Nathaniel Comfort’s misguided take on The Selfish Gene at 50

October 27, 2026 • 9:51 am

Nathaniel Comfort is identified by Wikipedia as “an American historian specializing in the history of biology. He is an associate professor in the Institute of the History of Medicine at Johns Hopkins University”. Comfort has written several books on the history of genetics, including a biography of Barbara McClintock, and I’ve heard he’s nearly finished what is likely to be the definitive biography of J. D. Watson. I have a great deal of respect for him.

Thus I was baffled by Comfort’s new piece in Nature discussing (or rather, dissing) Richard Dawkins’s The Selfish Gene. Despite that book’s influence and renown, Comfort claims that it’s outdated: indeed, not worth reading at all compared to books that discuss the view of evolution favored by Comfort. And Comfort’s favored view is that of the “Extended Evolutionary Synthesis” (“EES”), which argues that the “neo-Darwinian view of evolution” that fused natural selection and Mendelian genetics, is wrong and needs replacement with a new theory. I’ve discussed this view at length over the years (see my posts collected here), and, along with Doug Futuyma (see his article below), I note that while new discoveries have created add-ons to evolutionary theory (and dispelled some of Darwin’s own tenets, like the widespread inheritance of acquired traits), they don’t call for a new theory of evolution. The Selfish Gene is not outmoded—far from it.

In his essay, Comfort says that Dawkins’s view of evolution by natural selection as a process you can think of as driven by “selfish genes” is wrong: it’s too narrow and best left on the shelf. You can read Comfort’s piece here or by clicking on the title below:

As you may recall, Dawkins’s main point was that the unit of evolution by natural selection was the gene, or “replicator”: a bit of DNA that can reproduce itself from one generation to the next.  The unit is not the individual, the group, or the species, but the replicator, which can be seen as “selfish” because those genes that replicate faster than their alternative forms will be the ones most represented in the the future. Faster replication can, for example, be effected by building bodies (“vehicles”) that last longer and leave more offspring than others. This is the main way we think of evolution by natural selection, but Dawkins’s “gene’s-eye view” is broader than this.  Transposable genetic elements, for example, facilitate their own reproduction and survival by replicating quickly and infesting other parts of the genome.  They spread through a species not by enhancing an organism’s adaptation, survival, or reproduction, but their own reproduction.

Further, as the book points out, a gene can spread by selection even if it reduces the survival or number of offspring of the bearer itself, but enhances the number of copies present in relatives or groupmates—via kin selection or reciprocal altruism.  This view of natural selection can be thought of as the spread of “selfish” genes, but, as Dawkins asserts repeatedly, it need not lead to selfish or aggressive behavior of individuals—one of the most common misunderstandings of the book.

The gene’s-eye view influenced not just the public, but many biologists, including me, and it clarifies a number of points that were murky (e.g., kin selection). But Comfort says it’s narrow and outmoded. Take a look at Comfort’s second paragraph:

Re-reading it now, with decades of scholarship in the history of biology under my belt, it seems less benign. The determinism baked into the “gene’s-eye view” in the book troubles me, as does the passivity of the organism in Dawkins’s telling — a “vehicle”, a mere “replicator”. The implication: that traits such as aggression are hard-wired into people. Fortunately, over the past couple of decades, new tools, fresh models and scholars in many disciplines have begun to embrace the complex reality of biology. Readers in search of an understanding of life on Earth today would do better to reach for books that take a broader view.

Yes, in fact organisms are passive, for although they can influence the spread of replicators via their own behavior, those behavioral features are themselves the product of “selfish genes” (an example is “extended phenotypes”, like the beaver dam—one subject of Dawkins’s eponymous book). This is truly a deterministic, naturalistic process that has no room for “agency,” “will”, or teleology, though I’ve suggested that truly nondeterministic processes like quantum mechanics might influence evolution by producing mutations. Absent quantum effects, evolution is indeed deterministic, and organisms are vehicles that express the products of replicators. (Yes, I know that some physicists think quantum mechanics is deterministic in ways we don’t understand.)

As for the implication that selfish genes imply the evolution of aggression or other such behaviors, Comfort apparently hasn’t got Dawkins’s message.

So what is the “broader” view of biology that, Comfort argues, should replace that of the selfish gene? It is the “Extended Evolutionary Synthesis,” which calls for a wholesale rebuild of neo-Darwinian evolution because of things like epigenetic modification, “niche construction” (e.g., the beaver dam cited above), behavioral and morphological plasticity, and what is called “natural genetic engineering”, a quasi-teleological view, largely touted by James Shapiro, which claims that organisms engineer their own fates by some “intelligent” process that did not evolve in the Dawkinsian way.

As Doug Futuyma explains in his paper below, all the phenomena mentioned above, save “natural genetic engineering,” fit comfortably within the modern synthesis, even though some discoveries, like epigenetic modification of DNA, have been made in recent decades. (I’ll point out here that DNA modified by the environment can cause evolutionary change only insofar as it produces “selfish [modified] DNA that replicates faster than unmodified DNA. And we have almost no cases of epigenetic modification not themselves coded in the DNA forming the basis of evolutionary change.)

I’ll make just two more points; the first involving the “directionality” of evolution. Here’s more from Comfort’s piece:

For instance, neo-Darwinism teaches that evolution is a random walk through changing environments, with selection favouring whatever traits help an organism to survive. Today, many scholars argue that there has to be direction to evolution. In How Life Works (2023), for instance, journalist Philip Ball points out that in a single cell, there is an unfathomably large number of possible interactions between different kinds of molecule — and there are about 37 trillion cells in one human body. “Such a system,” Ball writes, “can only hope to be stable if, out of all this complexity, only a limited number of collective ways of being may emerge”. Living organisms are forced to evolve in those few directions.

And the neo-Darwinian idea of evolution as a random process seems to run counter to the unavoidable observation that life has evolved towards ever-greater complexity. Biochemist Nick Lane has argued that, right back to life’s origin, the main driver of this complexity is the second law of thermodynamics — entropy, the tendency toward disorder. “Energy-releasing chemical reactions are at the core of the living process of all organisms,” wrote he and others (W. F. Martin et al. Science 344, 1092–1093; 2014). The detailed chemistry behind this idea is outlined in depth in Lane’s brilliant 2015 book, The Vital Question. The overall idea is that complex life forms dissipate more heat than do their simpler counterparts. Life on Earth is pushed towards greater complexity and abundance because, given the composition of the planet, it is energetically favourable.

The first paragraph is in fact not a refutation of the selfish gene view.  The only direction to evolution—and one that Dawkins notes—is that replicators get better and better at replicating over time.  This in general leads to an increase in survival and reproduction of the “vehicles”—organisms—but it need not.  The spread of transposable genetic elements, which account for a great deal of “genetic junk” that dominates our own genome, is one example. And nobody I know of thinks that organisms are unconstrained, either by their own nature or by the environment, in the way they can evolve. There are guardrails.

Second, the discussion of why life was once simple but has become more complex is not new. For one thing, life started out simple and thus if it was to go anywhere, it had to become at least a bit more complex. But the view of unidirectional complexity is simply not true. What is true is that life is a cumulative process, with new “adaptations” evolving from old ones, so a great deal of adaptive residue remains in our genome. But you’d be hard pressed to show that “complexity” has increased unidirectionally after we had multicellar organisms inhabiting many of the world’s niches. (By the way, each organism becomes or makes niches for other organisms, so evolution creates new ways of life, but that doesn’t mean that “life is more complex”).

Finally, there are many organisms that have evolved to become less complex, as replicators that “de-evolve” some features may be favored in some environments. Parasites are a common example. Tapeworms, for example, used to be free-living flatworms, but when they invaded the guts of organisms they lost most of their nervous and sensory systems, their digestive system, and their genomes became much simpler.  Cave-dwelling organisms often lose their eyes: a decrease in complexity. Snakes used to be lizard-like organisms but have lost their limbs. Whales also lost their limbs. These examples are rife, and I won’t go on.  The point is that Comfort is either distorting what Dawkins says, distorting what the Modern Synthesis says or implies, or distorting what’s happened in evolution.

Touting the EES, Comfort tells us above that there are better books to reach for than The Selfish Gene if you wish to understand where the theory of evolution stands.  I would simply recommend Doug Futuyma and Mark Kirkpatrick’s high-level evolution textbook, simply called Evolution (Fifth Edition), published in 2022. To deal specifically with claims that the EES dismantles or greatly modifies the view of evolution in that textbook, you should read Doug Futuyma’s article below (click on the link). I’ve put its abstract below the title:

Abstract:

Evolutionary theory has been extended almost continually since the evolutionary synthesis (ES), but except for the much greater importance afforded genetic drift, the principal tenets of the ES have been strongly supported. Adaptations are attributable to the sorting of genetic variation by natural selection, which remains the only known cause of increase in fitness. Mutations are not adaptively directed, but as principal authors of the ES recognized, the material (structural) bases of biochemistry and development affect the variety of phenotypic variations that arise by mutation and recombination. Against this historical background, I analyse major propositions in the movement for an ‘extended evolutionary synthesis’. ‘Niche construction’ is a new label for a wide variety of well-known phenomena, many of which have been extensively studied, but (as with every topic in evolutionary biology) some aspects may have been understudied. There is no reason to consider it a neglected ‘process’ of evolution. The proposition that phenotypic plasticity may engender new adaptive phenotypes that are later genetically assimilated or accommodated is theoretically plausible; it may be most likely when the new phenotype is not truly novel, but is instead a slight extension of a reaction norm already shaped by natural selection in similar environments. However, evolution in new environments often compensates for maladaptive plastic phenotypic responses. The union of population genetic theory with mechanistic understanding of developmental processes enables more complete understanding by joining ultimate and proximate causation; but the latter does not replace or invalidate the former. Newly discovered molecular phenomena have been easily accommodated in the past by elaborating orthodox evolutionary theory, and it appears that the same holds today for phenomena such as epigenetic inheritance. In several of these areas, empirical evidence is needed to evaluate enthusiastic speculation. Evolutionary theory will continue to be extended, but there is no sign that it requires emendation.

