Punctilious scientists correct Google Doodle, possibly incorrectly

November 25, 2015 • 10:45 am

I wrote yesterday about the “Lucy” Google Doodle, which looked like this:

41st-anniversary-of-the-discovery-of-lucy-5736109501841408-hp

Some of my colleagues didn’t like that Doodle, and fixed it. They couldn’t help it . . .:

Actually, I’m not sure this is scientifically accurate, as it shows Lucy (middle figure; A. afarensis) as a lineage that split off from modern humans rather than being one of our direct ancestors. We don’t know that, as Lucy’s species could have continued evolving into modern H. sapiens. The leftmost ape, if it’s a modern chimp, is correct, as they certainly branched off before hominins. But I’m not even sure, nor are the people at the Beacon Center, whether it’s a modern chimp or some ancestor of modern humans.

I therefore asked Greg Mayer, who knows more about this stuff than I do, to tell me if I was right in what I just said. He responded at some length, and even made a figure (upshot: I was right, and readers not conversant with taxonomy needn’t read on). Greg’s comments:

Yes, afarensis may have living descendants, and thus to show it as a terminal lineage isn’t quite right (or, at least, it involves additional assumptions). Some conventions for depicting fossil species in a tree with living species are needed, and it could be plausibly argued that they should be shown as terminal taxa (i.e at the tip of a branch, as in the corrected Google doodle Figure A).

Lucy phylo tree

But when a fossil species may be ancestral to a living species, we would consider the branch leading to the fossil species to have 0 length (i.e. it is at the node: Figure B).

Fossil species are usually depicted as terminal taxa, on the reasonable notion that of all the many species in an ancestral group, the probability of finding the ancestor is small. (For example, we know that early synapsids are ancestral to mammals, but the chance that Dimetrodon grandis is the ancestor of all mammals is small, so it probably is accurate to show it as a terminal taxon.) But when dealing with recent events with a rich fossil record in a geographically proscribed area, the probability of finding the ancestor does go up to the point where it’s no longer safe to make the assumption that it won’t be found.

For molecular and chromosomal data, where a complete description of the phenotype/genotype (i.e., nucleotide or banding sequence) is possible, actual ancestors can often be identified, and are often shown in trees as lying along the branches or at nodes in the tree.

Based on what we know about how speciation occurs, most ancestral species are probably paraphyletic relative to their descendants (Figure C, with afarensis zoomed in on and shown as ancestral to the lineage leading to Homo), and thus some parts of afarensis are terminal relative to Homo. If Lucy were in one of these terminal bits (the X in Figure C), then the corrected Google Doodle could be construed as accurate.

(I made the figure before checking the original Google doodle, and now realize that the leftmost ape was not identified as a chimp. If it was intended to be a chimp, then all of the above holds. However, if Google intended it to be a fossil ancestral species– which I think most likely– then it should fall along the branch, and not be a terminal taxon.)

Today’s Google Doodle celebrates Lucy

November 24, 2015 • 8:15 am

Today’s Google Doodle is a good one for evolutionary biologists, for it celebrates “Lucy,” the largely-complete skeletal specimen of Australopithecus afarensis found 41 years ago today by Donald Johansen and his team in Ethiopia. (The story of how they found her is in chapter 8 of WEIT.)  Lucy is famous for the “intermediacy” of her skeleton, which shows features of both her apelike ancestors and of more modern humans, for the completeness of the skeleton (see below), and for the early age, about 3.2 million years. She clearly belongs to the hominins—members of subtribe Hominina, which includes all the species on the “human” side of the divide between us and the ancestor of modern chimps and bonobos. That split actually happened about 7 million years ago—four million years before Lucy.

Two beefs from yours truly. First, the figure below plays into the “evolutionary progression” scenario of a one-way march toward modern humans, which of course isn’t true (our common ancestor with chimps evolved into non-bipedal chimps as well as bipedal hominins).

41st-anniversary-of-the-discovery-of-lucy-5736109501841408-hp

Second, the Time magazine headline explaining this Doodle looks like this:

Screen Shot 2015-11-24 at 7.17.04 AM

While that’s technically correct, it should really have read “Lucy the australopithecine.” After all, there is more than one “Australopithecus: species, and she’s an A. afarensis if you want to be fully correct. Further, nobody would say, for instance, “New Google Doodle honors Charles Darwin the Homo.” (If anything, it would say “Charles Darwin the hominin”.)

Finally, there’s still a bit of controversy about whether Lucy was a fully bipedal species, though I think the evidence is quite strong that members of her species walked upright.

Here are Lucy’s remains along with a reconstruction of just the found bones in their proper position, and a then a reconstruction of the entire skeleton:

lucy-skeleton

220px-Lucy_Mexico

In the reconstruction below, the brown-colored bones are the ones we have, while the white bones are reconstrucitons. Note that this is shown in the assumed bipedal posture:

800px-Lucy_Skeleton

Two Google Doodles: one for a holiday, one for science

November 2, 2015 • 11:00 am

Today’s doodle in the U.S., and probably Mexico, features the Day of the Dead (click screenshot below), but I find the one in Ireland, sent by reader Grania, much more interesting, as it’s science-related.

First, Dia de Muertos (yesterday and today), which I was lucky to see first-hand a few years ago in Mexico City:

Screen Shot 2015-11-02 at 7.58.44 AM

But in Ireland, the Google page gives an animated graphic, which is a gif I’ve embedded below. First have a look at it, and figure out a. what’s going on here, and b. whom it’s celebrating:

george-booles-200th-birthday-5636122663190528.2-hp

That’s right, it’s showing Boolean logic: in the second “g”, when the x or y or neither or both light up, the corresponding letter or letters also light up.

And that means it’s celebrating the life of George Boole (1815-1864; today’s his 200th birthday), mathematician, polymath, and creator of Boolean algebra and Boolean logic, the binary decision system that’s become the basis for all computers (see here). Grania informed me that Boole was the first professor of mathematics at University College Cork (then known as Queen’s College) in Ireland, in the town where she lives. Boole died at only 49; Wikipedia tells the tale:

In 1864, Boole walked two miles in the drenching rain and lectured wearing his wet clothes. He soon became ill, developing a severe cold and high fever. As his wife believed that remedies should resemble their cause, she put her husband to bed and poured buckets of water over him – the wet having brought on his illness. Boole’s condition worsened and on 8 December 1864, he died of fever-induced pleural effusion.

In honor of Boole’s bicentennial, University College Cork has set up a George Boole 200 Page, where you can find information about his life  and about walking tours, videos, and information about celebratory events.  Here’s a short video showing the contributions he made to modern life:

Boole (I’m glad I live in an era when academics don’t have to wear coats and ties!):

George_Boole_color

 

 

Today’s Google Doodle honors the Father of Surfing

August 24, 2015 • 7:30 am

We’ll skip readers’ photos for one day as, including this post, there are already three light items for this morning (and be sure to watch Matthew’s video of the World’s Greatest Cat Toy two posts down).

When I saw today’s Google Doodle, I knew instantly who the honoree was. Yes, that handsome dude on the surfboard is none other than Duke Kahanamoku (1890-1968), the Father of Surfing—the original Big Kahuna.  Had he lived, he would have been 125 today.

If you don’t know who he is, Wikipedia gives a good summary in the first paragraph of its long biography:

Duke Paoa Kahinu Mokoe Hulikohola Kahanamoku (August 24, 1890 – January 22, 1968) was an American competition swimmer of ethnicHawaiian background who was also known as an actor, lawman, early beach volleyball player and businessman credited with spreading the sport of surfing. Kahanamoku was a five-time Olympic medalist in swimming.

Click on the screenshot below to go to Google’s own explanation.

Screen shot 2015-08-24 at 5.08.29 AM

Yes, his given name was Duke, and he was born on one of the Hawaiian islands (which one is unclear). He started surfing as a young boy, using a wooden board:

In his youth, Kahanamoku preferred a traditional surf board, which he called his “papa nui”, constructed after the fashion of ancient Hawaiian “olo” boards. Made from the wood of a koa tree, it was 16 feet (4.9 m) long and weighed 114 pounds (52 kg). The board was without a skeg, which had yet to be invented. In his later career, he would often use smaller boards but always preferred those made of wood.

That’s a long way from the shorter and lighter boards of today! Here he is with his board:

Duke_Kahanamoku_1920

Here’s some rare color footage of Duke surfing at the age of 49. I like the music, though most will find it cheesy:

(There’s also a very good short two-part video biography here and here.)

Duke won three gold medals and one silver medal in swimming in the 1912 and 1920 Olympics, traveled widely as an ambassador for both surfing and Hawaii, and landed in Hollywood, where he played bit parts in several films.Here’s a short 7-minute video biography, which, at 2:25, shows one of Duke’s movie appearances:

Duke’s name lives on, and he was widely admired; as Wikipedia reports:

Hawaii music promoter Kimo Wilder McVay capitalized on Kahanamoku’s popularity by naming his Waikiki showroom “Duke Kahanamoku’s”, and giving Kahanamoku a piece of the financial action in exchange for the use of his name. It was a major Waikiki showroom in the 1960s and is remembered as the home of Don Ho & The Aliis from 1964 through 1969.

Kahanamoku’s name is also used by Duke’s Canoe Club & Barefoot Bar, a beachfront bar and restaurant in the Outrigger Waikiki On The Beach Hotel. There is a chain of restaurants named after him in California and Hawaii called Duke’s. A bronze statue at Waikiki beach in Honolulu honors his memory. It shows Kahanamoku standing in front of his surfboard with his arms outstretched. Many honor him by placing leis on his statue. There is a webcam watching the statue, allowing visitors from around the world to wave to their friends.

On August 24, 2002, which was also the 112th anniversary of the birth of Duke Kahanamoku, a 37c first-class letter rate postage stamp of the United States Postal Service with Duke’s picture on, was issued. The First Day Ceremony was held at the Hilton Hawaiian Village in Waikiki and was attended by thousands. At this ceremony, attendees could attach the Duke stamp to an envelope and get it canceled with a First Day of Issue postmark. These First Day Covers are very collectable.

I came to learn about Duke when I was collecting aloha shirts, for there is a line (it’s still around) that carries his name. The vintage Duke Kahanamoku shirts can be quite pricey (I don’t have any of those, but I have a newer one): take a look at these babies. In honor of the Big Kahuna, I wore an aloha shirt to work this morning (I have about fifty). Here I am just at work, with my latte (four shots of espresso today) in my Hili cup (the famous “triple Hili mug”), and sporting my Hawaiian shirt:

Photo on 8-24-15 at 6.06 AM #2

All hail the Duke!

artb-450x361

Google Doodle celebrates Japanese fantasy filmmaker

July 7, 2015 • 3:24 pm

Today’s interactive Google Doodle (click the screenshot below to go to the animation) involves making your own movie.

Screen shot 2015-07-07 at 1.22.57 PM


As Google explains, this interactive Doodle (which I haven’t figured out how to work, but is surely easy) is a homage to Japanese monster-and-sci-fi-movie director Eiji Tsuburaya (“Godzilla” etc.), who, had he not died, would be 114 today. (He lived from 1901 to 1970.)

The lights dim. Cameras start to roll. A film crew silently watches. Suddenly! From behind a hand-built skyline, a towering beast appears! Shaking off a layer of dust, the massive foam-and-rubber monster leans back to act out an amazing roar (the sound effect will be added in later). Then, stomping towards the camera, the giant moves closer, and closer, until…”Cut!”

Seen this film before? This live action genre, known as “Tokusatsu” (特撮) in Japanese, is unmistakable in its style, and still evident in many modern beast-based thrillers. In today’s Doodle, we spotlight one of Tokusatsu’s kings, Eiji Tsuburaya, the quiet pioneer who created Ultraman, co-created Godzilla, and brought Tokusatsu to the global cinematic mainstream. Doodler Jennifer Hom led us through the inspiration behind the interactive Doodle. . .

. . . “While several of ideas revolved around a game format, I thought it would be more interesting and engaging to recreate the filmmaking experience from scratch – what better way to get an appreciation for the creative challenges Tsuburaya the director had to face?”

. . . “After deciding to focus on the filmmaking process, we went to work defining the look of the monsters themselves and building out the quick tasks the user had to complete. Above all, we wanted to make sure the beasts were both charming and Googley, and that the mini-challenges were appropriately fun and frantic!”

Have a go yourself and report back.

 

 

Happy Father’s Day!

June 21, 2015 • 7:00 am

Today’s incredibly cute animated Google Doodle (click on screenshot) features various animal fathers, including penguins, wolves, felids, and H. sapiens. (It’s also the winter solstice in the southern hemisphere, so if you live there you might get another Doodle.)

Screen Shot 2015-06-21 at 6.19.57 AMArtist Olivia Huynh describes the making of the doodle here.