Why Evolution is True is a blog written by Jerry Coyne, centered on evolution and biology but also dealing with diverse topics like politics, culture, and cats.
I sure don’t now what this is, and neither does a reader in Lafayette, Indiana (home of Purdue University), who sent me this photo she took on her patio.
Help her out and tell us what it is. (Note: this is not a joke!)
I have no idea what this animal is, but my funny bone would be tickled if it was in fact called a “joke”.
Looks like Eeyore to me.
What’s worng with Fred? I find it to be a very versatile name.
b&
Definitely Eeyore.
his may sound stupid but, big gray squirrel with shaved tail? But then who would do that? Anyway, I submit this for the way-out-there award.
Or, even better, “This may sound stupid …”
Muskrat maybe?
The fur doesn’t look real…
Pit bull puppy?
An ROUS is the first thing that comes to mind.
(obligatory)
Inconceivable.
Don’t you mean “I don’t think they exist?”
Yours is better.
My first guess would be nutria… not native to Indiana as far as I know, but apparently have been introduced there.
Definitely not nutria.
A furless squirrel?
Coypu (aka nutria)? Aren’t they making their way up from South America lately?
Just guessing.
No, they were introduced around the US as part of the fur trade decades ago.
Doesn’t look quite bulky enough for a nutria, but it appears to be hairless so that could be throwing me off. The tail and head certainly seem to be pretty close.
Pit bill puppy
It looks totally bald: if it is a wild animal that means mange, which can result in foxes and coyotes that look completely hairless. Can large rodents get mange? The head is rodent-like. The short tail and stocky limbs suggest one of the large ground squirrels that there are so many species of in the US. That’s the best i can do.
Now I have seen commenst above suggesting nutria: tail looks a bit too short for nutria, but its body looks big and stocky enough.
I’ve never seen nutria in person, so I can’t speak from experience there, but in some pictures I see tails that look about like that, and some that look a lot longer as well.
My first thought was some poor creature with mange too.
Badger?
We don’t need to show you no steenkin badgers.
This is what happens when you feed the local wildlife genetically modified corn. Just sayin…
😀
I almost made that joke on my FB wall, Su. But I’m sure someone would have taken my seriously and freaked out on me. Decided I’d pass on the GMO wars for today. ; )
we have several, the dog is wary of the largest one
Looks like a nutria pit bull hybrid.
It looks to me like a squirrel that has lost all the hair on its tail. Hard to tell the size from the photo, though.
(I had mistakenly put this comment on the picture page earlier.)
It was HUGE compared to a squirrel though. About 3 times the size of a large squirrel. But its face was exactly the same as a squirrel – body more like a very short haired dog.
I vote the same. Head looks like that of a large rodent, such as a woodchuck. I saw a rather sensationalized nature documentary a few months ago about someone photographing a very weird dog-like animal that was more or less hairless. Turned out it was a rare variety of fox.
A mammal will look very weird with less hair.
I forwarded the pic to the discovery institute. I’m sure they will know… also sure that the little critter disproves evolution. No way an animal that ugly could have evolved! Praise Jebus! And in the words of Jason Stackhouse “Praise his light”
Awww. I thought it looked cute.
Maybe it’s a whole new baramin. But wait….
My guess is that is a squirrel thats heavily into steroids and working out….a ‘gym rat’?
*groan*
I deserved the groan of course, but I do think it looks like an excessively muscular shaved squirrel.
Rocky the Squirrel? (more groaning)
I think it is a wild pig. Not all pigs have curly tails and its ear is hanging down over its nose distorting the face.
A grey pig who had its tail straightened and had a nose job. 🙂
That’s not an opossum or any sort of marsupial in the pic but it does show the effects of mange
Definitely not a possum. I’ve got a lot of those – their snouts are much longer and pointier.
exactly
opossum with mange
I agree. That’s what I was going to say.
I think the tail is too short for possum – I’m still going for a rodent
Resembles a young badger
Legs look marsupial. I grew up in Indiana, lived in Lafayette while in college, and it looks like a young possum, or opossum, Didelphis Virginiana, which are common in Indiana. Compare the head shape with http://stevecreek.com/baby-possum/
I think it looks like a marsupial too, my first thought was that it was a wombat that had found a way to regrow its tail! 😉
Looks like a racoon with mange. Right proportions for a coon.
Yes, my first thought was also a raccoon with mange. The size looks about right. It looks too big for a possum, and the nose isn’t pointy enough for a possum either. I think a groundhog is also a good guess, since the ears are so small and round.
it’s clearly a cockamouse.
It’s a racoon or an opossum, sans hair.
Correct; we’re all assuming Jerry was being straight with us when he said “this is not a joke!”
Quadruped. If you’re going to be vague, you should do it exactly.
Hadronic. Baryonic, even, mostly.
b&
With a soupçon of the leptonic?
That’s a rather charged question, isn’t it?
b&
I’d have to say, negative.
Might be a nutria, but with the short tail I’d rather go for one of the prairie dogs.
Looks like a wood carving or a ceramic ornament to me.
Otherwise I like the hairless skunk idea.
Obviously a baby Triceratops. You can see the bony frill that protects the area behind the head beginning to form and the stub of an incipient nose horn. Wonder where mom is hiding…
Any Australian could tell you that this is a Drop Bear – Thylarctos plummetus
Maybe a naked (mange) honeybager?
Nasty.
Muskrat with the mange….
Yep, it certainly looks like a species that should be called a “kthxbai”
Jerry’s long lost love child.
Mangy woodchuck.
Which brings up the eternal question: How much wood would a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck would chuck wood?
That’s not the interesting question.
The question — especially in this case — that needs answering is, how much yuck would a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck would up-chuck?
b&
Or how much mange could a woodchuck amass if a woodchuck could amass mange?
Yeah it’s not perfect but it’s still tongue twisty.
Also reminiscent of “Fuzzie Wuzzie wasn’t fuzzy, was he?”
No seems to be considering the behavior.
Assuming that it’s not ill, the fact that it has come up close to the house favors, by my guess, a possum or raccoon. A muskrat or beaver wouldn’t be wandering around up there near the house and people.
I don’t see squirrel – had it been one, I’m thinking that the reader would have suggested as much. Squirrels have familiar and distinctive ways of scampering about that the reader would have recognized.
(I’m agreeing that it’s a hairless specimen, due to disease or other misadventure).
Woodchucks are fat, short-tailed, squirrels that live underground (including in backyards). Their behaviors are quite distinct from tree squirrels.
Of course, that same disease or misadventure might explain (or be explained by) abnormal behaviour. Hairlessness does wierd things to appearance (see the Montauk monster, which is pretty clearly a raccoon)
It does look like an idealized general body plan for a rodent. The dark skin argues against a raccoon, but that could be lighting. The head and ear shape in that picture is wrong for an opossum (google “hairless opossum” and “hairless raccoon”). Size rules out squirrels, and the tail does look too short for nutria.
Long story short: I vote woodchuck. Feels like I should make a Bill Murray reference. Put that man in a movie with a burrowing sciurid, and you’ve got comedy gold.
You are aware that raccoons aren’t rodents, aren’t you?
Of course. The two statements were separate, though its not clear now that I read it again. I was more expecting a comment that gophers aren’t sciuridae.
By which I mean that the statements on raccoon and opossum were to support the statement about rodents. Opossum are even less like rodents (raccoons are at least placental).
Gotcha. 😀
But groundhogs are sciurids, and I assumed that was what you were referring to?
(Groundhog/woodchuck’s been my guess all along, FWIW.)
Perhaps this is what Creationists are looking for when they search for their ever-elusive “Crocoduck.” I present to you, the “Squirrel-Dog,” or as it will more likely come to be known in finer circles, “Squog.”
You’ve noticed a decline in the local bird population? Small pets have gone missing? Strange, unearthly howls?
What — did another Cthulhu get out.
<sigh />
Oh, Baihu! Go round us up some calamari, will you?
Yes, I know the freezer’s already full. I don’t know — maybe we’ll dry it, or see if we can talk the neighbors into another fish fry. Yeah, yeah — they all tripped out after the last one. But most have pretended to forget, and they might be too scared to say no.
But why’m’I explaining this to you? Just go get the damned thing and we’ll worry about what to do with it when you get it back, okay? Great. Love you! Bye.
Clearly a juvenile chupacabra.
I have no idea what this animal is, but my funny bone would be tickled if it was in fact called a “joke”.
Looks like Eeyore to me.
What’s worng with Fred? I find it to be a very versatile name.
b&
Definitely Eeyore.
his may sound stupid but, big gray squirrel with shaved tail? But then who would do that? Anyway, I submit this for the way-out-there award.
Or, even better, “This may sound stupid …”
Muskrat maybe?
The fur doesn’t look real…
Pit bull puppy?
An ROUS is the first thing that comes to mind.
(obligatory)
Inconceivable.
Don’t you mean “I don’t think they exist?”
Yours is better.
My first guess would be nutria… not native to Indiana as far as I know, but apparently have been introduced there.
Definitely not nutria.
A furless squirrel?
Coypu (aka nutria)? Aren’t they making their way up from South America lately?
Just guessing.
No, they were introduced around the US as part of the fur trade decades ago.
Doesn’t look quite bulky enough for a nutria, but it appears to be hairless so that could be throwing me off. The tail and head certainly seem to be pretty close.
Pit bill puppy
It looks totally bald: if it is a wild animal that means mange, which can result in foxes and coyotes that look completely hairless. Can large rodents get mange? The head is rodent-like. The short tail and stocky limbs suggest one of the large ground squirrels that there are so many species of in the US. That’s the best i can do.
Now I have seen commenst above suggesting nutria: tail looks a bit too short for nutria, but its body looks big and stocky enough.
I’ve never seen nutria in person, so I can’t speak from experience there, but in some pictures I see tails that look about like that, and some that look a lot longer as well.
My first thought was some poor creature with mange too.
Badger?
We don’t need to show you no steenkin badgers.
This is what happens when you feed the local wildlife genetically modified corn. Just sayin…
😀
I almost made that joke on my FB wall, Su. But I’m sure someone would have taken my seriously and freaked out on me. Decided I’d pass on the GMO wars for today. ; )
Allegheny Woodrat? http://www.discoverlife.org/mp/20q?search=Neotoma+magister&btxt=IWF%20Mammals%20Main%20Page&burl=www.indianawildlife.org/lifeMammals.htm
They apparently get to about 16 inches long.
Now that looks like a contender. Except for this part: “They forage only at night, … “
Allegheny Woodrat with rabies?
Could it be the elusive, hairless opossum?
Baby hippo.
Ha! I thought so too! I thought it was this – The House Hippo: http://youtu.be/NBfi8OEz0rA
😀
we have several, the dog is wary of the largest one
Looks like a nutria pit bull hybrid.
It looks to me like a squirrel that has lost all the hair on its tail. Hard to tell the size from the photo, though.
(I had mistakenly put this comment on the picture page earlier.)
It was HUGE compared to a squirrel though. About 3 times the size of a large squirrel. But its face was exactly the same as a squirrel – body more like a very short haired dog.
Looks like a naked woodchuck.
I vote mangy groundhog as well.
http://www.backyardchickens.com/t/187261/badger-or-groundhog-or-something-else
I vote the same. Head looks like that of a large rodent, such as a woodchuck. I saw a rather sensationalized nature documentary a few months ago about someone photographing a very weird dog-like animal that was more or less hairless. Turned out it was a rare variety of fox.
A mammal will look very weird with less hair.
I forwarded the pic to the discovery institute. I’m sure they will know… also sure that the little critter disproves evolution. No way an animal that ugly could have evolved! Praise Jebus! And in the words of Jason Stackhouse “Praise his light”
Awww. I thought it looked cute.
Maybe it’s a whole new baramin. But wait….
My guess is that is a squirrel thats heavily into steroids and working out….a ‘gym rat’?
*groan*
I deserved the groan of course, but I do think it looks like an excessively muscular shaved squirrel.
Rocky the Squirrel? (more groaning)
I think it is a wild pig. Not all pigs have curly tails and its ear is hanging down over its nose distorting the face.
A grey pig who had its tail straightened and had a nose job. 🙂
Vole or shrew, perhaps?
It looks like a skunk with a denuded tail.
A dachshund? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dachshund
I was thinking Chihuahua. But then it’s so hard to tell all those little dog breeds from rodents.
sub
http://i.imgur.com/eS5BP.jpg
Definitely a hairless opossum.
I was going to say that! … first
That’s not an opossum or any sort of marsupial in the pic but it does show the effects of mange
Definitely not a possum. I’ve got a lot of those – their snouts are much longer and pointier.
exactly
opossum with mange
I agree. That’s what I was going to say.
I think the tail is too short for possum – I’m still going for a rodent
Resembles a young badger
Legs look marsupial. I grew up in Indiana, lived in Lafayette while in college, and it looks like a young possum, or opossum, Didelphis Virginiana, which are common in Indiana. Compare the head shape with http://stevecreek.com/baby-possum/
I think it looks like a marsupial too, my first thought was that it was a wombat that had found a way to regrow its tail! 😉
I think, like others here, that it’s a woodchuck (Marmota monax) without its hair. The skull, posture, tail length, and limb proportions are all about right: http://www.harlananatomical.com/woodchuck_2011_017.jpg
That one’s missing the hair, skin, organs and eyes! Must have been a rough winter
A muskrat?
Sent from my iPhone
Here it is enhanced:
http://mtsujournalism.org/images/mystery_animal.jpg
I took a picture of a groundhog (woodchuck) in my yard the other day and the body is exactly like that but hairlessness is strange.
After finding how far off base I was with wolverines, badgers, and Tasmanian devils, I vote for the coypu.
Actually, I think it’s more related to devils.
Wasn’t one of those recently spotted on Mars? It’s an invasion.
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2013/05/29/lizard-on-mars_n_3350595.html
I, too, favor the hairless woodchuck ID.
Clearly someone’s baby wombat got loose… or maybe a womprat.
I change my vote to groundhog with alopecia
The torso length and position of the legs, and position of the tail suggest squirrel. The only thing missing is the fur.
I’m of the opinion that it’s a small animal of some sort.
LMAO, AdamK!!!!!
Here’s a hairless woodchuck… pretty close.
http://poeticmonkey.com/misc-pics/hairless-woodchuck/IMG_3465.JPG
you got my vote.
Wow, that’s really close. I think we may have a winner.
Yeh I think that might be it. Is it a genetic mutation or mange or something?
Might just be alopecia. He didn’t seem to be sick or uncomfortable in any way.
Be sure to check out all the pictures:
poeticmonkey.com/misc-pics/hairless-woodchuck/index.html
Also, here is a similar creature others claim is a hairless woodchuck:
http://www.backyardchickens.com/t/187261/badger-or-groundhog-or-something-else
You’re all assuming it’s a living mammal.
Ceramic garden ornament of imaginary species.
Looks like a racoon with mange. Right proportions for a coon.
Yes, my first thought was also a raccoon with mange. The size looks about right. It looks too big for a possum, and the nose isn’t pointy enough for a possum either. I think a groundhog is also a good guess, since the ears are so small and round.
it’s clearly a cockamouse.
It’s a racoon or an opossum, sans hair.
Correct; we’re all assuming Jerry was being straight with us when he said “this is not a joke!”
Argh; that was meant as a reply to Shuggy.
Giraffe or dolphin.
infant bear-dog?
http://dingo.care2.com/pictures/c2c/share/34/348/817/3481753_370.jpg
Quadruped. If you’re going to be vague, you should do it exactly.
Hadronic. Baryonic, even, mostly.
b&
With a soupçon of the leptonic?
That’s a rather charged question, isn’t it?
b&
I’d have to say, negative.
Might be a nutria, but with the short tail I’d rather go for one of the prairie dogs.
Looks like a wood carving or a ceramic ornament to me.
Otherwise I like the hairless skunk idea.
Obviously a baby Triceratops. You can see the bony frill that protects the area behind the head beginning to form and the stub of an incipient nose horn. Wonder where mom is hiding…
Any Australian could tell you that this is a Drop Bear – Thylarctos plummetus
Maybe a naked (mange) honeybager?
Nasty.
Muskrat with the mange….
Yep, it certainly looks like a species that should be called a “kthxbai”
Jerry’s long lost love child.
Mangy woodchuck.
Which brings up the eternal question: How much wood would a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck would chuck wood?
That’s not the interesting question.
The question — especially in this case — that needs answering is, how much yuck would a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck would up-chuck?
b&
Or how much mange could a woodchuck amass if a woodchuck could amass mange?
Yeah it’s not perfect but it’s still tongue twisty.
Also reminiscent of “Fuzzie Wuzzie wasn’t fuzzy, was he?”
No seems to be considering the behavior.
Assuming that it’s not ill, the fact that it has come up close to the house favors, by my guess, a possum or raccoon. A muskrat or beaver wouldn’t be wandering around up there near the house and people.
I don’t see squirrel – had it been one, I’m thinking that the reader would have suggested as much. Squirrels have familiar and distinctive ways of scampering about that the reader would have recognized.
(I’m agreeing that it’s a hairless specimen, due to disease or other misadventure).
Woodchucks are fat, short-tailed, squirrels that live underground (including in backyards). Their behaviors are quite distinct from tree squirrels.
Of course, that same disease or misadventure might explain (or be explained by) abnormal behaviour. Hairlessness does wierd things to appearance (see the Montauk monster, which is pretty clearly a raccoon)
It does look like an idealized general body plan for a rodent. The dark skin argues against a raccoon, but that could be lighting. The head and ear shape in that picture is wrong for an opossum (google “hairless opossum” and “hairless raccoon”). Size rules out squirrels, and the tail does look too short for nutria.
Long story short: I vote woodchuck. Feels like I should make a Bill Murray reference. Put that man in a movie with a burrowing sciurid, and you’ve got comedy gold.
You are aware that raccoons aren’t rodents, aren’t you?
Of course. The two statements were separate, though its not clear now that I read it again. I was more expecting a comment that gophers aren’t sciuridae.
By which I mean that the statements on raccoon and opossum were to support the statement about rodents. Opossum are even less like rodents (raccoons are at least placental).
Gotcha. 😀
But groundhogs are sciurids, and I assumed that was what you were referring to?
(Groundhog/woodchuck’s been my guess all along, FWIW.)
As to how close groundhogs will go to a house:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NWAvVJmY5jA
Shot that through my back door window. Looked a little better at 640×480, but YT dropped that version for some reason.
Baby copybara. Escaped from either the zoo, or some unscrupulous exotic pet dealer.
I take that back. No tails on copybaras. That Coypu sure looks promising.
Garden ornament.
My guess is raccoon. It’s not a muskrat – wrong tail.
Is it a possum by chance?
http://poeticmonkey.com/misc-pics/hairless-woodchuck/IMG_3465.JPG woodchuck does look right. (With an unhealthy dose of sarcoptic mange.)
Perhaps this is what Creationists are looking for when they search for their ever-elusive “Crocoduck.” I present to you, the “Squirrel-Dog,” or as it will more likely come to be known in finer circles, “Squog.”
You’ve noticed a decline in the local bird population? Small pets have gone missing? Strange, unearthly howls?
What — did another Cthulhu get out.
<sigh />
Oh, Baihu! Go round us up some calamari, will you?
Yes, I know the freezer’s already full. I don’t know — maybe we’ll dry it, or see if we can talk the neighbors into another fish fry. Yeah, yeah — they all tripped out after the last one. But most have pretended to forget, and they might be too scared to say no.
But why’m’I explaining this to you? Just go get the damned thing and we’ll worry about what to do with it when you get it back, okay? Great. Love you! Bye.
b&