I am doing non-website writing today, and not much is going on in the world, but I do have some heavier pieces to discuss in the next few days. But why not start off the year with a song—or two?
The Bob Marley hit “One Love” was called “One Love/People Get Ready” when issued in 1977, combining the Marley title with that of the famous Curtis Mayfield song. But there is little Mayfield in the Marley song—just enough to force Marley give it a composite title according to copyright law. Both songs, however, are masterpieces, and both are religious.
Wikipedia gives the backstory for Marley’s double title.
The famous version of “One Love” that appears on their album Exodus was recorded in 1977 for Island Records under the title of “One Love/People Get Ready”. This version credits Curtis Mayfield (as Island Records wanted to avoid copyright problems), and it gives co-authorship credits to both Marley and Mayfield as it contains an interpolation of the Impressions‘ song “People Get Ready“, written by Mayfield. As the main artist, Marley and his group were credited as Bob Marley and the Wailers. It was not released as a single until 16 April 1984, to promote the forthcoming greatest hits album Legend. However, the single became one of his biggest hits and has been included on many of Marley and the Wailers subsequent compilation albums. The original recording of the song does not credit Mayfield’s song and is simply titled “One Love”; this is because copyright law was not enforced for Jamaican recordings at this time. The original song was published in the key of B♭ major, but it has since been transposed so it is in the key of C major.
Here is the famous version of the Marley song, recorded on June 3, 1977. It is a work of genius, marred for me only by the toy-piano-like introduction, which even sounds a bit off key. When I listen to Marley, I always remember that he died at only 36, of metastatic skin cancer that he could have prevented by having his big toe amputated. (He refused.) It’s sad but futile to think about what musical paths he would have traversed had he just allowed the doctors to sever his toe.
I forgot that Greg posted this song two years ago, so go back and see his comments But you should definitely listen to it.
Below: The Marley lyrics. When I read the above, I played the Mayfield song back in my mind and tried to remember which bits of Marley could have been lifted from “People Get Ready”. I remembered one line (the third bolded line below), but when I listened to “People Get Ready” after several Mayfield-less years, I discovered four bits of “One Love” that Marley took from “People Get Ready”. They are all in bold, and you can hear the Mayfield song below. They don’t constitute word-for-word plagiarism except for the third bolded line—the one I rememberd:
[Chorus]
One love, one heart
Let’s get together and feel alright
Hear the children cryin’ (One love)
Hear the children cryin’ (One heart)
Sayin’, “Give thanks and praise to the Lord and I will feel alright”
Sayin’, “Let’s get together and feel alright, woah-woah-woah-woah”[Verse 1]
Let them all pass all their dirty remarks (One love)
There is one question I’d really love to ask (One heart)
Is there a place for the hopeless sinners
Who has hurt all mankind just to save his own beliefs?[Chorus]
One love (What about the one heart?), one heart (What about the—)
Let’s get together and feel alright (As it was in the beginning)
One love (So shall it be in the end), one heart (Alright)
Give thanks and praise to the Lord and I will feel alright
Let’s get together and feel alright, one more thing[Verse 2]
Let’s get together to fight this Holy Armagiddyon (One love)
So when the Man comes, there will be no, no doom (One song)
Have pity on those whose chances grows thinner
There ain’t no hiding place from the Father of Creation, singing[Chorus]
One love (What about the one heart?), one heart (What about the—)
Let’s get together and feel alright (I’m pleadin’ to mankind)
One love (Oh, Lord), one heart (Woah)
Give thanks and praise to the Lord and I will feel alright
Let’s get together and feel alright
Give thanks and praise to the Lord and I will feel alright
Let’s get together and feel alright
. . . and Mayfield’s song, (he wrote it), released in 1965—the same year Marley recorded the first version of “One Love”. It’s a beautiful song although a kind of religious hymn. From Wikipedia:
In 2021, Rolling Stone named “People Get Ready” the 122nd greatest song of all time. The song was included in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s 500 Songs that Shaped Rock and Roll. “People Get Ready” was named as one of the Top 10 Best Songs of All Time by Mojo music magazine, and was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1998. In 2015, the song was selected for preservation in the National Recording Registry due to its “cultural, historic, or artistic significance”. Martin Luther King Jr. named the song the unofficial anthem of the Civil Rights Movement and often used the song to get people marching or to calm and comfort them.
Prince (Rogers Nelson) also died after refusing an operation. He had one or both bad hips and really needed hip replacement in order to keep up his vigorous performances. But he was a Jehovas Witness and when he found out that the operation would require that blood products be used, he said No, can’t do that, I’ll take pain relief instead, and then he accidentally OD’d on what was suspected to be something sourced from ‘the street’.
Prince gave everything for music. His shows were huge productions and he would not perform sitting down – he HAD to dance. He donated 100s of 1000s dollars towards instruments for school music programs. He should be remembered for these things above all, in my opinion. He was also weird and a bit difficult, but primarily he was a great and dedicated entertainer who was never weird or difficult with his fans.
I have a serious question for Mr. Coyne. Should I post Email addresses for FFRF (Dan and Annie)? I have them, but I am not sure if I should post them. Would posting them be doxxing?
Their email addresses are available right on the FFRF website.
Yes, their addresses are public. I didn’t give them, but you can find them by Googling. If they weren’t public I would consider giving them out as unacceptable doxxing.
I would still like to put a layer of privacy for them simply by asking you not to post them on this site. But anybody can find them, they just have to do so themselves–via Google. I get emails all the time (lately, many of them hateful) from people who Google my email, and I have no qualms about them finding me. My email is public. (I do mind the hate!)
Done
Good music for the morning. Thanks for the post.
Very sad about Bob Marley — a victim of his own misapprehensions and, of course, of “alternative medicine”. Also, as Tim noted above, Prince might have done better if his religious beliefs had allowed plausible medical intervention.
That is a great reggae song.
I must confess that reggae music in general does not interest me much, as it seems stuck on always having the same sort of backbeat in the background.
One thing that strikes me is that although I can follow a beat in a non-reggae song (I think this is ska, though I may be wrong), the beat in a song like this seems very hard to follow, and if I were asked to play guitar to such a song, I’d find it hard.
I think it’s the emphasis on the first and the third beat for a drummer, bass drum on 1, snare on three. But guitar and keys are on the 2nd and 4th. All of which makes you wanna jump… or back and forward nod 😊
To me it has a kind of swing.
Thanks for posting this on New Years, Jerry. When I woke up I felt I should play some special music, but couldn’t decide what to put on. You came up with the perfect choice. Going to put it on now.
There is a great IMO version of “People get Ready” by Rod Stewart & Jeff Beck. Becks’ guitar contribution is a major part on the recorded rendition and make it for me.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yC_j_dzkaVE
I really like reggae it’s a great “feel” to play and makes you want to just move.
Here downunder, Bob Marley and the Wailers were the vanguard of reggae Jimmy Ciff is in there too, love the IThrees BM&tW female b/v trio.
That said, the Trojan recordings (Jamaican recording label) of multiple artist has got it all, from ska, rock steady, reggae. Easy listening with lots of cover tunes and instrumentals.
Not everyone’s cup of tea but there you go.
IIRC and I don’t know if it’s true, but reggae derived from ska, reason being ska had too fast tempos for the hot climes of Jamaica.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9l391SUuiXw&pp=ygUKI2RqYm94c2V0cw%3D%3D
That Beck/Stewart version is wonderful and yes, Beck’s contribution is what makes it wonderful.
https://x.com/Evolutionistrue/status/1874487109706477791 🐱🎶
https://youtu.be/3Uo0JAUWijM
Here is ABBA’s “New Year Song”. 🇸🇪🎶✨
https://x.com/Evolutionistrue/status/1874487109706477791 🐱🎶
https://youtu.be/m_LqF54RY40
Here is a Japanese “New Year Song”. 🇯🇵🎍🎶