NOVA series on evolution

November 19, 2026 • 9:45 am

I didn’t realize that NOVA/PBS/BBC has had a multi-segment series on evolution that you can watch online for free until December 12. It’s already at episode 17, and you can click the screenshot below to go to the programs available, They are a bit idiosyncratic, including shows on running, mating (really about sex), the evolution of the elephant, the evolution of feeding, and the evolution of intelligence. But I don’t know what was covered in the first 12 episodes. Some of these may be useful as adjunct material in evolution courses.

I decided to choose one episode to watch, just to get a sense of whether I wanted to see more. The episode was “The Mating Game,” which purports to answer the question,”How did sex create the wondrous world we see around us?”and I watched the entire 53 minutes.

My verdict is rather “meh”: the show is okay, but I think it could have been much better.  Perhaps I’m being hypercritical as a professor in this field, but I would have liked to talk to the creators before they put out the final version.  The cinematography is good, but the explanations seem wonky, and the whole show, while purporting to show how sex evolved and “unleashed” evolution (which it did to a large extent, but evolution, mutation, and natural selection did, too), is largely a recounting of what happened during evolution: there were cells, multicellular organisms, fish, fish that became terrestrial, amphibians, reptiles, and then the branches that led to birds and mammals.

In other words, the show is infused with a soupçon of teleology: that evolution was more or less a drive towards complexity, culminating in what we have today. Well, yes, what we have today is the longest-standing products of evolution, but evolution will continue, and natural selection doesn’t always favor more complexity (viz., tapeworms or lizards that have lost their legs).  Yes, some amphibians that produced amniotic (“terrestrial”) eggs may have had an advantage over their conspecific individuals because they didn’t have to return to the water to breed, but I the show doesn’t mention that this is how natural selection operated to produce evolutionary “innovations”, but there are still plenty of amphibians and plenty of fish still in the sea.

My view is that the producers missed a chance not only to raise some interesting questions, but also to emphasize that there are things we just don’t understand about sex and evolution.  One of these is the question, “Why did sex evolve?”  We don’t know the answer, but the show implies that it evolved to facilitate evolution. That’s a result of sex, but is a somewhat teleological answer, and scientists have many possible answers, all of which must involved the adaptive advantage of combining genes among individuals (technically, “to break up linkage disequilibrium among gene forms”). These include meeting environmental changes, meeting the challenge from parasites, getting rid of deleterious genes, repairing errors in DNA, and so on. (Just Google “why did sex evolve?”).  It could have been one or several of these advantages, but nowhere in the show will you hear “We don’t know the answer.” Nor do they answer the question of why we don’t see more asexual lineages since asexual mutants can have twice as many offspring as do their sexual ancestors; this is the “twofold cost of sex.”

Likewise, although they imply that there are two sexes, they don’t state that this condition holds in all animals and vascular plants. The question of “why sexes are always two?” was first asked by R. A. Fisher, and we have a pretty good answer involving “evolutionarily stable strategies.” Tbere is no mention made of this issue, which has become contentious.

The talking heads they use are somewhat idiosyncratic, concentrating almost entirely on North Americans and South Africans; I didn’t recognize any names save Sarah Otto, but perhaps the producers wanted to show some diversity among the commentators.

A few more of my notes:

A. Sexual selection is first shown in dinosaurs, favoring feathers, but of course sexual selection began evolving as soon as there were separate sexes. This isn’t mentioned, nor do they show that classically there are two forms of sexual selection: male-male competition (Darwin’s “law of battle”) and female-choice (Darwin’s “law of beauty,” the main explanation given here). There is no discussion about why some male traits, like bright colors and displays, are favored by females. To me, this is one of the great unsolved mysteries of evolution, and there are many possible explanations.  Further, the big claws of fiddler crabs, which are correctly mentioned as an example of sexual selection, not only enable males to fight with each other, but are waved in front of female crabs to attract them, showing that some features can participate in both form of sexual selection.

B. They make a big deal about the “invention” of the penis as a way to effect internal fertilization: “the origin of the penis was a major moment in evolution.” This importance is, they say, because it is THE way to effect internal fertilization in animals like birds, where the egg is fertilized before the shell is put on.  Unfortunately, 97% of bird species do not have penises (some ducks do); they have cloacas that they quickly evert when copulating in a “cloacal kiss”.  Other animals, including some amphibians, deposit spermatophores (packets of sperm) that a female snatches with her cloaca. I’m not sure why there’s all the brouhaha about penises unless the producers wanted to put a salacious spin on the theme.

C. Perhaps this is explained in an earlier show, but natural selection is minimized in comparison with sex (sexual selection is, of course, a form of natural selection involving mate choice or access, but that isn’t even mentioned.) It’s vitally important that these shows keep natural selection constantly in the foreground, and mention mutation and competition for reproduction between members of the same species.

Again, perhaps I am speaking from the point of view of an evolutionist; I’m not the kind of person who make up the target audience, but I was not impressed. I am not going to watch any more shows. But you can!  Watch this show for yourself, or choose another, and see if you want to go through other available videos.

Click below to go to “The Mating Game”. If you watch it, please comment below and let me know if I’m being unfair.


 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *