Friday: readers’ wildlife photos

September 18, 2015 • 7:15 am

If you have good photos, please send them to me while I’m on my trip, which will begin next Monday and end on Oct. 19. But today please enjoy a selection of bird photographs—plus one gratis mammal—by Colin Franks (Facebook page here, photography website here):

Western Sandpiper (Calidris mauri):

7D__11209

Western Kingbird (Tyrannus verticalis):

7D__11624

Bald Eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus):

7D__11781

Barred Owl (Strix varia):

7D__11799

Bonaparte’s Gull (Chroicocephalus philadelphia):

7D__12227

Greater Yellowlegs (Tringa melanoleuca):

7D__12461

Rhinoceros Auklet (Cerorhinca monocerata; I shot this from a kayak):

7D__12669

Harbour Seal (Phoca vitulina):

7D__13032

 

Friday: Hili dialogue (and Leon lagniappe)

September 18, 2015 • 6:30 am

It’s the end of the week, and at this time next week, with luck, I’ll be posting the Hili dialogues with the Princess herself asleep on my chest. It’s raining in Chicago (I can hear the thunder right outside), and will do so tomorrow as well. And, exactly one year ago, Scotland voted against independence from the UK. Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, The Furry Navel of the World and her BFF Cyrus take pleasure in the fact that, unlike the many Catholics who inhabit her land, they can still have noms on Friday (in Poland, “fasting” for Catholics means not eating meat).

Hili: Do you like Fridays?
Cyrus: Yes, with atheists, without any fasting.

z

In Polish:
Hili: Czy lubisz piątki?
Cyrus: Tak, z ateistami, bez postu.

 

And, as Friday lagniappe, we have Leon on his harness, also thinking about noms. (I will get to see Leon, too, on my visit to Poland):

Leon: I wonder whether mice have a developed sense of aesthetics and would come to admire heather.

11143324_1024572107563390_1218440645306453225_n

 

IgNobel Prizes awarded (and livestreamed) this evening

September 17, 2015 • 3:00 pm

“It’s like the weirdest f-ing thing that you’ll ever go to… it’s a collection of, like, actual Nobel Prize winners giving away prizes to real scientists for doing f’d-up things… it’s awesome.”Amanda Palmer

Reader Diane G. informs me that the annual IgNobel Prizes will be awarded at Harvard this evening, with the awards handed out by Genuine Nobel Laureates. The ceremony is always a hoot, and this year’s gala is described here. The ceremonies begin at 6 p.m. Eastern US time, and you can see them livestreamed at this site

Quebec considering blasphemy law

September 17, 2015 • 2:00 pm

O Canada! What is happening to you? Perhaps this has been in the works for some time, but it was new to me.  Kyle Shileder at Townhall.com  reports that mischief is afoot in Quebec:

The Quebec Parliament is currently debating whether to pass Bill 59, a bill that would grant the Quebec Human Rights Commission (QHRC) the authority to investigate so-called “hate speech”, even without a complaint being filed.

The Head of the QHRC, Jacques Frémont has already openly said that he plans to use such powers, “to sue those critical of certain ideas, ‘people who would write against … the Islamic religion … on a website or on a Facebook page’” according to Canada’s National Post.

Two years ago, the Canadian Parliament abolished “hate speech” conveyed by the Internet or telephone as part of human rights laws. Why this step backwards? It appears, as suggested above, to be a reaction to the misguided efforts to protect criticism of Islam. How dare Frémont single out Islam and ignore other faiths? There’s further evidence:

Marc Lebuis, the Director of Point de Bascule, which publishes research and information on the threat posed to Canada by Islamist organizations such as the Muslim Brotherhood, pointed out in his testimony before the Quebec Parliament that this resurrection is motivated in part by the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC).

What Mr. Frémont did not tell Radio-Canada when he alluded to these UN resolutions on December 2, 2014 is that they originally came from the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, the OIC, that claims equivalence between hate speech, blasphemy, criticism of Islam and defamation of religions.

Lebuis is rightly aware that Quebec’s proposed law will not be applied uniformly just as Section 13 [the section overturned in 2013] was not. In 2008, Lebuis filed a complaint against an Imam whose writings lauded beheading and exterminating homosexuals, denigrated Jews, and called for violent jihad in any place Muslims had the power to overthrow non-Muslim rule.

The Human Rights Commission declined to hear the case.

Let us make no mistake about it: it is odious for any democracy to prohibit criticism of any religion, be it Christianity, Islam, or Scientology. Such a prohibition is contrary to Enlightenment principles and inimical to social progress. “Hate speech” is often a euphemism for “criticism of religion,” or even “criticism of ideas I don’t like.” Yes, there can be genuine hate speech, like that uttered by the Imam above, but I don’t believe any of it should be banned unless it calls for imminent violence.

That’s the way the U.S. operates—or is supposed to. Is there any reason why our enlightened neighbor to the north shouldn’t follow suit? Not that I see. Fortunately, the saner Canadians are raising serious questions about this bill (see here, here, and here). Even some Canadian Muslims, peace be upon them, feel that the bill is unnecessary. Let us hope it dies a quiet death.

Here’s a map showing where blasphemy is criminalized. Black means you can be executed for it, red means you can be imprisoned for it, orange means you can be fined for it, and yellow means there are local restrictions on blasphemy. France and Australia—seriously?

blasphemy-laws-map16

Here’s the chipmunk!

September 17, 2015 • 11:00 am

Here’s the answer to today’s earlier “spot the chipmunk” post, with a comment by photographer Diana MacPherson:

Here is the chipmunk with a circle around him. They blend in so well in the leaves. When I saw this one, he hid behind a tree. It was cute that when I peered around the tree, he moved more behind the tree! 🙂

Squirrels of course do that too. I think it’s a behavior genetically instilled by natural selection, and one could test that by looking at the behavior of naive, hand-reared squirrels (or chimpmunks).

chipmunkreveal

 

Radio show today

September 17, 2015 • 10:15 am

I’ll be appearing on KPCC (a Southern California Public Radio Station) live today; the show is AirTalk with host Larry Mantle, and the topic is, as usual these days, the issue of faith versus fact.

The time is approximately 2:30 pm Chicago (Central) time (it could start as late as 2:40), 3:30 pm EDT (i.e., time in New York), and 8:30 pm London time. You can listen to it live here.

Schrödinger’s bacterium: physicists plan to put a microbe in two places at the same time

September 17, 2015 • 9:15 am

Okay, this is WAY above my pay grade, but I’ve been sent articles on this by several authors, including an explanation at the Guardian. It’s a description by two theoretical physicists of an experiment that uses quantum superposition to put a bacterium in two places at the same time. They plan to collaborate with experimentalists to actually carry it out. Here’s what the Guardian says about it:

The researchers plan to build on the work of others at the University of Colorado who showed in 2013 that a tiny, vibrating aluminium membrane could be placed in a superposition of states.

“We propose to simply put a small microbe on top of the aluminum membrane. The microbe will also be in a superposition state when the aluminum membrane is in a superposition state. The principle is quite simple,” Dr Li said.

The researchers plan to go one step further in a second experiment that would entangle the position of the microbe with the spin of an electron inside it. “The purpose of the second experiment is to make the system useful. It can be used to detect defects of DNA and proteins in a microbe, and image the microbe with single electron spin sensitivity,” Dr Li said.

Li said he hoped to conduct the experiment, but that leading scientists in the field had laboratories better equipped to take the project on, and that he hoped to collaborate with them. “If the top group in quantum electromechanics want to focus on doing this experiment, I think a microbe could be put into a superposition state in three years,” he said.

The experiment is proposed in a paper by Tongcang Li and Zhang-Qi Yin (full pdf here) placed at ArXiv before publication. The abstract:

Schrödinger’s thought experiment to prepare a cat in a superposition of both alive and dead states reveals profound consequences of quantum mechanics and has attracted enormous interests. Here we propose a straightforward method to create quantum superposition states of a living microorganism by putting a small bacterium on top of an electromechanical oscillator. Our proposal is based on recent developments that the center-of-mass oscillation of a 15-μm-diameter aluminium membrane has been cooled to its quantum ground state [Nature 475, 359 (2011)], and entangled with a microwave field [Science, 342, 710 (2013)]. A microorganism with a mass much smaller than the mass of the electromechanical membrane will not significantly affect the quality factor of the membrane and can be cooled to the quantum ground state together with the membrane. Quantum superposition and teleportation of its center-of-mass motion state can be realized with the help of superconducting microwave circuits. More importantly, the internal states of a microorganism, such as the electron spin of a glycine radical, can be prepared in a quantum superposition state and entangled with its center-of-mass motion. Our proposal can be realized with state-of-art technologies. The proposed setup is also a quantum-limited magnetic resonance force microscope (MRFM) that not only can detect the existence of an electron spin, but also can coherently manipulate and detect the quantum state of the spin.

And here’s the diagram of the experiment from the paper:

Screen Shot 2015-09-16 at 10.23.23 AM

Because this is all beyond my ken, I asked Official Website Physicist™ Sean Carroll for a comment on the feasibility of the experiment. (Note that Sean is giving the famous Gifford Lectures next year and has an intriguing Book on Everything coming out next May). His take:

As far as Schrödinger’s microbe is concerned — there’s no problem in principle, though I am quite dubious in practice. Quantum mechanics says that things can be in superpositions of different locations, and everything in the world (including bacteria) is governed by the rules of quantum mechanics, so it’s certainly conceivable.
The problem is that to count as a “superposition” you need to keep the system unentangled from the rest of the world — once the thing interacts with the environment, the superposition branches the whole wave function of the universe (the phenomenon known as “decoherence”). That’s why we can’t even imagine doing it for real cats; they’re always breathing and radiating heat and so forth, thereby interacting with their environments. It seems to me that the same would be true for a bacterium, or anything else that we would qualify as “alive” — unless you were talking about very short time periods indeed. (I’d be much less skeptical if it were a freeze-dried bacterium.) Note that the paper is a theoretical proposal, not an experimental result.
Well, I don’t fully understand this experiment yet (remember Richard Feynman’s dictum that if you think you understand quantum mechanics, you really don’t), but at least I understand it a bit more. Readers with physics expertise are invited to comment, explaining the design and its feasibility. Seriously!
And Matthew Cobb tells me that the experiment is being heavily discussed and criticized on Twi**er, noting, “Many people are saying in comments they don’t understand it and are suggesting authors don’t, either.” But he added this funny tw**t. I wonder if Deepak Chopra will tout this study as support for his woo.
IMG_3047

h/t: Grania