No, evolution does not need a rebuild, and The Selfish Gene is not outmoded. It remains, for those who haven’t read it, a page-turner.

h/t reader John, who called my attention to Comfort’s article

28 thoughts on “Nathaniel Comfort’s misguided take on The Selfish Gene at 50”

  1. On sees already in his subtitle that he has no idea what he’s talking about, i.e. “A focus on the gene alone …”. Obviously, Dawkins did not focus on the gene alone.

  2. WEIT, as always, fascinates.

    I have a question about my own understanding and am wondering if I’m thinking about this correctly. Bear with me, please.

    Comfort says;

    “For instance, neo-Darwinism teaches that evolution is a random walk through changing environments, with selection favouring whatever traits help an organism to survive.’

    I think this is correct, though the “randomness” has to do with the utility of the selected alleles. I would add that to me the “changing environments” means the topography of the “fitness space”, with its peaks and valleys indicating the various effects different alleles have on fitness. Is that about right?

    So, as a counterpoint to this, Comfort quotes journalist Phillip Ball;

    ““Such a system,” Ball writes, “can only hope to be stable if, out of all this complexity, only a limited number of collective ways of being may emerge”. Living organisms are forced to evolve in those few directions.”

    (emphasis mine).

    Isn’t that the same thing? I mean, selection does indeed constrain the direction organisms are “forced to evolve”. Am I getting this wrong?

    Me no understand.

    1. They are not the same thing. the first one talks about external constraints while the second refers to inner constraints of having a workable system. For example, there are certain ways (and restrictions) in order to make a wheel; how well it runs in a particular environment is a different matter. This is one major conceptual problem with natural selection: it conflates the origin of novelty and its adaptation to external conditions.

    2. The misunderstanding is Comfort’s, not yours.
      There is no evolutionary “force”. This next statement might sound tautological but this makes it no less true: Things that work, just work.
      The environment defines the criteria upon which selection acts. What constrains this is the availability of genetic variation. Evolution can only take small steps because complex mutations, that build distinct phenotypic change, usually take time to build up.
      This is an extreme example, but it illustrates this, important, point: Say it was evolutionarily advantageous for a human being to evolve wings and fly. This could not happen in one step, as the complex genetic instructions enabling flight would take hundreds of generations to take place. And importantly, for this to work, every step must be an improvement on the step before. The evolution of tiny wing buds on a human’s back would be of no use to the human carrying them and would be selectively disadvantageous.
      A useful book describing evolution in terms of what you describe as “peaks and troughs” is Dawkins’: “Climbing Mount Improbable”. Which uses exactly this terminology.

  3. I read The Selfish Gene with great interest when it came out, as did my advisor and all of my graduate student compatriots. We read and argued about it at seminar week after week, chapter by chapter. Incredible book that was probably the most influential book of the period in evolutionary biology. My personal favorite of Dawkins’s books is The Blind Watchmaker, which may be the best argument for evolution since Darwin himself.

    The view that evolution has some intrinsic drive toward complexity is an old one. Not only are there many counter examples, but given a simple beginning there’s just no other place for evolution to go. The supposed tendency toward complexity is a statistical artifact.

    Everyone wants to be an iconoclast, I suppose.

  4. It may be significant that most of the calls for a “new synthesis” come from science journalists, science historians, etc. Few seem to come from actual scientists, who spend their days in the lab and/or the field, doing actual research. It may be that the latter are considered too involved in our own refuses to consider the broader picture of an all-encompassing theory of life. I would argue against that, of course, because nothing encourages thought more than hands-on experience.

    Needless to say, if I were teaching a course on Evolutionary theory today (and students still read) Dawkins’ book would be kind on the list of the required reading.

    1. There is another niche called The Third Way of Evolution. They argue for essentially the same points as EES, but instead of favoring extensions of Neo-Darwinism, they seem to want to do away with it entirely and create a new synthesis of their own.

  5. The Extended Evolutionary Synthesis group have nothing good to offer to the theory of evolution except for unfortunately widely visible click-bait books and articles that serve to lend comfort to anti-science.

    I wonder what Nick Lane will think about the mis-use of his points about the upward mobility of the earliest life.
    One can tell a story that refers to evolution and complexity. Suppose there was a planet like ours, with oceans and land, and for some reason an oxygenated atmosphere. But this planet was otherwise lifeless. This is of course not possible as we understand things, but just pretend. Suppose that we flew over this planet and dropped in a population of worms which were capable of surviving there. What would happen to this new and evolving life? I bet that the different descendants would first ‘devolve’ toward simpler body plans, eventually arriving at forms that filled out the microbial niches. Then, and only then would life evolve upward to greater complexity. The reason for this is that niches for simpler life forms have faster generation times and greater reproductive potential, so simpler body plans are the most fit path for leaving descendants. Putting it another way, for maybe billions of years simpler bodies would be most fit for leaving gene copies — that being an essence of what evolution is.

  6. Dawkins does neglect some things. The focus on natural selection means that he completely ignores genetic drift which is a very important part of evolution. But when it comes to how natural selection works, I think The Selfish Gene is great. I read it long ago but I remember it had plenty of great insights and helped make a lot of concepts clearer.

    1. I wouldn’t say that Dawkins ignores genetic drift. From my recollection of his various writings he acknowledges the reality of drift, but argues that it can’t produce the kind of complex physical and behavioural adaptations that fit organisms to their environment and lifestyle. Natural Selection is the only mechanism we know of that can do this. Explaining the complexity of life is Dawkins’ main theme, so genetic drift is largely irrelevant to his argument.

  7. And the neo-Darwinian idea of evolution as a random process …

    The word random bugs me more than it should. Is anything truly random? Certain interpretations of quantum mechanics, perhaps. This is as much a philosophical issue as anything else. We can say with reasonable certainty that the process is difficult to predict and very definitely chaotic. And I suspect it is deterministic.

    1. I think by “random”, it’s inferred to mean in the way that outcomes happen in highly chaotic environments are not reasonably predictable. Like dropping a grain of sand in a hurricane and predicting where it will land. The outcome is not truly “random”, but as an approximation of our ability to predict physics it is practically random.

  8. Comfort’s article is nothing but a continuation of his work since at least the 2010’s. He has been dismissive of genetics and has equated it (or insinuated as much) with eugenics, as well as anything that is remotely gene-centric. He might be a decent biographer but his portrayal of genetics and evolution has been consistently biased.

  9. I can’t stand Comfort. His review of the book Blueprint by the behavior geneticist Robert Plomin was also accusatory and dismissive.

  10. The Selfish Gene (and Dawkins) weren’t actually anything new, contain no research, but were so clear and definitive in their explanation of how evolution had to work, that they became the standard for understanding this. I was a graduate student in a renowned evolutionary biology department in the 1990s, and one time over lunch my professors discussed Dawkins with great respect — not just his work on evolution, but the clarity that he brought to other issues, such as bat vision. In my personal experience, The Selfish Gene is the book that a great number of respected evolutionary biologists base their understanding of evolution on, and I completely concur that the calls for it to be updated are likely from people who are peripheral to the topic: philosophers of science, popular writers, etc.

    My response to this is that anyone who thinks it needs editing should point out where, precisely, it’s wrong. In the absence of this, I would assume that evolutionary science has produce accretions, but not a new foundation.

    1. As I said in my post, if you want an overview of modern evolutionary biology, you should read Doug Futuyma and Mark Kirkpatrick’s textbook (and Futuyma’s article as a corrective to Comfort). But grad students in evolutionary biology (or organismal biology in general) should also read The Selfish Gene.

  11. The point about “The Selfish Gene” is that it is the cell that is the basic biological unit of evolution, not the gene, although genes are crucially important tools that are used by cells. In addition, cells engage in cooperation on a vast scale when forming multi-cellular holobionts, for example, and can hardly be seen as fundamentally selfish!

    Alfonso Martinez Arias 2023 The Master Builder: How the New Science of the Cell Is Rewriting the Story of Life
    Ben Stanger 2023 From One Cell: A Journey into Life’s Origins and the Future of Medicine

  12. I haven’t read Comfort, but I think there is a parallel to ID creationism here. Some people just don’t want the evolutionary synthesis to be true because they think it robs the universe of meaning, and this biases their viewpoint. Evolution does not deprive the universe of anything. It is just a fact about existence. If you want meaning, biology is not where you should look.
    Others who aren’t necessarily creationists, like Denis Noble, have suggested alternatives to the evolutionary synthesis because the immense complexity of the natural world confuses them. Human lifetimes are just too short for us to appreciate what a simple system, like natural selection acting on genetic variation, can achieve over vast periods of geological time. Yes, systems like cell metabolism and epigenetics, including transgenerational epigenetics are almost absurdly complex. So what? They are all downstream of the immensely powerful mechanism of evolution by natural selection.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *