Movie: “Paging Hezbollah”

November 1, 2026 • 10:00 am

The movie “Paging Hezbollah” came out two days ago, and it’s a film worth noting, as Liel Leibovitz has done at the Free Press. I don’t know if it will be available on Netflix, but for sure you won’t find it at the local theater, nor will you see it reviewed in the NYT (I hope I’m wrong).

As you might guess from the title, it’s about “Beepergate”, also known as “Operation Grim Beeper” or, as Wikipedia calls it, the “2024 Lebanon electronic device attacks.” And you may remember some details: how, over a ten-year period, Mossad created an elaborate scheme of shell companies and advertising schemes that would sell pagers to Hezbollah, who decided that pagers and walkie talkies were safer than cellphones.  But the Israelis had put 3 grams of a cryptic explosive into each device, and then somehow sold thousands of pagers and walkie talkies to Hezbollah, rigged so that, after Mossad sent a signal to these devices, the receiver would buzz or vibrate, and, when the “notified” Hezbollah member tried to answer or clear them, they’d explode. The devices were set off on September 17 and 18, 2024.

This explosion would normally occur when the device was held beside the head, leading to head injuries, including loss of eyes or ears. They weren’t designed to kill, but to injure, taking Hezbollah members out of action but leaving them alive. Note that the specific targeting avoids injuries to non-combatants, refuting the notion that the attack on Hezbollah was “genocidal.” (Also note that Shin Bet’s current series of attacks to kill Gazans who participated in the October 7 massacre of Israelis is also targeted, again refuting “genocide.” We’ll read about that tomorrow.) At any rate, the ratio of civilians killed to terrorists killed was below 1:2—an extraordinary low figure. As Grok tells me when I asked for the mortality figures:

  • “Total: 42 (Lebanese government/Health Ministry figures; early reports were lower, around 32–37).
    • Pager wave (Sept. 17): At least 12 killed.
    • Walkie-talkie wave (Sept. 18): At least ~25–30 killed.
  • Civilians: At least 12, including two children (reported variously as an ~8–10-year-old girl and an 11-year-old boy) and several healthcare workers. Lebanese officials, including Foreign Minister Abdallah Bou Habib, stated that most people carrying the pagers were not fighters but civilians such as administrators or institutional staff. Health Minister Firass Abiad emphasized that many victims were in civilian settings (markets, homes, streets), included children and the elderly, and presented as non-combatants.
  • Hezbollah members: The remaining ~30. Hezbollah issued death notices for multiple fighters/members (e.g., at least 8–12 announced early on, including the son of a Hezbollah MP, with more overall). The Washington Post reported that most of the early toll (~37) appeared to be fighters based on the group’s notices. Many were part of Hezbollah’s broader network (reservists, logistics, political, or institutional roles) rather than solely active frontline combatants. Hezbollah has described most of the dead and wounded as its fighters or personnel.”

Despite this targeted operation and low civilian mortality, people were outraged, with some calling it an Israeli war crime.  I would take issue with that, and for sure Hezbollah would have done it to Israel if they had the capacity and smarts. And you won’t find a lower ratio of civilians/combatants killed in any such operation.

At any rate, here’s what Leibovitz says about the movie, starting off with a bit of jingoism (i.e., it’s a “feel good” movie) that I won’t reproduce:

Paging Hezbollah tells the story of how the Israeli military managed to trick the Lebanese terrorist organization into using beepers installed with plastic explosives, pressing the button one day in the fall of 2024 and watching the devices—and with them scores of hands, noses, eyes, and testicles—explode.

It’s a riveting tale, and the director, Justin Folk, enjoyed unprecedented access to Israeli officials, from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to David Barnea, the head of Mossad, Israel’s legendary intelligence agency. Indeed, this was the first time that the Mossad chief sat down for an on-camera interview to explain in detail precisely how he and his team pulled off one of the greatest operations in modern military history.

Incredible as these details are, they might’ve, in the hands of a lesser filmmaker, made for a mosaic of mere machismo, all boom and bluster and no soul. Thankfully, the man the Israelis trusted with telling their story also possesses a virtue no less important than the ability to spin a great yarn—a sturdy moral compass.

Rather than rush into his story, Folk takes his time explaining to his viewers what’s at stake. And at stake, he realizes, is the fate of our civilization, everywhere under attack by men hell-bent on death and destruction. Hezbollah, Folk reminds viewers who might’ve forgotten or have never really known, was founded in 1982 to murder not only Israelis but also Americans, a task at which the organization, sadly, once excelled: In 1983, the terrorist group bombed the Marine barracks in Beirut, killing 241 American service members. That same year, it bombed the U.S. embassy in Beirut as well, claiming the lives of 17 more Americans, before kidnapping, torturing, and executing others in years to follow, including CIA station chief William Francis Buckley. Folk shows us archival footage of these horrors, doing everything he can to help a generation reared on social media and enamored with blowhard banshees like Tucker Carlson realize who are the real enemies of Israel and America, and everywhere in the still-free world.

That history lesson, brief but deeply moving, is worth the price of admission alone. Hollywood these days is hardly known for its excess of moral clarity, which is why its luminaries love wearing the red hand pin, which appears to symbolize the lynching of two Israelis by a Palestinian mob in Ramallah in 2000. Folk delivers more candor and clarity in a few minutes than most of our self-appointed intellectual and moral betters have in decades, giving us an unvarnished look at the merciless marauders at war with the West.

. . .it’s here that reality—and with it, Folk’s film—takes a turn to the fantastic. The solution, like something out of a particularly twisted episode of Mad Men, turns out to be not technology but advertising: What if, quips one female Mossad agent, a would-be Don Draper with a license to kill, what if we could make Hezbollah’s terrorists believe that only large devices could withstand the wear and tear afflicted by real, tough men? What if we could turn comically large beepers into status symbols for the terrorist on the make?

No sooner does the film pose the question than Folk cuts to an actual commercial, produced by Mossad, showing the supersize pager—think about three tins of Altoids stacked on top of each other and encased in black plastic—in a host of manly settings. You can get it wet! You can toss it on the sand! It’s indestructible, just like you! Another recreation of an absolutely true story shows us what happened next: The terrorists, enamored with the well-marketed gizmo, place their orders, giving Mossad a direct supply chain into Hezbollah HQ.

And the end:

Because some things in life, Paging Hezbollah reminds us, really are that uncomplicated. Some cultures cling to life and others sanctify death. Some create and others destroy. And when the two clash—onscreen and in real life alike—we have no other job than to watch with bated breath and applaud wildly when the good guys, against all odds, pull it off.

I applaud the cleverness of this operation—especially the elaborate advertising and sales campaign—and I think it was a good way to target a nefarious enemy. And I’m surprised but pleased that Israel uncharacteristically shared details of the operation with the filmmakers.   But somehow I can’t share Leibovitz’s apparent glee, for it seems to celebrate the very sacralization of death that it abhors. Civilians were killed, and the terrorists had families.  I think of this as a necessary tragedy, but not something that should bring glee. But I will try to see it.

Here’s the trailer:

19 thoughts on “Movie: “Paging Hezbollah””

  1. I’m hoping to see this when it’s available on video. (I’d be a little wary of going to see it in a theater. You never know.)

    I’m still amazed that the Israeli’s pulled this off. Compromising supply chains and getting Hezbollah to buy the booby trapped pagers was an incredible feat. And, the devices actually worked! This operation was one for the ages.

  2. I can’t wait to see it. The actual operation was one of the most impressive things I’ve seen in my entire life.

    Further, because the Iranians were involved in the sourcing of the beepers, this caused a rift of mistrust between Hezbollah and Tehran.
    Allah Akbar to the operation I say. hehehehe

    D.A.
    NYC

  3. In short, intelligence can sometimes be found in an Intelligence agency, at least in Israel. I hope to watch the film, especially to enjoy the advertising copy used to sell the explosive pagers to their terrorist consumers. I’ll bet the advertising language belonged to the same pop culture in which phrases like “globalize the intifada” are slipped into empty heads on so many western college campuses.

  4. The most innovative ‘attack’ ever. Made possible by an advertising campaign (literally) targeted exactly to the right consumers. Looking forward to seeing it!

      1. Grok is reporting of order 4000 injured and hospitalised, of which ~ 2000 permanently maimed (300 losing both eyes; 500 losing one eye; multiple hundreds losing fingers or hands).

  5. I can’t help but think that if Hezbollah had been the one doing it, and had it seen the same civilian death ratio, the tone of the post would’ve still been very different.

    Because ultimately, what did it truly bring, in terms of effectiveness ? Did all the efforts justify the civilians who died, including children ? If the aim was to maim and not kill, then any civilian who did die is a failure. It might be an Intelligence marvel, but it should not be celebrated, nor vindicated…

    1. First of all, that’s a ridiculous hypothetical, for neither Hamas nor Hezbollah would go to such lengths to target just combatants. Second, Israel has the moral high ground here because, after all, it was Hezbollah attacks on Israel after 2023 that got them to finally blow up the devices.

      Second, the aim was to take fighters out of action (I’m not really sure if they knew the maim/kill ratio), which is what they did. And yes, it did terrify Hezbollah and disrupt their communication system. As for what “justifies” the low ratio of combatants to civilians killed, I suppose that, because the ratio of German or Japanese civilians/combatants killed was higher, you would say that WWII was not justified.

      Your argument that I think both sides are morally equivalent but I would be a hypocrite if the other side did the same thing is a dumb argument. The sides are not starting from a position of moral equivalence.

      1. #7’s comment hinges on an “if” (“if Hezbollah had been the one doing it”)
        rather than what Hezbollah actually does (firing inaccurate missiles and rockets in the general direction of Israeli civilians). This brings the “whatabout” line of argument into the realm of the imaginary—which is no surprise.

  6. “Civilians were killed, and the terrorists had families. I think of this as a necessary tragedy, but not something that should bring glee.”

    Agreed. It’s appropriate to take pride in the operation, as it is to regard some collateral damage as acceptable, whether it be from an exploding beeper or another military strike. Undesired deaths do not turn a strike into failure.

    That tragedy always strikes in war does not make it any easier: an incorrect target coordinate is relayed to those launching missiles or dropping bombs; a soldier under fire unintentionally hits civilians in return. But somewhere in Israel there are men and women living with the knowledge that they killed innocent children who didn’t deserve to die. And a few will find this burden very hard to bear.

  7. it’s about “Beepergate”, also known as “Operation Grim Beeper”

    Ooh, I have an other one: “From the Liver to the Knee” 🙃

    One year ago there was a documentary on German TV covering this operation. Watched it on youtube. I think it should still be available there.
    But I think I will watch this movie as well, as soon as it’s available over here.

  8. The pager campaign targeted members of a terrorist group effectively and cannot be construed as a genocidal act. The operation was a success. The civilian casualties are regrettable but do not detract from Mossad’s brilliant planning and execution.

  9. Just saw it in the theater today. It was quite good I thought. Only had one showing, mid day, only 5 people in theater.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *