Polynesian navigation and Indigenous “ways of knowing”

October 30, 2026 • 9:30 am

One of the most-cited empirical achievements of indigenous peoples is the ability of Polynesians, Melanesians, and Micronesians to navigate their way across vast, unmarked expanses of the Pacific Ocean to get to small, uninhabited islands. How did they do it? And, regardless of their navigational methods, how many attempted voyages failed, with the navigators and their human cargo perishing?  We’ll never know because there was no way to keep records.

One could think of the process of developing the techniques of cross-Pacific navigation as a form of natural selection on cultural variation, with the methods being refined incrementally because navigators who were successful survived to pass on their techniques. Over time, navigation would become increasingly refined and successful, though, even when “perfected,” people would still fail and die.

Finally, how did they know there were unihabited islands to go to, and where, roughly, they were? How, for example, did they get to Hawaii?

An article by science writer Patrick Whittle in Quillette, which you can access below or read part of it in this archived version, says that the methods of Pacific way-finding were uncovered by New Zealand physician and adventurer David Lewis by interviewing the few older Pacific people who recalled navigational techiques. His results were summarized in the 1972 book We, the Navigators, The Ancient Art of Landfinding in the Pacific.

Click on the cover image to go to the Amazon site:

I really need to read this book since the history and methods of long-distance voyaging have always fascinated and puzzled me. My most pressing question is “How did the navigators know where they were going; that is, how did they know there were nice uninhabited islands out there, and where they were?” I discovered that our library has this book (the second edition) and I’ve just requested it be pulled so I can pick it up.

Click below to read Whittle’s piece in Quillette (if you have a subscription)

The point of Whittle’s article, though, is not navigation: it’s whether the methods of navigation qualify as indigenous “ways of knowing,” and how this relates to modern science. This is a topic we’ve debated at length, and I have to say that Whittle comes to a fairly sensible conclusion, one that I wouldn’t deny. And that is this: indigenous ways of knowing that have an empirical basis, like navigation, can sit side by side with modern science, and can be taken as science insofar as they express empirical “truths” (in this case, a set of methods that with some reliability can get you from island to island). But, says Whittle, indigenous knowledge like this oten comes with a cultural overlay: stuff like taboos, spiritual interpretations, and so on. Here’s Whittle’s thesis:

Across the Anglosphere, traditional Indigenous knowledge systems are increasingly being discussed not simply as accumulated practical expertise, but as distinct “ways of knowing”—often described as holistic and relational, and as inseparable from ancestry, place and lived experience, rather than, like modern science, a detached body of objective knowledge. These ideas form part of a wider movement to “decolonise” knowledge by challenging the historical dominance of Western intellectual traditions. In New Zealand, for example—the largest landmass settled by ancient Pacific sailors—the incorporation of Mātauranga Māori (traditional Māori knowledge) into the school curriculum has prompted fierce debate about the relationship between traditional knowledge and empirical science. At stake is not merely cultural authority, but whether different knowledge traditions should be judged by the same standards, and even what it means for something to count as knowledge in the first place.

In my view, the spiritual overlay belongs in the realm of anthropology and sociology, while the empirically true and replicable kernel of knowledge should be incorporated into modern science. That is not the argument Whittle mentions, though. The “fierce” argument, as in New Zealand, is whether the whole panoply of “ways of knowing”, including their spiritual, religious, cultural, and ideological components, should be taught as coequal to modern science, as in the entire worldview of Mātauranga Māori  (“MM”; see my many posts on this subject here). It has been proposed that the whole gemisch of MM should be taught in New Zealand university classes, though I think that scheme is dead.

There are, however, two distinctions between modern science and indigenous “knowledge”. The first, which Whittle doesn’t mention, is that indigenous “knowledge’ is often scientifically wrong, but is retained anyway. One example is the NZ government-funded project to stem the fungal blight destroying kauri trees by dousing the trees with whale oil and playing whale songs to them. This is based on a Māori myth that kauri trees (Agathis australis) and whales were once related (brothers) in ancient times, but whales were sent to the sea. As the story goes, playing whale songs to the trees and dousing them with whale oil will enable whales to cure their landlocked and afflicted brothers.

