Mamdani disbands police unit targeting terrorism and violent protests, replaces with unarmed unit using “dialogue” and “deescalation”

November 17, 2026 • 8:00 am

Yep, Mamdani is keeping his campaign promises in a way that is delighting Democratic Socialists, for it amounts to disbanding the police—at least a police unit dedicated to fighting terrorism and violent protests. Hizzoner couches it as a step forward and a fulfillment of his pledge, but what it will amount to is giving license to terrorism and violent protests, whose participants know that the cops won’t be there. What’s worse is that Mamdani’s plan is to stop the protests and terrorism with DIALOGUE and DE-ESCALATION instead of cops.  Yes, maybe that will work on rare occasions but it’s best to have the copes on hand, too.  I am sure that, in light of protests we’ve seen in the last five years, you know how well dialogue and de-escalation will work.

I woke up to find the video below of the Mayor’s announcement, sent by reader Jay, who added, “It took me the longest time to figure out that this wasn’t parody.”  And indeed, the whole thing, including the handshake at the end, shouts “parody.” It’s stiff, overscripted and, to me, scary. But it isn’t parody!!

The NYT and Free Press have different takes on this, of course, with the NYT giving a more neutral take but also adding the approval of the Democratic Socialists of America, of which Mamdani is one, while the Free Press is more op-ed-ish (I agree with their take). Below are excerpts from both sides.

From the NYT (click to read or find the article archived here).

At 6:59 a.m. on Monday, Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a social media video to announce that he was disbanding the Strategic Response Group, a specialized police unit that has been criticized for its handling of protests.

The video was a 102-second victory lap, with Mamdani adopting a mission-accomplished tone for fulfilling a campaign vow.

But then his administration’s messaging got more complicated.

Roughly an hour later, Mr. Mamdani appeared again, this time with his police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, giving a more nuanced presentation to WABC-TV that sought to reassure New Yorkers that the changes would not make New York less safe.

. . . In its cautious approach in announcing the changes, the Mamdani administration seemed to acknowledge the potential volatility of doing anything that revamps Police Department protocol. Indeed, city leaders, police unions and activists were sharply divided over how the changes would affect clashes between officers and demonstrators.

Under the new plan, civilians from the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety would act as the first line of communication with protesters. They would create a dialogue with demonstrators with the goal of de-escalating tension before it can erupt into violence.

I can imagine how effective a group of unarmed officials in civilian clothes will be in “de-escalating tension” like the stuff we saw recently in European demonstrations! “Please, stop the looting and burning. It is hurting your fellow New Yorkers!”  But I digress. More from the NYT:

“This will not be a uniformed police unit,” Mr Mamdani said. “It will be made up of civilians without weapons or arrest powers.”

The civilians would work with 30 officers in a new unit known as the First Amendment Support Team. They will be trained in communication and de-escalation, as well as crowd management.

A new patrol unit of trained officers would make arrests “in rare instances, if necessary,” according to a statement from the mayor’s office. That unit would also take on other responsibilities that once fell to the Strategic Response Group, such as searching for missing people, patrolling major events like the Thanksgiving Day parade and responding to large-scale crime scenes.

“There will be no long guns, tear gas, kettling or pepper spray used as crowd control tactics,” said Chi Ossé, a New York City Council member who appeared in the video with Mr. Mamdani and who previously had introduced legislation known as the CURB Act, which aimed to restrict the Strategic Response Group’s tactics.

. . . In a statement, the Democratic Socialists hailed the mayor’s announcement as a “victory” and “historic.”

“The S.R.G. and its predecessors are violent teams that for decades have suppressed the people’s constitutional right to protest and organize,” the statement said.

. . . .Vincent Vallelong, president of the [police] sergeants’ union, noted in a statement that officers in the group were at Gracie Mansion in March, when, during a protest by right-wing agitators, two men tried to throw homemade bombs into the crowd.

“I fear this approach will embolden violent agitators to infiltrate peaceful demonstrations, putting protesters, police and bystanders at risk,” Sergeant Vallelong said.

. . . . The decision also divided members of the City Council. While Mr. Ossé and other progressive members hailed the changes, Joann Ariola, a councilwoman representing Howard Beach, said the mayor was appeasing his base at the expense of New Yorkers’ safety.

“When bridges are blocked and streets are overrun with agitators,” she wrote on social media, “who is going to keep New Yorkers safe?”

Indeed.  Who? Will discussion and de-escalation stop rioting? When the Democratic Socialists praise something like this, you have to be suspicious, just as you had to be suspicious when a spokesman for the Muslim Brotherhood applauded El-Sayed’s election in Michigan.  And the last question is one echoed by the Free Press article (click if you have a subscription), which is, as expected, quite critical. The author was a federal prosecutor in Brooklyn for a decade. Click below.

An excerpt:

For over a decade, I served as a federal prosecutor in Brooklyn, where I prosecuted terrorists, including ISIS fighters and those who tried to help them. It taught me something most New Yorkers never have to think about: A crowd is an opportunity for people who mean to do harm. I saw firsthand how protests can be infiltrated by criminals and terrorists who use the cover of peaceful demonstrators to carry out violence.

That is why Mayor Mamdani’s decision yesterday to disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG) alarms me.

The SRG is the department’s specialized unit trained and equipped to stop violence and terrorism at protests. The mayor is replacing 500 highly trained uniformed officers with three new de-escalation teams made up of unarmed civilians and backup patrol cops authorized to make arrests at protests only “in rare instances.” The changes will take effect by spring—just as the weather warms and protest season returns.

In a statement announcing the disbandment, the mayor said, “New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat.” To be sure, peaceful protesters deserve respect. But he’s missing the point. Protests are dynamic. They can turn from speech to violence in seconds, and when they do, we need highly trained officers ready to handle it.

We have seen what happens when they are not. The SRG’s predecessor, the Disorder Control Unit, was created after the 1991 Crown Heights riots in Brooklyn, when a state investigation found the NYPD unprepared and ill-equipped as three days of violence tore through the neighborhood. The city learned that lesson the hard way. It should not have to learn it again.

We are trading a tested unit for an untested promise.

Today, the threat of civil unrest is still very real. We have seen protests in this city that have turned violent—smashed windows, burning buses, physical assaults. In 2020, two attorneys threw a Molotov cocktail into an NYPD vehicle during a protest in Brooklyn. In March of this year, two men accused of being ISIS supporters threw homemade bombs at a protest outside Gracie Mansion. And look at what is happening abroad in France: More than half a million people took to the streets, enraged over the cost of living, and parts of the demonstrations descended into arson and looting.

Most protesters are peaceful. But it takes only a few people determined to commit violence, and the city needs a force ready to stop them.

. . .Dialogue teams don’t stand a chance against criminals. Just hours after Mamdani announced he would disband the SRG, two unarmed peace officers were shot while conducting a wellness check in the Bronx. The man who shot them didn’t want to have a dialogue. Neither do terrorists. That leaves the backup patrol cops. They may receive crowd-management training, but they will be hamstrung with new restrictions when facing down criminals who know that resisting arrest and assaulting a cop are no longer prosecuted with seriousness. Moreover, it will be a part-time assignment for officers who spend most of their time on patrol, and it is being stood up from scratch. We are trading a tested unit for an untested promise.

The most immediate effect of the decision to disband the SRG is the message it sends—it emboldens those determined to wreak havoc on our streets. Criminals will be more likely to commit violence knowing that there will be no one there equipped to stop them.

The article discusses the people who will be hurt by this decision, including peaceful protestors who may have agitators embedded in them, religious people like the many Jews who have been attacked in New York or were victims of hate crimes (see below the fold), owners of bodegas and small businesses who get attacked and looted during protests (try discussing looters out of looting!), and commuters and bystanders whose lives are disrupted by non-peaceful protests.  Author Komatireddy ends this way:

None of this is to say that every protest has been handled perfectly. Where there are specific instances of misconduct or excessive force, they should be investigated. And a discussion about methods and tactics is important for addressing legitimate concerns and ensuring all New Yorkers—including peaceful protesters—feel protected. But dismantling the entire apparatus creates a violence free-for-all. That is a step too far.

The mayor’s decision—to disband SRG rather than improve it—makes New York less safe. You can almost picture the press releases: Officials will condemn the inevitable violence that follows, calling it “random” and “senseless” when it is actually predictable and preventable. As always, it’s the innocent, hardworking New Yorkers who will pay the price.

My first thought when I heard Mamdani’s announcement was that this will hearten antisemitic and pro-Palestinian protestors who intend to hurt Jews or for whom hurting Jews is a likely outcome.  As you should know, anti-Jewish hate crimes are far more frequent than anti-black or anti-Muslim hate crimes. I’ve put the data for NYC below, and you can see that more than 52% of all hate crime incidents in New York City, more than 52% to 57% of them were against Jews: more than all other hate crimes combined. I’ve put in the references below (you can click on the two links), and my question to Grok is in bold.

In the last year, how many anti-Jewish hate crimes were committed in NYC versus anti-Black hate crimes and anti-Muslim hate crimes?
Grok’s answer:

In calendar year 2025 (the most recent full year with complete NYPD data), there were 330 reported anti-Jewish hate crime incidents in New York City, compared with 45 anti-Black and 30 anti-Muslim incidents, out of 576 total hate crime incidents.

These figures come from NYPD data released in early January 2026 and have been consistently reported across multiple outlets citing the same official numbers. Anti-Jewish incidents accounted for about 57% of the total (more than all other categories combined), despite Jewish New Yorkers representing roughly 10% of the city’s population. Overall hate crimes fell about 12% from 657 in 2024, and anti-Jewish incidents were down about 3% from 339 the prior year.

But it’s not just Jews who will suffer, though I’m sure that was on Mamdani’s mind when he announced this. The other groups will, too, especially small store owners who can lose their livelihood, as they did in the recent Paris riots.  What was Mamdani thinking when he made this bonehead decision?  To enact a defunding of the police, I think, as well as to satisfy his DSA supporters, and to give a big middle finger to Jews and those who think that the police are essential, especially in these troubled times.  Those people who voted for Mamdani, especially the Jews, are going to get what they deserve. And Democrats who endorse him will eventually regret their decision.

 

Here are three responses.  First, a direct message that arrived from my friend, U of C neurobiologist Peggy Mason (she is Jewish), right as I was writing this. She had independently read about Mamdani’s announcement and contacted me (we’re both up early, though she’s in British Columbia). Her words are redacted to protect the sensitive, and the quote is with permission.

I’m so disgusted. New Yorkers are going to learn the consequences of their election in a very painful way and I hope those f—–g do gooder Jews who voted for him feel really f——g bad.

Second, a tweet following the video above:

The Babylon Bee had its usual sarcastic take. (Click below to read.)

“We’re spending millions to address a problem that doesn’t exist,” said Mamdani. “New York City has never experienced any sort of terrorism before, leaving this police force with literally nothing to do. This is exactly the kind of government waste that we are wanting to target. New Yorkers want to know that their tax dollars are being spent on actual problems that have plagued the city, such as a lack of city-owned grocery stores selling government cheese.”

Asked whether he might be overlooking a significant event in the city’s history, Mamdani dismissed the suggestion.

“If something like that had happened here, surely someone would have told us to never forget it,” he said. “So either it never happened, or people forgot. Either way, it’s clearly not a big deal to New Yorkers.”

At publishing time, Mamdani had also disbanded the Central Park police unit, citing the fact that nothing bad had ever happened there.

Click “read more” to see Grok’s answer to my question about the relative frequency of demonstrations against Israel versus those against Hamas/Palestine.

My question

How many anti-Israel protests have occurred in New York City this year as opposed to anti-Hamas or anti-Palestinian protests?
Grok’s answer:

No precise official total count exists for either category in New York City for 2026. Public sources (news reports, ADL tracking of related incidents, Wikipedia summaries of Gaza-related protests, and local coverage) do not provide a comprehensive year-to-date tally of all street protests, campus actions, or rallies by topic.

Anti-Israel / pro-Palestinian protests

These have been frequent and ongoing throughout 2026, often organized by groups such as Students for Justice in Palestine chapters, Within Our Lifetime, Palestinian Youth Movement, Jewish Voice for Peace, and others. They commonly feature Palestinian flags, chants such as “globalize the intifada,” “from the river to the sea,” “Israel will fall,” and “resistance is justified,” and in some cases Hamas or Hezbollah flags/imagery. Documented examples include:

  • Multiple events around the October 7 anniversary (e.g., 100+ at Washington Square Park/NYU, dozens at Columbia, ~125 outside City Hall, and hundreds disrupting a vigil in Union Square).
  • Hundreds during Netanyahu’s UN General Assembly visit in September (including a sit-in with ~100+ arrests).
  • Nakba Day-related actions in May and a recent “Day of Rage” on Veterans Day (under 100 participants marching from Hunter College).
  • Other reported gatherings of ~500 with Palestinian flags and some Hamas/Hezbollah symbols in Manhattan.

Campus and street actions have continued at a lower intensity than the 2023–2024 peak in some reports, but dozens of such events are referenced across the year. Early national data from late 2023 showed pro-Palestinian events outnumbering pro-Israel ones by roughly 5-to-1; that disparity in frequency has persisted in NYC coverage.

Anti-Hamas / anti-Palestinian or pro-Israel protests

These have been less frequent and more episodic. They typically involve Israeli flags, calls against antisemitism or specific policies, support for hostages/victims of October 7, or opposition to figures like Mayor Zohran Mamdani on related issues. Examples include:

  • A large rally of “thousands upon thousands” supporting Israel at Dag Hammarskjöld Plaza.
  • Major Jewish community rallies against antisemitism near the UN (hundreds of participants) during the General Assembly period.
  • An ~200-person rally on the Upper West Side against rising antisemitism and Mamdani’s views following a stabbing incident near a synagogue.
  • Smaller counter-protests with Israeli flags at vigils or anti-Israel events, plus commemorative Oct. 7 events.

Overall pattern

Anti-Israel/pro-Palestinian protests have been substantially more numerous and regular in NYC this year, while pro-Israel or anti-Hamas gatherings have been fewer but sometimes larger for major organized events. This matches broader post-October 7 trends nationally. NYPD data shows Jews (about 12% of the city’s population) accounted for ~53% of confirmed hate crimes year-to-date in 2026 (279 incidents), with antisemitic incidents remaining elevated.

Exact numbers are hard to pin down because many smaller or campus events are not centrally tracked, definitions of “anti-Israel” vs. “pro-Palestinian” or “anti-Hamas” can vary, and official permit/arrest data is not broken out by cause in publicly summarized form. For the most detailed incident tracking related to antisemitism at protests, sources like the ADL’s reports are the primary reference.

Based on the hate-crime data, I’m guessing that second kind of protest is of course less violent on average than the first.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *