Dogs are used by first responders and the military for a number of tasks. Their keen sense of smell, speed, and keen hearing give them advantages over even drones or robots, and, according to Grok, trained dogs are used for a variety of tasks, including detecting explosives, providing security, locating enemies, doing sentry and perimeter work, and performing search and rescue. Two other duties mentioned by Grok are these.
- “Special operations support: High-risk missions (e.g., the dog Cairo on the 2011 bin Laden raid), including some aerial insertion (parachute or rappel with specialized gear).”
- “Israel has used MWDs heavily for detection and assault in Gaza (with high attrition).”
Note the “high attrition”: this means that the dogs die, even though they don’t choose to go into service. This is all I’m using from Grok; the rest of the writing here is mine or comes from the three sources below.
The breeds of dogs used in service are mainly German shepherds, Belgian Malinois, and Labradors, and of course undergo a period of intensive training. But, according to the Fortune article below, there’s a shortage of good “war dogs” (most of the mention of dogs in these articles involves military use):
The Army set up the K-9 Corps in 1942. Today the Department of War’s Military Working Dog Program has more than 2,200 dog teams, according to the company, and more than 80% of U.S. military working dogs are bought from Europe. Lamm cited a Senate Armed Services Committee warning that “due to the finite number of breeders overseas, as well as rising market demand, the cost… to procure whelped military working dogs from Europe is skyrocketing.” He also cited the American Kennel Club’s assessment that “there is now a shortage of even mediocre quality foreign dogs available.”
The U.S. is “competing against other country governments” for the same animals, Lamm said, China and Russia among them.
The losses after purchase are expensive, too. According to the company, fewer than half of the dogs bought are judged fit for service after a roughly three-year acquisition and training pipeline. That means the U.S. has to buy and train about 200 dogs today to field 100 working animals later.
But Mammon to the rescue! In stepped entrepreneurs and geneticists, in the form of Palmer Luckey (“an American entrepreneur and co-founder of defense technology company Anduril Industries“), Ben Lamm, billionaire entrepreneur and founder of our old friend Colossal Biosciences, the “de-extinction company,” and Dave Spirk, who will be the CEO of Warhound Corporation.
Warhound received over $200 million in seed funding, with investors including, according to Fortune, “In-Q-Tel, Sequoia Capital, ARK Invest, Franklin Templeton, 8VC, USIT, Bob Nelsen, Breyer Capital, CAZ Investments, Neogenesis, Builders VC and Lux Capital, among others.” Colossal also benefits: to quote Fortune again:
Colossal licenses technology to Warhound and has an economic interest in it. Spinning companies out of Colossal’s research is “an intentional part of our model,” Lamm said.
How it’s being done (they’ve already started cloning trained dogs), and what will happen to the puppies, are described in the following three articles, though the archived Fortune article is the most informative. Scientific American is okay, but they still fall for Colossal’s hype. They say this:
Colossal Biosciences, which has a stake in Warhound and is providing much of the science, is no stranger to genetic engineering: last year the firm cloned and edited a gray wolf to create an animal that was genetically similar to the extinct dire wolf. The process for Warhound will look similar, Lamm says, but with modern dogs.
Nope. As I’ve pointed out, the “de-extincted dire wolf” is really a gray wolf with 20 DNA edits in 14 genes, producing an animal that is not “genetically similar to the extinct dire wolf”. [I corrected the earlier figures.] As I wrote on October 5, “Since gray wolves and dire wolves differ by 12 million DNA bases, the edits comprise only 0.0002% of the dire wolf genome. In other words, what Colossal produced, as anyone with neurons knows, is a grey wolf with a few morphological changes.” I wouldn’t say that .0002% is a great deal of added similarity!
But I digress in my animus towards the crumbling Scientific American. Here are the three articles; click on the screenshot to read any.
From Scientific American:
From Fortune (archived):
From engadget:
The process will involve cloning service dogs that have proven to be great at their jobs, a process that first involves replacing the nucleus of an oocyte with the nucleus from a somatic (b0dy) cell of the chosen service dog. This nucleus-replaced egg cell is then genetically tweaked to make a number of edits; these edits are designed to remove genes causing defects like hip problems and cancer, as well as to add in bits of DNA that make dogs faster or better able to smell. Only a limited number of edits are possible (the faux “dire wolves” used 20), and you better know what the DNA bits you’re adding will do. This is a problem, as we don’t often know what genes are the ones causing problems.
The edited cells—you can make multiple clones by using different body cells from the same service dog—are then artificially fertilized using chemical stimulants, and these “fertilized” eggs are placed in a receptive surrogate mother dog. The pregnant mom’s embryos are checked genetically to see if they indeed correspond to the cloned service dog, and are usually removed by Caesarian section, as were the faux “dire wolves”. This poses an ethical issue, as it involves making dogs pregnant who never get to see their pups.
Now cloning body cells without editing has been going on for some time as rich people have sought to replace their dead or aging pets with ones that are largely genetically similar. This runs about $50,000 to $100,000 per animal, and has a pretty high failure rate, as things can go wrong at any step. I quote Sci. Am.:
Cloning dogs is not a new science. Research has shown that cloning service dogs produces puppies that have many of the same desirable traits. But the process can be harmful, says Lisa Moses, a veterinarian and bioethicist at Harvard University. The rate of successful live offspring remains low among the cloned dogs, and the process can put the surrogate mother in danger.
Another ethical problem to ponder! Once the cloned service dogs are removed from the surrogates and raised, they undergo training—after all, training is a behavioral and not a genetic modification—in the hopes that once you have puppies, not many of them will wash out. In addition, they will be EQUIPPED WITH WAR STUFF. As Fortune says, quoting Lamm:
Anduril is supplying equipment including eye and ear protection, body armor, and integration with its Eagle Eye system, so that “dogs, handlers, and autonomous systems operate as one team.”
Now the first thing I asked myself when I read about this is, “Why not just artifically select service dogs with the desired traits and not breed from ones with defects?” That’s a good question, as it might, in the end, be cheaper and easier. On the other hand, if you have a great service dog, cloning will enable you to get many copies of the dog at once via multiple surrogates. But that itself leads to another problem: since the multiple surrogates are pretty much genetically identical (that’s what clones are), perpetuating the line might lead to serious problem with inbreeding.
The upside of cloning is, of course, pecuniary. If you can get great service dogs this way, you could secure a government contract to keep providing dogs to the military, and that could be very profitable. I suspect this, and not scientific advance, is the main motivation for the effort. After all, you could take the aggressive genes out of pit bulls, but that wouldn’t be profitable.
Another problem, which I’ve noted above, is figuring out the limited array of genes you want to edit. Sci Am. quotes another geneticist:
Both scientists and private companies have genetically edited dogs before, and the research can “accelerate really fast because genomics in dog breeds already has a lot of data,” says Ben Novak, chief scientist at Revive and Restore, who works on wildlife cloning for conservation. Researchers have edited dogs to tweak genes for hip dysplasia, make them hypoallergenic and treat muscle disease, although the long-term health effects of these changes remain unclear.
But optimizing traits at scale and across service dogs could take time—and leave room for unintended consequences, Novak adds.
“It can be hard to figure out exactly what genetic element is creating a trait,” he says, “and some traits can be the combinations of hundreds or thousands of mutations across genes.”
Traits like smelling ability and running speed are, no doubt, “polygenic,” involving several to many genes, and changing just a couple may not effect much change in the War Dogs.
Finally, I’ve mentioned some ethical problems. Although the project is touted as being “certified by the American Humane Society,” I’m not sure what kind of certification will prevent problems like this (from Sci Am):
“It is by no means a perfect science, and by that, I mean it’s still a fairly inefficient process,” Moses says. “It requires a lot of dogs to have invasive things done to them and to be killed in order to produce one cloned puppy.”
Finally (again from Sci. Am.), cloning can have unintended detrimental effects that aren’t known until later, as Ben Novak notes above.
I don’t know any way this can be done without either producing unwanted dogs, killing or harming the surrogates, or producing genetically defective dogs when the cloning goes wrong. In my view, the Humane Society’s certification is premature.



“[C]ertified by the American Human Society?”
They seem to be certifying a biological weapon, no?
An error, of course. I’ll fix it.
Ha! I didn’t notice the error. I was just commenting on what the American Humane Society seems to be endorsing.
I grew up on a farm, hunted, fished, and eat meat. I’ve had working dogs who clearly loved having a job.
This topic enrages me.
Dogs are loyal companions and family members. I’d rather spend time with a dog than with a number of people I know. Training them to fight and kill is nothing more nor less than abuse. Bomb sniffing, search and rescue, and similar roles are fine; dogs enjoy being useful and working with their people. Turning them into weapons is actively evil.
“I grew up on a farm, hunted, fished, and eat meat. I’ve watched teen boys who clearly loved having a job.
This topic enrages me.
Teen boys are loyal companions and family members. I’d rather spend time with teen boys than with a number of other people I know. Training them to fight and kill is nothing more nor less than abuse. Search and rescue, and similar roles are fine; teen boys enjoy being useful and working to protect people. Turning them into weapons is actively evil.”
In my reformulation above, could you clarify for me what, if anything, distinguishes young men from dogs? Or is it the fighting and killing in general to which you object?
You specifically note that “turning them into weapons” is your objection rather than imperiling their lives, which both bomb sniffing and combat zone S&R can do. Risk to the dog appears acceptable, but the risk a well-trained dog that can “fight and kill” poses to others does not. Support and protect roles seem fine, but assaulting or potentially killing people do not. I’m trying to understand whether I correctly capture your distinction and what specifically would make this “evil.”
My objection is that dogs, intelligent as they are, lack the ability to choose. They are empathetic beings that can feel pain, being used as tools by horrible people who lack compassion.
I’m reminded of an excerpt from Terry Pratchett’s “I Shall Wear Midnight” where Granny Weatherwax is having a discussion with a young priest.
Weatherwax: There’s no grays, only white that’s got grubby. I’m surprised you don’t know that. And sin, young man, is when you treat people like things. Including yourself. That’s what sin is.
Priest: It’s a lot more complicated than that–
Weatherwax: No. It ain’t. When people say things are a lot more complicated than that, they means they’re getting worried that they won’t like the truth. People as things, that’s where it starts.
Priest: Oh, I’m sure there are worse crimes–
Weatherwax: But they starts with thinking about people as things…
— end excerpt —
Dogs are much, much closer to being people than things. They deserve to be treated as such.
I have always admired Granny Weatherwax.
It is deliberate cruelty to animals. People are good enough at killing each other that they shouldn’t have to involve dogs— who have been bred to like us in the process. And they’ll get to connect with their handle remotely? Doesn’t sound like a deal any dog would go for.
I prefer war mammoths.
The war dog project and Colossal Bioscience’s hocus-pocus illustrate the mysterious way technologies can achieve currency independent of their quality, usefulness, or even actual consumer appeal. Examples include Microsoft Word, those idiotic motion-activated paper towel dispensers in every public bathroom, and, worst of all, the ghastly robot telephone labyrinths that every private or government office now interposes between consumers and human consumer representatives. The robot systems are dumb, inefficient, maddening, and everybody hates them, yet they have become universal. Free market theory pretends that competition should by now have sent this anti-consumer technology into the dustbin, yet it remains universal. Economic/psychological explanations for the malignant proliferation of some technologies don’t all make sense. Let me suggest a term for it: techno-metastasis.
The WSJ also had an article on this.
https://www.wsj.com/business/entrepreneurship/the-plan-to-put-super-dogs-on-the-battlefield-of-the-future-02fbca9a
A lame article, with only one sentence of criticism of either War Dogs or “de-extinction” in general.
It looks like all of the war dogs articles stem from the press release put out by Warhound https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/warhound-launches-with-200-million-to-rebuild-americas-military-working-dog-supply-using-advanced-genetics-and-defense-technology-302918435.html with some embellishments added by the outlets. If you notice, the SciAm article was written by an intern – no real investigation, just regurgitate the press release and put some spin on it as is typical for these stories (or almost any other news story, when it comes down to it). This type of reporting will eventually all be done by AI using a simple prompt like “take the press release and add some spin to it to reflect the ethos and writing style of our publication. Pull in outside comments and color to support.”.
Good point. Sounds quite possible.
So much is wrong here.
One here is that it is unethical to use dogs in the battlefield where they will become a prized target.
Another error is the assumption that cloning a dog for its behavior traits gets you another dog with those traits. But it is well known that when people clone a beloved pet dog, the clone is not necessarily like the original in its personality. So after much expense, I suspect that what will be learned here that some people wasted a lot of money.
SNL did a bit on this on Nov 20, 2021 featuring Simu Liu, Cecily Strong, and James Austin Johnson – and a beautiful Golden Retriever. So they predicted the “super dog” weapon five years ago.
I don’t know if these cloned puppies will be raised differently than other service dogs, but…
Ordinarily, service dogs (military, seeing eye, etc.) are raised in a similar manner to other puppies. They’re born, either naturally or by C-section (very rarely fatal) if there is difficulty. They remain with their dam and litter mates for 6 to 8 weeks being nursed by their dam and being handled by people daily so that they learn to socialize with both dogs and people. Within a litter, each puppy is given a collar of a different color so that they can be easily identified. For service dogs the ‘handlers’ are also continuously evaluating their behavior (timid, brave, assertive, curious, determined, etc.). They are introduced to different surfaces (tile, carpet, grass, etc.), different toys, different sounds, etc. At weaning they’re sent to live with a foster family for their first year, so they can get basic training (house breaking, sit, stay, down, heel, etc.) while being exposed to all the things dogs normally encounter (children, sudden noises, runners, bicycles, skateboards, traffic, crutches, wheelchairs, appliances, tools, other animals, etc.) At a year old they are returned for their formal service training. I don’t know how the foster parents can part with them after a year. I know I couldn’t.
About half the dogs washout of formal training but I think the training facilities find the washouts homes (unless the reason for washout is being overly aggressive). I suspect a fair number may end up going back to their foster family. I have my doubts about whether cloning is going to reduce the washout rate substantially enough to compensate for the expense of cloning, but I guess that is an experiment and we’ll find out.
I’m fairly sure that the reason they can’t breed most of the already existing service dogs is that the vast majority are neutered to avoid some of the issues involved with sexually motivated adult dogs (though I hope they are not neutering very early with these large dogs who need their sex hormones until they are a year old to develop properly).
All that said, I agree that the dogs do not get to choose about being put in danger. In general domestic dogs don’t get to choose about much, not what home they live in, what they get to eat, who they get to associate with or whether to be neutered. A heartbreak for me during college was a young Doberman, Otto, who came to my house repeatedly. He was clearly terrified of his owner and would cower behind me when his owner came for him, yet there was nothing I could do. I couldn’t afford to buy him from his owner and while dogs may not be ‘things’, they are still for the most part ‘property’.
I think most service dogs are heavily bonded with their handler and would choose to defend them from danger as handlers also work hard to protect their dogs. I have high hopes that robo dogs or crawlers will be replacing living dogs for many of the most dangerous tasks. It sounds as if these dogs will at least be guaranteed proper safety gear. The military and police should be required to provide all their service dogs with this (though I know locally they often have to hold fundraisers for dog vests). They should also be required to ensure all facilities and vehicles are properly climate controlled at all times (too many dogs die of heat stress) and be required to make sure all service dogs get a good retirement (no killing them because it’s too expensive to bring them home). I don’t know what the death rate for Israeli military dogs in Gaza was but Google suggests that for the US military the death rate of dogs in service is probably in the area of 5% or less. That’s still high but being put into military service is not a death sentence. Remember that about half of all large wild mammals, who do get to make their own choices, die in their first year or two.
It does seem that things are on the slow arc to improvement for dogs in this country. About half the states now have laws about chaining dogs outside. Puppy mills are gradually going out of business. Arrests for animal cruelty or hoarding have become much more common. Emergency rescuers and shelters now provide for pets because of the PETS act, inspired in part by that little white dog left behind as a bus rescued people from hurricane Katrina. It was so needless, so cruel it still brings tears to my eyes, though Google says Snowball may have eventually been rescued.
I am a dog (and cat and most critters) lover, but amongst the things currently available to be outraged over, I guess cloning military service dogs does not make the top of my list.
It seems like an oversight that the military does not have their own conventional breeding program, whether in-house or contracted out. If service dogs truly are a valuable asset it would make sense to not be dependent on foreign breeders for your dogs.
Be human super soldiers next.