This is palpable nonsense, of course, and though it’s part of the Mātauranga Māori “way of knowing,” there’s no scientific basis to pursue this project, and the Kiwi government is wasting its money by funding it.

Further, a huge part of indigenous “ways of knowing” involve spiritual and herbal cures for diseases, most of which have not been tested in modern scientific ways to see if they’re effective. Thus, any untested claims are not “modern science” in any sense, but hypotheses.

Second, the fundamental methods of establishing indigenous knowledge and modern science differ, with the former involving trial and error (as in navigation) and the latter involving hypothesis testing, pervasive doubt, toosl like statistics and blind testing, and establishing universal truths.  A lot of indigenous knowledge is locality specific, like “here is how we create mussel beds in New Zealand.” That still counts as knowledge, but is not universal in the modern scientific sense. And the religious, teleological, spiritual, and mystical overtones of indigenous ways of knowing do not belong to modern science.

Like the seven Auckland Unversity professors who started off this controversy in 2021 with a letter in The Listener, I think that indigenous knowledge systems as a whole should be taught in anthropology and sociology classes, not in science classes, though the empirically true kernel of knowledge in such systems can fit into science class. (But I have to add that that kernel is tiny compared with the huge ambit of modern chemistry, physics, and biology.) So I don’t take much issue with Whittle’s conclusion:

Ironically, in trying to escape the seeming Western hegemony over what counts as “knowledge,” scholars sometimes simply replace one highly abstract category with another—Indigenous “ways of knowing”—that perhaps tells us more about contemporary academia than about the historical traditions it purports to describe. In reality, traditional practitioners like Lewis’s ancient mariners were not extraordinary masters of esoteric knowledge; they were ordinary human beings who had mastered the extraordinary capacities of cumulative culture.

Ultimately, when we clear away the institutional power dynamics and the culture war crossfire, a simple principle emerges: Indigenous knowledge deserves neither romanticisation nor dismissal. These traditions should be studied seriously, criticised where necessary, and appreciated for what they truly are—not timeless, inaccessible mysteries, but a vital part of humanity’s shared and evolving intellectual inheritance.

Who could disagree with that? But what we can dismiss are myths and religious stories like the actual brotherhood of kauri trees and whales.  That story has about as much credibility as saying the Moon is made of cheese; neither is science and neither deserves serious study since there is no substantive basis for the hypotheses.

This still leaves me with the mysteries about navigation discussed above. Apparently Lewis, in his studies, discovered that the navigators had a completely (to us) non-intuitive system of wayfinding, described like this:

For example, [Lewis] was initially baffled by the concept of etak, or “moving island.” As he came to realise, however, the old navigators weren’t treating the canoe as travelling across a static ocean; rather, they were seeing their vessel as fixed beneath the stars, with the islands and the sea moving past it (much as passengers on a moving train might imagine the landscape sliding backwards while they themselves remain stationary). To keep track of progress, therefore, the navigator would visualise a reference island off to one side—the etak—that would drift backwards under successive stars on the horizon. By noting which star this island was under at a given time, the navigator could work out how far the canoe had travelled and where it lay along its route. What at first appeared mystifying to Lewis gradually revealed itself as an ingenious mental framework—a “polydimensional system,” as he called it—for organising spatial information without maps or instruments.

I still don’t understand how the concept of a “moving island” would work, since it requires reference islands nearby, and often there weren’t any.  Further, the crucial question of “how often did this system work rather than fail?” must remain unanswered, as we lack the necessary data. Thus, even with the amazing navigation of the Pacific, we don’t have a scientific answer to a crucial question: was the system infallible or not, and if not, how fallible was it?

