It’s worth getting acquainted with both Dave Rubin and Gad Saad, and these two shortish videos give you the chance (they’re bits of a single one-hour video).
Dave Rubin is a comedian and talk-show host, best known to us nonbelievers as host of The Rubin Report (YouTube channel here), which is a good replacement for The Young Turks since the latter show went Full Leftist Authoritarian (I find it unwatchable; I’d rather listen to out-and-out conservatives like Bill O’Reilly!). Rubin has, in fact, been responsible for popularizing—and mocking—that group of identity politicians and Islam-apologists known as “The Regressive Left.” I prefer to call it the “Authoritarian Left” since not all their stands are regressive.
Saad, of Lebanese and Jewish origin, is an evolutionary psychologist and professor of marketing at Concordia University, right here in Montreal. He also has a widely read website, Homo Consumericus, at Psychology Today. His criticism of the Authoritarian Left, and his work on evolutionary psychology, are guaranteed to alienate the large section of the atheist blogosphere that rejects evo psych on purely ideological grounds while claiming that the entire field is scientifically worthless. Too bad—Saad’s a thoughtful and reasonable man, and I wish I had his equanimity. And it’s just dumb to reject wholesale the notion that while human morphology and physiology reflects our evolution, our behavior is an exception.
In the first video, Saad covers a lot of ground. For one thing, he goes after the dissimulator Reza Aslan, and wonders if Aslan knows he’s lying when he produces his “endless tsunami of nonsense.” He further considers whether there’s any difference between religiosity and lunacy, the connection between religion and sports, and whether religion that has no impact on the public sphere deserves criticism (i.e., is it injurious in any way to have unfounded religious belief on which you don’t act?). Finally, he tells us why religion will always be with us, and why “New Atheism” is demonized.
This second video, twelve minutes long, deals with evolutionary psychology, and why so many people are reluctant to give any credence to the notion that some of our behavior reflects natural selection that acted on our ancestors. Saad goes on to discuss what he calls “political correctness and the thought police,” and why their actions are harmful.
If you’d like to listen to Saad’s Ottawa lecture, “How political correctness limits the free exchange ideas on campus,” to which he refers in the video above, go here. I recommend it; Saad’s a very good speaker.
I think all of us are behooved to listen to those who oppose our views. How else can we critically examine our beliefs, or sharpen our arguments should we decide to retain them? But if you’re sick of The Young Turks or miscreants like Reza Aslan, Rubin’s show is a good palliative.















































