Reader’s wildlife tale

June 22, 2022 • 8:00 am

Today we have another combination story and biology lesson from Athayde Tonhasca Júnior, this time recounting how bumblebees can use electricity and the buzzing of their wings to find flowers and effect pollination. Athayde’s tale is indented, and photos, which you can enlarge by clicking, are attributed.

May the Force be with the bee

If we are asked how a bee finds a flower, we think of smells, colours, shapes and textures. These are important sensory signals, but there is another one whose relevance we are beginning to understand: electricity.

The platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus), a few fish and amphibians, and some ants, cockroaches, mosquitoes and fruit flies have the ability to detect external electric forces. But vertebrates need water as a conductive medium, while most insects respond only to unusually strong electric fields such as those generated by high voltage power lines. Bumble bees, however, have a sparking story to tell.

Now and then the thunder from a lightning bolt or the shock from a car door jolts us to the realisation that we are components of the Global atmospheric electrical circuit; our world is an immense electric motor. On a calm day, the air is positively charged, while the ground surface and any object connected to it – plants included – have a negative charge. So flowers have a slight negative charge in relation to the air around them. Flying insects experience different physical forces: as a bee buzzes along, electrons are stripped off its body by friction with the air, creating a surplus of positive charges. When the bee approaches a flower, she* attracts the negatively charged pollen grains. The grains stick to the bee, sometimes jumping from the flower even before the bee lands. These electrostatic forces are a great aid to pollination.

—–

*”She” because a worker honey bee is a sterile female. Apis mellifera sex has some quirks: embryos can develop as males through gene editing; populations of Cape honey bees (Apis mellifera capensis) reproduce without males; and some bacteria such as Wolbachia spp. change the sex of their arthropod hosts, including Hymenoptera (bees, wasps and ants). Nonetheless, their sex is typically binary, just as in Homo sapiens.

—–

Fig. 1. An electrifying encounter: a positively charged bee approaches a negatively charged flower © Hooven et al., 2019. Molecules 24, 4458.

Fig. 2. Pollen clinging to a bee © Ragesoss, Wikimedia Commons.

But flower power reaches shocking levels for the buff-tailed bumble bee (Bombus terrestris), and probably for other bumble bees as well: they are able to sense the weak electric field around a flower. No one knows exactly how they do it, but mechanoreceptive hairs must be involved. These special hairs are innervated at their base, so they detect mechanical stimuli such as air movement and low frequency sounds. Apparently, the flower’s electrical field moves the mechanoreceptive hairs of an approaching bee, similar to the way a wiped rubber balloon makes your hair stand on end. This hair movement is processed by the bee’s central nervous system and gives information about the shape of the electric field. It works just like Uri Geller’s mystical aura, except that the bee is not a fraud and its powers are not mystical.

Fig. 3. A buff-tailed bumble bee worker with a transponder attached to its back to track it with radar © Meadows, 2012. PLoS Biol 10(9): e1001391.

Fig. 4. Hairs provide thermal insulation, collect pollen and help bees sense air motion, sounds and electricity © Kevin Mackenzie, University of Aberdeen. Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).

But bumble bees’ capacity to detect electric forces may go beyond recognising flowers’ sizes and shapes: they could use the information to maximise foraging trips. Once a positively charged bee lands, the flower’s electric field changes and doesn’t go back to normal for about two minutes after the bee leaves. Researchers believe that an altered field warns the next bee that the flower is temporarily depleted of nectar; it’s like turning off a ‘we are open’ neon sign. So the next bee may as well buzz off to another flower with sufficient negative charge and a decent volume of nectar.

Bees and other insects detect ultraviolet and polarized light, and use magnetic fields for navigation. Sensing electricity is one more way their world is experienced differently from ours. And the relationship of bees with physics has other important implications, some of which affect our food supplies.

For most species of flowering plants, fertilization depends on the transfer of pollen from the male anthers of one flower to the female stigma of another. For the majority of those flowers, pollen is released through the splitting open (dehiscence is the technical term for it) of mature anthers. But for approximately 6% of the world’s flowering plants, pollen is kept locked inside non-dehiscent anthers and accessed only through small openings – pores or slits – in their extremities. We refer to them as poricidal anthers.

Fig. 5. Left: stamens, consisting of filaments and anthers. André Karwath, Wikimedia Commons. Most flowers release pollen by the splitting of the anthers along a line of weakness (top right); some only do it through a small hole or pore (bottom right).

Sometimes the whole flower has a poricidal arrangement, as it is the case for the tomato and related plants (Solanum spp.). Pollen is concealed inside a cone-shaped cluster of fused stamens and can only be released though a pore at the tip. Botanist say these flowers have a solanoid shape, after the name of the plant genus.

Fig 6. Solanoid-shaped tomato flowers © Muffet, Wikimedia Commons.

Extracting pollen from poricidal structures is not easy, but some bees know a way to do it.

A bee lands on one of these flowers, bites an anther and curls her body around it. She then lets out bursts of fast contractions and relaxations of her thoracic muscles – those muscles used for flying, but here the wings remain still. The contractions produce cyclical deformations of her thorax that last from fractions of a second to a few seconds: think of a body builder flexing his pectoral muscles really, really fast. These movements generate vibrations that are transmitted to the anther, causing pollen grains to fall though the apical pores and land on the bee’s body, adhering to it with the aid of electrostatic forces.

Fig. 7. A bee engaged in buzz pollination © Bob Peterson, Wikimedia Commons.

This head-banging pollen-harvesting manoeuvre generates a high-pitched buzz, hence it is known as ‘buzz pollination’; or as ‘sonication’ in technical reports. A physicist or an engineer could point out that this mechanism is not strictly sonication because it’s not sound that agitates and extracts pollen, rather the bee’s vibrations on the flower. But ‘sonication’ is the term commonly adopted, so we will keep it. Bumble bees (Bombus spp.), carpenter bees (Xylocopa spp.), and some other bees can buzz pollinate: honey bees (Apis spp.) and most leafcutter bees (Megachile spp.) cannot. And apparently only females know the trick; males have never been recorded buzz pollinating. Watch the whole sequence of events here (buzz pollination from 0:49) and here.

Plants with poricidal floral morphology are distributed across at least 80 angiosperm families, which suggests that buzz pollination has evolved independently many times. This has probably been helped by bees’ readiness to buzz for other reasons such as warning enemies, compacting nest materials, or cooling/warming their nests by beating their wings.

“Buzz-pollination syndrome”, the name given for this plant-bee association, is not just a biological curiosity. It makes a huge difference for crops such as tomatoes, raspberries, cranberries, blueberries, aubergines, kiwis and chili peppers. These plants don’t necessarily need buzz pollination to reproduce, but they produce more and better fruit if they are buzzed because more pollen is transferred and more ovules are fertilised.

In the late 1980s, Belgian and Dutch companies developed techniques to rear at a large scale the buff-tailed bumble bee, the ultimate buzz pollinator. Local producers of greenhouse tomatoes began replacing costly mechanical pollinators with boxes containing bumble bee hives, and a global, multi-million pound industry was born. Today, all ordinary tomatoes bought in a European supermarket have matured with the help of commercially reared bumble bees (they also transmit diseases to wild bees, but that’s a story for another time).

Fig. 8. A commercial bumble bee hive used in greenhouses © Elaine Evans, The Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education.

We may see pollination as a harmonious relationship where plant and insect go out of their way to help each other, but this is mistakenly romantic. A bee aims to take all the flower’s pollen: pollination happens because a few grains are dropped or rubbed off by accident. And a plant produces as little nectar and pollen as necessary to entice a flower visit. So the association between pollinators and flowers is best described as a mutual exploitation.

Buzz pollination fits nicely into this scenario. Poricidal anthers prevent excessive pollen expenditure by rewarding only a few specialist pollen gatherers, which increases the chance of pollination. Plants with poricidal structures typically secrete little or no nectar but their pollen is rich in protein, which convinces a bee to go to the trouble of buzzing to gain a small dose of the yellow stuff. It’s a clever and efficient trade agreement in the pollinators’ world.

26 thoughts on “Reader’s wildlife tale

  1. “… but there is another one whose relevance we are beginning to understand: electricity.”

    Yes!

  2. Mind bogglingly intricate! Thank you for yet another insightful view of nature from the perspective of our own biologist/physicyst/chemist/anthropologist/philosopher/RenaissanceMan.

  3. Wonderful post. I first heard about this bee pollination and sensing via buzzing and static electricity on QI (as with so many other things), but this is a much more involved and detailed explanation. Thank you!!

  4. Fascinating and informative. I’m a second year beekeeper who hopes you keep these chapters coming.

  5. What everyone up there^ said! Thank you for this introduction to the bumblebee’s umwelten. I had not heard of their ability to use electric fields in perceiving their world. Fascinating.

    1. What a great video, Lou. Those bees waste no time! I wonder how much pollen they get from such short visits.

    2. I love that sound of spring. I have a large Melastoma affine bush in my driveway and when in full flower it attracts great carpenter bees, blue-banded bees and teddybear bees who all love to buzz the pollen out of the flowers

  6. Very interesting and informative once i got past the intro (the world is an electric motor?) and the poorly written uninformative Wikipedia link.

  7. Athayde, your post is fascinating as always and timely as well. EdwardM mentioned Umwelten and that is directly connected to my current absorption in the works of Ed Yong, viz., his books, I Contain Multitudes and An Immense World. Have you read Yong?

    1. Thank you Stephen. I have not read Young. I have not read a science book in years; I guess I lost my mojo…

  8. What an informative and wonderful post. The videos of the bees buzz pollinating are fantastic.
    Headbanging up to 350 times a second is unimaginable. That’s quite a vibration.

  9. Fabulous article! I did not have any idea about the role of electricity in bumblebee pollination. So interesting.

    As a gardener, bumblebees are important pollinator for my tomatoes, going from blossom to blossom and plant to plant Their dabblings here and there are the bane of those who want to grow multiple open pollinating varieties in their garden and have the fruit seed true, but that has never been my goal. I like seeing the fat little gals clutching the blossoms for a foothold and going to work getting that pollen. I had not heard of buzz pollination, but reading your description makes perfect sense of what I have seen. Not everyone has the rich assortment of insects that I observe in my rural part of Idaho. For them, their garden tomatoes rely mostly on wind pollination.

    I found an article about use of bumblebees in greenhouse tomatoes in the SE USA which said that this didn’t work too well in smaller greenhouses (no dimensions were mentioned to know what they considered small). There typically was not enough pollen to support bumblebees in the more modest greenhouses and the hungry bees tended to damage the reproductive parts of the blossoms by repeated visits which defeated their purpose. In these smaller operations, it was cost-effective to use mechanical means to achieve pollination.

  10. Excellent post. Thanks for your efforts putting these thoughtful and enlightening articles together. I’ll regard bumblebees a little differently from now on- in a good way. 🙂

Leave a Reply