I’m just going to have to read Lewis’s book. There’s a fair amount of information about ancient navigation methods (use of the sun, birds, and so on) in the Wikipedia article on Polynesian navigation, including their use of double-hulled canoes:

 Polynesians made contact with nearly every island within the vast Polynesian Triangle, using outrigger canoes or double-hulled canoes. The double-hulled canoes were two large hulls, equal in length, and lashed side by side. The space between the paralleled canoes allowed for storage of food, hunting materials, and nets when embarking on long voyages

Here’s a modern replica of one, labeled, “Hōkūleʻa, a fibreglass-hulled replica of a Hawaiian double-hulled canoe sailing off Honolulu, 2009″:

Posted to Flickr, uploaded to Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 using Flickr upload bot on 27 September 2010, 07:17 by Kahuroa.

47 thoughts on “Polynesian navigation and Indigenous “ways of knowing””

  1. Now this is a coincidence. I just added Lewis’s book to my Amazon Wishlist (to be searched for elsewhere) the day before yesterday. I am into Hawaiian history right now, and am interested in when the Hawaiian’s lost touch with the rest of Polynesia.

    1. I’ve been rereading Jared Diamond’s “Collapse” and its chapter on the Easter Island culture that was established by and then cut off from the rest of Polynesian culture. Those ways of knowing were in some respects amazing but in other respects fragile.

  2. Indeed, fascinating – thrilling, even – I gotta get that book.

    A few quotes come to mind, emphasis on parsimony :

    “Je n’avais pas besoin de cette hypothèse-là” — “I have no need of that hypothesis”

    -Pierre-Simon Laplace to Emperor Napoleon Bonaparte, ca. 1802
    [obtained by Google Gemini]

    Nullius in Verba — On No One’s Word

    -Motto of The Royal Society, since 1662

    “Parsimony is always in the forefront of a scientist’s mind when choosing between theories, but it isn’t always obvious how to judge it.”

    -Richard Dawkins
    The Ancestor’s Tale: A Pilgrimage to the Dawn of Evolution
    2004 (1st. ed.)

    … and remember, the Counter-Enlightenment attacked reason itself, tracing from Kant, Hegel, et. al., which identified contradictions in reason — and therefore, in its relationship with reality — rendering reality subjective in nature.

    See Stephen R. C. Hicks’ book Explaining Postmodernism -I think it was his thesis, and it’s available as a free PDF at the moment.

    PS The “ways of knowing” subject here strikes me as the same strain of thought that Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs, and Steel developed – but that’s another can of worms.

  3. Important also to understand how indigenous knowledge and oral history/traditions “adopt” information. Let’s say scientific evidence shows clear DNA evidence linking Taiwan to Polynesians to Maori. Surprise surprise! Maori oral traditions later, often well later, claim such a link remembered by ancestors and passed on…. Classic example is Gambian oral histories remembering Kunte Kinte after Alex Haley made him up.

  4. Comment by Greg Mayer

    The Field Museum has a permanent exhibit that covers the geology, biology, and anthropology of the Pacific islands. The entrance to the exhibit was originally a hall entitled “Traveling the Pacific”, in which the formation of volcanic islands and atolls, and dispersal to them by plants, beasts, and man, are all touched upon. There are high-quality dioramas of atoll environments, one of which includes a modern outrigger canoe. Among the intriguing items included were “maps” of a sort, consisting of a stick framework entwined with string in various patterns, which record currents, directions, etc. I could not figure out how they were supposed to work, but they are (or were) important navigational aids.

    The further halls on the Pacific are more anthropologically focused, and include much on Melanesia (islands mostly much closer together, and and thus not presenting the same navigation problems as Polynesia and Micronesia). The exhibit has been modified considerably over the years (some of my favorite bits are gone), and may have been renamed, but last I checked the old “Traveling the Pacific” hall still includes the fascinating material on Polynesian navigation. Well worth a visit if you get a chance.

    GCM

    1. From some past reading I learned that one main feature of those stick maps is that, where most maps are designed to be looked at from a ‘god’s eye view’ looking down at the land and sea, the stick maps are designed to be held in one’s hand and used to orient by looking through the sticks. Where you and I can stand side-by-side and together read a regular map, only one of us — the one holding the stick map — can properly read the stick map.

      Of course, this quickly gets cast as evidence of a kinship with the postmodern turn against objectivity.

  5. My guess is that a careful analysis of the empirically verified discoveries made by indigenous peoples would determine that the discoveries were actually made by what we would regard today as among the methods of Science: hypothesis formation, empirical observation, experimentation, reason, etc. My conjecture is that, when carefully studied, one would conclude that the discoveries weren’t contingent upon “indigenous ways of knowing” at all. Such a conjecture could be tested empirically by studying individual cases.

    Regarding those brave souls who set sail on the open ocean looking for land: How did they overcome the raw fear of venturing out to sea and leaving land behind? Just imagine yourself in a small boat in the open ocean, scanning the 360-degree horizon—a formless field of misty gray—and realizing that you and your mates are completely vulnerable and alone. It’s terrifying just to think about!

    1. Good question. Perhaps the explorers were fleeing bad circumstances. Perhaps they’d lost a battle and faced a grim life at home. Of course you wouldn’t think they’d have time to build the boats if they were fleeing an enemy. Maybe it was a case of hunger or drought.

      1. Well, they would already have had the boats for fishing. But I share your suspicion that they had no other choice but to go to sea.

    2. Issues of motivation and intention may be usefully dealt with by “different ways of knowing”. For one example, having an accepted system of superstitious divination, linked to gods or ancestors or fate or “the universe”, can provide much more confidence than “WTF, let’s go that way.” Even unjustified confidence results in more overall exploration and thus more overall success (and more failures, but they are hardly noticed).

      And trial-and-error is a key methodology in the “modern science” I know best: computer science. One tends to hack around until accumulated failure force one into the painful job of thinking. Joseph Weizenbaum (1923–2008), famous for ELIZA the 1960s ur-chatbot, wrote a masterful chapter on “The Compulsive Programmer” in his opus Computer Power and Human Reason; which among other things discusses why programmers, like gamblers and sailors, tend to be superstitious. It’s available online, and IMO well worth a read.

  6. I feel compelled to ask the obvious question: how did that whale oil and whale song do? Are the trees cured of their affliction?

      1. Designing an experiment to test that hypothesis would be simple. And the experiment would be inexpensive to conduct.

        The problem is that the people promoting indigenous “ways of knowing” are not really interested in the results of experiments, or any other empirical evidence. Any experimental results would be dismissed if they showed that either of the 2 main variables had no effect.

        The type of people ignoring scientific evidence, the scientific method, and science in general in favor of their narratives will never be convinced by empirical evidence. That is why we have flat-earthers, people who believe that the polio vaccine is a sham (and same goes for smallpox!), that pasteurization is harmful, that the sun revolves around the earth, that the university is less than 6000 years old, that sex is a spectrum…..

        Oh, and by the way, I knew a young woman who spent quite a bit of time singing to trees. And just to connect to the Hili dialog, she smoked prodigious amounts of marijuana while doing so: it was miraculous that she didn’t set off any forest fires. She may have been thinking about whales at the time. This was back in the 70s, when marijuana was illegal, but no one in the area really cared.

  7. Whether the knowledge gained is fallible or not, the ability to transit thousands of miles in an open deck canoe is a tremendous achievement. Call it selection, call it skill or both, but first it entailed someone making an observation. When successful, the explanation can be in question, the mechanics may be obscure, but the initial, perhaps serendipitous, observation stands as gained knowledge. Manipulating the observed conditions (hypothesis testing and experimentation in the modern language) then proceeds to lead in a structured way to a desired outcome. Transmitting that information orally is learning. Indigenous knowledge gone scientific.

    I have a favorite quartet of human technologies with ancient roots that might be characterized as indigenous knowledge going scientific: the creation of cement, metallurgy, glass and finally the domestication of fruit trees. The three former technologies rest on one of the best examples of indigenous knowledge, the creation, control and use of fire. The example of fruit tree domestication is a favorite. To create some fruit of defined variety, grafting is a necessity. How did someone realize that taking a branch and splicing it onto another root ball would give a tree that produced an apple? And this process was described nearly 4000 years ago in China. Indigenous knowledge.

    I have no interest in the spiritual or cultural explanations that travel with observationally acquired knowledge, but it is a mistake to dismiss observational approaches since they made our modern world. They are the precursor to the scientific method. To editorialize, in an age of AI and computer augmented everything, the ability of humans to carefully observe and create is being lost.

  8. The “ways of knowing” shtick is the modern version of the noble savage myth. Polynesians extinguished twenty per cent of all the bird species on earth as they expanded across the Pacific. They converted the lush forest of Easter Island into a treeless grassland where giant stone statues lay abandoned in quarries because they had simply run out of logs to roll them into place. The first Maoris arrived at New Zealand in around 1320 – shortly before the sixth college of Oxford University was founded – and proceeded to kill and eat all twelve species of indigenous giant moa birds. For sure, they achieved incredible feats of navigation, but they were also a pre-scientific community of flawed humans. By all means, praise their achievements and learn from their mistakes, but don’t deify their ignorance.

    1. We, however, are a scientific civilisation of flawed humans, who have done (and presumably will continue to do) far more damage than our pre-scientific predecessors.

  9. The unique feature of science is that it evolved methods designed to determine the mechanisms that underlie observations about the world. Certainly humans (and other animals) have used native thought processes to acquire beliefs about the world and even manipulate their environments, some of which might actually be true and work. Otherwise they wouldn’t have survived (some probably didn’t). However, there is nothing culturally unique about these cognitive competencies except perhaps as driven by their context. Indigenous peoples in Mesoamerica bred maize from a native species, but equivalent achievements have been found worldwide, all without any clue as to the underlying mechanisms. Darwin’s first chapter in Origins was “Variation Under Domestication.”

    If it doesn’t violate the rules, here’s a short piece I wrote for Skeptic magazine. Although covered briefly, there is a MASSIVE and very scary literature out there.

    https://www.skeptic.com/article/other-ways-of-knowing-ethno-epistemic-challenges-to-the-universality-of-science/

    1. Thanks. I read this article when it was posted! Completely agree. Particularly about the mechanism part. And those indigenous examples can be important for understanding mechanism, modern applications and improvements. Roman concrete is – to this day – being used as a model for engineers and chemists to improve concrete.

      Explanations in indigenous knowledge are dependent on culture and context. As you point out in your article, the universality of a scientific explanation is an important differentiator from Ethno Epistemic Knowledge.

      Some make the glib criticism that science does not always get the mechanism correctly. True but it will eventually. I know people who are deep into alternative medicines and reject evidence based treatments, vaccines and pharmaceuticals. Most claim that medicine doesn’t have all the answers, is too caught up in its own dogma, which appears to change regularly, claims authority above the patients and hurts as often as it heals.

      I sometimes go to that all purpose repository of knowledge, Saturday Night Live. There is an old Steve Martin skit, Theodoric of York, a barber practicing medicine. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edIi6hYpUoQ Great stuff. Like the barber, Ethno Epistemic Knowledge and its proximity to religion or cultural practice puts up a formidable barrier to change.

  10. It’s important to distinguish not only modern science and indigenous knowledge systems, but also early science, including especially astronomy and associated understanding of geometry. The discovery that the morning star is the same heavenly body as the evening star is a great scientific advance. I think early mathematics is important to the development of Greek and then Islamic science. Pythagorean thought was chock full of mysticism but it contributed to the serious development of mathematics, and to astronomy. The conceptual development that went with the distinction between the “fixed stars” and heavenly bodies whose visual position shifted (the sun, the moon, and the visible planets) is part of the conceptual development leading up to Galileo’s thought, ultimately utilizing optical discoveries.

    1. But the ideological defense of early science is not the same as the ideological defense of indigenous science. The latter is often done to sacralize minoritized groups by calling attention to their “ways of knowing.” The Greeks were certainly not a minoritized group, nor were the early Islamic scientists and mathematicians.

  11. I am in the middle of reading Pathway of the Birds: The Voyaging Achievements of Māori and Their Polynesian Ancestors. Recommended by my cousins as a sensible and accessible approach to Maori navigation. Not sure if you’ve heard of the Tahitian, Tupaia, who accompanied James Cook to NZ. He drew a map that demonstrates his method of navigation, which is similar to that of my ancestors, the Maori.

    I have no doubt that there was much trial and error, and many died along the way, but when you consider the short initial voyages to an island in sight, followed by longer and longer voyages to unseen and unknown islands, what my ancestors did, without instruments, was remarkable. I prefer, however to celebrate known and likely facts, rather than those based on some ideology and I think you would find the above book quite acceptable

  12. My first thought about how people first settled Hawaii was, how did land turtles get to the Galapagos? I don’t think it was intentional.

  13. There is literally a world of difference between 1) repeated, semi-reliable two-way maritime journeying with high tonnage vessels and 2) heroic, occasional, long distance, almost always 1-way oceanic voyaging.
    1) leads to trade and builds up civilisation
    2) is part of the dispersal of homo sapiens across the globe.

    I suggest readers also look at William Dalrymple’s ‘the Golden Road’, which is the best popular account I have seen of Indian voyages to the Middle East, Egypt & South East Asia. From archaeological remains as well as surviving carvings ( eg on the great Javanese Buddhist temple of Borobudur ), these ships ranged from several hundred tonnes upwards. The journeys to Mesopotamia are attested in cuneiform records dating back before 2000 BC.

    The point here is that the development of global civilisation ( incorrectly reduced to ‘Western science’ by Indigenous Ignoramusses and White Wokesters ) depended on the circulation of ideas and physical goods, with tradeable goods available on a regular basis to cultures separated by hundreds to thousands of km. The Mediterranean , and the Persian Gulf-Red Sea-Indian ocean basins were the two central maritime groupings around which two of the three great global hubs of civilisation developed.

    So, how are the Polynesian peoplings of the great Pacific ocean more worthy of celebration than my Denisovan ancestors who walked across the entire Asian landmass, all of it, including up to caves in Tibet in freezing high altitudes?

    The Polynesian voyages to Keyaurastan New Zealand did not lead to reliable two-way communication with their island homelands. There is NIL archaeological evidence of two-way voyaging by Maori or Aussie Aboriginals to each other. Reciprocal voyaging was limited largely to the central Polynesian Islands.

    The Indian voyages to Indonesia brought metalworking and many other technologies as far east as Bali. But the ‘great Polynesian navigators’ do not seem to have voyaged far enough west from their homelands to bring metals, or the important idea of literacy, back to the Polynesian homelands. Which is why these cultures remained, until European colonisation, back in the neolithic era.

    Ramesh 49% Indian 49% Chinese 2% Heroic Denisovan Asiatic land explorers circa 150000 – 30000 BC

    1. And don’t forget the Chinese Treasure Fleet.

      The Polynesians never had empires or cities, just local warlords and villages. There was no need or value to them in long-distance trade. Poul Anderson wrote a sci-fi novel in which the Polynesians do build a global civilisation, after our one destroys itself. But that’s just fiction….

    2. You beat me to it, Ramesh!

      I’m not popular here among my woke NZ friends for asking why, if the traditional navigation and seafaring abilities were so incredible, that no voyages back were attempted in all those centuries? Especially as the Hawaiki homelands are so important that ‘spirits’ are supposed return to there after death.

      Even the short(ish) hop across the Tasman to Australia seems never to have been attempted.

      I, however, stand ready to be proven wrong on both statements, and certainly do find all traditional seafaring and navigation abilities that are documented both fascinating and (for this landlubber) courageous.

      1. Hey Gary,
        presumably a difficulty of reciprocal sailing between Australia and NZ for those with Neolithic technology, are the prevailing winds. ( Indian voyages to the Middle East exploited the fact that the winds shifted from West-East to East-West over the course of the seasons.)

        But here for the entertainment of all is the Keyaurastan New Zealand equivalent of the Antikythera Mechanism : The Sacred Sail.
        https://www.engineeringnz.org/programmes/heritage/engineering-heritage-records/ports-and-shipping/te-ra/

        What readers ought to be alert to is the gratuitous insertion of ‘sophisticated’ in the very first sentence. The rest of this article is a reasonable description.
        So, who can enlighten me on why almost every article on Maori navigational skills includes the specific word ‘sophisticated’, or ‘advanced’, and / or their synonyms Jackson-Pollocked into otherwise bland prose? Is this 18th century sail more ‘sophisticated’ than the nearly 2000 year older Antikythera geared mechanism?

        The irony is that the verbiage-spraying of ‘sophisticated’ onto Polynesian artefacts is endemic in Auckland, which has more ethnic Asians living in it than Maori and Pacific combined, and Auckland University, whose student body is actually 50% Asian. Nobody in Auckland University or Museum management sprays ‘sophisticated’ as a description of the technologies of pre-modern Asia.

  14. Erik the Red sailed to Greenland to found a colony after he was exiled from Iceland for murder. I wonder whether there might have been similar occurrences of Polynesians setting sail into the open sea, unsure what land they might find, owing to trouble at home.

  15. Ramesh and others raise an interesting point: it seems that only the peoples who did not contribute significantly to the advancement of science are held up as worthy for special study. All civilizations have advanced in their own ways, some more than others. While I suppose it’s worth looking at how all of them acquired and codified knowledge from an anthropological point of view, there should also be recognition that some were just plain better than others at doing this. Not equal or in any manner equivalent in terms of knowledge.
    And I’m getting tired of hearing how Māori’s were great stewards of the environment – they destroyed much.

    1. “Better” and “advancing” are carrying a heavy load here. “More”, definitely. And have we been “better” stewards?

  16. “In my view, the spiritual overlay belongs in the realm of anthropology and sociology, while the empirically true and replicable kernel of knowledge should be incorporated into modern science.”

    I learned early in life that striking my thumb with a hammer could cause intense and lingering pain. In what academic discipline should this be taught? It shouldn’t. This form of practical knowledge can be passed on in communities; it can be learned on one’s own; it can be relegated to appropriate vocations. We do not need peer-reviewed journals to validate the knowledge.

    This doesn’t preclude the biologist from studying and explaining the physiology of pain. Nor does it prevent an academic physician from teaching about how to repair any significant damage to the digit. If a given group of people practiced thumb striking as a long-standing social ritual, then the anthropologists could get involved. If it appeared as a fad among kids, then enter the sociologists and psychologists. Legislation to ban thumb striking could excite the political scientists. And were the thumb-striking tribe to write elegies to the master strikers, the literature folks would have something perhaps suited to their taste. None of these academicians would be teaching “thumb striking,” though some might be murdering to dissect.

    We have somehow conflated over time through our disciplinary labels the study of phenomena with the phenomena themselves. That’s understandable given that science is both a practice, long predating the modern academy, and the study of the practice. But the conflation doesn’t confine itself to language. I wonder what myths the anthropologist might be indulging and what fictional fancies the literary specialist might spin as they delight us with various “ways of knowing.”

