Unless I get ambitious this Christmas Eve, today’s Hili dialogue will be truncated. But first, Merry Christmas, the day on which Baby Jesus was supposedly born and, more important, Happy Coynezaa, of which today is the first day, extending through the day that Professor Ceiling Cat (Emeritus) was really born: December 30.
SO. . . . MERRY CHRISTMAS, HAPPY COYNEZAA, AND CHAPPY CHANUKAH!
. . . AND SEND IN YOUR PHOTOS OF CHRISTMAS MOGGIES (ONE CAT PHOTO PER CUSTOMER)
Because I prepare the Hili dialogues largely on the afternoon before they’re posted, I’m taking a Christmas break today; the Hili dialogue for tomorrow, then, will be very short. I do my best.
Welcome to a Hump Day (“aho ‘o e hump” in Tongan) Wednesday, December 25, 2024, Note that Jesus’s birth is not noted under notable birthdays in Wikipedia, showing that the editors are atheists. But it is the birthday of Isaac Newton, Clara Barton, and Rod Serling.
It’s also National Pumpkin Pie Day, an estimable but not world-class dessert.
Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the December 25 Wikipedia page.
Da Nooz:
*Shoot me now! Trump wants the U.S. to take over the Panama Canal after he takes office, and also to buy Greenland, even though the former now belongs to Panama and the latter to Denmark! (archived here):
Over the past two days, President-elect Donald J. Trump has made clear that he has designs for American territorial expansion, declaring that the United States has both security concerns and commercial interests that can best be addressed by bringing the Panama Canal and Greenland under American control or outright ownership.
Mr. Trump’s tone has had none of the trolling jocularity that surrounded his repeated suggestions in recent weeks that Canada should become America’s “51st state,” including his social media references to the country’s beleaguered prime minister as “Governor Justin Trudeau.”
Instead, while naming a new ambassador to Denmark — which controls Greenland’s foreign and defense affairs — Mr. Trump made clear on Sunday that his first-term offer to buy the landmass could, in the coming term, become a deal the Danes cannot refuse.
He appears to covet Greenland both for its strategic location at a time when the melting of Arctic ice is opening new commercial and naval competition and for its reserves of rare earth minerals needed for advanced technology.
“For purposes of National Security and Freedom throughout the World,” Mr. Trump wrote on social media, “the United States of America feels that the ownership and control of Greenland is an absolute necessity.”
On Saturday evening, he had accused Panama of price-gouging American ships traversing the canal, and suggested that unless that changed, he would abandon the Jimmy Carter-era treaty that returned all control of the canal zone to Panama.
“The fees being charged by Panama are ridiculous,” he wrote, just ahead of an increase in the charges scheduled for Jan. 1. “This complete ‘rip-off’ of our country will immediately stop.”
He went on to express worry that the canal could fall into the “wrong hands,” an apparent reference to China, the second-largest user of the canal. A Hong Kong-based firm controls two ports near the canal, but China has no control over the canal itself.
Not surprisingly, the government of Greenland immediately rejected Mr. Trump’s demands, as it did in 2019, when he first floated the idea. “Greenland is ours,” Prime Minister Mute B. Egede said in a statement. “We are not for sale and will never be for sale. We must not lose our long struggle for freedom.”
If Trump wasn’t serious, this would be funny. Actually, it is funny, because I doubt he’ll succeed in either endeavor.
*There’s a company that ranks the credibility of news sites, and it’s in trouble with conservatives:
Since 2018, NewsGuard has built a business offering advertisers nonpartisan assessments of online publishers — backed by a team of journalists who assess which sites are reputable and which can’t be trusted. It uses a slate of nine standard criteria, such as whether a site corrects errors or discloses its ownership and financing, to produce a zero to 100 percent rating.
Crovitz, a former publisher of the Wall Street Journal and a Republican, and Brill, a left-tending independent who founded Court TV and the American Lawyer magazine, engaged with publishers wanting to understand subpar ratings, sometimes wrangling for hours by phone over the details of a site’s correction policy.
But conservatives now question the company’s premise. Brendan Carr, President-elect Donald Trump’s pick to lead the Federal Communications Commission, accused the company of facilitating a “censorship cartel,” in a November letter to leading tech platforms. Noting that key legal protections depend on tech executives operating “in good faith,” Carr continued: “It is in this context that I am writing to obtain information about your work with one specific organization — the Orwellian named NewsGuard.”
You can find the NewsGuard site here, and here’s its rankings. It’s by no means a sharp separation between liberal and conservative sites.
*400,000 children came to America illegally as immigrants, let in along with their parents, and are studying in American colleges and universities. Some are classified as “Dreamers” under an eponymous Congressional act that never past. Some were allowed in under Obama’s DACA program, and thus are allowed to live and work here legally, but DACA does not permit permanent residency, and the status must be renewed every two years. All of these people now face deportation under Trump:
When Oscar Silva graduated from the University of North Texas in May, he proudly walked across the stage to claim his bachelor’s diploma.
Many of his fellow graduates went on to well-paying jobs, but Silva couldn’t launch a career with his accounting and economics degrees because he lacked legal status in the U.S. Instead, the 24-year-old Mexican immigrant enrolled in a master’s degree program, hoping to buy time for Congress to legalize him and thousands of other so-called Dreamers who came to the U.S. as children without authorized status.
Then Donald Trump was elected to a second term as president, vowing to deport millions of immigrants who are living in the U.S. unlawfully. “I had a mental breakdown,” Silva said. “I thought all of my work was for nothing and I immediately started crying.”
Silva is one of more than 400,000 students in American colleges without permanent legal status whose futures hang in limbo as they await what Trump has pledged to be the largest deportation program in U.S. history. Transition officials, including incoming border czar Tom Homan, have publicly started to narrow the effort’s scope to focus primarily on gang members, fugitives and those with criminal histories. Still, Homan recently has reinforced his intention of mass arrests. “If you’re in the country illegally, you’ve got a problem,” he said in a CNN interview Wednesday.
At-risk students are scrambling to learn their rights, making plans to go underground if necessary and—just in case—contacting distant relatives in home countries they barely remember should they end up being sent there.
Even the roughly 100,000 current students eligible for temporary protection from deportation under President Barack Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, fear that the program could be ended by the courts. Silva is among the majority of Dreamer students without that protection.
If there’s any group that should be allowed to stay, it is this one, for these people came to the U.S. as children and life here is all they’ve ever known. I’m hoping Trump will see reason and not dump them back in the countries where they came from—countries where they did not grow up. It would be inhumane.
*Abigail Shrier was demonized for writing her first book, Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters. Now, as the Free Press editors point out, “Abigail Shrier was vilified. Now she’s been vindicated.” (archived here)
In working on the book, Shrier found that the claims that daughters could be, and should be, turned into sons was reckless, and that transgender medicine was functioning more like a cult than a scientifically based specialty. The truth of what she revealed has been comprehensively substantiated.
She documented how devastated parents were lied to and coerced. A favorite tactic of gender clinicians was to tell parents that if they didn’t consent to life-altering treatments with a long list of side effects, including sterility, their girls were likely to commit suicide. Parents were routinely asked, “Would you rather have a dead daughter or a live son?”
This kind of rhetoric was not limited to fringe activists pushing an extremist agenda. Over the past decade, it became the standard trope—from human rights organizations, to the legacy press, to the Democratic Party. President Biden himself declared: “Affirming a transgender child’s identity is one of the best things a parent, teacher, or doctor can do to help keep children from harm.” Numerous federal documents encouraged medical intervention.
All this is how the transition of minors came to be seen as a necessity that could not be questioned. Those who dared challenge this orthodoxy risked social and professional ostracism.
Which is exactly what happened to Abigail Shrier.
Remember this from the ACLU’s LGBTQ+ director?
Shrier was right about social contagion but especially about the possible danger of medical transition for people before puberty. Her are some of the changes in treatment that have occurred since Shrier’s book:
A few encouraging developments:
- This month, the UK Health Secretary announced an “indefinite ban” on puberty blockers—a pharmaceutical intervention that prevents normal puberty. He said it was “a scandal” that this intervention was given to “vulnerable young children without the proof that it is safe or effective.”
- England’s Gender Identity Development Service, based in London’s Tavistock clinic, was closed this year after investigations revealed it provided quick medicalization and inadequate mental health care. The Cass Review, commissioned by England’s National Health Service to examine the quality of youth transition medicine, reported this year that “The reality is we have no good evidence on the long-term outcomes of interventions to manage gender-related distress.”
- In 2021, Arkansas became the first U.S. state to restrict youth gender transition. Today, just over half the states do so. The Biden administration and the ACLU brought suit against Tennessee to strike its ban, and in early December the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments on the case. At that oral argument, in response to questioning by Justice Samuel Alito about the allegedly high rates of suicide among gender-dysphoric youth, Chase Strangio, arguing for the ACLU, essentially blew up the suicide narrative that has been used to frighten so many parents. Strangio told Alito that “completed suicide, thankfully and admittedly, is rare.” (It’s widely expected the justices will decide in Tennessee’s favor.)
- For the most part, the legacy press either demonized, or largely ignored, Shrier’s work. But because she dared to go first, years later it is discovering this scandal for itself. New York Times opinion writer Pamela Paul has published tough pieces about the state of gender medicine. The Washington Post just editorialized about the Tennessee Supreme Court case that the “failure to adequately assess these treatments gives Tennessee reason to worry about them—and legal room to restrict them.”
More will come. Eventually, when we know the medical and psychological outcomes of transitioning before puberty, then we can begin to make the rules.
*This is one reason I oppose religion, for, at least for the Abrahamic faiths, they harbor a combination of conviction about the absolute truth, a moral code, and the idea that unless you obey that code, you will suffer eternal damnation, while if you obey it you play harps on a cloud (or get 72 virgins). This more or less prompts people—and people who often have a genuine concern for others—to try to convert them, or at least proselytize. And that’s the subject of a new AP article, “NFL players who use platform to share their faith say it’s their duty to spread their love of Jesus,”
Jake Bates was standing on the turf in his hometown of Houston when asked to reflect on an unlikely journey from learning how to sell bricks to making game-winning kicks for the Detroit Lions.
Bates used his platform as an NFL player to spread his love of Jesus in a prime-time interview on NBC after lifting the Lions to a win over the Texans with a 52-yard field goal as time expired.
A month later, Bates told The Associated Press it is a duty to share his Christian faith.
“This doesn’t happen without Jesus and by this, I mean any of this, like, living doesn’t happen without Jesus dying on the cross,” Bates said recently at the team’s practice facility. “He put us on a stage to glorify his name.”
The NFL is filled with players and coaches who feel the same way.
Quarterbacks C.J. Stroud of Houston, Kirk Cousins of Atlanta and Lamar Jackson of Baltimore along with Ravens coach John Harbaugh are among the many in the league who speak publicly about their Christian beliefs.v
. . . . Cousins has professed his faith publicly, dating back to his college years at Michigan State and continuing in the NFL with Washington, Minnesota and the Falcons.
“We all have a platform,” Cousins said earlier this month. “We all try to steward it the best we can. I just want to be able to give a reason to people who ask for the hope that I have.
Although Christianity is the dominate religion at all levels of the sport, some Jewish and Muslim players have also used their platform to publicly share their faith. Recently, for example, Jake Retzlaff became the first Jewish quarterback to play for Brigham Young University, the Utah private school run by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He has embraced his role as an ambassador of Judaism in football.
Oy! A proseltytizing Jew. They are rare except for some ultra-Orthodox Jews, as we chosen people try to make it hard to join the club. I don’t know exactly how Retzlaff spreads his faith, but some rabbi should tell him to knock it off. Here’s a bit from another AP article:
Retzlaff, 21, has embraced becoming an ambassador for his faith in college football and in a state where only 0.2% of residents are Jewish. The redshirt junior wears a silver Star of David necklace on campus and attends dinners on Shabbat, the Jewish day of rest, at the rabbi’s house during the offseason.
He led Utah County’s first public Hanukkah menorah lighting last year at Provo’s historic courthouse, brought a kosher food truck to a team weight training and wrapped tefillin with Zippel in the BYU stadium. The tefillin ritual performed by Jewish men involves strapping black boxes containing Torah verses to the arm and forehead as a way of connecting to God.
That is not as bad as I thought, but it still goes over the line, as Retzlaff pushes his faith on non-Jews. But why did he go to BYU?
Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili and Szaron strike a Christmas pose:
A: What are you doing?Hili: We are posing.Szaron: Speak for yourself.
Ja: Co robicie?Hili: Pozujemy.Szaron: Mów za siebie.
And baby Kulka posing with a poinsettia. Malgorzata has the story here:
A picture of Kulka with a Christmas flower we got from Jola (our home help). She fully accepts our atheism but she can’t stand a home without absolutely anything “Christmassy”. So every year she comes with something which shows that this is Christmas time. I think it’s very touching.
*******************
From Cat Memes:
From Cole & Marmalade:
And a Christmas dinner centerpiece, just right for eating after you’ve opened your presents under the Chanukah Bush (from Rivka):
Masih appears closed for the holidays, so here’s a post by Emma Hilton:
I love it when someone kindly informs me that I’m “beginning to ask the right questions” regarding the (useless) “bimodal model”. 😂
I mean, Maggie can’t answer the questions, but Maggie doesn’t care about that. https://t.co/Ol2Cv5x7Z8
— Emma Hilton (@FondOfBeetles) December 23, 2024
From The Pinkah: He mentions his newest book and highlights a Substack articke by Yasha Mounk highlighting the hypocrisy of BlueSky, something that I’ve noticed:
The Cruelty Is the Point: Why Bluesky, no less than X, has become an arena of aggressive mobbing. [Note that I discuss social-media mobbing in my forthcoming book on common knowledge, When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows….”] https://t.co/A3FgHbdylZ
— Steven Pinker (@sapinker) December 20, 2024
From Norman: an ice menorah—from Siberia!
Siberia pic.twitter.com/mqmkevMCaG
— Mossad Commentary (@MOSSADil) December 24, 2024
From God via Simon:
It's hard to book a party for My son's birthday because it happens to fall on Christmas.
From Malcolm, interspecies love:
Puppy chose cat as his best friend..🐶🐾🐈❤️ pic.twitter.com/hsxAJLNOIC
— 𝕐o̴g̴ (@Yoda4ever) December 7, 2024
From the Auschwitz Memorial, one that I posted:
A Czech man sent to Auschwitz. He survived 17 months but died shortly before liberation.
— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2024-12-25T11:09:38.151Z
Two tweets from Dr. Cobb; the first shows that 600 years ago people sequestered extra snowballs:
snowball fight, italy, ca. 1400
— weird medieval guys (@weirdmedieval.bsky.social) 2024-12-23T19:07:48.242Z
Another early Christmas:
Christmas as #AnneBoleyn saw it. Illuminations of The Nativity as seen in Anne’s two Books of Hours, housed at her home of Hever Castle. Merry Christmas, all 🎄
— Dr Owen Emmerson (@drowenemmerson.bsky.social) 2024-12-23T17:23:18.886Z


















































I do. The Electoral College is a relic, one that has perpetuated disproportionate minority rule by rural, mostly White, conservative states. Moving to a popular vote system would help correct one of the many mechanisms that give these sparsely-populated states disproportionate power.