracy and a powerful symbol of generational change — which many midterm results also seemed to endorse? The measures of seasoning or freshness that voters prefer could boost or diminish any bids by members of the younger crowd: Senator Jon Ossoff of Georgia, 39; Buttigieg, 44; Beshear and Gov. Wes Moore of Maryland, both 48. Ditto for possible contenders who are over 60, including Gov. JB Pritzker of Illinois, 61; Harris, 62; Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona, 62; and Rahm Emanuel, 66.

It’s interesting to imagine Pritzker and Ocasio-Cortez squaring off. They would be separated not only by a nearly 25-year age difference but by also by economic station. She was working as a waitress and bartender just before she was first elected to Congress in 2018; he’s an heir to the Hyatt hotel empire who’s worth more than a billion dollars. How much will such attributes matter at what seems to be a time of rising economic populism?

I could give a rat’s patootie who rich candidates are, especially if being poor means you’re more “progressive.” And age and repeated election, unless you have dementia, usually denotes wisdom and experience. Pritzker has made his way through the thicket of Illinois politics and actually done stuff, while AOC has been pushing herself forward on social media. None of the bills of which she was the primary sponsor have passed or made it to a vote, though she’s been one of several secondary sponsors of bills that have become law. Her view on Israel is abysmal, and would become more so were she elected.

Ossoff: As he focused on winning re-election to the Senate — which he just did, by an impressive 18-point margin — he proclaimed “zero interest” in a presidential campaign. Polymarket doesn’t believe him: As of Friday afternoon, it placed him atop the potential Democratic field, with a 27 percent chance of winning the party’s nomination. I promise you that he’s powerfully tempted to run.

And he emerged over the past year as one of the Trump administration’s most effective detractors. But the race for the Democratic presidential nomination won’t be about neutering Trump, now a lame duck quacking into the void.

Let’s keep our eye on Osoff. Unlike AOC, ten of the bills he’s introduced have become law, some of them with bipartisan support.

Ro Khanna. The 50-year-old House member from California has, like Emanuel, been more detailed than some of his peers about where he thinks the country should head and how it should address Americans’ economic frustrations. He, too, is a geyser of oratory and essays.

But something else about Khanna catches my eye and speaks to an important variable in any presidential election: Which Democrats can fold the agenda they put forward into a succinct and accessible narrative that stirs feelings as it kindles thoughts? Khanna seems acutely conscious of the need to do that, as he showed with his leading role in demanding the release of files related to Jeffrey Epstein. He cast the Epstein case as emblematic of rich, powerful elites doing as they pleased and evading accountability — and he turned that into a metaphor for many of government’s failings.

Khanna has been sole or primary sponsor of 13 bills enacted when he was in the House. His views on Israel are mixed: he is a “Zionist” in thinking that Israel has a right to exist, but he’s gone along with the dumb accusations of genocide by Israel. I wouldn’t hesitate to vote for him, though I favor others more.

Finally, Bruni has words of praise for Josh Shapiro, but you know Shapiro’s problem: he’s a member of the “tribe” and doesn’t demonize Israel. If that’s enough to keep him from the Presidency, then we are truly lost:

Josh Shapiro: The Pennsylvania governor, 53, should be formidable. He was just re-elected — by a staggering 22 points — in the nation’s most populous battleground state, which Trump won in 2024. He’s bright, measured, sensible.

But his obvious presidential ambitions are hostage to two forces perhaps more consequential than his virtues. As Democrats move on from the midterms, will the party’s progressives or moderates come to the fore? Shapiro has presented himself as a proud, practical-minded consensus builder who eschews extremes.

And how important will a candidate’s views of Israel be? In both political parties, there are voters more insistent than ever that America downgrade its alliance with Israel. But Shapiro, who has written and spoken extensively about the importance of his Jewish faith, takes a less censorious, more nuanced position. That might not be a big obstacle in the general election, but Democratic primaries are a different matter.

The point, however, is not to make recommendations, but simply to tender my own tentative views and ask readers to say who, at this point, they favor. Campaigning for 2028 will begin sooner than we think, and it’s good to air potential candidates for the Democrats, some of whom have emerged from the midterm elections.

Bill Maher on the midterms

November 7, 2026 • 10:00 am

Maher begins by analogizing the midterms to the World Series victory of the Milwaukee Brewers, a team with one of the smallest budgets in Major League Baseball.  They won, say Maher, because they “know how to deal,” trading away good players for even better players.  Maher says that the key to both Republican and Democratic success will be to make deals (Maher’s example is that he’d accept a border wall in trade for giving a pathway to citizenship for immigrants who came to the U.S. illegally but have contributed to America).

He adds “The way America has been governed in recent decades is exactly that [“the shove it up your ass” philosophy];  one party wins, the other gets drunk with power kowtows to their fringe, and shoves their ideological agenda up our asses when all we want is to be governed effectively.”

The solution: for both parties to “make deals”—to compromise. He names several deals that could be made to deal with immigration, guns, calls to pack the Supreme Court, environmental issues, trans rights, Ten Commandments in schools (a jocular deal, “I’ll give you five”), marijuana (“we get to smoke it; you get to tax it”), homelessness, and sending people to Mars (Maher doesn’t like it, but will agree if “Elon has to go first”). Well, it sounds good, but given the present political climate it doesn’t seem practical. Yet given Trump’s veto power, making bipartisan deals will be the only way for the people’s representatives to make laws.

The two guests you’ll see are journalist and author Ali Vitali, and along with author and podcaster Coleman Hughes, who’s clearly hit the big time. 

Vitali is clearly proud to be on the show. A post from her Instagram page:

Democrats crush GOP, take both houses of Congress and disputed governorships

November 4, 2026 • 6:00 am

Yesterday I vowed not to stay up to watch politics, but I did watch the news for an extra hour after dinner. At that time it was already clear that the GOP was going to be routed. But I had no idea how thoroughly the rout would be.  In a clear repudiation of to Trump and his policies, the Dems took the House, the Senate, all the “swing seats,”, and even the governorship of Texas. Here’s the headlines from the morning NYT (click to read). Remember that all the results aren’t yet in, but the Democratic hegemony of Congress is clear:

House elections, by district:

 

Senate results by state:

There will be plenty of pundits to chew over these results in the coming days, telling us “what we need to know” and giving us “ten lessons from the midterm elections”.

I am no pundit, am pretty pleased with the results save in Michigan, and am curious to see what will happen in the next two years.  Will Trump work with the new Congress, as he said, or will there be a string of vetoes?  Will Congress somehow pull us out of the Iran war? Can the Democrats start making good on their promise to curb inflation? What will happen with healthcare? Will this result empower the “progressives,” further dividing the Democrats?  Will this resounding victory put wind in the sails of the next Democratic Presidential candidate in two years? (The NYT has a list of rising Democratic “stars”.)

I have a busy day ahead, including a trip to Costco to get my new glasses and, really, I have little taste for giving my take, which is clearly inferior to that of people who really study politics.  Let us hope that Trump and the new Congress can work together and that the Democrats will begin to fix the issues that sank their opponents in this election.

Readers are invited and welcome to share their thoughts, their joy, their beefs, and their thoughts on the election.

Bret Stephens on El-Sayed

November 3, 2026 • 8:30 am

I was going to put this in my critique of Abdul El-Sayed yesterday, but forgot. Fortunately, Bret Stephens, in his latest NYT column, alludes to something like what I’m about to say:

This is what I forgot to add to my own post:

Imagine that a white American had some relatives killed by Islamic militants in Somalia (this has happened, albeit rarely, to both American civilians and military personnel).  Devastated, the American gets a gun, drives his truck into the The West Michigan Somali Cultural Religious Center in Grand Rapids, Michigan and opens fire on a group of children, wounding a security guard. Fortunately, nobody was killed, and the attacker takes his own life.  When asked about the attack, a white politician proffers an explanation: “Hurt people hurt people.”

Can you imagine how people would come down on that politician for heartlessness and obtuseness?

When Abdul El-Sayed said precisely that phrase after an attack on a Michigan synagogue and preschool this spring (apparently, some relatives of the would-be murderer were killed by the IDF in Lebanon), it was not just an explanation but an excuse.  El-Sayed later apologized for the statement, but I don’t believe his faux contrition. But he got away with it, even though it encapsulates his entire view of Jews and Israel.

But enough; Bret Stephens, a far better writer than I, draws the parallel in his latest NYT column, which you can read by clicking on the screenshot below. You can also find his piece archived here.

Excerpts (I hope you’ve seen Cenk’s pro-el-Sayed ad):

The stakes in the race were again brought home after Representative Haley Stevens, who had been El-Sayed’s opponent in the Democratic primary, endorsed Rogers after a falling-out with El-Sayed, largely over his refusal to condemn what may be the most nakedly antisemitic political ad in modern U.S. political history.

The ad, which came from an El-Sayed-friendly political action committee founded by Cenk Uygur, a left-wing media personality, features a couple shopping for groceries while discussing why they can no longer afford a $7 carton of eggs: The money has already been stripped from their wallets by the federal government so that it can be sent to Israel and spent on “killing Palestinians” while also “probably” funding Israel’s universal health care.

A voice-over then asks, “Why does Mike Rogers care so much about what Israelis want, and so little about what you want?”

What’s wrong with the ad? For starters, the price of a dozen eggs has fallen by about half since Trump returned to office; a price-conscious shopper in Michigan could pick up a dozen eggs at Walmart for under $2. And while prices for groceries have undoubtedly been affected by higher energy costs because of the war with Iran, for which Israel is partly responsible, they’ve also been affected by the war in Ukraine; droughts in Brazil, China and the Midwest; and Trump’s capricious tariffs. Is Israel to blame for all that, too?

The larger problem with the ad is that it unites three of the oldest antisemitic tropes in history. First: There’s a powerful Jew out there who’s picking the pockets of the less fortunate. Second, that Jew is doing so to slaughter the innocent. Third, he’s paying a non-Jewish intermediary (who, by implication, is either a dope or a stooge) to do his bidding. To suggest the ad is only about U.S. policy toward Israel would be like arguing that an ad denouncing foreign aid to African countries while featuring the worst stereotypes about people in those countries isn’t racist. It doesn’t pass the smell test.

That’s the ad, but what about El-Sayed’s reaction to it?  His failure to denounce it is one reason why Stevens endorsed Rogers. Bret Stephens says this:

It would have been morally right — and a political no-brainer — for El-Sayed to forthrightly and unequivocally denounce the ad. A similar dynamic played out in early 2008, when Barack Obama’s former pastor, the Rev. Jeremiah Wright Jr., turned out to have a record of incendiary rhetoric. Obama denounced the pastor’s statements, and, after Wright kept it up, broke off relations with the man. Doing so drew a firm and effective line under the controversy, underscoring Obama’s insistence that he was no radical.

Yet the most El-Sayed has said about the ad was that it “was not made by me,” that he didn’t agree with its content but that the controversy was “not worth my time.” That’s odd: It was El-Sayed himself who called Israel “an affordability issue” while adding “we should keep our money here instead of sending it there to drop bombs on people’s schools or their hospitals.” Nor has he been shy about denouncing Israel at nearly every opportunity he gets. The ad he now says he has nothing to do with merely expresses what he plainly believes.

It’s part of a broader pattern.

His initial response to the Temple Israel attack, where only a miracle spared the over 150 children and staff inside from death or injury, was that “hurt people hurt people.” It took him five months to offer a quasi apology. (“My comments may have been misconstrued.”) He campaigned alongside the antisemitic media personality Hasan Piker (who recently compared campaigning for El-Sayed in heavily Jewish West Bloomfield Township to campaigning for a Black candidate in a “Klan K.K.K. neighborhood”) and quietly distanced himself from him because he feared it was costing him votes, according to reporting by CNN. Tucker Carlson, the right’s most prominent normalizer of antisemitism, now features in one of El-Sayed’s campaign ads.

A question for Michigan voters, especially those who lean left: If the stigmatized minority here weren’t Jewish but, say, gay or Latino or Black, would you even consider a vote for any candidate abetting, or at least tolerating, the stigmatizing?

Remember that El-Sayed gained nothing with his “hurt people” statement, but he said it anyway. This is why I think it represents what he really believes, and why I distrust all his later apologies. El-Sayed doesn’t have much of a filter between his brain and his mouth.

Stephens finishes this way:

None of this will matter at all to voters who thrill to El-Sayed’s message. Nor will it matter enough to voters willing to put their misgivings about him aside because they feel that Rogers, for his part, has failed to call out the rhetorical excesses of Republicans, and that nothing is more important than sending Trump the sternest electoral rebuke they can. Yet come January, Trump will still be president, no matter how well Democrats do in the midterms.

The real issue for voters in Michigan is what moral price is worth paying for an additional seat in the Senate. There are, after all, other winnable Senate races in other states. And a vote to further strengthen the forces of antisemitism in American politics, under any party banner or political justification, is no vote for democracy, either.

This is a clear declaration that Stephens thinks El-Sayed an antisemite. I agree. But antisemitism and demonization of Israel are rapidly becoming hallmarks of not just “progressive” Democrats, but of mainstream Democrats as well. If party affiliation should always override principle, we are truly lost. And one principle should be that attacks on Jewish children, simply because they were Jewish, are evil and should at least be denounced.

What’s a Democrat to do?

November 2, 2026 • 8:45 am

As readers will know, I’ve been a lifelong Democrat, and though we don’t have to register by party in Illinois, I’ve always voted solidly Democratic, as I just did (it isn’t hard in Illinois). However, “liberal” Democrats like me, who are more towards the center than are “progressives” like AOC or “the squad”, are starting to face a dilemma, especially if they’re Jewish or sympathetic to Israel. (A hallmark of “progressive” Democrats is their demonization of Israel, sometimes flirting with anti-Semitism.)

I started to face this dilemma in the last Presidential election, which pitted Trump, who I see as an odious and unstable egomaniac, against Kamala Harris, a Democrat who I see as inexperienced, not overly bright, and a disser of Israel. I couldn’t vote for either of them, so I wrote in the Democrat Gretchen Whitmer (now I’d probably write in Democrat Pete Buttigieg).  I wasn’t worried that that would promote a Trump victory, because Illinois is a reliably Democratic state and my vote wouldn’t affect the outcome.  But were I in some other state, I’d have been a bit more hesitant to write in a Democrat rather than vote for Harris.

But were I voting in Michigan now, I would certainly not vote for Abdul el-Sayed, nor would I vote for Mike Rogers, even though Haley Stevens, el-Sayed’s opponent in the Democratic primary, who was defeated, has endorsed Rogers and said she’ll vote for him. Stevens withdrew her support for her fellow Democrat because he refused to condemn the odious ad (made by Cenk Uygur’s PAC) blaming Israel for the rise of grocery prices in America.  And El-Sayed has a history of anti-Israel actions and statements.

Now I’m not a one-issue voter, casting my ballot only for pro-Israel candidates, but up until recently Democrats have been pro-Israel candidates and were aligned with my values on most other issues.  But the party is moving leftwards towards “progressivism”, espousing policies that irk me—not just anti-Israel views, but open-border policies, defunding the police, emphasizing equity as opposed to equal opportunity, eliminating all private health insurance in favor of “Medicare for all” (I do favor healthcare for all, just not solely a government system), allowing trans-identified men to compete in women’s sports (and again I emphasize that this is one of the very few areas where I see women’s rights trumping trans rights), promoting drastic income distribution, like what Democratic Socialists favor, and so on.

On the other hand, I still differ—usually more seriously—with Republicans, who tend to be against abortion (I’m a full-on pro-choicer), against gun control (I favor strict regulation), in favor of more drilling and usage of fossil fuels, more willing to curb trans rights (like banning trans people from the military, a ban I oppose), historically less supportive of civil rights for minorities, and so on. The widespread Republican support for Trump—who I see as a narcissistic and unstable demagogue who, while he has done a few things that had good results, has damaged America—is something I cannot stomach, and I could never vote for a Republican who supported Trump.

Thus I can’t vote for nearly any Republican, and I won’t vote for Democrats who hold positions that oppose.  El-Sayed, for example, is not only a probable anti-Semite, but favors universal health care with the eventual abolition of private health care, which he sees as “redundant and unnecessary”, broader wealth taxes, and defunding the police.  His antisemitism and demonization of Israel—epitomized by his refusal to condemn Cenk’s “blood libel banana ad”—would alone erode my support for him, and, since I haven’t studied Rogers’s positions, were I to vote today I would probably write in a Democrat. This is worrisome because, of course, the Senate is at stake here because Michigan is more evenly divided politically than is Illinois. But my principles would prevent me from voting for an antisemite.

This post was prompted by two things. The first is the leftward move of the Democratic party, so that Stevens’s withdrawal of support from El-Sayed led Chuck Schumer, Democratic minority leader of the Senate, to denounce Stevens as committing a “despicable betrayal”, as if all Democrats are obliged to vote for El-Sayed. (And Schumer used to be a strong supporter of Israel.) Here’s Schumer’s tweet from yesterday.

It’s as if party must always override principle, and when it doesn’t, as in Stevens’s case, it’s a “betrayal.”

The second reason I’m writing this is an email I received from a friend urging me to stop saying I’m a diehard Democrat and start supporting Republicans.  I said that the GOP in general, and Trump in particular, was so offensive to me that I couldn’t contemplate that, even though the Democratic Party is becoming a party I can’t support in toto. I wrote that to my friend, who responded with this email (reproduced with permission):

I’ve been holding my breath on this issue forever. The straw that broke my back was the guy who commented that Michiganders should hold their noses and vote for Al Sayed. Why? Because he’s not a Republican. Now Chuck Schumer agrees. The Democrats have become the party of antisemitism. Like Amit Segal (and others) are saying: When the Democrats come into power they will recognize a Palestinian state; they will curtail (if not eliminate) arms sales to Israel; they will promote international financial sanctions against Israel, isolating the country internationally. In short, they will be an existential threat to the State of Israel. I get it that Trump provokes a certain visceral repulsion. But he is the only president we’ve had to stand up to Iran, he has stood up to DEI, he has stood up to campus antisemitism, he got Europe on the road to paying its own way in NATO.

I was a lifelong Democrat. We haven’t changed sides. The Democratic Party has. They’re the baddies now.

There’s a lot of sense in this, and a lot of things I agree with. I’m not quite as much a one-issue voter, but my friend is correct: the Democratic Party is isolating classical liberals by moving away from them, chugging inexorably towards the “progressive” Left.

I decided that from now on that I will simply study harder the positions of candidates (realizing that what they say may not wholly reflect how they feel, which I think is true in El-Sayed’s case), and then vote for the candidate whose values align better with mine.  Some readers will disagree, as this stand, if adopted by everyone, may lead to Republican victories in some swing areas. It could also do that by prompting people to write in candidates who don’t stand a chance. Yes, you may disagree, but never in a million years would I vote for Abdul el-Sayed simply because he’s a Democrat.

Photo of me in Spain in 2006. Thought balloons added with AI.

Bill Maher on accidental bipartisanship

October 2, 2026 • 8:15 am

This week Bill Maher’s comedy/news bit on “Real Time” mourns the lack of bipartisanship in American politics—something that was once admired but now is denigrated. His two examples of how both parties contributed to improving society involve drugs—the dramatic decrease of death from street drugs like fentanyl as well as the price drops in widely-used prescription drugs. Maher argues that this wasn’t due to deliberate collaboration between the Dems and GOP, but was “accidental bipartisanship”:each party independently did things that contributed to the overall welfare.

People aren’t going to be happy with Maher saying that the GOP did anything worthwhile, though.

The guests you see on the panel are the journalists Jonathan Swan and James Kirchick.