  17. Isn’t some of this due to confirmation bias? One has to assume that the discovery of any islands was just plain luck. The discoveries are noted, but the sailors who got lost at sea are not. If thousands of voyages occur in different directions, some of them are bound to find something.

    I greatly admire the ability to navigate by the stars on the open ocean, and the fact that this seems a novel method to do so is interesting. I’m not so impressed by the fact that they landed on other islands; I’m much more impressed that they made it back home!

  18. Well there is this:
    “Navigators would hang off the side of the canoe and drag their testicles in the water, sensing temperature and wave movement; or would sit on the bottom of the canoe with their testicles in direct contact with the boat’s hull — the idea being that testicles, as extraordinarily sensitive parts of the anatomy, were the best organs to use to detect the subtlest of movements.”
    eh… yes cold salt water would definitely give you a sensation.

    This is a quote from Brian Dunning’s Skeptoid site Sept 30 2025 and because I’m a aging juvenile I couldn’t help myself… but most likely to me, a certain amount of skill and good luck was at play, possibly a lot of beseeching, chanting as well.
    I know one thing for sure, in the case of New Zealand Aotearoa if they hadn’t been able seafarers I wouldn’t be here typing this.

    https://skeptoid.com/episodes/1008

    it’s a 2 part posting and is an easy read on the subject and as he states,
    “the great pleasure of presenting an episode on a topic that has fascinated me for almost my entire life.”

  19. Somewhat tangential, I just finished “The Traveler” by Andrea Wulf, which covers the travels and observations of Georg(e) Forster, a then-famous, mostly self-taught naturalist, who sailed with Capt. Cook on Cook’s second voyage, which went back and forth across the Pacific 1772-5. In addition to extensive notes on flora and fauna, he apparently made a lot of observations about the Polynesian cultures, languages, etc., and drew some prescient conclusions about their dispersal. (The ~second half of the book focuses more on his personal life and support of Enlightenment ideals and Revolutionary politics, ie, the French Revolution.)
    And while I’m at it, I’d highly recommend Wulf’s The Invention of Nature, about Alexander von Humboldt, a onetime student of Forster….another world famous man during his lifetime, and about whom I knew very little (other than Humboldt County, CA, and the Humboldt squid).

  20. In reply to CR, Humboldt’s significance is recognized in the name of the Humboldt University of Berlin, from the early 19th century. He was very important in the development of education in Europe.

  21. I know that our host doesn’t love the long-form podcast format, but this video essay by @jonkay gives an excellent explanation of one of the most important instances of indigenous ways of knowing and their awful consequences: the social panic about the supposed discovery of the remains of 215 indigenous children in a mass grave at the former Kamloops Indian Residential School.

  22. Suppose you’re the soon-to-be discoverer of Easter Island or Hawaii. You see in the wave patterns clues that tell you that there’s an island in a particular direction. But wouldn’t the wave patterns coming from the continents behind them be far stronger? How could you read the signal from Hawaii when the signal from North America (farther away, yes, but much bigger) would overwhelm it?

  23. It was a great system in going on a set course and back, one storm, however.

    Why much of it was done in a climate phase which was calmer and was done in the even calmer seasons.

  24. About 20 years ago, there was a great exhibition at the National Museum of Australia on the Polynesian colonization of the Pacific. Once you see all the tricks, it morphs from a miraculous achievement to a merely historically impressive one.

    AI reminds me:

    Navigating by the stars.
    Reading ocean swells.
    Observing seabirds.
    Interpreting clouds.
    Recognising floating vegetation and other debris.
    Understanding winds and currents.
    Searching systematically rather than sailing blindly.
    Using large, seaworthy sailing canoes.

    I also remember the technique of exploring against the prevailing winds. While counter-intuitive to the neophyte, it allows an unsuccessful explorer to just do a 180 and sit back for a cruisey ride home. Indeed New Zealand, which is to the southwest and not into the prevailing wind from the first islands found, was colonized last.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *