Saturday: Hili dialogue

November 21, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to CaturSaturday, November 21, 2026, shabbos for Jewish cats and National Gingerbread Cookie Day.  Gingerbread cookies at Christmas are a big deal in Poland, and here’s a hand-decorated pair I saw in Katowice in December of 2024:

It’s also National Cranberry Day, National Stuffing Day (celebrating the foodstuff, not the act), and Pumpkin Pie Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 21 Wikipedia page.

I will be out of Chicago from Monday through next Friday, as I’m going to visit friends for Thanksgiving in the warm Southwest. Posting will be erratic, but I trust that at least the American readers will be busy with the holidays. I do my best.

Da Nooz:

*This is just in the discussion stage, but I like the idea: according to the WSJ, U.S. envoys have been broaching the idea of Ukraine joining NATO. But there’s a catch (bolding below is mine):

In closed-door peace talks over the past few months, President Trump’s son-in-law and special envoy Jared Kushner has discussed an idea once believed to be dead-on-arrival: NATO membership for Ukraine if it cedes territory to Russia, said people familiar with the matter.

Moscow has fought for years to prevent Ukraine from joining the 32-member North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Trump himself ruled out NATO membership for Ukraine early last year as unacceptable to Russia.

But the idea has been raised in several conversations between European officials and Kushner and his fellow envoy Steve Witkoff in recent months, said people involved in the talks.

Most recently, Kushner discussed the possibility with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and European officials at a Dublin military airfield last week, said people familiar with the discussion. There, the U.S. envoys met with Zelensky, his adviser Rustem Umerov, and selected European national-security advisers.

It also came up in at least one meeting last week in the United Arab Emirates, where Kushner and Witkoff were meeting with Ukrainians, Europeans and Russians in a series of meetings aimed at negotiating a deal to end the war, said people familiar with those discussions. The idea was raised in a phone call as early as August, one European leader said.

The U.S. has raised two possible scenarios in recent talks, according to people involved in the negotiations. The first would require Ukraine to give up the territory it still controls in a region of eastern Ukraine known as the Donbas, where the two sides have been battling for much of the war, in exchange for full NATO membership. The second idea was to freeze the conflict along the front line—which would leave part of the Donbas territory in Ukrainian hands—and give Ukraine security guarantees to protect it from a future Russian assault through an international treaty with the U.S., and potentially with European allies.

A U.S. official said negotiators are discussing many ideas, but both Ukraine and Russia would need to agree to any final deal.

Broaching the idea of NATO membership for Ukraine shows how far Washington might be willing to go to break a stalemate in talks between Russia and Ukraine. Trump and previous U.S. administrations have resisted offering Ukraine membership in the military alliance, fearing that doing so would risk drawing the West into a confrontation with Moscow. Some European leaders share that fear.

Russia will certainly not agree to give Ukraine membership in NATO in return for anything, as it would represent an extension of Allied powers further into Europe, something Russia has adamantly opposed. The second alternative: security guarantees for Ukraine, is doubtful, and certainly would not work if those guarantees were international as well as with the U.S.  For that would be almost equivalent to Ukraine joining NATO. I think Russia will just keep fighting and destroying Ukrainian infrastructure.  That said, I’m wholly in favor of both suggestions. We are not doing enough to help Ukraine and Zelensky.

*I thought that Trump’s “triumphal arch,” one of the worst architectural ideas of this Administration (the Great Ballroom is in the running) was changed from a military-security facility containing snipers, drones, and ammo, back to a peaceful monument. Not so. As the NYT reports, it’s still going to be a military facility, too, putting weapons and ammo around tourist (article archived here).

The president is rebranding the triumphal arch as an armed military complex that would also host tourists. Nothing in the design explains how civilians would be kept safe.

President Trump has championed his idea for a 250-foot-tall arch in Washington as a commemoration of America’s 250th birthday or, on at least one occasion, a monument to himself. Recently, though, he has added a new rationale — national security.

Mr. Trump first announced in September that the arch would be outfitted with drones, snipers and ammunition storage. After a federal judge temporarily halted its construction this month, the White House promoted a website launched by Trump allies that declared it would be a “highly secretive” and “lethal” structure.

A New York Times analysis of the latest arch design shows how much it clashes with the administration’s military goals.

Converting the arch into a dual-use facility could put military operations in close proximity to up to 450 tourists at any given time.

An exploded diagram showing the interior of each floor. Public spaces are highlighted on each floor.

Plans for the arch have visitors flowing through much of its interior. The website promoted by the White House said munitions would be stored in the columns.

Any government snipers would likely have to be stationed on this public observation deck for tourists [JAC: the highest yellow level below]. . . … or on the roof. Sensors and communication equipment would also likely have to be housed at the top of the arch.

The website said drones would be launched from around the base of the monument, where visitors would be entering and exiting.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said in sworn statements to a federal court last month that the arch would address pressing security threats facing the nation’s capital, namely from small unauthorized drones.

The National Capital Planning Commission, a federal panel stacked with Trump allies, approved the arch on Nov. 5 without reviewing details of the military proposal. Immediately afterward, Tanya S. Chutkan, a federal judge, blocked construction, saying that the project would cause harm to surrounding areas and would most likely need congressional approval. Her order has been extended until Dec. 3.

Judge Chutkan called the national security argument “belated and unsupported.” The same retroactive justification may have helped secure a Supreme Court ruling in August that allowed construction to continue on Mr. Trump’s White House ballroom.

In an October hearing, Judge Chutkan demanded more evidence on the need for military use, which administration lawyers were unable to provide. “We’re not talking about plans for a cafeteria,” she said, later questioning, “munitions, military drones at a site that is anticipated to get between 2,000 and 22,000 civilian tourists a day?”

Seriously, if they need beefed-up security in Washington, D.C. (and I’m not sure they do), they can do it from government buildings in the city where public access is barred. This is insane.

Here’s a gif of the Arch’s architecture as taken from yesterday’s NYT morning report. The orange parts will supposedly be the bits open to the public.

*I was doubly surprised when I read this WaPo op-ed written by its editorial board. First, it notes that Starbucks workers have failed to unionize despite a movement to create a union. Second, the editorial says that American’s shouldn’t support these failed attempts to unionize (article archived here).

Nearly five years after Starbucks Workers United began trying to organize the coffee chain, the union still represents only about 5 percent of its U.S. baristas and has yet to secure a contract. Asking customers to stop patronizing Starbucks is its latest attempt to gain leverage.

So far, the boycott is a revolt on decaf. Union supporters last week staged rallies on about 40 college campuses. (There are more than 3,900 degree-granting institutions in the United States.) The Cleveland City Council voted this week to encourage residents to join the boycott.

The union claims to represent about 12,000 baristas at nearly 700 of the company’s more than 16,000 U.S. outposts. Its demands include a $17 wage floor, 4 percent annual raises, minimum staffing of three workers and “just cause” protections against discipline and firing.

Staffing mandates tie managers’ hands when stores are quiet. Automatic raises weaken the link between pay and productivity. “Just cause” rules make it harder to dismiss poor performers. Higher labor costs can mean higher prices for customers, fewer hours for workers, more automation and more store closures.

Competition offers better protection for workers than any union does. As rivals expanded, Starbucks’s share of U.S. coffee-shop spending fell from 52 percent in 2023 to 48 percent in 2025. If baristas don’t like their working conditions, they can take their talents to Dunkin’, Dutch Bros, 7 Brew, Scooter’s, Peet’s, Caribou, Tim Hortons, Blue Bottle or thousands of independent cafes. Restaurants and retailers want those workers, too.

Starbucks already offers generous benefits to attract and retain staff. The company says average hourly pay exceeds $19, and eligible workers can receive health coverage, stock, paid parental leave and college tuition. Turnover among hourly workers is roughly half the industry average.

Starbucks Workers United is free to call for a boycott. Americans are equally free to order a pumpkin spice latte and raise a toast to Thanksgiving in the land of liberty and free enterprise.

The same arguments could be raised against many unions or their contracts with management.  Of course people have the right to organize and employees have the right to resist. But unions have played a valuable role in preventing exploitation of workers, and it seems unseemly to say they somehow contradict “liberty and free enterprise.” Of course, it looks like the working conditions at Starbucks are pretty good, including high wages and medical benefits.

*A Democratic Socialist who decries the wokeness of Democrats? Yes, it’s Meagan Day, a writer for Jacobin magazine, with an op-ed in the NYT called, “I’m a socialist. Wokeness is stil the Left’s biggest liability” (article archived here).

A large and spirited class of freshman progressives is officially headed to Congress, including six democratic socialists and nine more candidates endorsed by Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont. Even moderate candidates won their midterm elections by talking about economic inequality and billionaires, suggesting the distinction between Democratic Party factions may be softening. The left has the best opportunity in decades to showcase its politics and values.

We can’t squander it. For nearly 20 years, I’ve watched one pattern pull the left off course after it takes power. It used to be called political correctness, then call-out culture, then cancel culture and now wokeness.

Over the summer, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York tried to consign these excesses to the recent past, declaring that “Woke 1 was crazy.” But woke rhetoric has embedded itself into the party, and Democrats will have to work to excise it. Representative Ro Khanna of California celebrated the election results as heralding the return of D.E.I. Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, whom Democrats on Wednesday nominated to be the speaker of the House, dismissed a group of critics because they were mostly white. Leftist groups still find themselves divided over identity and privilege. And progressives have flooded the internet with jokes that “woke is back.” These posts may be kidding, but if our movement doesn’t distance itself from identity politics, we could jeopardize everything we’ve achieved.

To hear many conservatives define it, I would be considered woke. I’ve been a member of the Democratic Socialists of America for 10 years. I believe this country needs deep criminal justice and police reform. I am galled by ICE agents ethnically profiling and brutalizing people. I not only support gay marriage but am an enthusiastic participant in one.

But wokeness is not about a basic concern for social justice. It hyperfocuses on language and identity, fights dirty from the moral high ground and mandates deference to self-appointed spokespeople for marginalized groups. It conflates disagreement with harm, and keeps careful watch for heretics.

. . .Wokeness’s vague, maximalist rhetoric trickled up to Congress. Moderate Democrats put on silly stunts to signal their “allyship” and co-opted woke terms like “feeling unsafe” to shut down protest. Leftists including Ms. Ocasio-Cortez and Representatives Rashida Tlaib of Michigan and Ilhan Omar of Minnesota echoed calls in 2020 to “defund the police,” an unpopular slogan that Ms. Ocasio-Cortez defended by tweeting that the “whole point of protesting is to make ppl uncomfortable.”

President Trump’s re-election quieted calls to defund and diversify. But wokeness persists today. In D.S.A., which I joined on the heels of the first Bernie Sanders presidential campaign, one still encounters debates about whether clapping is ableist or whether socialists should commit to “decolonizing ‘Minnesota.’” At its best, D.S.A. strikes me as our greatest shot at building a broad-based and politically serious organized left. At its worst, the energy reminds me of a scene from an Oberlin dining co-op, where a group of members filed in during a meal and silently unfurled a sign reading, “This co-op is messed up.” (They were protesting the privilege inherent in cliques; the sign’s wording was in fact less polite.)

The next Congress can’t let these debates trickle up again. The freshman representatives from the bluest districts, such as those in Brooklyn and Los Angeles, will still face pressure to spend their time denouncing offensive language and censuring members to their right. Instead, they should focus on making life better for working-class people — working toward Medicare for all, labor law reform, maybe even a Green New Deal. For the first time in a while, the moderate members of their party might actually be open to compromising on these issues.

That last paragraph lays out the characteristics of wokeness, but doesn’t define it. I’m often asked to do so, and my short reply, which isn’t really sufficient, is “Performative social-justice acts that flaunt one’s virtue and don’t create much (or any) social change.” You can tender your own definition below. All I can say is to echo Justice Potter Stewart’s statement on obscenity: “I know it when I see it.” A bit more:

I’ve seen a lot of wokeness in my time, and I’ve never seen it produce a sustainable, appealing and effective political formation. I have, on the other hand, seen the left make phenomenal advances by focusing on coherent, universalist, usually economic demands that unite people across differences and foster solidarity.

The American left can focus on meeting people’s material needs rather than scrutinizing their moral fallibility. But to get there, we must convey our actual opinions, not just the ones that keep us in good standing.

The message is not new: wokeness is not only a danger to Democrats, but a recipe for accomplishing nothing. What’s new is that the message is coming from a Democratic Socialist.

*As always, I’ll steal a few items from Nellie Bowles’s weekly news-and-snark column at the Free Press, called this week, “TGIF: Consensual non-consent.”

→ The new world: The good folks at Pew Research Center bring us new demographic projections. Here we go:

First of all, Jews are absolutely exploding in numbers from 0.01 to 0.02?! Wow, hell yeah! It’s 0.02 and don’t you forget it. Meanwhile, the religiously unaffiliated simply die off from lack of reproduction (which checks out). And Islam will be the largest religion in the world, by far. All ye worried about gender-related microaggressions in your Protestant societies are in for a rude awakening when you’re not allowed to go to the market in France without an escort. The LGBTQIA2S+ community will be begging to live under the Woke Pope’s benevolent papal authority after all of this shakes out.

→ Our underfunded schools: New York City’s public school population is down 21.5 percent since 2013. Yes, it’s fallen by a fifth as families with young children flee the city to find schools that teach their kids forbidden knowledge like math and reading. People suffer miserable commutes and deal with things like lawn care and carpooling because the alternative is a man-child communist telling their children that America is satanic while a kid twirls a handgun one desk over. Anyway, school enrollment is down 21.5 percent. But funding is up! Oh yeah it is. New York City now spends $59,450 per student! Per year! That’s the number people are arriving at because the ​​city’s public school budget this year is now $45.6 billion. For only 766,900 students. This is the math they don’t want you to do. $59,450. For that price, these kids should be speaking Mandarin while they code a new internet. For nearly 60 grand, those kids should be able to land back handsprings on the moon. Sixty grand should mean the kid has some alternative thoughts on Russian literature.

→ . . . Also on campus: ​​Hunter College’s “Cultural Arts Night” was canceled, apparently after it was discovered that Jewish student group Hillel had been invited to participate. Hunter’s Undergraduate Student Government (USG) declared, “USG does not endorse this event or this collaboration,” adding that it “doesn’t align with our values.” “Going forward,” they wrote, “every club and every member of USG will know who is involved in an event.” Student government president Sumaiya Ahmed and VP Ahmad Waraich signed the cancellation statement, drawing a flood of gleeful antisemitic social media comments and praise from City College’s Students for Justice in Palestine chapter. It’s always important to root out collaborators from the Cultural Arts Night.

→ One last thing on the JQ: One of America’s newly elected senators laid out his vision of an acceptable Israel. Here’s soon-to-be Senator Abdul El-Sayed on the Jewish state: “I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens. . . does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws. That’s, again, the question of peace, dignity, and self-determination.” So all the 25 or so countries whose official religion is Islam are totally fine. Now, if he said he hopes those nations also dropped their state religions—and, um, cultures?—that’s at least a cohesive argument. But no. The existence of those doesn’t seem to bother anyone.

→ Rest in peace, Fiona the Hippo: A beautiful premature hippo baby named Fiona grew up to be the star of the Cincinnati Zoo. She died Thursday, days after eating a hat a child had gotten into her enclosure. I’m not ruling out foul play. Lawyer up, kid.

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, but we have a vintage Hili dialogue.

Hili: How do we know what we know?
Andrzej: Usually from questionable sources.

In Polish:

Hili: Skąd wiemy to, co wiemy?
Ja: Na ogół z wątpliwych źródeł.

*******************

From Divy:

From CinEmma:

From Jesus of the Day:

From Masih; two Iranian protestors sentenced to death for “enmity against God”:

An old but a good post from my heartthrob Sophie Cunningham:

From my feed, food-stealing cats:

From Will. The Community note attributes the video: “This Woman HAS A NAME. https://x.com/Le_Turtle1/status/2123279706216874437 Her own posting of her own video generated no credit as others reposted and got an incredible amount of views.”  Another says, “The video was created by Simona Hap (Simona Hapciuc), a Dubai-based Romanian content creator. https://www.instagram.com/reel/Df4wE13MXGB/ https://www.instagram.com/eusimonahapciuc/

One from my feed; a heartwarming and tearjerking ad from Thailand:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

This Polish Jewish girl was gassed to death, along with 90% of her convey, as soon as they got to Auschwitz. She was 12 years old.

— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2026-11-21T12:26:33.489Z

And two–yes, two–from Dr. Cobb. First, a famous cat photo for Caturday, taken at just the right moment:

Cat jumping by Neil Hibbert, Salford 1957

— Mark Forrest (@rowiecrumbs.bsky.social) 2026-11-20T00:07:16.070Z

And a 43-second horse fart. Where is Guinness when you need them?

My sister sent me this: a 43-second horse fart. You are all most welcome

— Odd This Day (@oddthisday.bsky.social) 2026-11-06T14:05:48.077Z

.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *